
UK corporate crime reforms: Lessons for Malaysia
The United Kingdom's (UK) proposed Crime and Policing Bill 2025, which builds on the Economic Crime and Corporate Transparency Act 2023 (ECCTA), signals a fundamental shift in how corporate criminal liability is approached.
For Malaysia, grappling with recurring corporate scandals and persistent enforcement gaps these developments offer a timely lesson in legal reform.
The UK's current reforms break from its traditionally narrow 'identification principle', under which corporate criminal liability hinged on proving that the directing mind and will (typically, board-level executives) possessed the necessary criminal intent.
This model had long struggled to hold large, complex corporations accountable, as misconduct often occurred several layers below board level.
The result was a form of de facto immunity for major corporations an issue Malaysia knows too well from high-profile cases like 1MDB.
The ECCTA, along with the proposed Crime and Policing Bill, challenges and reshapes the existing status quo.
The UK is introducing a broader 'senior manager' test that attributes liability to a corporate entity if a senior manager, acting within their actual or apparent authority, commits an offence.
Initially limited to economic crimes such as fraud and bribery, the new Bill proposes to expand this principle to all criminal offences, including environmental breaches, health and safety violations, and potentially even regulatory offences under data protection or competition law.
Should Malaysia give serious consideration to this matter?
The relevance for Malaysia
Malaysia has made progress in recent years with frameworks like the corporate liability provision under Section 17A of the Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission Act 2009, which imposes liability on companies for bribery committed by associated persons.
But unlike the UK's evolving regime, Malaysia's framework remains limited in scope. It does not yet offer a comprehensive system that attributes liability to senior individuals beyond bribery, nor does it extend to a broader array of corporate misconduct.
In an era where corporate actors are transnational, crimes like money laundering, tax evasion, and environmental damage frequently cut across jurisdictions.
Yet Malaysia's legal system lacks the robust extraterritorial reach that both ECCTA and the proposed UK Bill provide. The UK reforms allow for corporate liability even where only part of the conduct occurs in the UK, or where the victim is a UK national.
Malaysia must adopt a similarly outward-facing approach, particularly given the global footprint of its GLCs, listed companies, and state-linked institutions.
Why reform is crucial now
First, Malaysia is at a credibility crossroads. Although enforcement agencies have made strides in tackling corruption and economic crime, public confidence in institutional accountability remains fragile.
Legal reform that closes loopholes in corporate criminal liability can help restore faith in the system and signal a genuine commitment to good governance.
Second, the global enforcement landscape is shifting. The creation of a new taskforce involving the UK, France, and Switzerland aimed at prosecuting international financial crime shows that enforcement is becoming more collaborative and less tolerant of inaction.
The US, traditionally a leader in anti-corruption enforcement via the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act, has slowed enforcement. This vacuum is being filled by European actors.
Malaysia, a regional economic hub, risks reputational harm and legal isolation if it does not modernise its approach.
Third, as ESG (environmental, social and governance) accountability becomes mainstream, companies are being judged not just by profitability but by compliance and integrity.
A modern liability regime that deters wrongdoing by making corporations answerable for the actions of their senior personnel aligns with this global shift.
This is especially pertinent given Malaysia's reliance on natural resources, extractive industries, and a growing digital economy sector where regulatory breaches can have far-reaching effects.
Key takeaways for Malaysian reform
Malaysia should consider key corporate liability reforms, drawing from the UK's legal framework. First, the basis of liability should be broadened beyond bribery to encompass all serious economic crimes, environmental offences, and regulatory breaches, ensuring comprehensive accountability.
A 'Senior Manager' test should also be introduced, holding companies liable for misconduct by individuals with significant decision-making authority, even if they are not board members.
Additionally, the scope of authority must be clarified to include 'apparent authority,' preventing firms from denying liability for criminal acts carried out in role-relevant contexts.
Malaysia should also enhance the extraterritorial application of its laws, enabling prosecution of offences that affect Malaysian interests, even when elements occur abroad.
Finally, to foster a culture of prevention, Malaysia could adopt a mechanism similar to the UK's Deferred Prosecution Agreement regime, which encourages companies to implement robust compliance programs and self-report misconduct in exchange for more flexible enforcement.
These reforms would significantly strengthen corporate accountability and regulatory integrity. ‒ June 26, 2025
R. Paneir Selvam is the principal consultant of Arunachala Research & Consultancy Sdn Bhd, a think tank specialising in strategic national and geopolitical matters.
The views expressed are solely of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Focus Malaysia.
