Do international carbon credits fight climate change?
FILE PHOTO: A coal-fired power station scheduled to shut down is seen in As Pontes, Spain, February 8, 2022. Picture taken February 8, 2022. REUTERS/Miguel Vidal/File Photo
BRUSSELS - The European Commission has proposed an EU climate target for 2040 that allows countries to count carbon credits bought from developing nations towards the EU goal for the first time.
Here's what that means, and why the EU move on Wednesday faced criticism from campaigners and some scientists.
WHAT ARE CARBON CREDITS?
Carbon credits, or offsets, involve funding projects that reduce CO2 emissions abroad in place of cuts to your own greenhouse gas emissions.
Examples include forest restoration in Brazil, or converting a city's petrol buses to electric. The buyer counts "credits" for those emission reductions towards its climate goal, and the seller gets finance for their green project.
Proponents say the system generates much-needed funding for CO2-cutting efforts in developing nations and lets countries work together to cut emissions around the world.
However, the reputation of CO2 credits has been dented by a string of scandals in which credit-generating projects failed to deliver the climate benefits they claimed.
Top stories
Swipe. Select. Stay informed.
Singapore 193ha of land off Changi to be reclaimed for aviation park; area reduced to save seagrass meadow
Business More Singapore residents met CPF Required Retirement Sum when they turned 55 in 2024
Singapore PAP questions Pritam's interview with Malaysian podcast, WP says PAP opposing for the sake of opposing
Singapore 1 in 4 appeals to waive HDB wait-out period for private home owners approved since Sept 2022
Sport A true fans' player – Liverpool fans in Singapore pay tribute to the late Diogo Jota
Singapore Healthcare facility planned for site of Ang Mo Kio Public Library after it moves to AMK Hub
Singapore $500 in Child LifeSG credits, Edusave, Post-Sec Education Account top-ups to be disbursed in July
Business 60 S'pore firms to get AI boost from Tata Consultancy as it launches new innovation centre here
WHY IS THE EU BUYING THEM?
The European Commission proposed allowing up to 3 percentage points of the EU's 2040 target - to cut net emissions by 90% from 1990 levels - to be covered by carbon credits bought from other countries.
The EU's existing climate targets require countries to meet the goals entirely by cutting emissions at home.
The bloc's executive Commission said last year it hoped the EU could agree a 90% emissions-cutting target for 2040, with no mention of carbon credits.
Tumultuous geopolitics and the economic woes of European industries have since stoked political pushback, with governments from Germany to Poland demanding a softer target.
In response, the Commission said it would add flexibilities, and landed on carbon credits as a way to retain a 90% emissions-cutting goal while reducing the domestic steps needed to reach it.
EU countries and the European Parliament must negotiate and approve the goal.
WHAT ARE THE RISKS?
The EU plan was welcomed by countries including Germany, which had pushed to include carbon credits in the goal, and by carbon credit project developers as a boost for climate finance.
But environmental campaigners said the EU was shirking domestic CO2-cutting efforts and warned against relying on cheap, low-value credits.
The EU's climate science advisers had also opposed buying credits under the 2040 target, which they said would divert money from investments in local clean industries.
The EU banned international credits from its own carbon market after a flood of cheap credits with weak environmental benefits contributed to a carbon price crash.
To try to address the risks, the Commission said it would buy credits in line with a global market and rules for trading carbon credits which the U.N. is developing. These include quality standards aimed at avoiding the problems that unregulated credit trading has faced in recent years.
Brussels will also propose rules next year on specific quality standards for the carbon credits the EU buys.
HOW MUCH WILL IT COST?
The EU doesn't yet know. Carbon credit prices today can be as low as a few dollars per tonne of CO2, up to more than $100, depending on the project.
EU emissions records suggest the bloc would need to buy at least 140 million tonnes of CO2 emissions to cover 3% of the 2040 target, roughly equivalent to the Netherlands' total emissions last year.
