What Sebi's proposed broker rule changes mean for algo trading and compliance
Neha Joshi From algos to qualified stock brokers, the draft cleans up three decades of circulars, hardwires investor safeguards and streamlines compliance. Public comments open till 3 September. Sebi has included definitions of 'algorithmic trading', which is order generated using automated execution logic and 'execution only platform (EOP)', a digital/online platform that facilitates subscription, redemption and switch transactions in direct plans of mutual fund schemes. Gift this article
The Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi) has issued a consultation paper proposing a ground-up rewrite of the 1992 Stock Brokers Regulations to simplify compliance, codify key circulars, and align the rules with today's tech-driven markets. It has invited public comments until 3 September.
The Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi) has issued a consultation paper proposing a ground-up rewrite of the 1992 Stock Brokers Regulations to simplify compliance, codify key circulars, and align the rules with today's tech-driven markets. It has invited public comments until 3 September.
Mint breaks down what changes most for brokers, investors, and markets. What are the proposed definitions?
Sebi has included definitions of 'algorithmic trading', which is order generated using automated execution logic and 'execution only platform (EOP)', a digital/online platform that facilitates subscription, redemption and switch transactions in direct plans of mutual fund schemes. Sebi also deleted the definition of a 'small investor' as the threshold of ₹ 50,000 was considered an outdated classification.
Legal experts who advise brokers believe the proposed definitions may be too broad or missing out on spelling out exceptions.
Sonam Chandwani, managing partner of KS Legal, said the proposed algorithmic trading definition is so broad that it risks capturing everything from basic order-routing tools to high frequency trading (HFT). 'This approach could subject low-risk participants to disproportionate compliance obligations designed for far more sophisticated and potentially disruptive trading systems." Chandwani said. Also Read | Sebi to reboot 30-year-old broker rules for a tech-first market How will registration and governance change?
Sebi's consultation paper has specified that at least one designated director must be resident in India (182+ days per financial year) for broker-companies at registration consideration. It also specified that brokers must intimate Sebi (via an exchange) and other market infrastructure institutions (MIIs) of any 'material change" in registration information, not just change in control. Change-in-control approvals are to be routed through an exchange.
Lawyers said the new 'material change" intimation will raise compliance overhead and may trigger disputes unless Sebi/exchanges clearly define scope, timelines, and formats through circulars.
'What is material change has not been defined in the proposed regulations. This additional requirement may increase the compliance burden on brokers, and the absence of a clear definition for 'material change' could lead to differing interpretations and potential disputes," said Akshaya Bhansali, managing partner at Mindspright Legal. What is changing for large brokers designated as QSBs?
Sebi has proposed to rely on size/scale metrics only for Qualified Stock Brokers (QSB) designations. The metrics will now include active clients, client assets held with the broker, trading volumes, end-of-day client margin obligations, and proprietary trading volumes. Compliance and grievance scores, Sebi suggested, will not be qualifying criteria, as it puts additional burden of compliance on an aspect that is already monitored.
Experts said this move is essential. 'While these requirements do increase compliance and operational costs, the large customer bases and high transaction volumes handled by QSBs make it essential for ensuring transparency and maintaining the credibility of market intermediaries," said Prakarsh Gagdani, chief executive officer (CEO) at Torus Digital.
However, Narinder Wadhwa, managing director & CEO of SKI Capital Services Ltd, said the debate of compliance burden for QSBs being proportionate or overly stringent remained, potentially affecting competitiveness. How is recordkeeping and digitisation being streamlined?
Sebi has proposed permitting electronic maintenance of books or records, essentially removing physical-security-era requirements, which includes paper contract note copies. Brokers must inform exchanges (not Sebi directly) where books/records are maintained, Sebi said, aligning submissions and communication through the exchanges.
'Changes in documentation, compliance technology, and reporting structures could require significant investment. There could be possible shifts in client onboarding norms, record-keeping formats, and real-time reporting obligations", Wadhwa said. How will fees and net worth requirements change?