Main image: Shutterstock
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


The Star
a day ago
- The Star
Malaysian Gig Workers Bill to be tabled this month despite delay, says Steven Sim
KUALA LUMPUR: The Malaysian Gig Workers Bill will be tabled in Parliament in August despite a last-minute delay, says Steven Sim. The Human Resources Minister said that the Bill, which was supposed to the tabled in Aug 14, sought to safeguard workers' rights while avoiding undue strain on businesses and the economy. "The Bill would mark Malaysia's first legislation for gig workers, placing the country among only 16 or 17 nations worldwide with such laws. 'When we crafted this Bill, we engaged over 4,000 stakeholders — from employers and unions to academics and NGOs — to ensure it provides protection for workers while not imposing unnecessary burdens on the system,' Sim said at the Asean & Beyond: Young Entrepreneurs Dialogue 2025 on Saturday (Aug 16). Earlier, Deputy Prime Minister Datuk Seri Dr Ahmad Zahid Hamidi had said that the Bill would be tabled in the Dewan Rakyat for its first reading on Aug 14, with the second reading supposed to take place on Aug 26. However, the Bill has yet to be tabled so far due to a last-minute delay. Sim said that the Bill, which he stressed would be tabled sometime this month, represented a crucial step for Malaysia in striking a balance between nurturing its digital and gig economy and ensuring fair treatment for workers. 'The government has always been rational when it comes to balancing development with protection. We want to see the digital economy grow, but not at the expense of workers' rights,' he said. Addressing concerns from businesses about rising labour costs, Sim said that protecting workers was not only a government responsibility but also a business imperative. 'Post-Covid, one of the most valuable assets in business is human capital. If you don't protect your workers, you will lose talent. They will move to places like Singapore, where opportunities and wages are better,' he said. He urged business leaders to play a greater role in raising wages, improving conditions and safeguarding workers' welfare, adding that this was vital for retaining talent both in Malaysia and across the region. Meanwhile, Associated Chinese Chambers of Commerce and Industry of Malaysia (ACCCIM) president Datuk Ng Yih Pyng said the Asean & Beyond: Young Entrepreneurs Dialogue 2025 was built on three key objectives: to provide a platform for Asean youth to exchange ideas, to encourage socio-economic cooperation, and to expand regional markets to create more opportunities for young entrepreneurs. 'This platform is about forging partnerships, sparking innovation and fostering inclusive economic growth. I encourage all of you to use this opportunity to share ideas, build relationships and create impact, not only for your enterprises but for a vibrant and resilient Asean economy,' he said in his welcoming remarks. Ng stressed that young entrepreneurs were at the forefront of shaping the region's future by driving innovation, building resilience and opening new markets. As organiser, ACCCIM remained committed to empowering future business leaders by equipping them with networks, knowledge and platforms to build a connected, innovative and sustainable Asean. He added that the dialogue came at a time of shifting global trade dynamics, with several Asean economies, including Malaysia, facing US-imposed tariffs averaging 19%, while others faced tariffs of between 10% and 40%. Ng said that under the Asean Community Vision 2025, the Asean Economic Community had significant potential to boost intra-regional trade, supported by a population of nearly 660 million and a combined GDP of more than US$3.8 trillion. 'To harness these advantages, we must remain agile, diversify supply chains, maximise benefits from RCEP, promote local currency settlements and support Asean-led green initiatives,' he said.
![News@9: Today's top headlines - August 14, 2025 [WATCH]](/_next/image?url=https%3A%2F%2Fassets.nst.com.my%2Fimages%2Farticles%2FBH14oren1_1755176416.jpg&w=3840&q=100)
![News@9: Today's top headlines - August 14, 2025 [WATCH]](/_next/image?url=https%3A%2F%2Fassets.nst.com.my%2Fassets%2FNST-Logo%402x.png%3Fid%3Db37a17055cb1ffea01f5&w=48&q=75)
New Straits Times
3 days ago
- New Straits Times
News@9: Today's top headlines - August 14, 2025 [WATCH]
Here are today's top stories: Rafizi links attack Pandan MP Datuk Seri Rafizi Ramli says yesterday's attack on his son may be tied to a meeting with whistleblowers on a scandal. The government has recovered RM29.7 billion linked to 1MDB and SRC International since the Asset Recovery Trust Account was established in 2018. Ruling stays Rumah Bonda founder, Siti Bainun Ahd Razali will serve her 12-year sentence after the Court of Appeal rejected her final bid to overturn her conviction for abusing Bella, a teenager with Down's Syndrome. Malacca Strait smuggling A smuggling syndicate, involving five armed forces officers, allegedly moved contraband and drugs through the Strait of Malacca before being crippled by the MACC.


Free Malaysia Today
3 days ago
- Free Malaysia Today
Malaysia has recovered US$7bil in funds linked to 1MDB
1MDB, a state investment fund that took shape under former prime minister Najib Razak, is at the centre of a multi-billion dollar scandal. (Reuters pic) PETALING JAYA : The Malaysian government has recovered RM29.7 billion (US$7 billion) of funds relating to 1Malaysia Development Bhd (1MDB) and its former unit SRC International Sdn Bhd since the establishment of the Assets Recovery Trust Account, according to the finance ministry. As of the end of July, RM42.17 billion has been channeled to 1MDB to finance debt repayments and fulfill the company's commitments, the finance ministry said in a written parliamentary reply yesterday. 'Of the amount, RM15.44 billion was channeled from the finance ministry and the Minister of Finance Incorporated in the form of shareholder advances or loans, while RM26.73 billion came from the proceeds of 1MDB's asset recovery,' it said. 1MDB, a state investment fund that took shape under former prime minister Najib Razak, is at the centre of a multi-billion dollar scandal that has spawned probes in Asia, the US and Europe. Najib, convicted of crimes linked to 1MDB, is currently serving a prison sentence but is seeking to spend the remainder of it under house arrest. He is expected to be released in 2028. 'The process to recover 1MDB and SRC funds is still ongoing and is a complicated and long process that will take years,' said the finance ministry. 'This is because it not only involves cooperation between several local agencies and foreign agencies from various countries, but also involves legal processes in court and settlement negotiations,' it added. Other findings from the finance ministry's reply are: About RM28.93 billion was used to pay 1MDB's principal debt, while RM13.24 billion was for interest payments and the company's commitments. 1MDB's remaining debt, involving principal and interest payments until 2039 is RM9.02 billion, comprising principal of RM5 billion and interest of RM4.02 billion. For SRC International, RM5.35 billion has been channeled by the government to finance principal, interest on debt and meet the company's commitments.