BBC drops film about Gaza doctors after delaying its broadcast for months
The documentary, Gaza: Medics Under Fire, was ready to broadcast in February but was pulled because of a scandal that erupted over another BBC documentary on children in Gaza, entitled How to Survive a Warzone.
Britain's public broadcaster said it would broadcast Gaza: Medics Under Fire after the review into the earlier documentary was concluded.
But on Friday, the BBC announced it would not air the film.
"We have come to the conclusion that broadcasting this material risked creating a perception of partiality that would not meet the high standards that the public rightly expect of the BBC," the broadcaster said in a statement.
New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch
Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters
"Therefore, we are transferring ownership of the film material to Basement Films... Any film broadcast will not be a BBC film."
'No moral or professional reason'
Basement Films, the company which produced the documentary, had previously questioned the BBC's decision to delay the broadcast, saying, "there is no moral or professional reason why a mistake in one film should repeatedly prevent the release of another film."
In a statement on Friday, Basement Films said: "we would like to thank the Doctors and contributors and survivors, and to apologise for not believing them when they said the BBC would never run a film like this.
BBC coverage of Israel's war on Gaza 'systematically biased against Palestinians' Read More »
"It turned out they were right."
The documentary tells the stories of Palestinian doctors working in Gaza under Israeli bombardment and was made by Oscar-nominated, Emmy and Peabody award-winning filmmakers, including Ben de Pear, Karim Shah and Ramita Navai.
The BBC did not explain in its statement why the film would not have met "the high standards that the public rightly expect of the BBC".
Basement Films said that the BBC "gave us no less than 6 different release dates" after having "told us several times verbally and by email" that the film "had been approved for broadcast".
In May, over 600 prominent figures from the arts and media wrote to the BBC, accusing it of "political censorship" over its delay in screening the documentary.
"Although the BBC are now taking their names off this film," Basement Films said, "it will remain theirs, and we hope it serves to open up the debate on how the nation's broadcaster covers what is happening in Gaza."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The National
a day ago
- The National
Mounia Akl directing Netflix's House of Guinness and other Arab filmmakers behind popular series
While Arab film has reached new heights in recent years, gaining attention at festivals and during award season, major Arab film directors are increasingly bringing their talents to the small screen as well. From popular shows such as Netflix's Palestinian dramedy Mo to broad comedies such as Only Murders in the Building, filmmakers from the Middle East are thriving no matter the subject matter, exemplifying the creative depth the region has to offer. Peaky Blinders creator Steven Knight's new show, House of Guinness, coming to Netflix in September, is the latest to have an Arab filmmaker behind the camera. Here are several award-winning filmmakers who have found success in the world of television. Mounia Akl Lebanese filmmaker Mounia Akl will be directing three episodes of the upcoming Netflix series House of Guinness. Created by Steven Knight, who is set to write the next James Bond film, it follows the children of brewery mogul Sir Benjamin Guinness and their struggle for control of their father's fortune. Akl previously worked on the British television shows B oiling Point and The Responder, both of which were nominated for Bafta awards. Prior to her move to television, Akl directed Costa Brava, Lebanon in 2021, which debuted at the Venice Film Festival. The film went on to screen at multiple international festivals, including Toronto and London. In 2016, Akl's short film Submarine was in consideration for the Cinefondation Award at the Cannes Film Festival. The 21-minute short film was a commentary on the garbage crisis in Lebanon. Mohamed Diab The Egyptian filmmaker received recognition for his work on the Marvel television series Moon Knight, which is primarily set in Egypt. That meant Diab was a great choice for the show which stars Oscar Isaac, Ethan Hawke and May Calamawy. His directorial career began with the 2010 drama Cairo 6,7,8. The film is about three women who navigate everyday life in the Egyptian capital. In 2016, he directed Clash, a movie set primarily inside a police bus transporting arrested protesters. Clash screened at Cannes Film Festival and competed at the London Film Festival. Diab has also written for Egyptian television shows, including Tayea and Renegades in 2018. Amr Salama Since directing his debut feature film Zayy el-Nahardah in 2006, the Egyptian filmmaker has worked on several different projects, including episodes of Saturday Night Live Arabia and the Netflix original Paranormal. Salama has directed many celebrated films, the most famous of which are Sheikh Jackson in 2017 and Fireworks in 2023. He also