UK corporate crime reforms: Lessons for Malaysia
The United Kingdom's (UK) proposed Crime and Policing Bill 2025, which builds on the Economic Crime and Corporate Transparency Act 2023 (ECCTA), signals a fundamental shift in how corporate criminal liability is approached.
For Malaysia, grappling with recurring corporate scandals and persistent enforcement gaps these developments offer a timely lesson in legal reform.
The UK's current reforms break from its traditionally narrow 'identification principle', under which corporate criminal liability hinged on proving that the directing mind and will (typically, board-level executives) possessed the necessary criminal intent.
This model had long struggled to hold large, complex corporations accountable, as misconduct often occurred several layers below board level.
The result was a form of de facto immunity for major corporations an issue Malaysia knows too well from high-profile cases like 1MDB.
The ECCTA, along with the proposed Crime and Policing Bill, challenges and reshapes the existing status quo.
The UK is introducing a broader 'senior manager' test that attributes liability to a corporate entity if a senior manager, acting within their actual or apparent authority, commits an offence.
Initially limited to economic crimes such as fraud and bribery, the new Bill proposes to expand this principle to all criminal offences, including environmental breaches, health and safety violations, and potentially even regulatory offences under data protection or competition law.
Should Malaysia give serious consideration to this matter?
The relevance for Malaysia
Malaysia has made progress in recent years with frameworks like the corporate liability provision under Section 17A of the Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission Act 2009, which imposes liability on companies for bribery committed by associated persons.
But unlike the UK's evolving regime, Malaysia's framework remains limited in scope. It does not yet offer a comprehensive system that attributes liability to senior individuals beyond bribery, nor does it extend to a broader array of corporate misconduct.
In an era where corporate actors are transnational, crimes like money laundering, tax evasion, and environmental damage frequently cut across jurisdictions.
Yet Malaysia's legal system lacks the robust extraterritorial reach that both ECCTA and the proposed UK Bill provide. The UK reforms allow for corporate liability even where only part of the conduct occurs in the UK, or where the victim is a UK national.
Malaysia must adopt a similarly outward-facing approach, particularly given the global footprint of its GLCs, listed companies, and state-linked institutions.
Why reform is crucial now
First, Malaysia is at a credibility crossroads. Although enforcement agencies have made strides in tackling corruption and economic crime, public confidence in institutional accountability remains fragile.
Legal reform that closes loopholes in corporate criminal liability can help restore faith in the system and signal a genuine commitment to good governance.
Second, the global enforcement landscape is shifting. The creation of a new taskforce involving the UK, France, and Switzerland aimed at prosecuting international financial crime shows that enforcement is becoming more collaborative and less tolerant of inaction.
The US, traditionally a leader in anti-corruption enforcement via the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act, has slowed enforcement. This vacuum is being filled by European actors.
Malaysia, a regional economic hub, risks reputational harm and legal isolation if it does not modernise its approach.
Third, as ESG (environmental, social and governance) accountability becomes mainstream, companies are being judged not just by profitability but by compliance and integrity.
A modern liability regime that deters wrongdoing by making corporations answerable for the actions of their senior personnel aligns with this global shift.
This is especially pertinent given Malaysia's reliance on natural resources, extractive industries, and a growing digital economy sector where regulatory breaches can have far-reaching effects.
Key takeaways for Malaysian reform
Malaysia should consider key corporate liability reforms, drawing from the UK's legal framework. First, the basis of liability should be broadened beyond bribery to encompass all serious economic crimes, environmental offences, and regulatory breaches, ensuring comprehensive accountability.
A 'Senior Manager' test should also be introduced, holding companies liable for misconduct by individuals with significant decision-making authority, even if they are not board members.
Additionally, the scope of authority must be clarified to include 'apparent authority,' preventing firms from denying liability for criminal acts carried out in role-relevant contexts.
Malaysia should also enhance the extraterritorial application of its laws, enabling prosecution of offences that affect Malaysian interests, even when elements occur abroad.
Finally, to foster a culture of prevention, Malaysia could adopt a mechanism similar to the UK's Deferred Prosecution Agreement regime, which encourages companies to implement robust compliance programs and self-report misconduct in exchange for more flexible enforcement.
These reforms would significantly strengthen corporate accountability and regulatory integrity. ‒ June 26, 2025
R. Paneir Selvam is the principal consultant of Arunachala Research & Consultancy Sdn Bhd, a think tank specialising in strategic national and geopolitical matters.
The views expressed are solely of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Focus Malaysia.
