Trump's threats against Russia are a charade meant to buy Putin time
was going to end the
Russo-Ukrainian war
in 24 hours. Then it was two weeks, then 100 days, then two weeks again – several times – and now 50 days. Trump increasingly resembles Humpty Dumpty in Alice in Wonderland. Words mean whatever he wants them to mean – that is to say, nothing.
Trump reversed the announced suspension of weapons transfers to Ukraine on July 14th, when he promised to
sell Patriot missiles and other weapons to Nato members, who could in turn pass them on to Ukraine
. And if
Vladimir Putin
doesn't accept peace with Ukraine in 50 days,
Trump says he'll slap 100 per cent tariffs on trade with Russia
and countries including China and India which fund Putin's war with purchases of Russian hydrocarbons.
Since his inauguration, Trump has punished Ukraine, the victim, repeatedly; Russia, the aggressor, not once. So what are we to make of the apparent change in policy?
Nothing, says Phillips Payson O'Brien, professor of strategic studies at University of St Andrews in Scotland. 'Trump basically gave Putin 50 days' protection from new sanctions,' O'Brien says. 'Trump is allowing Putin to hit Ukrainian cities hard for the rest of the summer and take little pieces of land. Then Putin can ask for a ceasefire if he wants to, keeping everything he has. What Trump has done benefits Putin. The weapons will take months to reach Ukraine and are in any case significantly less than transfers before Trump took office.'
READ MORE
Trump's threat of 100 per cent tariffs on Russia 'is all fantasy', O'Brien says. A Bill proposed by Senators Lindsey Graham and Richard Blumenthal would impose 500 per cent tariffs on Russia. 'Trump was under pressure to allow a vote on Graham-Blumenthal by the end of July, and now he can put that off until September ... The White House wanted to create a narrative that Trump is standing by Ukraine, but it's not true.'
In his book War and Power: Who Wins Wars and Why, to be published by Penguin Viking next month, O'Brien criticises those who predicted Ukraine would rapidly collapse, and who believe Ukraine will inevitably be defeated. They labour under the 'great power paradigm' – a 19th century belief that powerful countries do what they please while weak countries suffer what they must.
The so-called experts 'had a high school boys' war game view of war: the Russians win and march to victory. But war doesn't work that way. It's unpredictable. War always goes off the rails'.
A 'monoculture' comprised mostly of western Russia experts with a Russo-centric view, who saw Ukrainians as 'almost-Russians', badly misjudged the conflict, O'Brien says. The Ukrainians did not just roll over. Like the Vietnamese and Afghans before them, they have fought fiercely because they are fighting for their independence.
Ukraine still controls 80 per cent of its territory, despite Russia's superior strength and numbers. Ukraine's ability to 'win the adaptation cycle' or 'fight smart' is one reason, O'Brien says.
[
Nato's new defence spending commitment aims to reverse decades of military decline
Opens in new window
]
Former defence minister Andriy Zagorodnyuk last month defined 'strategic neutralisation' as a strategy for Ukraine's survival, based not on battlefield victory or negotiations, but on systematically denying Russia the ability to achieve its military goals.
Precedents are
Ukraine's destruction of much of Russia's Black Sea fleet using unmanned sea drones
. The Russian navy still exists, but it can no longer blockade Ukraine's ports. Likewise, Ukraine's use of kamikaze drones has created a frontline 'kill zone' 20km to 40km deep which prevents Russian troops from advancing. The air war remains Ukraine's greatest problem, with Russia firing hundreds of drones and missiles at Ukrainian cities nightly.
Europe's failure to draw up a serious plan for Trump's presidency was 'a huge failure of European leadership', says O'Brien. Europe has often let Ukraine down, but now it must try to compensate for lost US support.
The
'Coalition of the willing'
led by British prime minister Keir Starmer and French president Emmanuel Macron is 'not very good but it's all we've got', O'Brien continues.
The British are desperate to preserve their 'special relationship' with the US. 'The French in many ways have been the great disappointment, because de Gaulle was saying this moment would arrive 60 years ago: 'The US will go home. The US is unreliable. Europe needs to look after itself, have the capacity to be a power.' This is the French narrative and this is their moment. They have bungled it until now.'
[
Republicans' rush to shift stance on Ukraine shows Trump's iron grip on party
Opens in new window
]
O'Brien is scathing about liberal American academics including Jeffrey Sachs, John Mearsheimer and Stephen Walt, who claim that confrontational policies on the part of the US and Nato provoked Russia's war on Ukraine.
'You cannot counter it, because they believe it. It's like a religion, not actually fact. How does one counter the belief in papal infallibility?'
But why has Putin's 'Nato made me do it' excuse won such broad currency in the West? 'People love lies,' O'Brien replies. 'Look at Trump. We live in an era of lies. This is just another one.'
