School lunch documents reveal nutritional assessments, student taste test results
Photo:
RNZ / Louise Ternouth
The amount of coconut cream allowed in a curry, the questionable categorisation of potato as a salad vegetable, and the wildly varying results of taste tests are among matters covered by school lunch scheme documents obtained under the Official Information Act.
The documents provided insight into meal development by the
School Lunch Collective
last year and earlier this year as it prepared to take over the
contract for feeding students at about 440 schools
.
They included Education Ministry assessment of the nutritional value of the meals and accompanying side snacks, ministry emails to staff at Compass, the company leading the School Lunch Collective, and the results of taste testing of three meals last year.
They showed that curries should not have more than 15ml (about one tablespoon) of coconut cream per serving and soy sauce in a teriyaki meal should not exceed half-a-teaspoon.
They also showed that children's reactions varied enormously with one child describing a meal as "five star", but another in the same class writing "taste bad and looks bad and smell is bad" about the same meal.
The documents included advice from the now-defunct food preparation company Libelle on how schools could increase children's uptake of the meals.
It suggested withholding treats until after lunch, serving meals at the first break of the day rather than waiting until lunch time, and providing condiments such as tomato sauce.
It also suggested serving food buffet style so children could choose, changing lunch orders on an online portal to avoid unpopular meals, and "the five senses initiative" which asked children to consider their meal and note their observations on a brightly-colour checklist.
Advice from food preparation company Libelle told schools how they could increase children's uptake of the provided meals.
Photo:
Screenshot / Compass Group
The documents inluded results from taste tests last year of three meals with children in different schools.
In February last year a taste testing of a beef curry and rice meal across a number of schools and classrooms resulted in comments ranging from "meat is amazing" and "liked everything about the meal" to "too bland" and "didn't look appetising".
Multiple comments noted difficulty opening the meal containers and that a hot meal was not appealing on a hot day.
Overall, 13 percent of students did not like the meal, 35 percent were neutral and 53 percent liked or strongly liked it.
"As a result of receiving the above summary feedback, Libelle made changes to the process of cooking the diced meat and started to investigate the claims of difficult to open lids again," the document said.
It showed a macaroni and cheese meal was revised to improve the cheese flavour and hide vegetables following feedback that akonga "do not like vegetables and couldn't taste the cheese flavour".
A test of the revised meal across six schools resulted in 57 percent of pupils giving a positive rating, 21 percent neutral and 23 percent negative.
One school said all children ate the meal and wanted it back on the menu, but another said everyone disliked it: "Their feedback was that it was gluggy. I dissected a meal and it was quite congealed and the pasta did appear overcooked and mushy".
The document showed further investigation revealed the negative feedback was from a school that received the meal several hours before it was consumed and negative opinions about the meal from school staff might have influenced pupil opinions.
Comments about the meal included "I love it, give us more of it please", "it was so cheesey", "looks weird", "smell yuck", "basic and ok".
A trial of beef rissoles across two schools proved the most divisive with 44 percent positive, 24 percent neutral and 32 percent negative.
"It was good but not that good," wrote one student, while another wrote "I like all of it and it was amazing".
"Too much thyme or mixed herbs - it's in everything almost every day," wrote another.
By 22 May last year, Libelle noted that 13 schools had opted to stop receiving the beef rissoles and gravy meal and it was planning to update the meal with a new improved version for the following term.
Documents released under the Official Information Act reveal 13 schools opted to stop receiving a beef rissoles and gravy meal from the school lunch programme.
Photo:
Screenshot / Compass Group
Among the released documents was a spreadsheet showing Education Ministry assessments of 24 meals and, for older children, accompanying snacks against nutritional requirements.
It showed an early version of Mac n Cheese failed to make the grade because it was too light, 209 grams instead of at least 240 grams with just 30 percent of the required protein, while a gluten-free version had 99.875 percent of the protein required.
Muesli bars, yoghurt raisins, banana chips and pretzels failed to make the grade as acceptable snacks.
A 12 December 2024 email from the Education Ministry to Compass Group said all main meals for the proposed menu for term 1 2025 had been assessed as meeting nutrition requirements, but two changes were requried for the sides that accompanied lunches for students in Year 9 and above to ensure the total meal met nutritional requirements.
"There are four meals that fall short of meeting nutrition standards, two are within an acceptable margin (Beef Rissoles and Mac n Cheese), however the other two will need to be adjusted to meet nutrition standards. Beef bolognese is 9g below the protein food requirement and Chicken Teriyaki Rice exceeds the amber allowance by 8g," the email said.
The School Lunch Collective said amber ingredients, such as coconut cream, were allowed in meals, but only up to a certain amount.
On 10 January 2025, the ministry emailed Compass Group asking for changes to four meals.
"Butter Chicken: Coconut cream is double the allowed serving size for both age group. Needs to be reduced to 15mls per serve.
"Ham Mac n Cheese: no percentage of cheese in the sauce so can't confirm meets protein requirements.
