
Europe does not have to choose between guns and butter. There is another way
But to frame the dilemma facing Europe in this way is a big mistake. History teaches us that the political choice has never been about guns or butter, but rather guns or taxes.
The collapse of the Soviet Union in the early 1990s seemed to close almost a century of global ideological conflict, but it was also supposed to make us all richer. With the end of the cold war, Europeans would no longer need to uphold an expensive military apparatus for territorial defence. Governments ditched conscription and walked back defence outlays. Cashing in on that so-called 'peace dividend', governments could spend on the domestic priorities of their liking, boosting non-military investment.
Last month's Nato summit in The Hague showed how this tide has been dramatically reversed. Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine and Trump's uncertain commitment to Nato means that European governments have no choice but to invest more in their own mutual defence. The peace dividend, as Kristalina Georgieva, the head of the IMF, stated, 'is gone'. Europe's Nato members pledged to increase spending on 'hard defence', such as tanks and military salaries, from 2% to 3.5% of GDP by 2035.
The question now is how to finance it. For some experts, the only way to build a warfare state that can deter Russia is to slash social spending. After all, goes the misleading argument, governments in the 1990s splashed the savings from defence on expensive welfare promises.
Even before the Nato agreement in The Hague, the public were being softened up for the new reality. In a TV address in March, the French president, Emmanuel Macron, warned citizens that in a 'more brutal' world, they would have to make budget sacrifices. Macron ruled out higher taxes. Denmark's prime minister, Mette Frederiksen, decided to scrap a public holiday to finance higher defence spending. The UK has cut savagely into its international development aid budget for the same reason.
But Europe would be drawing the entirely wrong lessons from history if it weakened the welfare state to build up the military state. There is another way: instead of slashing social spending, Europe's governments should raise taxes on corporations and capital to finance deterrence.
Let's look at what actually happened in the 1990s. While cutting defence spending after the collapse of the Soviet Union allowed governments to increase social spending, it mostly gave them room to cut taxes and budget deficits, which they did with great zeal, as the 1990s neoliberal consensus took hold and tax competition intensified.
Yes, the 'peace dividend' helped to finance big increases in social spending, but with ageing societies it was mostly devoted to pensions, health and longterm care. Social protection for the working age population has fallen across Europe since the end of the cold war.
But from the mid 1980s to 2023, corporate income tax rates fell by around half within the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD). Capital gains tax rates also dropped significantly: from up to 53% in the early 1990s to 26% today in Germany, or from up to 30% to up to 24% today in the UK for the same period. The 'peace dividend' was in fact a boon for the wealthiest in Europe.
Savings in defence not only went to the private sector via tax cuts, but also via reduced fiscal deficits. Germany's adoption of its contentious constitutional 'debt brake' in 2009 helped it to achieve a balanced budget; something that would have been impossible without cutting defence spending to the bone.
Sign up to This is Europe
The most pressing stories and debates for Europeans – from identity to economics to the environment
after newsletter promotion
In the years ahead, Europe cannot afford politically to place the burden of the defence buildup on the most disadvantaged groups. More public debt, as Germany has now committed itself to, will be necessary. But debt is often a regressive tax, weighing more on the poorest, as the wealthy own a large share of the debt. Moreover, if EU members don't agree to common borrowing to finance the defence surge, as happened during the pandemic, financial markets may not let EU countries with a high debt load, such as Italy or France, increase deficit-spending on defence.
The 'new normal' of higher defence spending should thus also be funded by increasing taxes, especially on corporate income, high wealth and capital gains. This won't be possible without limiting tax competition at a Europe-wide level.
Indeed, the idea that some European tax havens continue to suck up corporate tax resources from others while they free-ride on their defence spending will become increasingly difficult to sustain. France and Germany have long pushed for the harmonisation of corporate taxes across the EU's 27 members. The EU must now rein in tax-dumping countries such as neutral Ireland. Europe cannot achieve better defence without better tax revenues.
And only a defence buildup that is supported by the wider public across Europe can run beyond the short-term momentum and thus develop into a credible deterrence.