Lara Marlowe will interview Professor Phillips O'Brien at the Galway Arts Festival today, Saturday, July 19th, at 2pm in Bailey Allen Hall, University of Galway
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Daily Mirror
5 minutes ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Putin and Zelensky to meet, Donald Trump says following European leaders' summit
Presidents Vladimir Putin and Volodymyr Zelensky will meet, Donald Trump has said following a White House summit with European leaders aimed at bringing an end to the war in Ukraine. The US president spoke directly with the Russian president to begin planning a meeting between the two warring leaders, which will then be followed by a three-way meeting involving himself. It comes after Mr Trump said Moscow will "accept" multinational efforts to guarantee Ukraine's security while hosting several European leaders including the Ukrainian President, UK Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer, French President Emmanuel Macron and Nato secretary general Mark Rutte. Posting on his Truth Social platform after the meeting, Mr Trump said he and the eight leaders discussed security guarantees before he called the Russian president. Russia's President Vladimir Putin. (Image: POOL/AFP via Getty Images) He described the meeting as "very good" and added: "During the meeting we discussed security guarantees for Ukraine, which guarantees would be provided by the various European countries, with a coordination with the United States of America. "Everyone is happy about the possibility of PEACE for Russia/Ukraine. "At the conclusion of the meetings, I called president Putin and began arrangements for a meeting, at a location to be determined, between president Putin and president Zelensky. "After the meeting takes place, we will have a trilat which would be the two presidents plus myself." Before the White House talks, the US president said he would "probably" be able to find common ground with the leaders on a plan to ward off future attacks on Ukraine. He previously met with Mr Putin in Anchorage, Alaska, on Friday, where he declared there was "no deal until there's a deal" to end more than three years of fighting in eastern Europe. "The Alaska summit reinforced my belief that while difficult, peace is within reach and I believe, in a very significant step, President Putin agreed that Russia would accept security guarantees for Ukraine," Mr Trump said on Monday. "And this is one of the key points that we need to consider." United States President Donald Trump makes remarks as he participates in a Multilateral Meeting with European Leaders in the East Room of the White House in Washington, DC, US. Picture date: Monday August 18, 2025. PA Photo. Photo credit should read: Aaron Schwartz/PA Wire He later said: "We also need to discuss the possible exchanges of territory taken into consideration the current line of contact." Mr Trump's envoy, Steve Witkoff, had suggested measures similar to Nato's article five mutual defence provision – that an attack on one member is an attack on the entire bloc – could be offered by the US without Kyiv joining the alliance. "We were able to win the following concession: that the United States could offer article five-like protection, which is one of the real reasons why Ukraine wants to be in Nato," Mr Witkoff told CNN over the weekend, as he spoke about the Alaska summit. Future three-way talks "have a good chance" of stopping the conflict, the US president claimed. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky participates in a Multilateral Meeting with European Leaders in the East Room of the White House in Washington, DC, US. Picture date: Monday August 18, 2025. PA Photo. Photo credit should read: Aaron Schwartz/PA Wire But the president appeared to share conflicting views on whether a ceasefire was necessary to stop the war. "I don't think you need a ceasefire," he had originally said, before later explaining that, "all of us would obviously prefer an immediate ceasefire while we work on a lasting peace". Mr Zelensky, whom Mr Trump greeted at the door of the West Wing with a handshake earlier in the evening, wore a black shirt with buttons and a black blazer to the meeting at the White House. His attire had appeared to become a point of irritation for Mr Trump during a previous meeting in February. Early in the meeting, the Ukrainian described the talks as "really good", saying they had been "the best" so far. Mr Zelensky said: "We are very happy with the president that all the leaders are here and security in Ukraine depends on the United States and on you and on those leaders who are with us in our hearts." Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news from the Irish Mirror direct to your inbox: Sign up here.
Irish Examiner
35 minutes ago
- Irish Examiner
Putin and Zelenskyy to meet, Donald Trump says following European leaders summit
Presidents Vladimir Putin and Volodymyr Zelenskyy will meet, Donald Trump has said following a White House summit with European leaders aimed at bringing an end to the war in Ukraine. The US president spoke directly with the Russian president to begin planning a meeting between the two warring leaders, which will then be followed by a three-way meeting involving himself. It comes after Mr Trump said Moscow will 'accept' multinational efforts to guarantee Ukraine's security while hosting several European leaders including the Ukrainian President, UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer, French President Emmanuel Macron and Nato secretary general Mark Rutte. Posting on his Truth Social platform after the meeting, Mr Trump said he and the eight leaders discussed security guarantees before he called the Russian president. He described the meeting as 'very good' and added: 'During the meeting we discussed security guarantees for Ukraine, which guarantees would be provided by the various European countries, with a coordination with the United States of America. 'Everyone is happy about the possibility of PEACE for Russia/Ukraine. 'At the conclusion of the meetings, I called president Putin and began arrangements for a meeting, at a location to be determined, between president Putin and president Zelenskyy. 'After the meeting takes place, we will have a trilat which would be the two presidents plus myself.' Before the White House talks, the US president said he would 'probably' be able to find common ground with the leaders on a plan to ward off future attacks on Ukraine. He previously met with Mr Putin in Anchorage, Alaska, on Friday, where he declared there was 'no deal until there's a deal' to end more than three years of fighting in eastern Europe. 