Tensions surface in German coalition over asylum-seeker ruling
Tensions are surfacing within Germany's conservative-led coalition government over migration, after a court ruling last week appeared to prohibit rejecting asylum seekers at the country's borders.
The Berlin Administrative Court ruled on Monday that the summary rejection of three Somalis during a check on the border with Poland was unlawful.
The urgent ruling meant that "there can no longer be blanket rejections because the courts will stop them," said Matthias Miersch, head of the parliamentary group of the Social Democrats (SPD), which is the junior member of Chancellor Friedrich Merz's coalition.
Without clarification as to which EU state is responsible for the asylum application of those affected, they should not be turned away, according to the ruling. The court also said the government lacked evidence for its argument that it could reject asylum seekers on the grounds of public safety.
The three Somalis are now back in Berlin.
Miersch told the weekend edition of the Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung newspaper that the court's decision raised fundamental questions that the government should address.
"The chancellor also stated this very clearly when he said that the practice must be reviewed again in light of this court decision," said Miersch.
"And I expect this to happen now," he said, pointing to the possibility otherwise of more legal problems in the near future.
Interior Minister Alexander Dobrindt introduced the more intensive border controls on May 7. He defended the policy again on Saturday, in remarks to the Funke media group of newspapers.
"This is an individual judgement," said Dobrindt, referring to the court ruling. "We will provide sufficient justification, but the European Court of Justice should decide on this."
The head of the Berlin Administrative Court, Erna Viktoria Xalter, said however that this would not prove successful. Speaking to news portal Zeit Online, she said: "How is this supposed to go through to the ECJ? The urgent decision is incontestable."
Merz, who belongs to the conservative Christian Democrats (CDU), recently said he would continue to refuse asylum seekers at the border even after the administrative court ruling.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
8 hours ago
- Yahoo
Survey: Germany's Merz gaining in popularity as leader
German Chancellor Friedrich Merz has risen markedly in popularity in his first weeks in the job, according to a new poll published on Saturday. The survey, conducted by the INSA research institute for the Bild newspaper, found that 36% of the 1,202 respondents were so far satisfied with the performance of the 69-year-old conservative chancellor, who took office on May 6. This is 13 percentage points higher than his rating four weeks ago. Another 45% of respondents said they were dissatisfied with Merz, 4 percentage points less than in the last survey, while 19% did not know how to answer. Germany's coalition government under Merz is also viewed more positively than it was a month ago. Some 37% said they were satisfied with the partnership of his Christian Democrats (CDU) and their Bavarian sister party the Christian Social Union (CSU) with the Social Democrats (SPD), up from 29% in the last survey. Again, 45% expressed dissatisfaction, and 18% did not know how to answer. On a weekly basis, however, there was hardly any movement in the ratings of the five parties represented in Germany's lower house of parliament, or Bundestag. The CDU/CSU bloc gained one percentage point from the previous week to reach 27% support, followed by the far-right Alternative for Germany with 23%, one percentage point down from the previous week. The SPD (16%) and the Left Party (10%) both lost one percentage point, coming in at 16% and 10% respectively, while the Greens gained one point to garner 11% support. Public opinion polls are fraught with uncertainty. Among other things, declining party loyalty and increasingly short-term election decisions make it hard for pollsters to accurately assess the data collected. Generally, surveys only reflect opinion at the time they are conducted and are not forecasts of possible election outcomes.
Yahoo
11 hours ago
- Yahoo
Tensions surface in German coalition over asylum-seeker ruling
Tensions are surfacing within Germany's conservative-led coalition government over migration, after a court ruling last week appeared to prohibit rejecting asylum seekers at the country's borders. The Berlin Administrative Court ruled on Monday that the summary rejection of three Somalis during a check on the border with Poland was unlawful. The urgent ruling meant that "there can no longer be blanket rejections because the courts will stop them," said Matthias Miersch, head of the parliamentary group of the Social Democrats (SPD), which is the junior member of Chancellor Friedrich Merz's coalition. Without clarification as to which EU state is responsible for the asylum application of those affected, they should not be turned away, according to the ruling. The court also said the government lacked evidence for its argument that it could reject asylum seekers on the grounds of public safety. The three Somalis are now back in Berlin. Miersch told the weekend edition of the Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung newspaper that the court's decision raised fundamental questions that the government should address. "The chancellor also stated this very clearly when he said that the practice must be reviewed again in light of this court decision," said Miersch. "And I expect this to happen now," he said, pointing to the possibility otherwise of more legal problems in the near future. Interior Minister Alexander Dobrindt introduced the more intensive border controls on May 7. He defended the policy again on Saturday, in remarks to the Funke media group of newspapers. "This is an individual judgement," said Dobrindt, referring to the court ruling. "We will provide sufficient justification, but the European Court of Justice should decide on this." The head of the Berlin Administrative Court, Erna Viktoria Xalter, said however that this would not prove successful. Speaking to news portal Zeit Online, she said: "How is this supposed to go through to the ECJ? The urgent decision is incontestable." Merz, who belongs to the conservative Christian Democrats (CDU), recently said he would continue to refuse asylum seekers at the border even after the administrative court ruling.
Yahoo
12 hours ago
- Yahoo
Call for German coalition talks to resolve legal limbo over asylum
Germany's new coalition government needs to start negotiations to respond to a court ruling that prohibits rejecting asylum seekers at the country's borders, a senior member of parliament told reporters. "In my view, there can no longer be blanket rejections because the courts will stop them," said Matthias Miersch, head of the parliamentary group of the Social Democrats (SPD), which is the junior member of the conservative-led coalition. The Berlin Administrative Court ruled on Monday that the rejection of three Somalis during a check on the border with Poland was unlawful. Without clarification as to which EU state is responsible for the asylum application of those affected, they should not be turned away, according to the ruling. The three Somalis are now back in Berlin. Miersch told the weekend edition of the Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung newspaper that the court's decision raised fundamental questions that the government should address. "Incidentally, the Chancellor [Friedrich Merz] also stated this very clearly when he said that the practice must be reviewed again in light of this court decision," said Miersch. "And I expect this to happen now, because otherwise we will see further proceedings being lost in the coming months." Interior Minister Alexander Dobrindt introduced more intensive border controls on May 7, and ordered that asylum seekers should also be able to be turned back at the border in future. Merz, who belongs to the conservative Christian Democrats (CDU), recently said he would continue to refuse asylum seekers at the border even after the administrative court ruling. Monday's decision may narrow the government's room for manoeuvre on the issue, although at the current time authorities can effectively still turn back asylum seekers at the border.