The experience of 'military Keynesianism' globally, and across history, has never been about guns or butter, but guns and butter. In a war, you not only need weapons, but also a supportive population to operate them. Keeping the peace on the home front is just as important as holding the line in the trenches. Rather than slashing the welfare state to build up the military state, Europe's leaders should think about how to improve and modernise social spending. Only the prospect of a better and fairer world will keep our societies united and capable of fighting.
Shahin Vallée is a senior research fellow at the German Council for Foreign Relations. Joseph de Weck is a fellow with the Foreign Policy Research Institute
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

Western Telegraph
26 minutes ago
- Western Telegraph
Mass protests planned in London and Windsor for Trump's state visit
The Stop Trump Coalition is also planning further protests, including one near Windsor Castle, during Donald Trump's high profile trip in two months' time. Buckingham Palace confirmed on Monday that the King is to host the controversial American leader at the Berkshire royal residence from September 17-19, when he will be feted with a ceremonial welcome and a state banquet. US President Donald Trump will be hosted by the King (Victoria Jones/PA) The trip will be Mr Trump's second state visit to the UK – an unprecedented gesture for a US president – with his last one in 2019 seeing thousands of people turn out on the streets in London in opposition. A 20ft Trump baby blimp also took to the skies above Parliament Square, just as it did during a previous visit by the billionaire-turned politician in 2018. The Stop Trump Coalition has yet to confirm whether the famous inflatable effigy, which depicts the US president as an angry baby in a nappy clutching a mobile phone, will make a reappearance. The original was donated to the Museum of London in 2021. The Donald Trump baby balloon in Parliament Square during Donald Trump's last state visit in 2019 (David Mirzoeff/PA) Other inventive creations by protesters in 2019 included a 16ft talking robot of Mr Trump sitting on a gold toilet, which said the phrases 'No collusion', 'You are fake news' and 'I'm a very stable genius' in audio of Mr Trump's own voice; and Handmaids Against Trump – women draped in red with white hoods in homage to Margaret Atwood's dystopian novel about a crackdown on reproductive rights. On September 17 – the first day of Mr Trump's visit – demonstrators will assemble at London's Embankment at 2pm and march to a 5pm rally at an as-yet-undisclosed location. Further protests, including one near Windsor Castle, are set to be confirmed once more details of Mr Trump's visit is known. Security is expected to be at peak levels for the American leader, who survived an assassination attempt last year. The then-Prince of Wales and Duchess of Cornwall with US President Donald Trump and his wife Melania in 2019 (Chris Jackson/PA) The Stop Trump Coalition's spokesperson Seema Syeda said: 'This will be a massive protest against Trump's state visit. 'Trump and his authoritarian politics are not welcome here. Keir Starmer should not be rolling out the red carpet for Trump. 'They are already running scared. They have chosen the first possible date that stops Trump from being able to address Parliament. 'We know that Trump is deeply unpopular with the public. 'We mobilised hundreds of thousands of people against Trump during his first term, and he has only got worse since then. 'We are working at speed to bring together all the movements – for democracy, for equality, against climate change, for a free Palestine – to show our unity against Trump.' A 16ft talking robot of US President Donald Trump sitting on a gold toilet in Trafalgar Square in 2019 (Jacob King/PA) The House of Commons will not be sitting at the time of Mr Trump's visit as it will be in recess for party conference season, meaning the president will not be able to address Parliament as French President Emmanuel Macron did during his state visit last week. However, the House of Lords will be sitting. Nick Dearden, director of Global Justice Now which is part of the coalition, accused Mr Trump of being a bully and suggested there was a growing global resistance against him. 'Trump is engaged in economic warfare against both friend and foe,' he said. 'He's bullying countries, including the UK, to give in to the demands of American multinational corporations. 'And he's taking his own country down an increasingly fascist path – crushing the rights of Americans, ignoring the courts, threatening the media and universities.' Charles and Mr Trump during his ceremonial welcome at Buckingham Palace six years ago (Toby Melville/P) Mr Dearden added: 'Why on earth would we want to accord this man a second state visit? 78% of Britons have a negative view of Trump, and with good reason. 'If Starmer won't stand up to Trump, we will – by taking to the streets as part of the growing global resistance against Trump and the oligarchs that surround him.'


