Dr. Lindsay C. Gibson Thinks Compassion for Our Parents Can Be a Trap

New York Times

22-03-2025

We live in a culture permeated by therapy, one in which people are eager to apply psychotherapeutic concepts to themselves and their closest relationships. That includes, naturally, the relationship with our parents. But the desire to understand the hows and whys of our parents' emotional influence is hardly new. Indeed, a classic poem by Philip Larkin, 'This Be the Verse,' was buzzing around my mind as I prepared for this interview with the clinical psychologist Dr. Lindsay C. Gibson, author of the book 'Adult Children of Emotionally Immature Parents.' Larkin's poem begins like this: 'They mess you up, your mum and dad./They may not mean to, but they do./They fill you with the faults they had/And add some extra, just for you.' (Poetry aficionados will notice I swapped in a clean word for a foul one. Forgive me, Philip.)
But what do we do with the age-old knowledge that parents can bend us in damaging ways? That's where Gibson comes in. Her book has become a slow-burning best seller since it was published in 2015 and has earned a devoted following on social media, where videos of people talking about it have been seen by millions. In the book, Gibson argues that a key to understanding harmful parental behaviors is, as her title suggests, the notion of emotional immaturity. Furthermore, that parental immaturity has negative ripple effects for children that last into adulthood. But thankfully, she says, it's possible to get out from under the weight of those emotionally immature parents. Even if that means, in drastic cases, breaking off the relationship entirely.
So as someone for whom Larkin's poem rings true, I had much to ask Gibson, as well as a fair degree of skepticism about her work to put to her, all of which she was game to entertain, and all of which can still at times leave me muttering to myself: 'Parents. Oy.'
Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Spotify | YouTube | Amazon | iHeart | NYT Audio App
The broad definition of emotionally immature parents is parents who refuse to validate their children's feelings and intuitions, who might be reactive and who are lacking in empathy or awareness. But can you give me examples of emotionally immature behaviors? The biggest one is egocentrism. Imagine that a person starts and ends all their consideration with what's best for them — that's egocentrism. I just started watching 'The Sopranos' for the first time. If you listen to the dialogue, they completely nailed it, because everything always comes back to the viewpoint of the emotionally immature character. It's always all about them. Another one is the lack of empathy. The parent just doesn't get it. They say, 'Why are you so upset about this?' Or, 'This is not a big deal.' They cannot enter into the reality of their child's emotional truth.
Those characteristics can show up even among the best parents sometimes. So how do people distinguish between normal, flawed parental behavior and behavior that's detrimental enough to rise to the label of 'emotionally immature'? If you think of emotional maturity and immaturity as being on a continuum, all of us have a spot that we tend to hang out on. It doesn't mean that we stay there. If you're tired or you're sick or you're stressed, you are not going to be as emotionally mature as you could be when you're rested and well and not stressed. However, if you're in one of these compromised states, you may do some things that look immature, but it's going to bother you. You're going to think about what you did. The emotionally immature person, it's like: 'That was in the past. Why are you wallowing in it?' The more emotionally mature person would get why you're still upset, and they're going to do something that indicates that they have felt for the other person's experience.
Want all of The Times? Subscribe.