Govt panel opposes three-language policy, asks CM to roll back decision on Hindi in primary classes
The Language Advisory Committee, which makes recommendations to the government on matters related to the Marathi language, passed a resolution on Friday demanding that no third language, including Hindi, be taught before Class 5.
The resolution was passed during a meeting held in Pune, attended by 20 out of 27 committee members. Kiran Kulkarni, secretary of the Marathi language department, was also present during the meeting.
A language row has erupted in Maharashtra after the state government recently issued an amended order stating that Hindi will "generally" be taught as a third language to students from Classes 1 to 5 in Marathi and English medium schools.
According to the order, if 20 students per grade in a school wish to study any other Indian language, they can opt out of Hindi. If such a demand arises, either a teacher will be appointed, or the language will be taught online.
Speaking to reporters, the committee's chairman, Laxmikant Deshmukh, said that it was the first time a government-backed body has taken such a stand against a government decision.
"We are not against Hindi or any other language, but imposing it in early schooling is neither educationally sound nor culturally appropriate. Language learning in the early years must focus on the mother tongue for strong foundational skills," he said.
Deshmukh said the committee had previously flagged concerns after the government's decision to make Hindi a part of the primary school curriculum, but its objections were brushed aside.
"The government attempted to bypass this by presenting misleading interpretations. We want the government resolution on this matter to be cancelled outright," he said.
Committee members, including renowned language expert Prakash Parab and senior Marathi writer Shripad Bhalchandra Joshi, raised the issue during the meeting and received unanimous support.
Joshi, a scholar and educationist, warned of consequences.
"English was introduced as a compulsory subject for primary classes in Marathi-medium schools in 1999. It is worth noting that Marathi was made compulsory in English-medium schools seven years later, and as a result, children could not learn either language properly. Now, by adding Hindi or any other third language early on, children's linguistic abilities will only weaken," he said.
He claimed the move was a systematic attempt to dilute Maharashtra's intellectual strength.
The main functions of the committee are to advise the government on the development and preservation of the Marathi language, and this includes preparing new dictionaries, selecting standardised words, setting guidelines for the use of the language and determining policies, among other things.
The committee's resolution also states that the idea of introducing a third language should only be considered after Class 5, and even then, it should remain optional.
"As an advisory committee, we strongly recommend that the government avoid introducing a third language in primary schools," Deshmukh said.
Doing so could negatively affect students' psychological development and undermine the cultural identity of the state, he said, adding that the committee has also decided to participate in the Shiv Sena -MNS morcha on July 5.
This article was generated from an automated news agency feed without modifications to text.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
&w=3840&q=100)
Business Standard
a minute ago
- Business Standard
Russian crude oil continues to flow to India: First Deputy PM Manturo
Russian oil and energy resources continue to flow to India as Moscow sees potential for LNG exports, Russia's First Deputy Prime Minister Denis Manturo said on Wednesday. "We continue to ship fuel, including crude oil and oil products, thermal and coking coal. We see potential for exporting Russian LNG," Manturov said, co-chairing the 26th session of the India-Russia Intergovernmental Commission on Trade, Economic, Scientific-Technological and Cultural Cooperation (IRIGC-TEC). From the Indian side, the commission was co-chaired by External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar, who arrived here on Tuesday on a three-day visit. "We expect to expand comprehensive cooperation in the peaceful nuclear sector, including on the basis of the successful experience of the Kudankulam NPP construction project," the Russian leader said. Manturov noted that trade between Russia and India in national currencies has exceeded 90 per cent. "An equally important task, especially in the current realities, is to ensure seamless mutual settlements. We have already managed to transfer more than 90 per cent of payments between Russia and India to national currencies," Manturov said. India and Russia will continue to develop cooperation in the banking sector to further strengthen interbank cooperation and interaction in the insurance sector, he added. After the meeting, Jaishankar in a social media post said, We had detailed discussions on our cooperation in a wide-ranging arena including trade & economic sector, agriculture, energy, industries, skilling, mobility, education and culture. As we prepare for the Annual Leaders Summit, confident that the outcomes of the IRIGC-TEC meeting today will further drive the time-tested India-Russia partnership, he added. Jaishankar and Manturov signed the protocol of the IRIGC-TEC sessions; details of which would be released later by the governments in New Delhi and Moscow. Earlier, Jaishankar laid wreaths at the Tomb of Unknown Soldier at the Kremlin Wall to pay homage to Soviet people who died in World War II. He also met with experts of top Russian think-tanks to explain recent developments in India's foreign policy. Before leaving for home on Thursday, he will meet his Russian counterpart Sergei Lavrov to discuss current issues amid the global turmoil and Trump administration's sanctions on India. Lavrov and Jaishankar will also set the agenda for President Vladimir Putin and Prime Minister Narendra Modi's meeting on the sidelines of the Shanghai Cooperation Summit in China from August 31 to September 1. The relations between New Delhi and Washington are on a downturn after US President Donald Trump doubled tariffs on Indian goods to a whopping 50 per cent, including a 25 per cent additional duties for India's purchase of Russian crude oil that will come into effect from August 27. (Only the headline and picture of this report may have been reworked by the Business Standard staff; the rest of the content is auto-generated from a syndicated feed.)
