Woodside boss roasted for accusing Gen Z of fueling emissions hypocrisy
The boss of gas giant Woodside has ignited a storm of backlash after critics slammed her attack on Gen Z as 'tone-deaf' and 'out of touch.'
Speaking on Tuesday, Meg O'Neill had raised the impact of ultra-fast fashion brands such as Temu and Shein, which have surged in popularity after entering the market with extremely competitive prices.
'It's been a fascinating journey to watch the discussion, particularly amongst young people, who have this very ideological, almost zealous, view of 'fossil fuels bad, renewables good,'' she said, as reported by The West Australian.
'But (they) are happily plugging in their devices, ordering things from Shein and Temu, having one little thing shipped to their house without any recognition of the energy and carbon impact of their actions.
'The consumer's role in driving energy demand and emissions is a missing space in the conversation.'
Greens leader Larissa Waters dismissed the comments, saying 'you couldn't make something like that up'.
'Here is a very well-paid, wealthy fossil fuel executive trying to claim with a straight face that the climate crisis is the fault of young people shopping online for goods they can afford in a cost-of-living crisis,' she said.
'You can't be the head of a massive dirty gas company and point the finger at other people about the climate crisis.'
O'Neill's comments came a day before newly-minted federal environment minister Murray Watt provisionally approved Woodside's proposal to extend its North West Shelf project in Western Australia, subject to conditions including impact on air emission levels.
Traditional owners have raised concerns about the impact of the expanded project on sacred rock art and have launched legal action in a bid to compel Senator Watt to protect the artwork.
Woodside Executive Vice President Liz Westcott said the proposed approval 'will secure the ongoing operation of the North West Shelf and the thousands of direct and indirect jobs.'
'This nationally significant infrastructure has supplied reliable and affordable energy to Western Australia for 40 years and international customers for 35 years, and will be able to continue its contribution to energy security,' Westcott said.
'Since starting operations in 1984, the North West Shelf Project has paid over $40 billion in royalties and taxes, and supported regional development opportunities in the Pilbara.'
Woodside said it is reviewing the conditions relating to cultural heritage management and air quality.
Senator Watt rejected last-minute objections to the extension from Greenpeace and the Conservation Council of WA, which said the minister had declined to meet them.
Research released by the Australia Institute showed that emissions from the planned extension would be equivalent to 33 years of Australia's entire emissions.
It is one of the biggest proposed fossil fuel developments in the world, and it would make climate change worse, research director Rod Campbell said.
'Vast amounts of gas are exported… by a handful of predominantly foreign-owned corporations that get most of the gas for free and pay no resources tax on the gas they export,' he said.
'We would never consider allowing dozens of new coal power stations, yet Woodside's gas export expansion plans would have even more emissions.'
The Offshore Alliance, a partnership between the Australian Workers' Union and the Maritime Union of Australia, backed the government's decision, saying it secured 'the future of hundreds of our members and their families.'
'What Minister Watt has done today ensures these union wages will continue to flow into communities in north-west WA for decades to come,' alliance secretary Brad Gandy said.
'All federal ministers should respect and acknowledge the value of workers within this important industry.
'To transition to a net-zero future, we need fuels for firming capacity as renewable energy sources are built and connected to the grid, and our members are very proud to be a crucial part of that transition.'
'Climate bomb'
The Climate Council described the government's decision as a 'failure of leadership' and a 'polluting stain on its climate record.'
'Communities in NSW are starting the cleanup after record-breaking floods. It is shocking that at the same time the Albanese Government has approved this massive climate bomb as the first act of this term of government,' Council Chief Executive Amanda McKenzie said.
'They've just opened the floodgates on over 4 billion tonnes of climate pollution.'
Greenpeace Australia Pacific argued the approval would bring 'Woodside's destructive gas drills one step closer to Scott Reef, a magnificent marine ecosystem that is home to threatened species like pygmy blue whales and green sea turtles.'