The Independent
31 minutes ago
- The Independent
Starmer to meet Trump during Scotland trip ahead of state visit
Sir Keir Starmer will meet Donald Trump when the US president visits Scotland ahead of his second state visit to the UK. Mr Trump is expected to travel to Scotland in July before the state visit in September. A Downing Street spokesman said: 'The White House has confirmed that President Trump will be making a private visit to Scotland later this month. 'Given he is visiting a private capacity, there will not be a formal bilateral but the Prime Minister is pleased to take up the president's invite to meet during his stay.' Police Scotland have said they will seek Government help with the 'considerable' costs of the Trump visit, after it emerged last week that the force was in the early stages of planning for a visit. The US president's state visit will follow from September 17 to 19, Buckingham Palace has confirmed. He will be hosted by the King and Queen at Windsor Castle and accompanied by his wife, Melania Trump. There had been speculation about whether Mr Trump would be able to address Parliament, as French President Emmanuel Macron did during his state visit last week. MPs will not be around during the confirmed dates, which fall just after they start a break for party conference season. Nigel Farage told GB News Parliament should be recalled to allow the president to speak to MPs and peers. The Liberal Democrats meanwhile did not urge for MPs to be called back, but said Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney should be invited for a state visit and to address Parliament. 'The Prime Minister should invite Mark Carney for an official visit to the UK just ahead of Trump's visit, including the opportunity to address Parliament. 'This would send an important signal that Britain stands shoulder to shoulder with Canada against Trump's chaotic trade war,' Sir Ed Davey said. Asked for Sir Keir's view on the president addressing Parliament, the Prime Minister's official spokesman said: 'The Prime Minister is focused on welcoming President Trump to the UK for an historic second state visit and building on the excellent relationship they've had that's been delivering for working people. 'The dates of the visit are for President Trump and the Palace (…) details around the programme will be announced in due course.'


Daily Mail
33 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Brigitte Macron puts on a brave face as she joins husband Emmanuel for French Bastille Day celebrations as furore over ludicrous claim she is actually a man continues
France's first lady put on a brave face and joined her husband for the Bastille Day celebrations in Paris, as it emerged she had taken her libel case against women who claimed she used to be a man to the highest appeals court. Brigitte Macron, 72, joined President Emmanuel Macron, 47, at the Place de la Concorde for a record-breaking procession through the capital, intended to show off the military's 'operational credibility' on Monday. She was pictured at her husband's side as her lawyer announced she would take her case to the Cour de Cassation, after the Paris appeals court overturned earlier convictions against the two women for spreading false claims. Ms Macron filed a complaint against the two women after they posted a video in 2021 alleging she had once been a man named Jean-Michel Trogneux - who is Ms Macron's brother. The nation marked Bastille Day on Monday with an unprecedented parade on the Champs-Élysées after President Emmanuel Macron warned of Russia 's 'lasting threat' to Europe and wider freedoms. Some 7,000 military personnel were joined by columns of tanks in the traditional march from the Arc de Triomphe to Place de la Concorde as scores of planes and helicopters performed manoeuvres in the skies. Celebrations are planned nationwide as the country commemorates the storming of the Bastille fortress and prison on July 14, 1789 - a pivotal moment in the French Revolution that ultimately brought about the end of absolute monarchical rule. The holiday period also sees special awards handed out to people of note. Gisèle Pelicot, who became a hero to victims of sexual violence during a four-month trial this year, was among this year's recipients of France's most prestigious award, the Légion d'honneur. On the eve of the parade, President Macron used his annual speech to announce a €6.5 billion euro (£5.63bn) boost to defence over the next two years - around six per cent more than the total €110bn already planned for 2026/27. 'Since 1945, freedom has never been so threatened, and never so seriously,' he said of the military and cyber threats facing Europe. 