The consultation paper removes references to the outdated 1990s transition-year and has standardised fee payment processes and timelines through exchanges and online gateways. Exchanges collected these fees segment-wise.
Sebi also proposed to remove the fixed base net worth and the formula-based variable net worth in the current regulations tied to client cash balances at brokers. The regulator reasoned that the provisions became less relevant after it introduced the mandatory upstreaming of client funds to clearing corporations. Through this, the investors' clear credit balances are transferred by the broker to the clearing corporation every day.
Experts said the absence of clarity on how 'variable net worth" will be computed created uncertainty for capital planning. 'The shift of variable net worth to circulars means Sebi can change the formula quickly. Helpful if upstreaming lowers balances, but risky if they widen what counts. Large brokers can absorb swings; smaller ones may face sharper, less predictable capital demands", Ajay Kejriwal, executive director at Choice Equity Broking, said. What is the new power to relax strict enforcement?
The regulator proposed an enabling provision to relax strict enforcement in specified circumstances such as undue hardship, procedural or technical issues, factors beyond control, and non-relevance for a class. It proposed including a mechanism for confidential treatment of requests or responses for up to 180 days.
Legal experts said the discretion seemed inherently subjective. 'Without clearly defined parameters, market participants may challenge decisions as being arbitrary. Further, the provision allows for confidential treatment of such requests and Sebi's responses. So, such relaxations will not be in the public domain for up to 180 days (or not at all if withdrawn)", Bhansali said.
Chandwani echoed the view and said that without precise criteria and published interpretive guidance, this flexibility could fuel interpretational uncertainty and litigation. Will inspections increase or be better coordinated?
Beyond Sebi's inspection powers, recognised stock exchanges, clearing corporations, and depositories may conduct inspections as per their by-laws, the consultation paper said. Sebi and MIIs will be allowed to conduct joint inspections, aiming to avoid multiple duplicative checks.
Lawyers said without a clearly defined jurisdictional hierarchy, regulated entities could be subjected to overlapping inquiries into the same issues. 'This not only creates procedural inefficiency but also heightens the risk of conflicting conclusions between authorities", Chandwani said. What timelines and operational impact should brokers expect?
Industry sources note that adaptation windows for paperwork/policy updates could be a few months, with longer lead times for tech/algo controls and full QSB governance uplift; Sebi historically staggers implementation via circulars and master circular updates.
'Most brokers could adapt in six months for paperwork and policy updates, nine months for tech/algo compliance, nine months for full QSB governance upgrades, with likely phased timelines for any new net worth formula, giving smaller brokers extra breathing room", Kejriwal said. Topics You May Be Interested In Catch all the Business News , Market News , Breaking News Events and Latest News Updates on Live Mint. Download The Mint News App to get Daily Market Updates.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Economic Times
an hour ago
- Economic Times
AMFI leads economic transformation with 3 decades of building an investor-first India
Synopsis AMFI's 30-year journey reflects India's economic transformation, from UTI's monopoly era to a ₹75 trillion AUM industry today, driven by SIPs, regulation, awareness, and growing retail participation, supporting PM Modi's Viksit Bharat 2047 vision. AMFI celebrates 30 years of fostering trust, awareness, and inclusion, with mutual fund AUM tripling to ₹75 trillion, supporting India's vision of becoming a developed nation by 2047. A few years ago, our Hon'ble Prime Minister, Shri Narendra Modi, articulated a bold and compelling vision - to see India emerge as a Viksit Bharat (Developed Nation) by 2047. At Association of Mutual Funds in India (AMFI), this vision is deeply personal. For us, nation building is not only about infrastructure, industry or GDP numbers. It is equally about mobilising savings, fostering an investment mindset, and ensuring every citizen – from the largest city to the smallest village – has the tools and knowledge to achieve financial independence. When I look back at AMFI's 30-year journey, I see it running parallel to India's own transformation - from a closed, cautious economy in the early 1990s to a confident, investment-aware nation today. And at the heart of this change lies one