eThekwini Municipality pays a collective R1 million in damages for unlawful arrests
Image: Willem Phungula / Independent Newspapers
The eThekwini Municipality has paid out collective damages of R1 million in a case brought by three men who said they were unlawfully arrested by Metro police officers for carrying sealed bottles of beer.
A judgment handed down by the Durban High Court earlier this year revealed that the men were initially suspected of drinking in public by the Metro police due to their possession of the sealed bottles. The situation thereafter escalated and the men were arrested and spent time in jail, where they said they were subjected to severe mistreatment. One of the men, Philani Lukhele, was also shot in the leg during the incident.
The court awarded the men damages for past loss of earnings, unlawful arrest and detention, and assault and contumelia. Msizi Cele was awarded R231,000, Welcome Hlongwa received R240,200 while Lukhele's case was distinguished from the other due to the severe injury he sustained. He was awarded R649,500. The court judgment noted that all three victims testified in support of their claims, while the municipality closed its case without calling any witnesses.
'The undisputed evidence of the plaintiffs' case is that on 15 December 2012, they were walking in Chatsworth towards the taxi rank, carrying two sealed bottles of beer,' the judgment stated. The men testified that a Metro police officer, who was in a private vehicle, approached them and accused them of drinking in public.
The three denied this, asserting that their beers were sealed. The three boarded a taxi to Durban and the Metro police followed them in their vehicle and then stopped the taxi at a roadblock. Other officers were also at the roadblock. The officer who had initially questioned them pointed them out to other officers, leading to their removal from the taxi.
'When the victims inquired about their alleged wrongdoing, the police did not respond. Instead, they were assaulted publicly. The police fired four shots in the direction of Msizi but missed him; they eventually shot Philani in the knee,' said the judgment. The men said they were handcuffed and placed in a Metro police van and pepper spray was sprayed in the back of the van. When Lukhele, who suffers from asthma, requested his inhaler, one of the officers took it from his pocket and inhaled from it, the judgment said.
Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Unmute
Current Time
0:00
/
Duration
-:-
Loaded :
0%
Stream Type LIVE
Seek to live, currently behind live
LIVE
Remaining Time
-
0:00
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque
Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps
Reset
restore all settings to the default values Done
Close Modal Dialog
End of dialog window.
Advertisement
Next
Stay
Close ✕
Ad loading
It said the police then transported them to Chatsworth police station, where they were further assaulted. The three, according to the judgment, said they had overheard one officer instructing another to fabricate a story that they had attempted to deprive the officer of his firearm. Shortly thereafter, an ambulance arrived, but the driver spoke to the police officer and then drove away. Lukhele was taken to the hospital, where he was treated for his injury while being guarded by police and handcuffed to a bed.
'Msizi and Welcome were taken to Bellair police station, where they were detained for four days before being brought to Chatsworth Magistrates' Court, where they were released without appearing in court.'
During their four days in detention, Msizi and Welcome said they did not eat any food; they were given one meal by another detainee who was receiving food from his family. Philani spent six days in hospital and was released without appearing in court.
The court found that the circumstances of the case demonstrated malice on the part of the Metro police during the arrests. 'The evidence indicated that the police were not investigating any offence and had no reasonable suspicion against the plaintiffs when they were arbitrarily arrested. The police shot at unarmed individuals who posed no threat, victimising those they were meant to protect.'
The plaintiffs were represented by attorney Ajit Severaj.
It is understood that the municipality has made payment to the plaintiffs. The City was contacted for comment last week but had not responded by publication.
THE MERCURY
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
4 hours ago
- IOL News
Leaked affidavit exposing Landiwe Ntlokwana's involvement in a multi-million rand scheme
According to the affidavit, Ntlokwana managed investor data, tracked payments, and even used her company's bank account — GTT Wealth (Pty) Ltd — to receive millions of rands from individuals drawn into Bushiri's now-notorious commodities investment platform. Image: Supplied A leaked affidavit has exposed Landiwe Ntlokwana, a former auditor and financial coordinator for Prophet Shepherd Bushiri, as a key figure in a multi-million rand investment scheme — and strongly suggests she is using her testimony under Section 204 of the Criminal Procedure Act in a strategic bid to escape prosecution. According to the affidavit, Ntlokwana managed investor data, tracked payments, and even used her company's bank account — GTT Wealth (Pty) Ltd — to receive millions of rands from individuals drawn into Bushiri's now-notorious commodities investment platform. Her phone, she claims, was used by multiple committee members as the central point of contact for investor communication. 'The committee and I continued our administrative duties as described previously. My phone continued being passed around for whoever wanted to focus on that function,' she said. With a strong background in Microsoft Excel, Ntlokwana took responsibility for consolidating all investor information into a single master file, which she says was used by the IT team for internal reporting and to generate investor statements. The affidavit details the rapid expansion of the scheme and growing unrest within the church community. Ntlokwana describes how popularity surged beyond South Africa's borders, leading to complaints from international followers of Bushiri's Enlightened Christian Gathering Church who felt excluded from the opportunity. 