"Thai Chicken: Coconut cream again is over the amber serving limit of 15mls per serve.
"Beef rissoles: Doesn't meet veg content (note saying potato considered as salad veg?) but even with veg in rissole, brownie and onion in gravy it is still short."
On 13 January 2025 a ministry email to Compass Group listed changes required to five meals.
"Butter Chicken and Thai Chicken - reduce the coconut cream content to no more than 15mls per serve.
"Mac n Cheese: confirm cheese content (needs to be at least 17g per servce to meet yr 4-8 protein requirement) and ensure sides contribute sufficient protein to meet Y9+ requirements of at least 50g.
"Teriyaki Chicken: ensure that soy sauce content is less than 1/2 tsp (2.5ml) per serve.
"Beef Rissoles: increase vegetables by at least 15g to meet Y4-8 min requirement (60g)."
School Lunch Collective figures showed it was delivering about 103-107,000 lunches to about 440 schools a day with waste or uneaten lunches ranging from six to 10 percent.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
9 hours ago
- RNZ News
Faith Farm Fresh keeps milk flowing direct to customers
rural farming 15 minutes ago It's a busy time of year for Stacey Faith, calving 300-plus cows, rearing their calves and keeping the Faith Farm's roadside milk dispensing outlet going, providing locals with milk fresh from the cows over the fence - with the cream on top.
RNZ News
15 hours ago
- RNZ News
Third-annual national wild goat hunting competition gets underway
Wild goats are are believed to occupy around 14 percent of Aotearoa. Photo: Supplied / Department of Conservation Hunters are targeting thousands of wild goats in a nationwide competition in efforts to protect farmland and the environment. Wild goats were prolific breeders that threatened native biodiversity, forests and farmland, and were believed to occupy around 14 percent of Aotearoa. The third-annual national wild goat hunting competition begins today, running into November. The Department of Conservation (DoC) and New Zealand Deerstalkers Association event aims to address the growing population of wild goats, estimated to be several hundred thousand. Association board member and its Hutt Valley branch president, Trev Gratton said in the first year they totalled 10,000 goats, 12,500 last year, and now they hoped to exceed that figure. "Goats are an issue throughout the country and it's something that we've identified along with our partners at DoC as something that we want to be involved in, with trying to help mitigate those numbers," he said. "They are a pest and they need to be managed. And one of the ways of doing that is looking holistically and working with partners within the community to actually start getting those numbers under control." Gratton said there were 5000 hectares of huntable private land it was working to get hunters onto this year for goat removal. He said its landowner assist plan will give both hunters and landowners like farmers confidence about the hunting operations in the coming months. "We've had a tremendous response from landowners from one end of the country," Gratton said. "Particularly when it comes to going onto private land like that, it's a very considered operation. It's not done where you're posted on a Facebook page and say, 'hey show up there and feel free to go on.' "It's done via the local branch and the local branch management in conjunction with the landowners, so that everyone's comfortable with how things are going to progress going forward. So it is a very considered, very methodical process." Gratton said the plan detailed insurance coverage around NZDA hunters and health and safety to mitigate any concerns, and it held future possibilities. "We're looking at obviously bringing these relationships further field and doing it all year round with other problems with deer and what-not onto this land. "So it's a collaborative effort to talk to landowners and to build those ongoing relationships within the community." Ten landowners have already registered their interest. The event was also being supported by Federtaed Farmers, Hunting and Fishing and Te Tari Pūreke Firearms Safety Authority. The Department of Conservation said on its website, goats arrived in Aotearoa as early as the late 1700s when Captain James Cook released them in the Marlborough Sounds during his second voyage - and the government has run wild goat control operations for about a century. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
16 hours ago
- RNZ News
Warning after three injured trying to sort fires in Dunedin homes
Photo: RNZ / Cole Eastham-Farrelly Three people have been badly injured in separate attempts to remove a burning mattress, dryer and pot of oil from their Dunedin homes. Fire and Emergency said they were lucky not to have been killed by the fires in recent weeks, with one person asleep in a house without working smoke alarms. Otago risk reduction advisor Matt Jones said people should not try to deal with fires themselves. "These people have sustained serious injuries, but we were fortunate to not be responding to fatal fires," he said. "Let this be a reminder to people that if a fire is bigger than a football, then you can't put it out. You must get out and stay out. That means closing the door to the room if safe to do so, getting everyone out of the house and calling 111. Let the firefighters do their job and put the fire out safely." Jones said the mattress fire was caused by a vape's battery overheating while charging on a bed. "That caused a very intense, hot fire inside the mattress," he said. "The person attempted to remove the mattress three times, but this put themselves and others in danger, not only from the fire, but from the toxic smoke being emitted. "Everything in that house can be replaced, except for the people inside. People should never risk their lives to save their property - it's just not worth it." The home did not have working smoke alarms, Jones said. "It was just fortunate the person arrived home when they did as there was another person asleep inside the house at the time," he said. FENZ recommended having working smoke alarms in all bedrooms, hallways and living areas and a three-step escape plan.