simple, yet powerful idea: an informed investor is an empowered citizen. Starting from 1963 and well into the 1980s, the mutual fund industry was a single player domain- dominated by the state-owned UTI - catering to a limited number of investors. Market maturity was low, retail participation was negligible, and large institutions often influenced market movements. The early 1990s were a turning point. The early 1990s were a turning point. Economic liberalisation opened India's economy, and the creation of SEBI as an independent regulator brought much-needed structure, credibility, and investor protection to our capital markets. It was in this backdrop that AMFI was born in 1995, with a mission far greater than industry representation — to instill trust, transparency, and investor-centricity in the DNA of mutual funds, and to take investment awareness to every corner of India. Over the years, AMFI worked alongside SEBI to strengthen regulation and set benchmarks for self-regulation. The shift to NAV-based pricing was a watershed moment — for the first time, investors could see the daily value of their holdings, making wealth creation transparent and the late 1990s, we introduced Systematic Investment Plans (SIPs) — a quiet revolution that democratised investing. No longer was wealth creation the privilege of the affluent. Even the smallest saver could participate in India's growth story with as little as ₹500 a such as the Riskometer, Scheme Categorisation Norms, and Uniform Disclosure Standards simplified mutual funds for millions. KYC norms, and later e-KYC, streamlined onboarding, while technology opened new frontiers for distribution and industry faced its share of challenges — the 2008 Global Financial Crisis, the 2012 Taper Tantrum, and volatile market cycles. Each time, we emerged stronger, not just in numbers but in investor the mid-2010s, mutual funds had crossed ₹10 trillion in assets under management (AUM). Between 2014 and 2017, AUM doubled to ₹20 trillion, and by November 2020, crossed ₹30 last five years have been the most remarkable yet. From June 2020 to July 2025, AUM has tripled to ₹75 trillion. Investor folios now exceed 240 million, with nearly 2.5 million new folios being added every month — a clear testament to growing trust and surge is no longer limited to metros. Today, a first-time earner in a Tier-3 town is just as likely to start their financial journey with a mutual fund as someone in Mumbai or turning point was 2017, when AMFI launched the 'Mutual Fund Sahi Hai' campaign — breaking the myth that mutual funds were only for the wealthy, and speaking to every Indian in their own language. It took investment awareness to the smallest towns, rural markets, and digital screens across the has been a game changer — with smartphones and UPI, investing in a mutual fund has become as simple as sending a text message. Improve financial literacy in schools, colleges, workplaces, and communities. Create financial independence by empowering citizens with the knowledge to save, invest, and plan for their future. Reach the unreached — the hundreds of millions of Indians who have yet to take their first step into formal investing. We envision a future where every Indian household has an investment plan, where women and youth lead the way in disciplined savings, and where financial security becomes a way of life, not a journey has always been about more than products or performance. It has been about trust built patiently over decades, discipline nurtured through awareness, and empowerment delivered through AMFI, we remain steadfast in keeping the investor-first approach at the heart of everything we do. Because when investors grow, India grows. And when India grows, the dream of Viksit Bharat will not just be a vision — it will be a reality. 'Karmanye vadhikaraste, Ma phaleshou kada chana' You have the right to perform your actions, but not to the fruits thereof. This timeless wisdom captures the spirit that guides us — to act with integrity, dedication, and unwavering purpose. At AMFI, our commitment remains clear: to empower every Indian with the knowledge and tools to invest wisely and build a secure future. Because when we focus on the right actions, the outcomes — for the investor, the industry, and the nation — will follow. (The author Venkat N Chalasani is Chief Executive – Association of Mutual Funds in India (AMFI). Views are own) (Disclaimer: Recommendations, suggestions, views, and opinions given by experts are their own. These do not represent the views of the Economic Times) (Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this column are that of the writer. The facts and opinions expressed here do not reflect the views of
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
AMFI leads economic transformation with 3 decades of building an investor-first India
