Indian emails ‘akin to spam': New Zealand minister Erica Stanford's slur draws ire
New Zealand's Minister of Immigration, Erica Stanford, has come under significant criticism for remarks perceived as racially insensitive towards Indians, following a parliamentary exchange that likened emails from Indians seeking immigration advice to spam. The comments provoked a strong response, notably from Indian-origin Labour Party MP Priyanca Radhakrishnan, who was born in Chennai.
On 6 May 2025, during a parliamentary session, Labour MP Willow-Jean Prime asked Minister Stanford to confirm whether every email related to her ministerial portfolios sent to or from her personal email account had been properly recorded, as required by the Cabinet Manual. Stanford replied, 'I have complied with the Official Information Act. I have also made sure that everything is available to be captured and have forwarded everything that I've needed to to my parliamentary email address.'
However, Stanford then added a contentious remark: 'I will acknowledge, though, in a very similar case to Kelvin Davis, I receive a lot of unsolicited emails like, for example, things from people in India asking for immigration advice, which I never respond to. I almost regard those as being akin to spam, and so there are those ones. But, similarly, other Ministers have had probably very similar issues.'
This comment effectively singled out Indians as a group whose emails she considered comparable to spam.
The questioning arose after it was revealed that Stanford had used her personal Gmail account for official government correspondence, including forwarding pre-Budget announcements to herself for printing.
This practice raised concerns about compliance with official record-keeping protocols.
Stanford admitted to this breach of best practice and assured Parliament that she had taken steps to prevent such occurrences in the future.
Priyanca Radhakrishnan, an Indian-born Labour MP, responded sharply to Stanford's remarks on social media. She wrote, 'Earlier this week, in response to a question by Willow Jean Prime the Immigration Minister felt the need to single out people from one country/ethnicity in a negative light. If you're from India, don't bother emailing her because it's automatically considered spam.'
Radhakrishnan criticised the comments as undermining New Zealand's government efforts to strengthen ties with India, stating, 'So much for the National govt's all-of-government focus on strengthening the relationship between India & NZ and focus on people-to-people links.'
She described Stanford's remarks as 'careless at best and prejudiced at worst,' emphasising that such stereotyping reinforces negative perceptions against an entire community.
The Labour Party MP also added a news screenshot of news article with the headline 'Luxon calls for an all-of New Zealand investment India relationship".
Christopher Luxon is the 42nd Prime Minister of New Zealand, and belongs to New Zealand National Party.
In the wake of the backlash, Erica Stanford sought to clarify her statement, asserting that her comments had been misunderstood. 'I did not say that I consider them as spam,' she explained. 'I only said that I consider them almost akin to spam,' attempting to soften the original phrasing.
Erica Stanford further clarified that her official correspondence is handled through her parliamentary email account, and unsolicited emails to her personal account, including those from overseas, are not part of her ministerial duties and therefore do not receive responses.
Erica Louise Stanford, born in 1978, is a New Zealand National Party politician currently serving as the 49th Minister of Education and the 60th Minister of Immigration. She has represented the East Coast Bays electorate since 2017 and was appointed to her ministerial roles following the formation of the National-led government in 2023.
Stanford's background includes work in export sales and television production before entering politics. She holds a Bachelor of Arts in politics from the University of Auckland and is noted for her progressive stances within the National Party, including support for decriminalising abortion and euthanasia.
Priyanca Radhakrishnan is a Labour Party MP of Indian origin, born in Chennai and raised partly in Singapore before moving to New Zealand for higher education. She made history as the first Indian-Kiwi woman to become a minister in New Zealand in 2020.
Radhakrishnan has held portfolios including Minister for Ethnic Communities and Minister for Diversity, Inclusion and Ethnic Communities. She is a vocal advocate for multiculturalism, ethnic minority rights, and social justice, often speaking out against racial stereotyping and discrimination.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
33 minutes ago
- Time of India
BJP netas woo industrywith promise of strong eco
Ludhiana: Senior BJP leaders are busy holding indoor meetings with the business fraternity to solicit votes for party candidate Jiwan Gupta. Late Friday, BJP national general secretary Tarun Chugh and former Gujarat CM Vijay Rupani, along with several other leaders, met industrialists. Most of the industrialists reside in the West constituency, and almost all the parties are reaching out to them. The BJP delegation led by the party's district chief, Rajnesh Dhiman, called on Omkar Singh Pahwa and sought his support for Gupta. Tarun Chugh and Vijay Rupani were also part of the delegation. Addressing the industrialists, Rupani informed them about PM Narendra Modi's policies for the industry. He said India had become the fourth largest economy in the world, surpassing Japan. He added that the Indian Rupee was doing well in the global market, showing strength against the US dollar. Rupani said in the next few years, the Indian economy could become the third largest in the world, surpassing Germany. BJP national general secretary Tarun Chugh said BJP could save Punjab's industry, which was forced to shift to other states due to lack of security and anti-industry policies. He urged the industrialists to vote for the BJP if they wanted to save the industry of Punjab. Onkar Singh Pahwa promised support for BJP candidate Jiwan Gupta on behalf of the cycle industry. Several other meetings were held with representatives of the hosiery and dyeing industry.
