Jury rules in favor of St. John Parish officials in case involving environmental advocate
NEW ORLEANS — A jury reached a verdict Wednesday afternoon (Jan. 29) on a First Amendment case filed by environmental justice activist Joy Banner against St. John the Baptist Parish President Jaclyn Hotard, Parish Council President Michael Wright and the parish.
The nine jurors found three things to be true in their verdict: that Wright, Hotard and the parish did not restrict Banner's speech, that the three defendants did not engage in First Amendment retaliation and that they did not violate Louisiana's Open Meetings Law. As a result, Banner will not receive compensatory or punitive damages.
The jury took more than three hours to deliberate in the U.S. Eastern District of Louisiana courthouse in New Orleans where the trial took place. Hotard and Wright were not in the courtroom for the verdict.
Cam Owens, one of the jurors, said that the video of the 2023 council meeting that set this case off was the deciding factor for the jury.
He said that he felt the testimonies were a bit muddled and that the video helped to clarify what occurred. He also said that he felt Banner had the chance to speak at the meeting.
'We broke down her amount of time, and when she was stopping, when she was interrupted, and she had three minutes [to speak], and even though they were interrupting her, she did get out what she was trying to say,' he told reporters. 'I think at the end of the day, they did try to stop her, but she did actually say what she had to say.'
Owens said he thinks Banner was not fully able to say what she had to, but that it would still be inaccurate to say that her First Amendment rights were violated because she did get to talk.
In Nov. 2023, Banner attended a council meeting and attempted to make a public comment about the council's potential decision to hire an attorney for Hotard to represent her in an ethics investigation related to the now-canceled Greenfield grain terminal project. Hotard interrupted Banner at that meeting and told Wright to stop Banner's comment.
Wright read off a statute that implied that Banner could be fined or imprisoned for continuing to speak. After trying to speak several times, Banner eventually walked away from the podium.
Banner and her twin sister Jo Banner founded The Descendants Project, an organization dedicated to telling the history of and advocating for Black communities within the River Parishes. They opposed the Greenfield development because they believed it would have negative environmental effects on their Wallace community.
Both Banner sisters commented on the verdict outside of the courtroom, along with Joy's attorney William Most.
Joy Banner said that wished the outcome was different, but that the case shined a light on transparency issues within St. John. In this way, she said the case was a win.
St. John president's mother-in-law admits she would have benefited from land deal
'A win would have been nice, but it was honestly making the parish president [and] Michael Wright, our public officials have to answer for the decisions that they've made,' Joy said.
Joy said that she knows she made the right decision to go forward with the trial and said that this was an eye-opening process.
Text messages that surfaced as evidence in the case had revealed that Hotard had kept her mother-in-law, who stood to benefit from a rezoning measure tied to the Greenfield project, updated on the project, though Hotard had previously claimed no such communications existed.
'I think that President Hotard took a lot of effort to keep a lot of things hidden, and now it's out there,' Jo Banner said. 'It's a matter of public record.'
Joy also described an accusation by Hotard's attorney that she and her sister are trying to be social media influencers as 'inaccurate' and that social media helps amplify their activism.
Most said that there may be future legal repercussions with regard to Hotard. He said that this trial revealed that Hotard's husband had a financial stake in the land where Greenfield would have been.
'The parish president has not committed to recusing herself from decisions about that plan [about Greenfield], so there may be future legal repercussions,' Most said.
Verite News reached out to Hotard and Ike Spears, Hotard's attorney, for a comment on potential future legal repercussions resulting from what was revealed in the case, but they did not immediately respond.
Joy Banner said that she will 'absolutely' continue her advocacy at St. John meetings and that the problems with transparency among parish leadership have become a 'rallying cry.'
'We will continue to do the work,' Joy said. 'They see us fighting.'
This article first appeared on Verite News and is republished here under a Creative Commons license. .