'They started saying what was the point of belonging to a community where only a select few can participate in empowerment initiatives,' she said. These concerns, she claims, were taken directly to response, Ntlokwana says Bushiri called a closed-door meeting with her and five other women in his inner circle — Gladness, Rosemary, Shirley, Jumoke, and Memory. During the meeting, Bushiri announced the launch of a new investment round: Commodities Trade Cycle 3. This phase, however, was exclusive to high-net-worth individuals, with a minimum investment of R1 million. Despite her corporate background at firms like Grant Thornton and Allan Gray, Ntlokwana admits there were no formal contracts governing her role. Legal experts find this highly questionable. 'She's not an amateur. She knows how finance works,' said a senior investigator. 'The absence of contracts and the use of her company account are not rookie mistakes — they point to direct involvement.'Under Section 204, an accused may be granted immunity in exchange for full and truthful testimony. ''But such a deal hinges on credibility — something that could be Ntlokwana's biggest hurdle.'She handled the money, the records, and the investor lists,' the investigator continued. 'Now she's trying to claim she was just assisting — but this affidavit proves she was in control.' With Bushiri still in Malawi and his extradition proceedings stalled, Ntlokwana's testimony could close the case but she if found to be self-serving or unreliable, the prosecution could be left with little to stand on
The Citizen
15 hours ago
- The Citizen
Zondo blasts Ramaphosa over state capture and corrupt ministers
Zondo speaks of his 'pain' in swearing in corrupt ministers. Chief Justice Raymond Zondo (L) hands over the state capture report to President Cyril Ramaphosa at the Union Building in Pretoria. Picture: Twitter/@PresidencyZA Former chief justice Raymond Zondo has expressed the pain he had to ensure to swear in corrupt cabinet ministers who had serious state capture findings against them Zondo made the remarks on the sidelines of a South African Council of Churches (SACC) anti-corruption summit on Wednesday. State capture commission Rampant corruption was revealed during the hearings before the commission chaired by Zondo that was established in January 2018. The commission, which cost close to R1 billion, wrapped up its proceedings with Zondo handing his final report to President Cyril Ramaphosa in June 2022. About 1,400 individuals were implicated during the commission. It exposed corruption at the Passenger Rail Agency of South Africa (Prasa), State Security Agency (SSA), Eskom and SABC, and called for prosecutions, further probes, and systemic reforms. ALSO READ: 'Ramaphosa will go down in history as one of the most useless presidents' – analyst Corruption Zondo said that more than 30 years after democracy, corruption had reached crippling levels. He delivered a scathing rebuke to Ramaphosa about the ministers he had appointed to be part of his Cabinet, 'It was like the president was saying, 'I don't care what you have found about these people. I think they are good enough to be promoted,'' Zondo told the Sunday Times. 'The recommendations that were made were based on evidence that was led transparently, when the whole nation was watching… We are defending the report because we believe it is sound. 'But yes, I had to swear them in, remembering what I found against them,' Zondo said in an unprecedented attack by such a senior judicial officer on a sitting president. Ramaphosa response While The Citizen has contacted Ramaphosa's spokesperson for comment, he told the paper the president would not be drawn into a public spat with Zondo. 'The former chief justice has had access to the president whenever there were matters of concern to be discussed. 'The president will respond directly to the former chief justice should [he] seek an opportunity to raise his issues through a direct and constructive engagement,' he said. Presidency report In 2023, the Presidency published a detailed report on the implementation of the actions on Ramaphosa's response to the recommendations of the state capture report. It followed Ramaphosa's own 76-page state capture implementation plan, which he submitted to Parliament in October 2022. The president's response to the recommendations of the state capture inquiry outlined his plan of action, as well as his stance and commitment to fighting corruption within the government. ALSO READ: Ramaphosa's actions on state capture are 'major reforms that will take years' – Presidency report Recommendations In its 16 main recommendations, the Zondo commission found that Parliament failed in its oversight role to hold the executive to account after several state institutions were captured, costing the state billions. It said the recommendations by Zondo were mainly in relation to the national legislature's oversight mandate. Mchunu inquiry Referring to the latest inquiry ordered by Ramaphosa, in which acting deputy chief justice Mbuyiseli Madlanga will probe the allegations of KwaZulu-Natal police commissioner Lieutenant-General Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi, Zondo said the way the government had responded to the state capture commission did not bode well. 'My feelings are that people in South Africa have seen how slow the progress is with the implementation of the commission's recommendations, even regarding those recommendations that are being implemented.' '[Will] the same not happen to the [Madlanga] commission … because this commission is also important.' National dialogue Zondo also expressed doubts over the upcoming national dialogue, saying he was concerned about basic failings in the country that should be fixed without having to convene such a forum. 