Official sorry over 'fiasco' delay that stopped Westminster law scrutiny
Neil Gibson, the permanent secretary at the Department of Finance, said he took "full responsibility" for the delay and promised to learn lessons from what happened.
The Data Use and Access bill, which aims to modernise laws around the sharing of data, will now be passed without the legislative consent of assembly members at Stormont.
Instead they will discuss and "note" the bill when it comes before the chamber.
Speaker Edwin Poots said it was "unacceptable" while the leader of the opposition, and chair of the Finance Committee, Matthew O'Toole described the delay as a "fiasco".
The Scottish Parliament and Welsh Assembly have already given their consent for the legislation, which is expected to receive royal assent within weeks.
Appearing before the Finance Committee, Neil Gibson apologised to members and linked the delay to the Windsor Framework.
He said officials waited for more than two months to get an assessment from the UK government on how the new legislation might impact the Windsor Framework.
This was a process the Scottish and Welsh administrations were not required to do, he added.
He accepted officials should have notified the committee about the hold up, which he said was his "biggest regret".
Mr Gibson also confirmed a new tracker system will be put in place to ensure all Westminster bills which require a legislative consent motion from the Northern Ireland Assembly is progressed on time.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
JD Vance lands in Scotland for next leg of UK holiday
US Vice-President JD Vance has arrived in Scotland during his visit to the UK. Vance is on a private family holiday, and will stay in a plush country estate in the outskirts of Kilmarnock in Ayrshire. The vice-president arrived on Air Force Two at Prestwick Airport and was expected to be driven a short distance to Hulford in a motorcade. His arrival comes just weeks after President Donald Trump was in Scotland, where he played golf on his courses at Turnberry and in Aberdeenshire. Vance will stay at Carnell Estates, a privately owned estate which has a 14th century tower and 10-bedroom mansion situated on over 2,000 acres of land. The estate is about a 40-minute drive away from Trump's Turnberry golf club. Police Scotland previously confirmed they had plans in place for "a significant policing operation." Officers were seen at the estate ahead of Vance's arrival on Wednesday and some road closures were in place. A number of protests are expected to take place during the visit, including one outside Carnell Estate. On Tuesday, Vance met US troops stationed at the Royal Air Force Base in Fairford, Gloucestershire, where he received a briefing on the base's capabilities. While not on official White House business, he met David Lammy for talks about Gaza and other international affairs at the foreign secretary's official residence, Chevening House, in Kent on Friday. Lammy has since referred himself to a watchdog after photos emerged of the pair fishing without the correct license. Vance also met Conservative MP's Robert Jenrick and Chris Philp and Reform UK leader Nigel Farage. Earlier this year the vice-president criticised Scotland over buffer zones which prevent demonstrations or vigils taking place close to abortion clinics. He used the new law as an example of Europe not protecting free speech enough and used a speech in Munich to claim "even private prayer within their own homes may amount to breaking the law". Gillian Mackay, the MSP behind the legislation, said at the time the comments were inaccurate. She said: "This is shocking and shameless misinformation from VP Vance, who is either very badly informed about what my Act has done or he is knowingly misrepresenting it." However, Vance has also described himself as a "Scots-Irish hillbilly at heart" in the past, with his ancestors having moved to the Appalachian region in the US more than three centuries ago. A Scottish government spokesperson said: "The Scottish government continues to work collaboratively with partners, including the UK government and Police Scotland, to manage the impact of a potential visit by the US Vice President to Scotland." JD Vance meets Jenrick and Philp in Cotswolds Police Scotland preparing for potential JD Vance visit Lammy admits fishing without licence on Vance trip
Yahoo
10 hours ago
- Yahoo
Sir George Reid's lifetime of dedication to serving public