One senior Commission official said the bloc was determined not to hoover up cheap junk credits.
"I don't think that would have any additional value. The credits we see currently on voluntary carbon markets are very, very cheap, and that probably reflects a lack of high environmental integrity," the senior official said. REUTERS
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
2 hours ago
- Straits Times
US Treasury chief sees 100 countries getting 10% reciprocal tariff
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent expects 'a flurry' of trade deals to be announced before a July 9 deadline that could see tariff rates increase sharply. WASHINGTON - About 100 countries are likely to see a reciprocal tariff rate of 10 per cent, US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said on July 3, adding that he expects 'a flurry' of trade deals announced before a July 9 deadline that could see tariff rates increase sharply. 'We'll see how the President wants to treat those who are negotiating, whether he's happy that they're negotiating in good faith,' Mr Bessent told Bloomberg Television. 'I think that we're going to see about 100 countries who just get the minimum 10 per cent reciprocal tariff and we'll go from there. So I think we're going to see a lot of action over the coming days,' Mr Bessent said. If 10 per cent tariffs were given to 100 countries, that would be fewer than originally envisioned by the Trump administration. Its original reciprocal tariff list showed 123 jurisdictions that were given a 10 per cent tariff rate - mostly small countries, along with some territories like Australia's uninhabited Heard and McDonald Islands. Mr Trump in April temporarily reduced the tariff rate for most countries to 10 per cent to allow time for negotiations. Many countries with an initial 10 per cent duty rate have not had any negotiations with the Trump administration, with the exception of Britain, which reached a deal in May to keep a 10 per cent rate and won preferential treatment for some sectors including autos and aircraft engines. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore Seller's stamp duty rates for private homes raised; holding period increased from 3 years to 4 Singapore 193ha of land off Changi to be reclaimed for aviation park; area reduced to save seagrass meadow Business More Singapore residents met CPF Required Retirement Sum when they turned 55 in 2024 Singapore PAP questions Pritam's interview with Malaysian podcast, WP says PAP opposing for the sake of opposing Sport 'Pedal to the metal' for next 2 years, says Singaporean powerlifter Farhanna Farid Singapore 1 in 4 appeals to waive HDB wait-out period for private home owners approved since Sept 2022 Sport A true fans' player – Liverpool supporters in Singapore pay tribute to late Diogo Jota Singapore Healthcare facility planned for site of Ang Mo Kio Public Library after it moves to AMK Hub Major trading partners now involved in negotiations with the US could see much higher tariff rates, including 20 per cent for the European Union, 26 per cent for India and 24 per cent for Japan. Other countries that have not engaged in trade talks with the Trump administration face even higher reciprocal tariffs, including 50 per cent for Lesotho, 47 per cent for Madagascar and 36 per cent for Thailand.
