Bill for new National Maternity Hospital could reach €2 billion
The new
National Maternity Hospital
could ultimately cost close to €2 billion to develop, senior health service figures believe.
If the estimate is borne out, it would mean the bill for the maternity facility, to be constructed on the St Vincent's hospital campus at Elm Park, Dublin, would be more than 10 times the amount originally allocated when the project was announced more than a decade ago.
Tenders for the building of the hospital are being examined by an evaluation group in the HSE and are expected to be given to a project board shortly.
Minister for Health
Jennifer Carroll McNeill
will then have to bring a final business case to Cabinet later this year if the project is to receive final approval.
READ MORE
Senior health service figures maintain construction costs for the hospital are likely to be about €1.5 billion, or higher, and that other bills associated with developing and commissioning the facility could push the final price to some €2 billion.
'The tenders are higher than expected,' a senior individual with direct involvement in the project said.
It is understood there are contingency elements included in some tenders to minimise the likelihood of a repeat of the experience with the national children's hospital. That project, which will also cost in excess of €2 billion, has experienced significant overruns and is running way behind schedule.
Some sources maintained that the development of the facility on an existing hospital campus rather than a greenfield site increased costs. A rise in construction inflation, allied with uncertainty over trading conditions because of the potential impact of US tariffs, are also said to have contributed.
The Irish Times also understands that the
HSE
will face monetary charges if any undue delay on its part in making decisions leads to additional costs or delays.
In May 2013, the then minister for health, James Reilly, announced the government had agreed to commission a new facility to replace the National Maternity Hospital's ageing premises at Holles Street.
Dr Reilly said an 'indicative sum' of €150 million had been approved for the project. At the time it was forecast that construction would commence in late 2016 and be completed in 2018.
The project was beset by a row over governance, ethos and whether there could be restrictions on the types of services provided to women being treated there.
Campaigners, including some prominent medical figures, argued it would have a Catholic ethos because of the legacy of religious control of St Vincent's, which was founded by an order of Catholic nuns.
They contended that this could prevent certain treatments – legal in Ireland but not permitted under church rules – from being made available. But the government, other staff at Holles Street and authorities at St Vincent's rejected these suggestions. Ultimately a 299-year lease was secured on the site to ensure its operational and clinical independence.
Over the years cost estimates for the project increased significantly. In February 2017, the HSE projected it would cost €296 million. In June 2021, the Department of Health said cost estimates had risen further to about €800 million, including €300 million for commissioning and transferring services from Holles Street.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Daily Mirror
24 minutes ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
'I thought I was just tired, it was cancer and I'd ignored the signs for months'
A Kildare dad-of-four never imaged he could get cancer, until months of tiredness and a foul smell from his penis turned out to be signs of a rare but serious disease. Cormac France, who describes himself as "very fit and active" shared his experience of penile cancer as part of a new HSE awareness campaign called 'Know the Signs', launched to coincide with Men's Health Week. "I'm a very fit and active person. I used to do a lot of training," cancer survivor Cormac explained. "Because I don't smoke, I didn't think I would be a candidate to get cancer, never mind penile cancer, which is rarer again." He initially dismissed the symptoms for months. Cormac said: "Looking back from when I was diagnosed, I did notice, the six months or so previous, that's when the changes really started with weight loss, chronic tiredness, and as time progressed, the smell from my penis was horrendous, and then the penis started to split. That was due to the tumours. Cancer can reach every part of your body, and people have to realise that. To get the news is devastating, but there are people there to help." Penile cancer, a rare but aggressive disease diagnosed in about 60 men in Ireland each year, mostly affects men over 50. Early detection significantly improves survival rates and can preserve function and appearance. The HSE is urging men to take early signs of penile cancer seriously and to seek medical help of they notice any changes. Consultant Urologist Mr Ivor Cullen, who leads the National Penile Cancer Service at Beaumont Hospital, emphasised the importance of awareness, saying: "These new resources are aimed at increasing knowledge of penile cancer among men. Although a rare disease, penile cancer is a very aggressive disease when it has spread. Penile cancer is, in large part, preventable, yet we're still seeing men present late because of stigma and lack of awareness. It's a sensitive subject, yes, but early detection makes all the difference, not just for survival, but for preserving function and quality of life." Men are advised to watch for these signs and symptoms: Alison Doran, Clinical Nurse Specialist in Penile and Bladder Cancer at Beaumont Hospital, added that risk factors include age over 50, HPV infection, smoking, poor hygiene and conditions like phimosis, which cause chronic inflammation. She said: "The main risk factors are men over 50 years of age, and infection with HPV, human papillomavirus, which is a significant risk factor. We would see over half of our cases linked to HPV. Smoking also increases the risk, and poor hygiene is another key factor. If a patient has a previous experience of phimosis, which is tightening of the foreskin, or if there's a build-up of smegma under the foreskin, that can create chronic inflammation and create cancer cells as well." Smegma is a build-up of thick, cheesy-looking secretions around your genitals that collects when you don't wash them regularly. It can be white or yellow and is a combination of oils from your sebaceous glands. The campaign is running across HSE social media channels and includes a new booklet, 'What I Need to Know About Penile Cancer', available for free download at This guide helps men, families and healthcare providers recognise symptoms early, understand risks and find support. Men across Ireland are urged not to ignore unusual symptoms and to seek medical advice immediately as early action could save lives.