&w=3840&q=100)
First Post
34 minutes ago
- First Post
Lammy meets PM Modi, pushes UK-India counter-terrorism cooperation and trade deal
British Foreign Minister David Lammy is the highest-profile Western official to have visited both New Delhi and Islamabad since the South Asian neighbours agreed to a ceasefire last month after their worst fighting in nearly three decades. read more Britain and India held talks on strengthening their counter-terrorism cooperation in the wake of recent cross-border clashes between India and Pakistan, UK Foreign Minister David Lammy told Reuters on Saturday following a meeting with Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi. Lammy's visit makes him the most senior Western official to travel to both New Delhi and Islamabad since the South Asian rivals agreed to a ceasefire on May 10, ending their most intense period of conflict in nearly 30 years. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD Thank you Prime Minister @narendramodi for your warm welcome to India. Building on the free trade agreement between our great countries, we will continue working together to deepen our partnership, celebrate our unique living bridge, and deliver growth and security. — David Lammy (@DavidLammy) June 7, 2025 Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi stressed the need for decisive international action against terrorism and those supporting it in a meeting with Lammy. The Prime Minister's Office said Lammy strongly condemned the Pahalgam terror attack. PM Modi expressed satisfaction at the successful conclusion of the India-UK Free Trade Agreement and Double Contribution Convention and appreciated the constructive engagement by both sides that led to this milestone. Pleased to meet UK Foreign Secretary Mr. David Lammy. Appreciate his substantive contribution to the remarkable progress in our Comprehensive Strategic Partnership, further strengthened by the recently concluded FTA. Value UK's support for India's fight against cross-border… — Narendra Modi (@narendramodi) June 7, 2025 STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD The PMO statement said Modi welcomed the growing momentum in bilateral ties and expressed satisfaction at the deepening of the India-UK Comprehensive Strategic Partnership. He welcomed the continued collaboration under the Technology Security Initiative and noted its potential to shape trusted and secure innovation ecosystems. Tensions had surged in April after 26 people were killed in India's Kashmir, an incident India blamed on Pakistan-backed militants, which Islamabad denied. In response, India launched strikes on what it described as terrorist infrastructure inside Pakistan, prompting retaliatory moves and escalation until both countries agreed to halt hostilities. 'We want the situation to be maintained, but of course we recognise fragility, particularly in the backdrop of terrorism, terrorism designed to destabilise India,' Lammy said in an interview at the residence of the British High Commissioner in New Delhi. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD 'We are keen to continue to work with our Indian partners on counter-terrorism measures.' He said he discussed the next steps with both Modi and Indian Foreign Minister S. Jaishankar, but gave no specifics. Last year, India and Britain discussed combating the financing of terrorism, cooperation between law enforcement and judicial bodies and information sharing. Lammy said he also discussed boosting trade between the world's fifth and sixth largest economies. The countries concluded talks for a free trade deal early last month. 'I know that Prime Minister Keir Starmer is very much looking forward to coming to India very soon to sign the free trade agreement,' Lammy said. 'There is so much that our two nations can continue to do together.' With inputs from agencies
Time of India
37 minutes ago
- Time of India
Rahul sounds 'match-fixing' alarm again, says Bihar next
Congress leader Rahul Gandhi on Saturday renewed his allegation of electoral malpractices in last November's assembly election in Maharashtra that the BJP-led alliance swept and said " match-fixing will come next in Bihar", which goes to polls later this year. Gandhi, who has been attacking the central government over its handling of Operation Sindoor, again raised the allegation of electoral malpractices in identical articles written in more than a dozen newspapers and through social media posts. He focussed his charges more on the authenticity of electoral rolls and high voter turnouts and less on electronic voting machines. He again objected to the Chief Justice of India not being part of the search committee for election commissioners. Incidentally, all these issues are topics of petitions currently pending before the apex court. Maintaining the Maharashtra poll was a blueprint for "how to steal an election" and "for rigging democracy", Gandhi claimed it was done through various steps. "Step 1: Rig the panel for appointing the Election Commission , Step 2: Add fake voters to the roll, Step 3: Inflate voter turnout, Step 4: Target the bogus voting exactly where BJP needs to win, Step 5: Hide the evidence. It's not hard to see why the BJP was so desperate in Maharashtra," he wrote on microblogging platform X. "But rigging is like match-fixing - the side that cheats might win the game, but damages institutions and destroys public faith in the result. All concerned Indians must see the evidence. Judge for themselves. Demand answers. Because the match-fixing of Maharashtra will come to Bihar next, and then anywhere the BJP is losing. Match-fixed elections are a poison for any democracy," he said. Gandhi renewing the charges over Maharashtra election results after a pause on the front and the fact that his latest burst is mostly a summary of the old charges, have made many in the Congress wonder whether he was using it more as a caveat ahead of the upcoming Bihar assembly poll, where Gandhi's new-found switch to 'social justice' plank has high-stakes. They said his article is mostly inspired by the "investigations" done by the AICC's data wing.