Straits Times
3 hours ago
- Straits Times
While You Were Sleeping: 5 stories you might have missed, July 4, 2025
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox The latest changes will apply to all residential property purchased from midnight on July 4. Seller's stamp duty rates for private homes raised Sellers of private homes will have to pay higher seller's stamp duty (SSD) rates of between 4 per cent and 16 per cent if they sell a residential property less than four years after the date of purchase. The SSD is currently payable by those who sell a residential property within three years of purchase, at rates of between 4 per cent and 12 per cent. The Ministry of National Development, Ministry of Finance and Monetary Authority of Singapore announced the longer holding period and higher rates, which will kick in on July 4, in a statement late at night on July 3. The authorities said that in recent years, the number of private residential property transactions with short holding periods has increased sharply. READ MORE HERE Trump's Big Beautiful Bill wins congressional approval US House Speaker Mike Johnson bangs the gavel to mark the passing of US President Donald Trump's so-called 'One Big Beautiful Bill' on the floor of the House of Representatives, on July 3. PHOTO: AFP President Donald Trump's tax-cut package cleared its final hurdle in the US Congress on July 3, as the Republican-controlled House of Representatives narrowly approved the massive Bill and sent it to him to sign into law. The 218-214 vote amounts to a significant victory for the Republican president that will fund his immigration crackdown, make his 2017 tax cuts permanent and deliver new tax breaks that he promised during his 2024 campaign. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore Seller's stamp duty rates for private homes raised; holding period increased from 3 years to 4 Singapore 193ha of land off Changi to be reclaimed for aviation park; area reduced to save seagrass meadow Business More Singapore residents met CPF Required Retirement Sum when they turned 55 in 2024 Singapore PAP questions Pritam's interview with Malaysian podcast, WP says PAP opposing for the sake of opposing Sport 'Pedal to the metal' for next 2 years, says Singaporean powerlifter Farhanna Farid Singapore 1 in 4 appeals to waive HDB wait-out period for private home owners approved since Sept 2022 Sport A true fans' player – Liverpool supporters in Singapore pay tribute to late Diogo Jota Singapore Healthcare facility planned for site of Ang Mo Kio Public Library after it moves to AMK Hub It also cuts health and food safety net programmes and zeroes out dozens of green energy incentives. READ MORE HERE Four injured in 'violent' attack on German train Police and forensic experts investigating the attack on a high-speed ICE train on July 3, near the village of Strasskirchen, in Germany's Bavaria region. PHOTO: AFP Four people were wounded on a high-speed train in southern Germany on July 3 when a fellow passenger wielding a hammer and axe attacked them, police said. The suspect is a 20-year-old Syrian man, while three of the four wounded – ages 15, 24 and 51 – are also Syrian nationals, police said in a statement on July 3. An earlier statement said the suspect was arrested at the scene following the incident on a train carrying around 500 passengers as it passed near the village of Strasskirchen. READ MORE HERE Four people stabbed near shopping mall in Finland Police working at a cordoned off area outside the Ratina shopping centre in Tampere, Finland on July 3. PHOTO: REUTERS Four people were injured in a stabbing attack near a shopping mall in the Finnish city of Tampere on July 3 and one person was arrested, but there were no indications of a terrorist or racist motive in the incident, police said. A police statement gave no further details on the injuries from the attack in the Nordic country's third largest city but said the situation was under control and there was no further threat to the public. The daily Ilta-Sanomat reported that a witness saw bystanders giving first aid to two people lying on the ground at the time police arrived, and that, according to its information, the person arrested was a Finnish man in his twenties. READ MORE HERE Reservoir Dogs, Kill Bill actor Michael Madsen dies Actor Michael Madsen played Mr Blonde in 1992 film Reservoir Dogs, and appeared in several other movies from director Quentin Tarantino. PHOTO: REUTERS Michael Madsen, an actor who appeared in dozens of films including Reservoir Dogs and Thelma & Louise, has died at age 67, his representatives said on July 3. Madsen died of cardiac arrest at his home in Malibu, California, his manager, Ron Smith, said. Born in Chicago, Madsen began acting in the early 1980s in projects that included the TV show St Elsewhere and the movie The Natural on his way to racking up more than 300 on-screen credits.