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Activist Cara Darmody (14) to call for declaration of national health emergency at Dáil committee on disability
Disability activist Cara Darmody (14) is set to call for the declaration of a national health emergency in an address to the Dáil committee on disability on Wednesday morning. The secondary school pupil from Co Tipperary is expected to criticise what she has described as an ' all talk no action ' approach to the assessment-of-needs crisis. Last month, Ms Darmody carried out a 50-hour picket in front of Leinster House , calling on the Government to remedy the large number of children waiting for six months or more for a disability or autism assessment. More than 15,000 children are waiting for an assessment of need, but the HSE estimates the number will grow to 25,000 by the end of this year. READ MORE On Wednesday morning, she is expected to 'call out the blatant assessments-of-needs lawbreaking by the Taoiseach and the Government'. 'My message to the Taoiseach today is very simple – immediately declare this as a national emergency, set up a taskforce to physically knock on every private psychologist and therapist's door in the country with an emergency request for help, and dramatically finance 'Cara's Fund',' her opening statement to the committee reads. The teenage activist has said her motivation stems from the experiences of her brothers, Neil (12) and John (8), who have autism and intellectual disabilities. She is also expected to challenge comments on a lack of capacity in the private sector, noting '37 psychologists wrote to me unsolicited since my protest, offering immediate assessments for my brothers'. Lianne Quigley, chairperson of the Irish Deaf Society (IDS), IDS chief executive John Sherwin and Damien Walsh of Independent Living Movement Ireland will also address the committee.
Irish Times
5 hours ago
- Irish Times
Average cost of health insurance jumps to almost €2,000
The cost of private health insurance has jumped sharply, with average prices of almost €2,000 per person forcing some people to go without cover, according to new data published on Wednesday. As well as a spike in prices, the figures from the health insurance watchdog highlight a significant slowdown in the numbers taking out cover in the first three months of the year. In its latest market report, the Health Insurance Authority (HIA) reports that 2.52 million people in Ireland now have private health insurance, with the average cost of a plan standing at €1,929. That represents an increase of almost €200 compared with the average price the HIA recorded in 2024. READ MORE The research also suggests that just 7,318 people entered the market in the first quarter of 2025 compared with 13,633 in the last three months of last year. [ My health insurer wanted an extra €900 to maintain my plan. Time to look for options Opens in new window ] The findings continue a recent trend of reduced growth in the health insurance market, with the HIA's 2024 Annual Market Report showing an increase in coverage of 1.3 per cent between 2023 and 2024, and a further decrease in the number of children insured at 21.6 per cent compared with 23 per cent in 2019). All the State's private health insurance companies have increased their prices in recent months, with the VHI, Laya and Irish Life Health all rolling out at least two hikes during the year, blaming an increase in claims and the higher cost of treatments. The fresh figures from the HIA are likely to stoke fears that if prices continue to climb, private health insurance will become unaffordable for many, particularly for younger people. These are the people who are typically in better health and make fewer claims, so they effectively subsidise the cost of healthcare for older people who are more likely to need it. If younger people drop out of the health insurance system because prices climb too high, they are likely to put more pressure on the public system while driving up costs for insurers who will inevitably pass it on to their customers creating a vicious circle of price increases. How to manage your pension in these volatile times Listen | 37:00 'Although health insurance continues to be a very popular product purchased by almost half of the population, rising prices could potentially be affecting further growth in the market,' said HIA chief executive Brian Lee. 'At an average cost of almost €2,000, it may be that many potential consumers no longer choose to buy private health insurance due to financial pressures or other considerations,' he continued. He stressed that there were steps consumers could take to save money and noted that 'shopping around is the best way to save money on health insurance, and with a lot of consumers renewing their plan in July we recommend reviewing your plan now to see what you're covered for and what you actually use'. He encouraged those who are happy with their current providers to look at what other plans they have that might be more suitable, while also being more affordable. The HIA noted that some plans that have been on the market for a long time 'don't offer as much value as newer plans [and] just by shopping around, consumers could find a plan with very similar benefits for a lower price'. It also encouraged consumers to consider increasing the hospital excesses on their policies 'This is the amount that you pay each time you are admitted into a private hospital. If you're in good health, looking for a plan with a higher excess can be a good way to save money.' And it said people could consider reviewing their plans and reducing cover for benefits they don't use.