Sir George Reid will undoubtedly be remembered as one of Scotland's most respected public figures. The journalist-turned-politician became the second presiding officer at the Scottish Parliament in 2003, using his tenure to foster cross-party working and winning awards for his efforts. Post-politics, Sir George's contribution to public life continued, with his experience in the devolved Parliament put to great use in a variety of roles, including as a teaching fellow at Stirling University and as a member of Nicola Sturgeon's standing council on Europe. Born in Tullibody, Clackmannanshire, in 1939, he was educated at Abercromby School, Dollar Academy and the University of St Andrews. He started his career as a journalist in the 1960s, working for the BBC, Scottish Television, Granada and a number of newspapers. He later became a producer and correspondent with ITV and the BBC in the UK, elsewhere in Europe and Africa. He was an SNP MP and member of the parliamentary assemblies of the Council of Europe and Western European Union between 1974 and 1979. Between 1984 and 1996, he was director of public affairs for the International Red Cross and Red Crescent, based in Geneva but also working worldwide in conflict and disaster zones. From 1998 to 1999 he was in the steering group for the Scottish Parliament and became a list MSP and deputy presiding officer in 1999. In May 2003 he was elected as constituency MSP for Ochil and presiding officer, where he was tasked with stewarding the completion of the then controversial Holyrood building and move of the Parliament from its original base on the Mound in Edinburgh. He won the Herald newspaper's Scottish politician of the year award in 2003 and 2005, and was given a lifetime achievement gong in 2013. Sir George stepped down from frontline politics in 2007 but continued to monitor parliamentary standards for five years as a special adviser on the ministerial code, and served as a UK electoral commissioner from 2010 to 2014. In 2008 he was appointed as the Lord High Commissioner to the General Assembly of the Church of Scotland, and in 2011 he was named Her Majesty's Lord Lieutenant of Clackmannanshire. He held five honorary doctorates and lectured regularly at universities in the UK, Europe and North America. Sir George was knighted in 2012, an honour which he said rounded off a life spent serving the public both at home and abroad. Surgery for bladder cancer in October 2013 saw him step back from his various public roles, although he was appointed a professorial fellow at the University of Stirling and the London Academy of Diplomacy, and was elected a fellow of the Royal Society of Edinburgh in 2015. The EU referendum led Sir George back to frontline politics for the first time in a decade, with an appointment to then first minister Ms Sturgeon's standing council on Europe and a self-proclaimed 'moral responsibility' to speak out on the risks posed by Brexit. He is survived by Daphne, his wife of 57 years, his daughter Morag, her husband and five grandchildren.
Yahoo
2 days ago
- Yahoo
Trump's mental decline is on vivid display as he rages about Epstein, windmills
It was nice of Donald Trump to travel to Scotland and show our European allies firsthand that the United States is led by a self-absorbed and deeply weird man in obvious mental decline. Over the span of a weekend, the U.S. president's addled brain raced about like a dull-witted Labrador attempting to outsmart squirrels. He went on lengthy diatribes about windmills. He ranted about the ungratefulness of starving children. He forayed into nonsensical conspiracy theories regarding the Jeffrey Epstein scandal consuming his administration, while laughably saying upon arriving in Scotland on July 25: 'I'm not focused on conspiracy theories.' Trump's head, based on his overseas babbling, is 90% conspiracy theories and 10% brain cells. Coverage of Trump's Scotland trip doesn't show the extent of his rambling The trip was largely a taxpayer-funded chance for the grifter in chief to promote his Scottish golf properties, which in the realm of 'things Trump can do that no other president would ever get away with' barely registers as a blip. It was also a chance for him to talk 'deals' with the European Union and the United Kingdom, with a 'deal' being something resulting in trade tariffs that will negatively impact American consumers. Or as Trump likes to call it, 'Winning.' Opinion: MAGA is realizing Trump lies. How can they trust anything he says on Epstein? News coverage tends to trim Trump's voluminous prattling into digestible sound bites that sound vaguely sane. But if we care about a president's lack of mental acuity – and I've been told by many that we do – it's worth sticking your head in the high-pressure stream of nonsense that shoots out every time Trump opens his face hole. Trump shows he's laser-focused on the scourge of windmills On July 25, Trump deplaned in Scotland and immediately showed reporters he was armed with weapons-grade non sequiturs. 'This immigration is killing Europe,' he said, racistly. 'And the other thing, stop the windmills killing the beauty of your countries.' Two days later, he sat with European Commission chief Ursula von der Leyen, who looked like she would love to be elsewhere, and uncorked this: 'And the other thing I say to Europe, we will not allow a windmill to be built in the United States, they're killing us. They're killing the beauty of our scenery, our valleys, our beautiful plains. And I'm not talking about airplanes, I'm talking about beautiful plains, beautiful areas of the United States, and you look up and you see windmills all over the place, it's a horrible thing. It's the most expensive form of energy; it's no good. They're made in China, almost all of them. When they start to rust and rot in eight years, you can't really turn them off, you can't bury them, they won't let you. But the propellers, the props, because they're a certain type of fiber that doesn't go well with the land, that's what they say. The