Is it legal for your neighbor to record you on camera in New York?
While New York state law doesn't ban neighbors from taking video of you on your property, legal lines are drawn when privacy can be reasonably expected.
When recording you on your property becomes illegal
New York law does not prohibit filming individuals in areas where they can be seen from the public, including lawns, driveways or front porches. If you're visible from the street or your neighbor's yard, the recording is likely lawful.
However, when you step into settings where privacy is expected, like behind high fences or in secluded corners of your backyard, the legal status changes.
Under New York Civil Rights Law section 52-a, it is unlawful to install or use a video surveillance device in any location where a person has a reasonable expectation of privacy, such as a restroom, bedroom or any 'private place without the knowledge or consent of the person being observed.'
As for backyards, if yours is fenced in, shielded from public view and generally treated as a private space, this law could apply, especially if the recording feels targeted or intrusive.
Add audio recording and the NYS rules change
The rules shift once audio recording is introduced.
New York is a "one-party" consent state, meaning permission is required from at least one person being recorded with audio. In a situation where your neighbor is recording a private conversation they are not involved in, there must be either written or verbal consent.
Not obtaining permission violates Section 250.05 of the New York Penal Law.
Even if the recording doesn't clearly violate section 52-a, repeated or intrusive surveillance could amount to civil harassment, stalking or invasion of privacy. You may be able to take legal action, even if there's no criminal charge.
Love thy neighbor? Can I remove my neighbor's fence if it's on my property? What New York state law allows
What to do if you're concerned
Start by having a conversation with your neighbor. In many cases, people aren't aware that their security cameras or smartphones are capturing more than intended.
Consider whether your concerns are about a setting that truly offers privacy. According to Nolo, a legal information website, it's essential to understand "the extent of one's legal privacy [which] depends on things like layout, openness and other location-specific details."
It's also important to document the issue. If a camera seems deliberately pointed at your property or if recording appears frequent and targeted, take note of dates, times and any interactions.
Nolo also said, "A simple demand letter from an attorney might persuade your neighbor that you will not submit to unwarranted snooping, even if you would not ultimately proceed to court with such a claim."
If the issue persists, legal support or community mediation services may help resolve the situation. Involving a real estate or civil attorney can clarify your rights and help prevent future conflicts.
This article originally appeared on Rockland/Westchester Journal News: NY privacy laws: When does it become illegal to film someone's property?
Solve the daily Crossword
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
16-07-2025
- Yahoo
Is it legal for your neighbor to record you on camera in New York?
In an age where smartphones and security cameras are everywhere, you might feel uneasy if you spot a camera pointed toward your home or property. While New York state law doesn't ban neighbors from taking video of you on your property, legal lines are drawn when privacy can be reasonably expected. When recording you on your property becomes illegal New York law does not prohibit filming individuals in areas where they can be seen from the public, including lawns, driveways or front porches. If you're visible from the street or your neighbor's yard, the recording is likely lawful. However, when you step into settings where privacy is expected, like behind high fences or in secluded corners of your backyard, the legal status changes. Under New York Civil Rights Law section 52-a, it is unlawful to install or use a video surveillance device in any location where a person has a reasonable expectation of privacy, such as a restroom, bedroom or any 'private place without the knowledge or consent of the person being observed.' As for backyards, if yours is fenced in, shielded from public view and generally treated as a private space, this law could apply, especially if the recording feels targeted or intrusive. Add audio recording and the NYS rules change The rules shift once audio recording is introduced. New York is a "one-party" consent state, meaning permission is required from at least one person being recorded with audio. In a situation where your neighbor is recording a private conversation they are not involved in, there must be either written or verbal consent. Not obtaining permission violates Section 250.05 of the New York Penal Law. Even if the recording doesn't clearly violate section 52-a, repeated or intrusive surveillance could amount to civil harassment, stalking or invasion of privacy. You may be able to take legal action, even if there's no criminal charge. Love thy neighbor? Can I remove my neighbor's fence if it's on my property? What New York state law allows What to do if you're concerned Start by having a conversation with your neighbor. In many cases, people aren't aware that their security cameras or smartphones are capturing more than intended. Consider whether your concerns are about a setting that truly offers privacy. According to Nolo, a legal information website, it's essential to understand "the extent of one's legal privacy [which] depends on things like layout, openness and other location-specific details." It's also important to document the issue. If a camera seems deliberately pointed at your property or if recording appears frequent and targeted, take note of dates, times and any interactions. Nolo also said, "A simple demand letter from an attorney might persuade your neighbor that you will not submit to unwarranted snooping, even if you would not ultimately proceed to court with such a claim." If the issue persists, legal support or community mediation services may help resolve the situation. Involving a real estate or civil attorney can clarify your rights and help prevent future conflicts. This article originally appeared on Rockland/Westchester Journal News: NY privacy laws: When does it become illegal to film someone's property? Solve the daily Crossword