directed three episodes of the comedy crime series Bimbo, starring Ahmed Malek and Wegz. Karim El-Shinnawi The Egyptian filmmaker's latest move, The Tale of Daye's Family, is screening at this year's Berlin Film Festival. The film constitutes a return to the big screen for El-Shinnawi, who has been directing television shows since 2018. El-Shinnawi has worked on Egyptian shows such as Take Care of Zizi in 2021 and Seventh Year Itch in 2023. He also directed episodes of the Kuwaiti Netflix original show The Exchange, which returns this year for a second season. Cherien Dabis The Palestinian-American filmmaker and actress directed All That's Left of You, which screened at this year's Sundance Film Festival. She can also be seen in the second season of the Netflix hit series Mo, playing the sister of the titular main character played by comedian Mo Amer. Dabis has directed several episodes of hit American shows such as Ozark and Only Murders in the Building. She also directed six episodes of the Arab-American comedy series Ramy. Her first feature film was Amreeka, in 2009, about a Palestinian immigrant mother and her son who relocate to Illinois. Solvan Naim The Algerian-American director has an extensive career in directing television shows, including episodes on Power, Snowfall and The Blacklist. More recently, he directed 12 episodes of the Netflix show Mo. Annemarie Jacir The Palestinian filmmaker's first feature film was Salt of This Sea in 2008. It follows a woman who needs to return to her ancestral home in Haifa to retrieve her grandfather's savings. In 2016, she directed The Rendezvous, then followed it up with her most famous film, Wajib. Starring Mohammad Bakri and Saleh Bakri, Wajib screened at multiple international film festivals, receiving acclaim and recognition from juries and audiences alike. In 2022, Jacir directed an episode in the third season of Ramy. Majid Al Ansari The Emirati filmmaker rose to prominence with his feature film debut Zinzana, starring Ali Suliman and Saleh Bakri. Since then, Al Ansari has directed three episodes of the Netflix horror original Paranormal alongside Amr Salama. In 2023, Al Ansari directed an episode of the Emirati anthology horror series Kaboos. He also served as a producer on the Saudi supernatural romantic film Hwjn. Ali Selim The Egyptian-American director has one feature film, Sweet Land, which he directed, wrote and produced. More known for his television work, Selim has directed episodes of hit shows such as Criminal Minds, The Looming Tower, Manhunt and Marvel's Secret Invasion. Haifaa Al Mansour Working on short films between 1997 and 2001, the Saudi filmmaker got her big break with Wadjda in 2012. The film was nominated for Best Film Not in the English Language at the Baftas and won Best Film at the Tromso International Film Festival. Al Mansour 's second feature film was Mary Shelly, a biographical about the writer of Frankenstein. Since then, Al Mansour has directed episodes of many hit television shows including Archive 81, Mayfair Witches, Bosch: Legacy and Fear the Walking Dead.
The National
a day ago
- The National
Edinburgh Fringe award-winner retells story of West Bank landmark destroyed by Israel
Palestinian actor Alaa Shehada had been performing fragments of a story for months. It began with a four-minute piece that grew to 10 minutes, then 15, before he realised he had a full one-man play. The Horse of Jenin, about a statue that once stood in his home town in the occupied West Bank city of Jenin, earned him a Fringe First award at the Edinburgh Festival Fringe this month. The recognition, organised by The Scotsman, is among the most coveted at the world's largest arts festival. For Shehada the prize validates more than craft. 'The show tells a story that has always mattered, and never more so,' he tells The National from Edinburgh, where he continues performing nightly until the festival ends on August 25. 'As the genocide in Gaza and the West Bank continues, and the occupation of Palestine persists, we must keep amplifying Palestinian voices, preserving culture and advocating for justice, freedom and an end to the violence.' The play centres on a horse sculpture that stood in Jenin. Built in 2003 from debris left after an Israeli military incursion, the statue became a local landmark. In 2023, Israeli forces destroyed it with a bulldozer. Shehada, now based in Amsterdam, recalls feeling an urgent need to respond. 'What is it that makes the army fear a statue?' he says. 'What is that thing that this statue brings that let them take it and just remove it? And it disappeared in a second from our lives.' The destruction forced him to consider 'what a statue can do and what a symbol of resistance, resilience can do.' Those questions became the foundation for a 70-minute performance that weaves together childhood memories, family stories and moments of absurdity that punctuate life under occupation. 'It's about what is on our skin,' Shehada says. 'It's all about the story, about how hard the daily life is here, and funny sometimes, and confusing. So it has everything in one day.' During the writing process, Shehada stuck scenes across his bedroom wall and unearthed memories he hadn't planned to include. One was his English teacher Samir, who acquired Jenin's first mobile phone when Shehada was six. 