A few years ago, our Hon'ble Prime Minister, Shri Narendra Modi, articulated a bold and compelling vision - to see India emerge as a Viksit Bharat (Developed Nation) by 2047. Independence Day 2025 Modi signals new push for tech independence with local chips Before Trump, British used tariffs to kill Indian textile Bank of Azad Hind: When Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose gave India its own currency At Association of Mutual Funds in India (AMFI), this vision is deeply personal. For us, nation building is not only about infrastructure, industry or GDP numbers. It is equally about mobilising savings, fostering an investment mindset, and ensuring every citizen – from the largest city to the smallest village – has the tools and knowledge to achieve financial independence. When I look back at AMFI's 30-year journey, I see it running parallel to India's own transformation - from a closed, cautious economy in the early 1990s to a confident, investment-aware nation today. And at the heart of this change lies one simple, yet powerful idea: an informed investor is an empowered citizen. Best MF to invest Looking for the best mutual funds to invest? Here are our recommendations. View Details » by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like AirSense 11 – Smart tech for deep sleep ResMed Buy Now Undo From Monopoly to Market Movement: Starting from 1963 and well into the 1980s, the mutual fund industry was a single player domain- dominated by the state-owned UTI - catering to a limited number of investors. Market maturity was low, retail participation was negligible, and large institutions often influenced market movements. Live Events The early 1990s were a turning point. The early 1990s were a turning point. Economic liberalisation opened India's economy, and the creation of SEBI as an independent regulator brought much-needed structure, credibility, and investor protection to our capital markets. It was in this backdrop that AMFI was born in 1995, with a mission far greater than industry representation — to instill trust, transparency, and investor-centricity in the DNA of mutual funds, and to take investment awareness to every corner of India. Pioneering a Culture of Awareness and Inclusion Over the years, AMFI worked alongside SEBI to strengthen regulation and set benchmarks for self-regulation. The shift to NAV-based pricing was a watershed moment — for the first time, investors could see the daily value of their holdings, making wealth creation transparent and relatable. In the late 1990s, we introduced Systematic Investment Plans (SIPs) — a quiet revolution that democratised investing. No longer was wealth creation the privilege of the affluent. Even the smallest saver could participate in India's growth story with as little as ₹500 a month. Initiatives such as the Riskometer, Scheme Categorisation Norms, and Uniform Disclosure Standards simplified mutual funds for millions. KYC norms, and later e-KYC, streamlined onboarding, while technology opened new frontiers for distribution and service. Resilience Through Challenges, Growth Through Trust The industry faced its share of challenges — the 2008 Global Financial Crisis, the 2012 Taper Tantrum, and volatile market cycles. Each time, we emerged stronger, not just in numbers but in investor confidence. By the mid-2010s, mutual funds had crossed ₹10 trillion in assets under management (AUM). Between 2014 and 2017, AUM doubled to ₹20 trillion, and by November 2020, crossed ₹30 trillion. The last five years have been the most remarkable yet. From June 2020 to July 2025, AUM has tripled to ₹75 trillion. Investor folios now exceed 240 million, with nearly 2.5 million new folios being added every month — a clear testament to growing trust and awareness. From Metro to Mohalla: Taking Awareness Nationwide This surge is no longer limited to metros. Today, a first-time earner in a Tier-3 town is just as likely to start their financial journey with a mutual fund as someone in Mumbai or Delhi. The turning point was 2017, when AMFI launched the 'Mutual Fund Sahi Hai' campaign — breaking the myth that mutual funds were only for the wealthy, and speaking to every Indian in their own language. It took investment awareness to the smallest towns, rural markets, and digital screens across the country. Digitisation has been a game changer — with smartphones and UPI, investing in a mutual fund has become as simple as sending a text message. The Next Chapter: Financial Literacy as a National Mission As India marches towards Viksit Bharat, we see our role going beyond AUM numbers. Our next frontier is clear: Improve financial literacy in schools, colleges, workplaces, and communities. Create financial independence by empowering citizens with the knowledge to save, invest, and plan for their future. Reach the