'To be free in this world, we must be feared. To be feared, we must be powerful.' (From L) Two French Air and Space army Cougar helicopters and a French Air and Space army helicopter Puma helicopter perform a fly-over past the Sacre-Coeur Basilica during the annual Bastille Day military parade in Paris on July 14, 2025 General Loïc Mizon, the Military Governor of Paris, told Radio France Internationale the parade was intended to show off France's 'operational credibility' against security challenges. Soldiers from the 7th Armoured Brigade marched in full combat gear, rather than ceremonial garb, in an unprecedented move Mizon described as a 'clear demonstration of our determination and effectiveness'. The Paris event included flyovers by fighter jets, trailing red, white and blue smoke above the capital as soldiers and military vehicles proceeded down below. Two riders fell from their horses near the end of the parade, and it was unclear whether anyone was hurt. Such incidents happen occasionally at the annual event. Each parade uniform has a touch of symbolism. The contingent from the French Foreign Legion was eye-catching, its bearded troops wearing leather aprons and carrying axes, a reference to their original role as route clearers for advancing armies. Finnish troops serving in the U.N. force in Lebanon, and Belgian and Luxembourg troops serving in a NATO force in Romania also paraded through Paris, reflecting the increasingly international nature of the event. Among the dignitaries invited to watch will be Fousseynou Samba Cissé, who rescued two babies from a burning apartment earlier this month and received a last-minute invitation in a phone call from Macron himself. 'I wasn't expecting that call,' he told online media Brut. 'I feel pride.' More than 450 Indonesian service members joined the parade on foot after the Patrouille de France air show. Indonesia is this year's guest of honour, with France having recently concluded a strategic defence partnership to strengthen its role in the Indo-Pacific. Jaguar armored vehicles of the 1st Spahis Regiment drive down the Champs-Elysees avenue during the annual Bastille Day military ceremony in Paris, France, July 14, 2025 The Southeast Asian country was expected to confirm purchase of French Rafale fighter jets and other military equipment during the visit. Indonesian President Prabowo Subianto, who was accused of rights abuses under Indonesia's prior dictatorship, will be treated to a special holiday dinner at the Elysée Palace. What does Bastille Day commemorate? Bastille Day commemorates the storming of the Bastille prison on July 14, 1789, and the unity of the French people at the Fete de la Federation a year later. The storming of the Bastille was a major turning point in the early days of the French Revolution, as militias took up arms against royal troops. Civilian insurgents and mutinous French Guards went to the fortress in Paris, long a symbol of Royal tyranny, and demanded its surrender. After a tense standoff, several guards were killed and the governor was beheaded, setting a precedent for violence. The French Revolution would ultimately overthrow the monarchy and lay the groundwork for more Enlightenment-inspired ideals of freedom and rights - though France soon descended into political turmoil, repression, and mass executions, before Napoleon's eventual rise to power. And late this evening, the capital will host a half-hour firework show at the Eiffel Tower. This year's event is set against the backdrop of growing uncertainty across Europe around the fate of the War in Ukraine and the perceived threat from Russia. European intelligence bureaus and security think tanks have warned in recent months that Russia could be looking to attack a NATO members before the end of the decade. Pressed by the United States, European members have sought to hike defence spending in response to the perceived threat. Germany alone plans a 70 per cent increase in military expenditure to €162bn by 2029. On the eve of Bastille Day this year, France's Macron announced 6.5 billion euros in extra French military spending in the next two years because of new threats ranging from Russia to terrorism and online attacks. The French leader also called for intensified efforts to protect Europe and support for Ukraine. 'While we had planned to double the defence budget by 2030, we will double it by 2027,' he told an audience of top military officials in the gardens of the French defence ministry on Sunday. 'There will be €64 billion for defense in 2027. That's twice more than in 2017. It's a new, historic and proportionate effort.' Macron did not say where the money would come from. France's prime minister, Francois Bayrou, is to unveil a plan for the 2026 budget tomorrow, with defence set to be the only area to receive a boost. The government is looking to find as much as €40bn by cutting spending and raising taxes to balance the books. Most opposition parties support a raise in defence spending, at least. French army during the annual Bastille Day military parade on the Champs-Elysees Avenue in Paris, France on July 14, 2025 Paris aims to be able to deploy a 'war ready' brigade of more than 7,000 personnel within 10 days if required, and aspires to be able to do the same with an entire division of 20,000 within 30 days by 2027. France separately bestowed prestigious awards on notable people around the Bastille Day celebrations today. This year's recipients include Gisèle Pelicot, who became a global hero to victims of sexual violence during a four-month trial in which her husband and dozens of men were convicted of sexually assaulting her while she was drugged unconscious. Others earning the honor are Yvette Levy, a Holocaust survivor and French Resistance fighter, and musician Pharrell Williams, designer for Louis Vuitton.