Straits Times
3 hours ago
- Straits Times
Mistakes interns make have consequences, but are also learning opportunities
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox The TL;DR: Students on internship can make mistakes that affect their confidence and impact the company. Career advisers encourage them to own up and treat missteps as learning opportunities in this final instalment of a three-part series on navigating internships. A career counsellor said the key is to find the root cause of the problem, so that the interns can reflect on it and do better from there. It is not surprising that interns make mistakes when they join a company, given that they have little to no work experience. But committing a blunder might cause frustration and add to the workload of other employees. During his final-year polytechnic internship in the creative industry, Andre was tasked with setting up a website – a month-long project on which he worked on his own. The 20-year-old, who spoke on condition of anonymity, said: 'The website creation software was a new software (the company) was trying, so I had to figure everything out myself. 'The only help I got was from a full-timer who fine-tuned my project towards the end.' Andre created the website, but his work was rejected due to 'content errors, typos and technical mistakes'. 'As it was past the deadline already, my producer had to (work) overtime with me,' Andre recalled. 'In the end, we stayed in the office until ( midnight ) before we were done.' Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore Seller's stamp duty rates for private homes raised; holding period increased from 3 years to 4 Singapore 193ha of land off Changi to be reclaimed for aviation park; area reduced to save seagrass meadow Business More Singapore residents met CPF Required Retirement Sum when they turned 55 in 2024 Singapore PAP questions Pritam's interview with Malaysian podcast, WP says PAP opposing for the sake of opposing Sport 'Pedal to the metal' for next 2 years, says Singaporean powerlifter Farhanna Farid Singapore 1 in 4 appeals to waive HDB wait-out period for private home owners approved since Sept 2022 Sport A true fans' player – Liverpool supporters in Singapore pay tribute to late Diogo Jota Singapore Healthcare facility planned for site of Ang Mo Kio Public Library after it moves to AMK Hub Ms Clarice Chan, director of Aureus Consulting, a firm providing education, career and life coaching services, said interns in such situations should 'own up to their mistakes fully and immediately' and offer a proper apology. 'When you apologise to your colleagues, acknowledge the impact of your errors, such as stress and extra work for others. Thank them for their patience in helping you fix the problem, and do not make up excuses – such as it happened because you were rushing,' she said. In fact, some bosses tend to be more understanding toward interns. 'I was very lucky to have a nice producer,' said Andre. 'She didn't blame me and said that I was in the intern role to learn from my mistakes.' Mr Gerald Tan, a career counsellor and projects director at Avodah People Solutions, said it is important for interns to process their mistakes. 'The key is to find the root cause of the problem, whether it is competency or not understanding certain instructions, so that the students can reflect and do better from there,' he said. Mr Tan, whose company offers career guidance and job transitioning support to individuals and organisation employees, added: 'Saying 'sorry' would definitely help the situation, but I always tell my student clients not to say sorry too much, or else it becomes insincere.' Not all interns encounter understanding supervisors and might lose the trust of their employers. Stanley (not his real name), a 23-year-old who will soon start his university studies , had to repeat a week-long experiment as a research facility intern, severely delaying his report submissions. 'It was very easy to mistake one (experiment) parameter for another; after looking at numbers the whole day, they eventually lose meaning. In that state of mind, I picked the wrong number to set for the experiment,' he said, speaking on condition of anonymity, fearful that his future work prospects might be hampered. 'I remember my supervisor telling me: 'Go see the big boss and explain yourself'. In the end, my fellow full-time co-workers lost trust in me, as some of them were appointed to supervise me while I performed my experiments even though they were supposed to focus on their own projects,' he added. While Stanley was initially frustrated at his mistake, he decided to make use of the extra scrutiny. 'I ran all my plans through my supervisor, explaining the rationale behind every step. More than a month later, I managed to regain their trust and was allowed to run my tasks independently,' he said. He added that his improvement was even apparent in conversations with his colleagues. 'Though it was subtle, when they spoke about me (a month later), they implied that I knew what I was doing,' he said. Mr Jeremiah Wong, lead career developer in career counselling and coaching at Avodah People Solutions, said that students with appointed supervisors 'may not necessarily need to see (making a mistake) as a bad thing', as learning from mentors could be a more 'enriching experience'. Mr Tan added that lost trust could be slowly regained. He said: 'Supervisors may even give you more autonomy, when they see that you can better manage your work independently.' Mr Tan said that students may be pursuing internships for different reasons, with some feeling the need to stack internships to appear more ready for their first job. He added that this does not honour the learning and growth intent of the internship process. He said: 'Internships are created to help students learn about work and work culture, learn about themselves, get acquainted with making mistakes and building skills for the future. 'The most important thing is to be open to absorbing new knowledge and gaining new experiences.'