Indian Express
a minute ago
- Indian Express
Pakistan extends airspace ban for Indian aircraft till September 23
Pakistan authorities on Wednesday extended its airspace ban for Indian aircraft till September 23. The Pakistan Airports Authority has issued a fresh NOTAM (notice to airmen) announcing the one-month extension of the restriction on Indian aircraft in Pakistan's airspace. 'All aircraft operated by Indian airlines will not be allowed to use Pakistani airspace. The ban also remains in place for military and civilian aircraft that are Indian-owned or leased,' the authority said. The ban was initially imposed on April 23 for one month in the wake of tension between the two countries following the Pahalgam terrorist attack. The move barred Indian carriers and aircraft from flying over Pakistani territory. Days later, on April 30, India responded with a reciprocal airspace closure for Pakistani aircraft and airlines. The tit-for-tat restrictions were first extended on May 23.
Hindustan Times
a minute ago
- Hindustan Times
Eye on US, Jaishankar says India, Russia need to be creative to overcome challenges
NEW DELHI: India and Russia should adopt a 'more creative and innovative approach' to tackle challenges posed by a complex geopolitical situation, external affairs minister S Jaishankar said on Wednesday while co-chairing a meeting of a bilateral economic panel amid US threats of punitive action against energy trade between New Delhi and Moscow. External affairs minister S Jaishankar with First deputy prime minister Denis Manturov of Russia during the 26th India-Russia Inter-Governmental Commission on Trade, Economic, Scientific, Technological and Cultural Cooperation IRIGC-TEC, in Moscow on Wednesday. (X/DrSJaishankar via ANI) Jaishankar also sought urgent steps to address the sharp imbalance in India-Russia trade and to diversify trade and investment between the two sides, while addressing the meeting of the India-Russia Inter-Governmental Commission for Trade, Economic, Scientific, Technological, and Cultural Cooperation (IRIGC-TEC) in Moscow. The meeting, part of preparations for Russian President Vladimir Putin's planned visit to India later this year for a summit with Prime Minister Narendra Modi, was held against the backdrop of the Donald Trump administration in the US railing energy trade between India and Russia. The US is set to impose a 25% punitive tariff on Indian exports from August 28 over Russian oil purchases, which will be in addition to a 25% reciprocal tariff. 'We are all acutely aware that we are meeting in the backdrop of a complex geopolitical situation,' Jaishankar said without referring to the trade and tariff policies of the US. The different working groups under the IRIGC-TEC, he suggested, should adopt a 'more creative and innovative approach' to face the challenges posed by the geopolitical landscape. Russian deputy prime minister Denis Manturov, who co-chaired the meeting, emphasised Moscow's commitment to continuing to meet New Delhi's energy needs. 'We continue to ship fuel, including crude oil and oil products, thermal and coking coal. We see potential for the export of Russian LNG,' he said. The Indian side reiterated its concerns about the imbalance in two-way trade, driven largely by purchases of Russian energy, while Indian exports have remained stagnant. Bilateral trade reached a record of $68.7 billion in 2024-25, although India's exports were valued at only $4.88 billion. Jaishankar noted that two-way trade in goods has increased more than fivefold in the past four years, whereas the imbalance has risen ninefold from $6.6 billion to $58.9 billion. 'So we need to address that urgently,' he said. He suggested that addressing tariff and non-tariff trade barriers, removing bottlenecks in logistics, promoting connectivity through the International North-South Transport Corridor, Northern Sea Route and Chennai-Vladivostok Corridor, and implementing payment mechanisms smoothly could help tackle the imbalance and allow the two sides to achieve the target of growing trade to $100 billion by 2030. Jaishankar also called for the early conclusion of the India-Eurasian Economic Union free trade agreement, whose terms of reference were finalised on Wednesday. Economic cooperation can be deepened by the smoothness of trade settlements, diversification of the trade basket, creating more joint ventures and collaborating on the mobility of professionals, he suggested. 'We should not get stuck on a beaten track. Doing more and doing differently should be our mantras,' he said, while calling for the setting of quantifiable targets and specific timelines for trade and investment and for tackling barriers. India and Russia have two inter-governmental commissions, one for trade and technology-related issues and another for defence and military cooperation, and these are among the highest bilateral decision-making bodies. The India-Russia Inter-Governmental Commission on Military Technical Cooperation is set to meet in New Delhi in the coming weeks. Manturov said that in addition to direct supplies of crude oil, the two sides are jointly implementing projects to extract and process hydrocarbons in Russia and India. 'We plan to expand comprehensive cooperation in the peaceful nuclear sector, including on the basis of the successful experience of the Kudankulam NPP construction project,' he said. Putin and Modi have spoken on the phone twice in recent weeks to discuss the situation in Ukraine and the overall bilateral relationship. The fallout from the actions of the US administration is also understood to have been discussed in their phone conversations. The external affairs ministry has defended India's purchases of Russian energy and bilateral defence ties on the grounds that they are linked to the country's energy and national security interests.