Stream free on
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Advertiser
7 hours ago
- The Advertiser
Carbon tariff on the table for overseas businesses
Labor has left the door open to a tax on cement and steel coming in from places not taking sufficient climate action. Energy Minister Chris Bowen said Australia remained on-track to meet its legislated 43 per cent by 2030 emissions reduction target but that the nation needed to do more to achieve it. Asked if a carbon tariff - a tax charged on imports - was still a prospect, Mr Bowen flagged particular sectors were being considered. But consultation with Australian industry was still underway, he added. "I've had lots of meetings with steel makers and cement makers about these things over the past 12 months ... getting their feedback, and we'll have more to say during the course of this term," he told the ABC on Sunday. Mr Bowen said gas giant Woodside will be required to ensure the North West Shelf project meets net-zero emissions by 2050. Woodside hosts Australia's biggest gas export plant, and last week was given approval by the Albanese government to keep operating until 2070. The move has been slammed by environmental groups. "In effect, all the facilities covered, the more than 200 facilities covered by the safeguard mechanism are obliged to have a pathway to net-zero," the minister said. The mechanism is a policy designed to limit emissions at Australia's largest industrial facilities in line with the nation's climate targets. Religious leaders in Western Australia have expressed their disappointment at the 40-year expansion given to the energy giant. Reverend Ken Devereux, from the Australian Religious Response to Climate Change, said the next test for the government was to make sure the Browse project does not go ahead. Woodside has been trying to get environmental approvals for the $30 billion Browse gas project off the Kimberley coast since 2018. "We believe that moral and ethical choices for the greater good for humanity and creation need to take precedence over the benefits to fossil fuel corporations and the short-term economy," Rev Devereux said. Asked if approving gas projects would make it harder for Australia to win a global climate summit it is bidding to co-host with Pacific Island nations next year, Mr Bowen said these decisions would always be controversial. "I don't deny that, but we'll always set Australia's domestic policy in Australia's domestic best interest," he said. "There's a great opportunity for our country, (it) restores Australia's leadership in climate against the bad years of the decade of denial and delay, (and) shows we're back in a very meaningful way". Turkey is also bidding for the climate talks, with the energy minister hopeful the issue is resolved soon. Mr Bowen said Australia remains on track to reduce emissions by 43 per cent by 2030, despite a small increase in emissions last year. He also ruled out a retrospective domestic gas reservation policy to existing fields. Labor has left the door open to a tax on cement and steel coming in from places not taking sufficient climate action. Energy Minister Chris Bowen said Australia remained on-track to meet its legislated 43 per cent by 2030 emissions reduction target but that the nation needed to do more to achieve it. Asked if a carbon tariff - a tax charged on imports - was still a prospect, Mr Bowen flagged particular sectors were being considered. But consultation with Australian industry was still underway, he added. "I've had lots of meetings with steel makers and cement makers about these things over the past 12 months ... getting their feedback, and we'll have more to say during the course of this term," he told the ABC on Sunday. Mr Bowen said gas giant Woodside will be required to ensure the North West Shelf project meets net-zero emissions by 2050. Woodside hosts Australia's biggest gas export plant, and last week was given approval by the Albanese government to keep operating until 2070. The move has been slammed by environmental groups. "In effect, all the facilities covered, the more than 200 facilities covered by the safeguard mechanism are obliged to have a pathway to net-zero," the minister said. The mechanism is a policy designed to limit emissions at Australia's largest industrial facilities in line with the nation's climate targets. Religious leaders in Western Australia have expressed their disappointment at the 40-year expansion given to the energy giant. Reverend Ken Devereux, from the Australian Religious Response to Climate Change, said the next test for the government was to make sure the Browse project does not go ahead. Woodside has been trying to get environmental approvals for the $30 billion Browse gas project off the Kimberley coast since 2018. "We believe that moral and ethical choices for the greater good for humanity and creation need to take precedence over the benefits to fossil fuel corporations and the short-term economy," Rev Devereux said. Asked if approving gas projects would make it harder for Australia to win a global climate summit it is bidding to co-host with Pacific Island nations next year, Mr Bowen said these decisions would always be controversial. "I don't deny that, but we'll always set Australia's domestic policy in Australia's domestic best interest," he said. "There's a great opportunity for our country, (it) restores Australia's leadership in climate against the bad years of the decade of denial and delay, (and) shows we're back in a very meaningful way". Turkey is also bidding for the climate talks, with the energy minister hopeful the issue is resolved soon. Mr Bowen said Australia remains on track to reduce emissions by 43 per cent by 2030, despite a small increase in emissions last year. He also