unreached — the hundreds of millions of Indians who have yet to take their first step into formal investing. We envision a future where every Indian household has an investment plan, where women and youth lead the way in disciplined savings, and where financial security becomes a way of life, not a privilege. Investor First, Always Our journey has always been about more than products or performance. It has been about trust built patiently over decades, discipline nurtured through awareness, and empowerment delivered through education. At AMFI, we remain steadfast in keeping the investor-first approach at the heart of everything we do. Because when investors grow, India grows. And when India grows, the dream of Viksit Bharat will not just be a vision — it will be a reality. As the Bhagavad Gita wisely teaches us: 'Karmanye vadhikaraste, Ma phaleshou kada chana' You have the right to perform your actions, but not to the fruits thereof. This timeless wisdom captures the spirit that guides us — to act with integrity, dedication, and unwavering purpose. At AMFI, our commitment remains clear: to empower every Indian with the knowledge and tools to invest wisely and build a secure future. Because when we focus on the right actions, the outcomes — for the investor, the industry, and the nation — will follow. (The author Venkat N Chalasani is Chief Executive – Association of Mutual Funds in India (AMFI). Views are own)
India Today
2 hours ago
- India Today
What nobody tells you about buying motor insurance
India's passenger vehicle market is rising, with more people buying cars than ever before. In FY25, domestic wholesale sales touched 4.30 million units, up 1.97% from 4.22 million units in while car sales are climbing, many buyers remain unaware about the finer points of motor insurance, a gap that can cost them money and create problems when making a INSURANCE MARKET IS GROWING FASTThe motor insurance market in India is already large and growing fast. Expert Market Research values it at USD 11.39 billion in 2024, while IMARC Group puts it at USD 29.80 billion and Mordor Intelligence at USD 13.19 2034, the market is expected to cross USD 30 billion, growing at an annual rate of 7.13% to 10.40%. Motor insurance makes up 31.68% of the general insurance sector and recorded 13% growth in of September 2024, it continues to grow at 9%, driven by higher vehicle ownership, rules that make insurance compulsory, more people buying policies online, and the rising demand for specialised cover for electric MISTAKES FIRST-TIME BUYERS MAKEHowever, experts say that many people still make avoidable mistakes when buying a policy, especially first-time Kumar, Sebi-registered investment adviser and founder of Sahaj Money, said, 'Many first-time motor insurance buyers make the beginner's mistake of buying only basic third-party coverage without comparing other policies. They also underestimate required coverage, don't provide correct details, or don't go through policy terms, which could later lead to claim rejection.'One of the most important decisions for a buyer is setting the Insured Declared Value (IDV) of the advises, 'First-time buyers should decide about the vehicle's IDV based on its current market value instead of basing the coverage on its sale price. They should also go for comprehensive coverage and not just third-party coverage.'CHOOSING ADD-ONS WISELYAdd-ons are another area where many car owners are unsure. According to Kumar, 'A coverage which provides zero depreciation, engine protection, and roadside assistance as part of the coverage is a great option as it would help in reducing out-of-pocket expenses and help in emergencies or major repairs.'On the other hand, he said that some add-ons are often unnecessary: 'Add-on cover which provide benefits such as daily allowance, excessive consumables, tyre protection (unless roads are very rough), and loss of belongings are often bought but rarely claimed or needed by vehicle owners.'Balancing cost and coverage is also key. 'Buyers should use online insurance aggregator sites to compare policies online, then tailor their IDV accordingly, choose only needed add-ons, leverage No Claim Bonus, and consider voluntary deductibles to cut premium costs,' says THE FINE PRINT BEFORE SIGNINGHe also warns against skipping the fine print. 'First-time buyers should look for exclusions, deductibles, limits on claims, add-on conditions, renewal rules, and claim procedure before finalising the policy as missing out on these details can affect what they can actually claim and have to pay.'With car ownership growing and the motor insurance market expanding rapidly, better awareness about coverage types, add-ons, costs, and policy terms can help buyers avoid expensive mistakes and ensure that their insurance truly protects them when needed.- Ends advertisement