Main image: Shutterstock
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
4 days ago
- The Star
Urban Renewal Bill to be tabled this month, says Nga
PUTRAJAYA: The Urban Renewal Bill is expected to be tabled in Parliament before the current meeting ends this month, says Housing and Local Government Minister Nga Kor Ming ( pic ). The Bill, which will oversee redevelopment, regeneration and revitalisation of cities and towns in Peninsular Malaysia, was initially slated to be tabled for first reading last month. 'I am planning to table the Urban Renewal Bill, which will promote prosperity among Malaysians in towns, during this Merdeka Month,' Nga said after launching the Semarak Jiwa Merdeka at his ministry here on Friday (Aug 8). The Bill proposes allowing the en bloc sale of entire strata developments even if not all the owners agree. An en bloc sale happens when all unit owners of a building agree to sell to a single buyer, often for redevelopment purposes. At present, Section 57 of the Strata Titles Act 1985 states that a strata development can only be sold if there is 100% agreement from the owners. The proposed new law aims to lower this threshold, depending on the building's condition and age. For example, if the building is less than 30 years old, it only needs 80% approval. The proposed threshold for structures above 30 years old is 75%. Meanwhile, for abandoned housing projects, a simple majority of 51% will suffice.
The Sun
4 days ago
- The Sun
Be ready to mobilise trillions of ringgit in climate financing: KRI deputy director of research
KUALA LUMPUR: Malaysia's local banks and financial institutions must be ready to mobilise trillions of ringgit in climate financing, said Khazanah Research Institute deputy director of research Yin Shao highlighted that until 2023, Malaysia did not have a clear costed policy for its energy transition making it difficult to justify raising funds.'Because, why go out and look for funds when you don't even know how to use them?' he said in a panel session at Climate Finance Summit 2025 said the introduction of the National Energy Transition Roadmap in 2023 provided Malaysia with its first rough estimate of the cost involved. 'The estimated bill came to around RM1.3 trillion.'However, Yin noted that the cost of climate adaptation, which has received less attention, has yet to be determined.'It's easy to imagine the total bill reaching RM3 trillion. That's an eye-watering amount. It's hard to even grasp,' he context, Yin pointed to Malaysia's pensions gap, which stands at around RM700 billion. He added that 1MDB, often cited as a major debt burden, involved only RM53 billion.'So those are double-digit billions, compared to trillions,' he stressed that Malaysia has never attempted to mobilise funding at such a scale before.'One of the lessons we can learn from international climate finance is that 80% is domestically mobilised, and only 20% comes from international sources,' he he explained, is largely because there simply isn't enough international funding available.'It's a recurring point of contention at every climate convention in November and December. Last year's convention, in particular, got very heated because not enough was promised.'Yin said there was a pledge to increase contributions from US$100 billion (RM423 billion) per year to US$300 billion, but people were asking for trillions.'The truth is, there simply isn't enough available.'Now that Malaysia has begun quantifying the potential costs, Yin said, the country must begin seriously looking for financing. 'And we haven't even started on what it will take to conserve forests, which are expected to absorb 90% to 95% of our emissions let alone adaptation,' he admitted he has doubts about whether Malaysia can raise that much money domestically.'How many bonds can we realistically issue before the market starts asking, 'Can this really be deployed and paid back?'Sure, some bonds can be rolled over, he said, but without a clearer picture of adaptation costs, Malaysia is flying blind.'That could be significant, considering 70% of our population lives in coastal zones. That's a lot to protect,' he pointed to the 2021 floods, triggered by about a week of rain, which caused RM6.1 billion in damage, according to the Statistics Department.'We weren't prepared. We're still not prepared for that kind of cost. And RM6.1 billion is roughly what our Covid-19 vaccine programme cost.'Yin said he is not optimistic about the outlook stating that the way the United States has gone since 2024 is not encouraging. 'And I'm not optimistic about the European Union either. It has traditionally been a climate champion, but it has now veered sharply to the far right and is talking more about missiles than climate.'It is incredibly frustrating that international climate action is slowing down and, as a result, the availability of international finance may also shrink, Yin said. 'That means for us, we may have to shoulder even more adaptation costs ourselves as time goes on.'
The Star
4 days ago
- The Star
Gig Workers' Bill to be tabled on Aug 14
KUALA LUMPUR: The Gig Workers' Bill 2025, a legal framework aimed at officially recognising and protecting gig workers, is to be tabled in the Dewan Rakyat for its first reading on Aug 14, says Deputy Prime Minister Datuk Seri Dr Ahmad Zahid Hamidi. He said the second reading would take place on Aug 26. "It is during the second reading that the Bill will be explained in detail and debated by MPs from both the government and Opposition before being put to a vote. "The vote does not require a two-thirds majority, just a simple majority," he said. He was speaking during the "Sembang Santai Teh Tarik Industri Gig" session organised by the Human Resources Ministry, which was attended by gig industry representatives and other stakeholders. Also present were Human Resources Minister Steven Sim Chee Keong and his deputy Datuk Seri Abdul Rahman Mohamad. – Bernama