ruled out a retrospective domestic gas reservation policy to existing fields. Labor has left the door open to a tax on cement and steel coming in from places not taking sufficient climate action. Energy Minister Chris Bowen said Australia remained on-track to meet its legislated 43 per cent by 2030 emissions reduction target but that the nation needed to do more to achieve it. Asked if a carbon tariff - a tax charged on imports - was still a prospect, Mr Bowen flagged particular sectors were being considered. But consultation with Australian industry was still underway, he added. "I've had lots of meetings with steel makers and cement makers about these things over the past 12 months ... getting their feedback, and we'll have more to say during the course of this term," he told the ABC on Sunday. Mr Bowen said gas giant Woodside will be required to ensure the North West Shelf project meets net-zero emissions by 2050. Woodside hosts Australia's biggest gas export plant, and last week was given approval by the Albanese government to keep operating until 2070. The move has been slammed by environmental groups. "In effect, all the facilities covered, the more than 200 facilities covered by the safeguard mechanism are obliged to have a pathway to net-zero," the minister said. The mechanism is a policy designed to limit emissions at Australia's largest industrial facilities in line with the nation's climate targets. Religious leaders in Western Australia have expressed their disappointment at the 40-year expansion given to the energy giant. Reverend Ken Devereux, from the Australian Religious Response to Climate Change, said the next test for the government was to make sure the Browse project does not go ahead. Woodside has been trying to get environmental approvals for the $30 billion Browse gas project off the Kimberley coast since 2018. "We believe that moral and ethical choices for the greater good for humanity and creation need to take precedence over the benefits to fossil fuel corporations and the short-term economy," Rev Devereux said. Asked if approving gas projects would make it harder for Australia to win a global climate summit it is bidding to co-host with Pacific Island nations next year, Mr Bowen said these decisions would always be controversial. "I don't deny that, but we'll always set Australia's domestic policy in Australia's domestic best interest," he said. "There's a great opportunity for our country, (it) restores Australia's leadership in climate against the bad years of the decade of denial and delay, (and) shows we're back in a very meaningful way". Turkey is also bidding for the climate talks, with the energy minister hopeful the issue is resolved soon. Mr Bowen said Australia remains on track to reduce emissions by 43 per cent by 2030, despite a small increase in emissions last year. He also ruled out a retrospective domestic gas reservation policy to existing fields. Labor has left the door open to a tax on cement and steel coming in from places not taking sufficient climate action. Energy Minister Chris Bowen said Australia remained on-track to meet its legislated 43 per cent by 2030 emissions reduction target but that the nation needed to do more to achieve it. Asked if a carbon tariff - a tax charged on imports - was still a prospect, Mr Bowen flagged particular sectors were being considered. But consultation with Australian industry was still underway, he added. "I've had lots of meetings with steel makers and cement makers about these things over the past 12 months ... getting their feedback, and we'll have more to say during the course of this term," he told the ABC on Sunday. Mr Bowen said gas giant Woodside will be required to ensure the North West Shelf project meets net-zero emissions by 2050. Woodside hosts Australia's biggest gas export plant, and last week was given approval by the Albanese government to keep operating until 2070. The move has been slammed by environmental groups. "In effect, all the facilities covered, the more than 200 facilities covered by the safeguard mechanism are obliged to have a pathway to net-zero," the minister said. The mechanism is a policy designed to limit emissions at Australia's largest industrial facilities in line with the nation's climate targets. Religious leaders in Western Australia have expressed their disappointment at the 40-year expansion given to the energy giant. Reverend Ken Devereux, from the Australian Religious Response to Climate Change, said the next test for the government was to make sure the Browse project does not go ahead. Woodside has been trying to get environmental approvals for the $30 billion Browse gas project off the Kimberley coast since 2018. "We believe that moral and ethical choices for the greater good for humanity and creation need to take precedence over the benefits to fossil fuel corporations and the short-term economy," Rev Devereux said. Asked if approving gas projects would make it harder for Australia to win a global climate summit it is bidding to co-host with Pacific Island nations next year, Mr Bowen said these decisions would always be controversial. "I don't deny that, but we'll always set Australia's domestic policy in Australia's domestic best interest," he said. "There's a great opportunity for our country, (it) restores Australia's leadership in climate against the bad years of the decade of denial and delay, (and) shows we're back in a very meaningful way". Turkey is also bidding for the climate talks, with the energy minister hopeful the issue is resolved soon. Mr Bowen said Australia remains on track to reduce emissions by 43 per cent by 2030, despite a small increase in emissions last year. He also ruled out a retrospective domestic gas reservation policy to existing fields.