'It's so big, we called it the fridge,' he recalled. 'Samir is so impressed, showing it off wherever he goes. Everywhere he goes, he speaks English because he wants every Palestinian to speak English.' The memory expanded to include the antenna, Samir parading the phone around town. 'These details allow the show to live, to really beat,' Shehada said. The Horse of Jenin shifts between such moments and deeper loss without warning. Audiences laugh at Samir's phone theatrics, then sit quietly as Shehada describes meeting his girlfriend 'secretly under the horse's legs, the statue of the horse' or the death of his childhood friend Ahmed. 'That's what makes it special to those not familiar with daily life of Palestinians,' he says. 'It makes you experience everything in terms of emotions. You're laughing; and then you're sad and depressed; and then you're confused and not understanding; and then you're educated; and then you're shocked; and then you're laughing so hard; and then you have tears.' Beyond theatre, Shehada cofounded the Palestinian Comedy Club in 2019, splitting operations between London and Jenin. The collective runs workshops in the West Bank and tours internationally. This month, five comedians are performing in Edinburgh, Glasgow and Newcastle. 'Comedy has many ways of reaching people,' Shehada says. 'First, it breaks the stereotypes about Palestinians because international comedy has one stereotype about how Palestinians look and act. You see us, you watch us all over the media – it's like checkpoints, fighting, and you don't see how a love story grows in Palestine. 'You don't see how a teacher, an English teacher, teaches his kids in a little school in Jenin. You don't see how the conversation happens in my family about me gaining more kilograms. You don't see the messages that we give to our lovers.' Shehada's own circumstances reflect the displacement that shapes Palestinian experience. Though born in Jenin, he has spent the past 15 years working between the Netherlands, UK, US and Australia, recently settling more permanently in Amsterdam. When asked about home, he paused. 'There is no home,' he said. 'I live in Jenin, I'm from Jenin, the West Bank, and I was there all the time, but I have moved over the past two years to Amsterdam.' With The Horse of Jennin to be performed in Europe, North America and Australia next year, Shehada's life as a touring artist compounds the complexity. 'That's why, when you ask me about what's home, it's really difficult to say what's home,' he says. "Even if I'm sitting down, I stay two or three months and then go to the UK. Then I go to Jenin and then somewhere else.' The work also represents a broader Palestinian response to loss that extends beyond art. 'This is something to do with the Palestinian mentality: if you lose your friend, you have to live, you have to keep moving,' he says. 'If you go from Jenin to Nablus and there's a checkpoint, you don't go back. You go to the mountain, find another way to go to Nablus.' While that survival instinct can drive creative expression, Shehada is clear about its source. 'It's coming from a painful place from all of us," he says. "It's a way to stay alive under an occupation. It's something that pushes you to stay alive, otherwise you're smashed. You are full of sadness and depression and hopelessness because of the situation. 'Ultimately, what we want to do – like everyone in this world – is to live. That is our only demand. We want to end occupation and have a normal life.'
UAE Moments
2 days ago
- UAE Moments
More Celebrities Speak Out on Gaza: U2, Madonna, Olivia Rodrigo, and Radiohead
More and more artists are stepping into the conversation on Gaza, with U2, Madonna, Olivia Rodrigo, and Radiohead recently making statements. Some are heartfelt, some are cautious, but all show how the crisis is impossible to ignore. U2 Divided in Their Words The Irish band made a joint post on August 10, with each member sharing their take. Bono condemned both Hamas and Israel, calling Netanyahu's government a 'moral failure.' Meanwhile, The Edge didn't hold back—using words like 'genocide' and 'ethnic cleansing.' The mixed messaging sparked even more debate among fans. Olivia Rodrigo's Emotional Plea The young pop star spoke up in July, calling the Gaza humanitarian crisis 'horrific and completely unacceptable.' She spotlighted children suffering without food, water, or medical care and even donated to Unicef, encouraging her fans to pitch in too. Madonna's Call to the Pope Madonna appealed to Pope Leo XIV earlier this month, asking him to bring light to Gaza's children. Her post was deeply personal—she tied it to her son's birthday, saying the best gift she could give was to fight for innocent lives. Still, she avoided directly condemning Israel, sticking to a 'both sides suffer' message. Radiohead's Complicated Stance Radiohead has long faced heat for performing in Israel despite boycott calls. But in May, Thom Yorke finally addressed Gaza head-on, slamming Netanyahu's government as 'out of control' and labeling the siege 'horrific.' Critics, however, said his words still fell short—especially when he questioned the 'Free Palestine' rallying cry.