Chicago Tribune
18-06-2025
- Chicago Tribune
Porter Superior Court Judge Roger Bradford remembered for fairness, Portage pride
Retired Porter Superior Court Judge Roger Bradford is being remembered for his fairness on the bench, athleticism and Portage pride since his passing Sunday. Porter County Prosecutor Gary Germann has known Bradford since 1970, when they attended Valparaiso University Law School together. 'People do not realize what a really great athlete he was,' said Germann, who played on Nolo contendere, the Porter County Bar Association softball team, with Bradford for over a decade. 'He was our second baseman.' That was a continuation of Bradford's sporting days at Portage Township Schools, where he was nicknamed 'Mr. Machine' in basketball, according to his obituary with Edmonds & Evans Funeral Home. After attending Indiana State University, Bradford taught fourth and fifth grades in Union Township. He married Mary Kaltenbach, with whom he had two daughters and one granddaughter. After graduating from VU Law School, Bradford worked in private practice and was appointed to county court in Portage and then to Porter County Superior Court in 1979. He served on that bench for over 40 years before retiring in 2020. The state awarded him the Sagamore of the Wabash. Germann said Bradford was one of the best judges he's ever appeared under. 'He was a great listener, very consistent, which is what you always want from a judge,' Germann said. Even when Bradford ruled against him, Germann always felt his judgment was fair. That's a sentiment echoed by Porter County Sheriff Jeff Balon, who used to appear before Bradford when he testified in court as a detective for the Valparaiso Police Department. 'There were cases where I had success in front of Judge Bradford and cases where I did not,' Balon recalled, but either way, he 'was fair overall.' 'Judge Bradford was the epitome of a good judge,' Balon added. 'He was fair. He was firm. He was honest. He was trustworthy. Let's add knowledgeable to that list.' Porter County Chief Public Defender Ken Elwood knew Bradford for 30 years. 'He was just a good person, very even-keeled,' he said. 'The time that he was on the bench, Porter County residents should have definitely felt safer.' Elwood also played in the Porter County Bar Association Golf League with Bradford for several years and said those Wednesday evening games and the Ryder Cup-style tournaments Bradford organized were a lot of fun. Porter County Board of Commissioners President Jim Biggs, R-North, said Bradford was very involved in the community. 'He was everything you wanted a judge to be,' said Biggs. 'He was a very quiet individual, especially if you didn't know him, but he was a consummate professional. You never heard any complaints. He just went about his job.' That community involvement extended to Bradford's lifelong love of Portage. Elwood said Bradford's family had a farm off Willowcreek Road and McCasland Avenue. 'It was pretty neat to hear the Portage roots,' he said. 'I coached Portage High School football in the 90s and he came to every game for years. He was a Portage guy through and through.' Visitation will be from 4 to 8 p.m. on Thursday, June 19, at Edmonds & Evans Funeral Home, Portage Chapel, 6941 Central Ave. in Portage. The funeral is at 6 p.m. Friday at the funeral home with additional visitation from 4 to 6 p.m.
Yahoo
04-05-2025
- Yahoo
N.Y.C. Man Discovers Human Remains While Gardening in His Yard: 'Bone Fragments Were Left Behind'
A man discovered human remains at the "rear" of his home in Queens, N.Y., on Thursday, May 1 A spokesperson for the NYPD told PEOPLE that the remains are from a human cremation and that "bone fragments were left behind" Authorities said an investigation into the situation is still ongoing A man made a startling discovery while gardening at his home. A spokesperson for the New York Police Department (NYPD)'s Public Information Office confirmed to PEOPLE that officers responded to a 911 call from a 33-year-old man regarding the discovery of 'human remains' at a residence in Whitestone, a neighborhood in Queens. The call came at about 8:25 a.m. local time on Thursday, May 1. The spokesperson said officers 'observed possible ashes' and dentures located at the 'rear' of the residence. They further told PEOPLE that the New York City Office of Chief Medical Examiner and an anthropologist have since confirmed that the remains "were from a human cremation and that bone fragments were left behind." Related: Human Remains Found in Gravel Beside Children's Playground in 'Shocking' Discovery: Reports The investigation is still ongoing, according to the NYPD. Both The New York Post and The New York Daily News reported that the man who made the discovery was gardening at the time the remains were found. Never miss a story — sign up for to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories. While there are no state regulations in New York regarding the burial of human remains on private property, there are local regulations in many areas, per the New York Department of State. In New York City, specifically, one must have permission from the property owner to bury the remains and also attain a permit, according to the legal information site Nolo. Read the original article on People