Sky News AU
13 hours ago
- Sky News AU
Chris Bowen says government could slap green tariffs on carbon intensive imports whilst stating Australia remains ‘on track' to achieve 2030 renewables target
Energy and Climate Change Minister Chris Bowen has stated the Albanese government is considering enforcing targeted levies on carbon intensive imports and reiterated Australia was on track to meet its 2030 emission reduction targets despite new figures indicating otherwise. After Environment Minister Murray Watt controversially decided to approve Woodside's North West Shelf gas project extension until 2070, the government has faced increased scrutiny about its climate and environmental commitments. Mr Bowen, appearing on the ABC's Insiders program said the government was open to considering new policies if needed to meet its targets, including leveraging targeted tariffs to ensure companies were not offshoring emitting activities and avoiding Australia's climate laws. The energy minister said the government would have 'more to say' about its plan to impose green tariffs on a range of emission-intensive imports including cement and steel. Labor launched a review into the practice known as carbon 'leakage' and 'carbon border adjustment mechanisms' (CBAM's) which seek to protect local industry from imports which are not adhering to Australia's emission standards and maintain competition in the energy transition. The review, which was handed down to Mr Bowen earlier this year indicated that clinker, cement and lime were prone to high leakage levels, whilst ammonia, glass and steel posed a moderate risk. Despite not publishing the contents of the Jotzo review nor indicating if the government would consider its recommendations, Mr Bowen said that any levies would be specific and that he would not pre-empt the call. 'I urge against sweeping generalisations about policy settings and, you know, what could be the case is obviously we look at particular sectors, first around cement and lime,' he said. "We have been clear that we want to ensure Australian industry is best placed to compete in a decarbonising world," he said. "What could be the case is we look at particular sectors first around cement and lime, [which] are places that we looked at in particular, but I'm not going to get in front of the process. Mr Bowen remained coy on altering liquified natural gas agreements to initiate an east coast gas reservation plan, in a similar vain to that proposed by the Coalition during the recent federal election campaign. As concern for gas shortages in the coming years increases, Mr Bowen was asked if the government was considering enacting its gas security mechanism to establish an east coast reservation, of which Resources Minister Madeleine King stated in recent days was under review. 'We made clear that there are a number of policies that are up for review,' Mr Bowen said. 'They're coming to their review time and the gas mechanism, the gas code we'll look at those and see what more can be done.' However, when pressed if Labor was contemplating altering the rules governing the wholesale gas market, Mr Bowen said the government would not modify existing contracts to bolster supply to the east coast. 'No, we have a very clear matter of principle that we don't agree with sovereign risk. We don't agree with retrospective policy actions. I think that is uncontroversial, that is good governance.' He also remained confidant that Australia would achieve its 2030 target of 82 per cent renewable energy generation, despite numerous industry magnates raising the alarm about the government's renewables timeline and green hydrogen programs. 'We're now at 46 per cent renewables in the last quarter last year and 43 per cent in the first quarter of this year. It moves from quarter to quarter,' Mr Bowen said. 'The 82 per cent target does have challenges. I never suggested it's a linear line. The federal government will be required in the coming months to legislate it's 2035 emission reduction targets, which will be finalised once the Climate Change Authority, chaired by former NSW Liberal Treasurer Matt Kean hands down it's advice. With the 2035 target yet to be unveiled, Mr Bowen said the governments approach would be 'ambitious and achievable'.
The Advertiser
14 hours ago
- The Advertiser
Gas project extension will need to meet net-zero
Woodside will be required under the safeguard mechanism to ensure a gas project extension meets net-zero emissions by 2050. The energy giant's North West Shelf project, which hosts Australia's biggest gas export plant, was last week given approval by the Albanese government to keep operating until 2070. The safeguard mechanism is a policy designed to limit emissions at Australia's largest industrial facilities in line with the nation's climate targets of 43 per cent below 2005 levels by 2030 and net-zero by 2050. Asked if Woodside had to get the project down to net-zero emissions, Energy Minister Chris Bowen replied "yes". "This will be legally obliged and required under our safeguard mechanism to meet net-zero by 2050," he told ABC's Insiders on Sunday. "In effect, all the facilities covered, the more than 200 facilities covered by the safeguard mechanism are obliged to have a pathway to net-zero." Asked if approving gas projects would make it harder for Australia to win a global climate summit it is bidding to co-host with Pacific Island nations next year, Mr Bowen said these decisions would always be controversial. "I don't deny that, but we'll always set Australia's domestic policy in Australia's domestic best interest," he said. "There's a great opportunity for our country, (it) restores Australia's leadership in climate against the bad years of the decade of denial and delay, (and) shows we're back in a very meaningful way". Turkey is also bidding for the climate talks, with the energy minister hopeful the issue is resolved soon. Mr