Judgment on Sabah's 40pc federal revenue claim delayed, High Court sets Aug 7 for next steps
High Court judge Justice Datuk Celestina Stuel Galid fixed the date on Monday following the conclusion of the substantive hearing, noting that additional time was needed due to the complexity and volume of documents in the case, according to The Star.
While courts typically deliver decisions within four weeks, Justice Stuel said this case required further consideration before judgment could be issued.
The August 7 e-review will decide whether more clarification is required or if a judgment date can be scheduled.
SLS filed the judicial review in June 2022, challenging the Federal Government's alleged failure to uphold Sabah's constitutional revenue rights.
The High Court granted leave in November 2022, and subsequent appeals by the Federal Government to the Court of Appeal and Federal Court were dismissed unanimously.
This allowed the case to proceed to a full hearing on its merits at the High Court.
SLS is represented by Dr David Fung and a legal team comprising Jeyan Marimuttu, Janice Lim, and Grace Liew, while the Federal Government is represented by Senior Federal Counsel Ahmad Hanir Hambaly @ Arwi and others.
The Sabah government is represented by state Attorney General Datuk Brenndon Soh, along with Devina Teo and Roland Alik.
On Monday morning, several state assemblymen attended the proceedings, including former chief ministers Datuk Seri Mohd Shafie Apdal and Datuk Yong Teck Lee.
Also present were assemblymen Datuk Darell Leiking (Moyog), Assaffal P. Alian (Tungku), Calvin Chong (Elopura), and Justin Wong (Sri Tanjong), as well as former Kota Kinabalu MP Datuk Jimmy Wong Sze Phin and Science, Technology and Innovation Ministry permanent secretary Datuk Mohd Hanafiah Mohd Kassim.
Deputy Chief Minister Datuk Seri Jeffrey Kitingan joined the court in the afternoon session.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Malay Mail
26 minutes ago
- Malay Mail
Tok Mat: BN to defend all seats, reclaim traditional constituencies ceded to Bersatu in last Sabah polls
KUALA LUMPUR, Aug 16 — Barisan Nasional (BN) will contest all the seats it currently holds in Sabah and move to reclaim traditional constituencies that were previously handed to Parti Pribumi Bersatu Malaysia (Bersatu) in the last state election (PRN). BN deputy chairman Datuk Seri Mohamad Hasan said this to Sinar Harian when asked about seat distribution for the Sabah polls, expected later this year after the State Legislative Assembly automatically dissolves on November 11. He stressed that BN remains firm in its stand to return to its traditional seats, which he said were 'given away' to a coalition partner during the previous state election. 'We will remain firm in contesting the seats we won, as well as the traditional seats that were previously handed over to Bersatu. 'During the last Sabah polls, many Umno-BN traditional seats were given to Bersatu in the spirit of cooperation. 'But in the end, we were stabbed in the back. We do not want that to happen again,' he reportedly said after officiating the joint delegates' meeting of the Rembau Umno Women's, Youth and Puteri wings in Seremban today. Mohamad also underlined that Umno-BN must emerge as the dominant party in Sabah after the coming election. On Gabungan Rakyat Sabah's (GRS) plan to contest 39 seats, he said this would depend on the outcome of ongoing negotiations. 'We have appointed the Umno secretary-general and the BN secretary-general to negotiate on seat distribution. 'What matters is that BN and Pakatan Harapan (PH) have finalised their cooperation to face the Sabah polls. The rest is still open,' he said, as cited by the national daily. He added that BN does not want to lock itself too tightly into early discussions, preferring to give space to the joint committee to work out the most effective cooperation and allocation of seats. 'We want the negotiations to be concluded quickly because the election is drawing near. 'The grassroots machinery must understand and be clear about the party's direction as we head into this election,' he said.
Malay Mail
an hour ago
- Malay Mail
Women's minister says no need for new anti-bullying law, Penal Code sufficient
KUALA LUMPUR, Aug 16 — Malaysia does not need a new law to tackle bullying as the offence is already covered under the Penal Code, Datuk Seri Nancy Shukri said today. Harian Metro reported that the women, family and community development minister said stricter enforcement is more important than drafting new laws, though amendments could be considered if necessary. 'The Penal Code states that bullying is a criminal offence and provides for a fine of up to RM3,000. This shows the current mechanism remains relevant and enforceable,' she told reporters in Kuching. 'At this stage, there is no need to draft a new law. What matters is strict implementation and enforcement.' She added that evolving circumstances may provide ideas for strengthening existing legislation, but responsibility for lawmaking lies with the Legal Affairs Division of the Prime Minister's Department. 'However, we can make proposals or raise ideas in Cabinet discussions if there are issues on bullying that need to be addressed,' she was quoted as saying by the national daily. Nancy also stressed the role of parents, schools and the wider community in curbing bullying, which has sparked public concern following a spate of cases in schools and universities that went viral on social media. Her comments came after the Anti-Bullying Act Advocacy Movement (GAB) urged the government to introduce legislation to define bullying, set out preventive measures and establish complaint procedures. GAB said current laws, including the Penal Code and the Child Act 2001, lack specific provisions and do not adequately protect victims.
Malay Mail
an hour ago
- Malay Mail
Zahid: Multi-cornered fights in Sabah polls ‘unavoidable' despite BN-Pakatan pact
KUALA LUMPUR, Aug 16 — Barisan Nasional (BN) has confirmed that it has not held any official discussions with Gabungan Rakyat Sabah (GRS) on seat negotiations or cooperation ahead of the Sabah state election. According to national daily Utusan Malaysia, BN chairman Datuk Seri Ahmad Zahid Hamidi acknowledged that at least three-cornered fights were unavoidable due to the likelihood of participation by other parties, including new ones. He stressed, however, that there would be no clashes or overlapping seats between BN and its ally, Pakatan Harapan (PH), while respecting negotiations between PH and GRS. 'What has been finalised is BN-PH, and we respect PH-GRS. There are no direct negotiations between BN and GRS. So far, any other talks to avoid three-cornered contests or overlapping seats are taking place behind the scenes. 'However, I believe that with so many new parties in Sabah wanting to contest this time, three-cornered contests cannot be avoided — it could even go up to eight-cornered fights. 'That's the reality of Sabah's political landscape. But BN and PH will not clash in any seats,' he told reporters at the 16th National-level Civil Defence Student Corps (Kor Sispa) Graduation Parade and Commissioning Ceremony in Shah Alam today. Utusan Malaysia previously reported that efforts to form a BN-PH-GRS coalition to face the Sabah polls, expected in October, were becoming increasingly difficult as seat negotiations had reached an impasse. Although such a coalition was seen as a way to avoid vote-splitting and secure a majority victory, GRS' demand to contest at least 70 out of the 73 state assembly seats has raised concerns, particularly in BN's traditional strongholds. If GRS insists on its demand, the chances of forming a grand coalition may collapse. But if GRS is willing to soften its stance and renegotiate, the path towards establishing a unity government at the state level could still be realised.