'The Alaska summit reinforced my belief that while difficult, peace is within reach and I believe, in a very significant step, President Putin agreed that Russia would accept security guarantees for Ukraine,' Mr Trump said on Monday. 'And this is one of the key points that we need to consider.' We are very happy with the president that all the leaders are here and security in Ukraine depends on the United States and on you and on those leaders who are with us in our hearts He later said: 'We also need to discuss the possible exchanges of territory taken into consideration the current line of contact.' Mr Trump's envoy, Steve Witkoff, had suggested measures similar to Nato's article five mutual defence provision – that an attack on one member is an attack on the entire bloc – could be offered by the US without Kyiv joining the alliance. 'We were able to win the following concession: that the United States could offer article five-like protection, which is one of the real reasons why Ukraine wants to be in Nato,' Mr Witkoff told CNN over the weekend, as he spoke about the Alaska summit. Future three-way talks 'have a good chance' of stopping the conflict, the US president claimed. But the president appeared to share conflicting views on whether a ceasefire was necessary to stop the war. 'I don't think you need a ceasefire,' he had originally said, before later explaining that, 'all of us would obviously prefer an immediate ceasefire while we work on a lasting peace'. Keir Starmer welcomed plans for a security guarantee, after Mr Trump introduced him at the negotiating table as a 'friend'. Mr Starmer said: 'Your indication of security guarantees, of some sort of article five-style guarantees, fits with what we've been doing with the coalition of the willing which we started some months ago, bringing countries together and showing that we were prepared to step up to the plate when it came to security. United States President Donald J Trump leads European leaders, including Sir Keir Starmer, in the Cross Hall of the White House (Aaron Schwartz/PA) 'With you coming alongside, the US alongside, what we've already developed, I think we could take a really important step forward today – a historic step, actually, could come out of this meeting in terms of security for Ukraine and security in Europe.' Mr Zelenskyy, whom Mr Trump greeted at the door of the West Wing with a handshake earlier in the evening, wore a black shirt with buttons and a black blazer to the meeting at the White House. His attire had appeared to become a point of irritation for Mr Trump during a previous meeting in February. Early in the meeting, the Ukrainian described the talks as 'really good', saying they had been 'the best' so far. Mr Zelenskyy said: 'We are very happy with the president that all the leaders are here and security in Ukraine depends on the United States and on you and on those leaders who are with us in our hearts.'
Extra.ie
35 minutes ago
- Extra.ie
Positive outcome after White House meeting with Ukraine
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky sounded optimistic after his meeting at the White House yesterday, in which he held discussions with President Donald Trump aimed at ending Russia's war in Ukraine. European officials said the hastily arranged talks reflected the urgency many leaders feel, along with President Trump, on ending the war, which has claimed thousands of lives over the past three and a half years. Trump and Zelensky held an initial meeting, before they were then joined in a discussion with key European leaders from Britain, France, Germany, Italy, Finland, The European Commission and NATO. WASHINGTON, DC – AUGUST 18: U.S. President Donald Trump meets with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky at the White House on August 18, 2025 in Washington, DC. (Photo by) The atmosphere was much friendlier than that of the last meeting at the White House, which descended into a shouting match between President Zelensky, President Trump and Vice President JD Vance. This time, Volodomyr Zelensky broke from his usual military style clothing and wore a smart suit to the meeting, and he also handed over a letter from his wife Olena, for the American first lady Melania Trump, thanking her for her message to Vladamir Putin about the suffering of children during the war. WASHINGTON, DC – AUGUST 18: U.S. President Donald Trump hosts a meeting with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen, NATO Secretary-General Mark Rutte, and other European leaders at the White House on August 18, 2025 in Washington, DC. President Trump hosted President Zelensky at the White House for a bilateral meeting and an expanded meeting with European leaders to discuss a peace deal between Russia and Ukraine. (Photo by) It's understood their discussion covered security guarantees and humanitarian concerns, but, there was also some discussion on the possibility of Ukraine purchasing American weapons, through European funding. Zelensky also said both men discussed a map of Russian-captured areas in Ukraine, adding that he had 'argued' with Trump about the amount of territory held by Russia. It's understood President Trump paused the meeting with Zelensky to phone Putin and tell the Russian leader what had been discussed and come to an agreement on setting up a meeting between Zelensky and Putin, something it's believed Putin was supportive of. WASHINGTON, DC – AUGUST 18: U.S. President Donald Trump meets with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky in the Oval Office at the White House on August 18, 2025 in Washington, DC. (Photo by) Speaking after the meeting Donald Trump promised American assistance saying 'When it comes to security, there's going to be a lot of help,' adding that European countries would be involved. 'They are a first line of defence because they're there, but we'll help them out.' Afterwards the Ukrainian president was upbeat as he described the promise of American help as a 'major step forward' saying these guarantees would be 'formalized on paper within the next 10 days'. Donald Trump also said he had already begun making plans for a bi-lateral meeting between Putin and Zelensky, adding that he would join in a tri-lateral session, after the two men held initial talks. The Ukrainian leader added that he is ready for 'any format of a meeting' with the Russian President.