Bowen said Australia remains on track to reduce emissions by 43 per cent by 2030, despite a small increase in emissions last year. He also ruled out a retrospective domestic gas reservation policy to existing fields. During the federal election campaign, the coalition promised to redirect gas to domestic users. Woodside will be required under the safeguard mechanism to ensure a gas project extension meets net-zero emissions by 2050. The energy giant's North West Shelf project, which hosts Australia's biggest gas export plant, was last week given approval by the Albanese government to keep operating until 2070. The safeguard mechanism is a policy designed to limit emissions at Australia's largest industrial facilities in line with the nation's climate targets of 43 per cent below 2005 levels by 2030 and net-zero by 2050. Asked if Woodside had to get the project down to net-zero emissions, Energy Minister Chris Bowen replied "yes". "This will be legally obliged and required under our safeguard mechanism to meet net-zero by 2050," he told ABC's Insiders on Sunday. "In effect, all the facilities covered, the more than 200 facilities covered by the safeguard mechanism are obliged to have a pathway to net-zero." Asked if approving gas projects would make it harder for Australia to win a global climate summit it is bidding to co-host with Pacific Island nations next year, Mr Bowen said these decisions would always be controversial. "I don't deny that, but we'll always set Australia's domestic policy in Australia's domestic best interest," he said. "There's a great opportunity for our country, (it) restores Australia's leadership in climate against the bad years of the decade of denial and delay, (and) shows we're back in a very meaningful way". Turkey is also bidding for the climate talks, with the energy minister hopeful the issue is resolved soon. Mr Bowen said Australia remains on track to reduce emissions by 43 per cent by 2030, despite a small increase in emissions last year. He also ruled out a retrospective domestic gas reservation policy to existing fields. During the federal election campaign, the coalition promised to redirect gas to domestic users. Woodside will be required under the safeguard mechanism to ensure a gas project extension meets net-zero emissions by 2050. The energy giant's North West Shelf project, which hosts Australia's biggest gas export plant, was last week given approval by the Albanese government to keep operating until 2070. The safeguard mechanism is a policy designed to limit emissions at Australia's largest industrial facilities in line with the nation's climate targets of 43 per cent below 2005 levels by 2030 and net-zero by 2050. Asked if Woodside had to get the project down to net-zero emissions, Energy Minister Chris Bowen replied "yes". "This will be legally obliged and required under our safeguard mechanism to meet net-zero by 2050," he told ABC's Insiders on Sunday. "In effect, all the facilities covered, the more than 200 facilities covered by the safeguard mechanism are obliged to have a pathway to net-zero." Asked if approving gas projects would make it harder for Australia to win a global climate summit it is bidding to co-host with Pacific Island nations next year, Mr Bowen said these decisions would always be controversial. "I don't deny that, but we'll always set Australia's domestic policy in Australia's domestic best interest," he said. "There's a great opportunity for our country, (it) restores Australia's leadership in climate against the bad years of the decade of denial and delay, (and) shows we're back in a very meaningful way". Turkey is also bidding for the climate talks, with the energy minister hopeful the issue is resolved soon. Mr Bowen said Australia remains on track to reduce emissions by 43 per cent by 2030, despite a small increase in emissions last year. He also ruled out a retrospective domestic gas reservation policy to existing fields. During the federal election campaign, the coalition promised to redirect gas to domestic users. Woodside will be required under the safeguard mechanism to ensure a gas project extension meets net-zero emissions by 2050. The energy giant's North West Shelf project, which hosts Australia's biggest gas export plant, was last week given approval by the Albanese government to keep operating until 2070. The safeguard mechanism is a policy designed to limit emissions at Australia's largest industrial facilities in line with the nation's climate targets of 43 per cent below 2005 levels by 2030 and net-zero by 2050. Asked if Woodside had to get the project down to net-zero emissions, Energy Minister Chris Bowen replied "yes". "This will be legally obliged and required under our safeguard mechanism to meet net-zero by 2050," he told ABC's Insiders on Sunday. "In effect, all the facilities covered, the more than 200 facilities covered by the safeguard mechanism are obliged to have a pathway to net-zero." Asked if approving gas projects would make it harder for Australia to win a global climate summit it is bidding to co-host with Pacific Island nations next year, Mr Bowen said these decisions would always be controversial. "I don't deny that, but we'll always set Australia's domestic policy in Australia's domestic best interest," he said. "There's a great opportunity for our country, (it) restores Australia's leadership in climate against the bad years of the decade of denial and delay, (and) shows we're back in a very meaningful way". Turkey is also bidding for the climate talks, with the energy minister hopeful the issue is resolved soon. Mr Bowen said Australia remains on track to reduce emissions by 43 per cent by 2030, despite a small increase in emissions last year. He also ruled out a retrospective domestic gas reservation policy to existing fields. During the federal election campaign, the coalition promised to redirect gas to domestic users.