'I don't want to say it's a bad thing … [but] I'm concerned about simple things that don't need a national dialogue. I'm concerned about making sure that in municipalities we have competent people who are doing their job, people who have integrity'. ALSO READ: D-Day for Ramaphosa's plan of action on state capture report 'Ramaphosa inconsistent Zondo told the SACC event on Wednesday that Ramaphosa had been 'inconsistent' in disciplining cabinet ministers implicated in wrongdoing, citing the recent scandals involving the minister of human settlements, Thembi Simelane, embattled police minister Senzo Mchunu, who has been placed on special leave, and the now-fired higher education minister Nobuhle Nkabane. 'So the question arises, what is the rule? As a minister, when do you get shifted to another department and continue to be a minister and enjoy your position and benefits even though there are allegations against you? When do you get out on special leave, and when do you get removed? 'The president is the No. 1 citizen in the country. It is very important that the message he sends, through what he does and through what he says, must be consistent,' Zondo said. Swearing in ministers Zondo said this is similar to what happened two years ago. 'I found myself having to swear in ministers against whom I had made adverse findings in the commission. One was a deputy minister who was now promoted to a full minister, and I had to swear them in, knowing the findings I had made. 'Another one was the deputy minister who was a chairperson of the portfolio committee who had previously been minister of transport, and I had made findings against them, and the president was promoting them despite the findings of the commission. What does that do to our fight against corruption?' Zondo said. Ridding SA of corruption Zondo said for the country to effectively rid itself of corruption, it needs to hold the executive to account and not compromise on those who serve in the highest offices of the land. He said that those facing corruption allegations should not be appointed to any positions. 'There are many people who have no allegations of fraud or corruption hanging over their heads who qualify to be ministers,' said Zondo. 'Even in the same party, there is no reason why somebody should be appointed before they clear themselves of such allegations. But also, there are people in public service who are allowed to continue with their work as usual even when there are findings of wrongdoing against them. The state simply allows them to continue. This is not the kind of leadership we need if we are going to fight corruption.' 'Consequences' In November 2022 in his weekly newsletter, Ramaphosa said there must be consequences for those who had plundered South Africa and involved in state capture. He also said the country had learnt its lesson in plundering money over the years of state capture 'As we recover from state capture, we must ensure there are consequences for the perpetrators of state capture. We also need to make sure that public institutions can never be weakened in this way again,' Ramaphosa said. Ramaphosa said South Africa needed to build a public service that is professional, ethical and driven by merit. ALSO READ: WATCH: Moeletsi Mbeki criticises Ramaphosa: 'He's been a very weak president'
IOL News
a day ago
- IOL News
Trial of alleged Durban hitman delayed due to absent lawyer
The trial of two hitmen has had a setback as lawyer Sthembiso Nkatha fails to come to court Image: FILE Concerns as a trial of alleged hitmen charged with 15 murders faces delays due to a lawyer who also acts as a Magistrate has been a no-show at the Durban High Court. The lawyer has 'failed' to formally excuse himself from the case. The murders include the mass shooting at Durban's iNanda, which resulted in the death of six people. The said lawyer, Sthembiso Nkatha, represents Sbonelo 'Madanon' Wiseman Shangase. Shangase is charged alongside Thalente Mkhize. They together face 28 charges, including the 15 murders, robberies, attempted murders, possession of firearms and ammunition, and kidnapping. Their trial was scheduled to run from July 21 to August 22; however, on Monday, the matter could not commence as Nkatha was not present. Additionally, last year, the pre-trial of the men faced delays due to Shangase's payment issues with Nkatha. However, despite all of that, Nkatha committed to Judge Bruce Bedderson that he would continue representing Shangase after he was assured of payment. Judge Bedderson warned Nkatha that by agreeing to continue representing his client, 'he was handcuffed to the train and wouldn't be able to jump off.' Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Next Stay Close ✕ Moreover, last year, when Shangase had failed to pay Nkatha, the court had warned him that he would represent himself. On Monday, he applied for legal Aid as Nkatha was a no-show. On Thursday, Shangase made a brief appearance at the high court before Judge Jacqueline Henriques, who asked him if Nkatha had contacted him regarding funds. 'Is there a possibility that he may have contacted members of your family?' she asked. Shangase seemed to be in the dark. Judge Henriques asked him if any of his family members were present in court. Shangase turned back to look at the gallery and responded by telling the Judge that no one was there. She asked Shangase if he had consulted with Nkatha before July 21, and he said no. Judge Henriques, who looked concerned and kept on brushing her hair with her hand and seemed frustrated, asked again when Shangase had a consultation with Nkatha. Shangase said it was before the end of 2024. Additionally, it had been said that Nkatha withdrew his services due to non-payment; however, the State senior prosecutor, advocate Krishen Shah, told Judge Henriques that he had not received an email from Nkatha stating that. He said in the past weeks he had emailed Nkatha and advocate Phumelele Daniso from Legal Aid additional statements, and it was delivered to both of them. Daniso is representing Mkhize. 'There was no response from Nkatha,' he said. Shah confirmed to Judge Henriques that Nkatha acts as a magistrate. Judge Henriques asked Shah to forward her the email he had sent to Nkatha and delivery receipts. He adjourned the matter to Monday for Shangase's legal representation issue.