environmentalists say you can't bury them because the fiber doesn't go well with the land; in other words, if you bury it, it will harm our soil. The whole thing is a con job.' OK. That was a thing nobody asked for. It's also filled with lies – wind isn't the most expensive form of energy, and windmills last far longer than eight years. But who would expect honesty from someone rambling like that? Again with the windmills? Heck, just let the old man cook. And Trump wasn't done with windmills. On July 28, during his meeting with UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer, the president said: 'It destroys the beauty of your fields, your plains, and your waterways, and look out there – there's no windmills. But if you look in another direction, you see windmills.' Are the windmills in the room with us right now, Mr. President? Propose prosecuting Beyoncé? Check! Babble incoherently? Check! Trump did take a break from talking crazy over the weekend to post something crazy on social media, writing July 26 that pop star Beyoncé should be prosecuted for a nonexistent $11 million payment from Kamala Harris' presidential campaign. So that happened. And it's not ideal. On July 27, alongside von der Leyen, Trump was asked how he feels about the images of starving children in Gaza, to which he said: 'That whole place is a mess. The Gaza Strip, you know, was given many years ago, said that they could have peace. That didn't work out too well. When Israel gave that up, whoever was the prime minister at the time, who I know, who it was, but it was not exactly a very clever thing to do. Because that was given so that they finally have peace, but it's actually made the situation worse. But we'll see what happens. I think Iran is acting up. We have a lot of people acting, we have Venezuela acting up in a different way. They continue to send people that we rebuff to our border. They continue to send drugs into our country, Venezuela. They've been very nasty.' Opinion alerts: Get columns from your favorite columnists + expert analysis on top issues, delivered straight to your device through the USA TODAY app. Don't have the app? Download it for free from your app store. So when shown images of starving children in Gaza, Trump feels the place is a mess because an Israeli prime minister whose name he DEFINITELY knows but isn't going to say gave up the Gaza Strip so there could be peace but that made things worse and Iran is acting up and, hey, let me tell you about Venezuela, which is about 7,000 miles away from Gaza. Opinion: Trump is unpopular, polls show, and he's building an America most Americans hate Republicans would have impeached Biden if he talked like Trump Had Joe Biden said something like that when he was president, Republicans would have either impeached him or ordered him locked in a room at Walter Reed National Military Medical Center. It got worse when Trump was asked if Israel should be doing more to allow food into Gaza to help the aforementioned starving children. The president's few remaining brain cells decided to focus on how ungrateful all those starving people are: 'We gave $60 million two weeks ago, and nobody even acknowledged it, for food. It's terrible, you know, you really at least want to have somebody say thank you. No other country gave anything; we gave $60 million two weeks ago for food for Gaza. Nobody acknowledged it, nobody talks about it. And it makes you feel a little bad when you do that, and you have other countries not giving anything, none of the European countries, by the way, nobody gave but us, and nobody said, 'Gee, thank you very much,' and it would be nice to have at least a thank you.' During his meeting with Starmer, Trump apparently forgot he had been talking about the Gaza Strip the day before and said: 'We do have to take care of the humanitarian needs on what they used to call the Gaza Strip. You don't hear that line too much anymore. You don't hear the Gaza Strip. But it is the Gaza Strip. Amazing.' Yes. Amazing. Epstein, Epstein, Epstein. Trump can't stop talking about the scandal. Trump's mental dullness led him to keep talking about the Epstein scandal he wants everyone to stop talking about, effectively telling the world the Epstein stuff is 'not a big thing,' but probably involves former Democratic President Bill Clinton and a former president of Harvard University and 'hedge fund guys' and was probably made up by Democrats who probably put fake stuff in the Epstein files but then, I guess, didn't use any damning information against Trump before the election. He also gave a third explanation for why he stopped being friends with Epstein and said of the convicted sex offender's notorious island: 'I never had the privilege of going to his island.' The privilege? Spoken like a man whose mind has turned to mush. So nice of Trump to share his cognitive decline with the world. Follow USA TODAY columnist Rex Huppke on Bluesky at @ and on Facebook at You can read diverse opinions from our USA TODAY columnists and other writers on the Opinion front page, on X, formerly Twitter, @usatodayopinion and in our Opinion newsletter. This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Scotland trip shows Trump's mental decline in real time | Opinion