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Boston Globe
28 minutes ago
- Boston Globe
Air Force's top uniformed officer is retiring early in latest Trump military shake-up
For example, Trump fired Air Force General CQ Brown Jr. as chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff in February. Brown was the second Black general to serve as chairman, and Air Force Gen. Dan Caine later took over the role. Advertisement Allvin, a command pilot with more than 4,600 flying hours, was appointed Air Force chief of staff by President Joe Biden, a Democrat, serving since November 2023. Before that, he was vice chief of staff during Trump's first term. 'I'm grateful for the opportunity to serve as the 23rd Air Force Chief of Staff and I'm thankful for Secretary Meink, Secretary Hegseth and President Trump's faith in me to lead our service,' Allvin said in the Air Force's statement. When asked for more details on Allvin's departure, the Air Force directed The Associated Press to its statement. Advertisement


Fox News
2 hours ago
- Fox News
Chicago residents call Obama Presidential Center a 'monstrosity,' fear they'll be displaced: report
Chicago community leaders and longtime residents say the Obama Presidential Center risks washing away the neighborhood's fabric, warning that proposed luxury developments tied to the project could price out families who have long called the South Side home, according to a report. They also say the sprawling 19.3-acre site in historic Jackson Park, with its 225-foot-tall concrete museum, has become an eyesore that disrupts the natural landscape and all locals are getting in return for the unsightly structure is soaring rents and higher tax bills. "This is a monument to one man's ego," Steve Cortes, a longtime Chicagoan and former adviser to President Trump, told the Daily Mail. "Look at the Reagan Library. It's beautiful. This? There are almost no windows. What are they hiding? And this Brutalist cement look in a city known for its incredible architecture." The Obama Foundation secured a 99-year lease for the public parcel for $10 in 2018 and promised to revitalize the area. Obama said at the time that the project did not intend to displace residents, adding that its overseers are trying to balance boosting jobs and economic development in the area while maintaining and protecting existing affordable housing. Alderwoman Jeanette Taylor, who represents much of the working-class neighborhood surrounding the site, fears that locals are being priced out. "Every time large development comes to communities, they displace the very people they say they want to improve it for. This was no different, and we're living what is actually happening," Taylor told the outlet. "We're going to see rents go higher and we're going to see families displaced." She has pushed for protections such as affordable housing requirements around the site, tenant purchase rights and rental assistance to shield residents from displacement. She won some concessions in the 2020 agreement – whereby 30% of new units on city-owned land were to be affordable -- but many of her broader demands, including a full Community Benefits Agreement (CBA), were not adopted. A CBA is a binding deal that requires developers to deliver protections such as affordable housing, local hiring, or other safeguards to ensure big projects don't push out existing residents. "The city of Chicago should have done a Community Benefits Agreement before the first shovel went into the ground, but they didn't," Taylor said. "We're going to see small landlords having to raise the rent. Their property taxes are going up and we're going to see development that is not inclusive to our community." Residents point to a proposed 250-room luxury hotel as a symbol and a driver of economic pressures far beyond the scale of existing neighborhood development. Once a major luxury project is approved, surrounding property values typically spike and so its presence signals to investors and developers that the area is shifting toward wealthier clientele and away from its historically working-class, majority-Black base. The hotel's approval is still under review, and residents have held demonstrations calling for its rejection. The investment firm behind the project is headed by Allison Davis, a veteran real estate developer and lawyer who was Obama's first boss out of Harvard Law School. "When you got people's rent going from $850 to $1,300 you're telling people you don't want them in the neighborhood," said Dixon Romeo, an organizer with the Obama Community Benefits Agreement Coalition, told NBC Chicago at a demonstration in April. Since ground was broken, construction has progressed at a snail's pace while costs have ballooned from an original estimate of $330 million to a 2021 foundation projection of $830 million -- with no updates since then. The center, which aims to honor former President Barack Obama's political career, will also consist of a digital library, conference facilities, a gymnasium, and a regulation-sized NBA court. It will also house the nonprofit Obama Foundation, which is overseeing the center's development. The scale of the project and the aesthetics of its centerpiece library have come in for criticism. Ken Woodard, an attorney and father of six who grew up in the area, called it a "monstrosity." "It looks like this big piece of rock that just landed here out of nowhere in what used to be a really nice landscape of trees and flowers," Woodward told the Daily Mail. "It's over budget, it's taking way too long to finish and it's going to drive up prices and bring headaches and problems for everyone who lives here. It feels like a washing away of the neighborhood and culture that used to be here." Kyana Butler, an activist with Southside Together who campaigned for a CBA around the Obama Center, shared similar sentiments with the outlet. "It's pretty huge and monstrous," Butler said. "It could have been smaller in scale and cost a lot less money. We're all worried about the impact on the community." Tyrone Muhammad, director of Ex-Cons for Community and Social Change, said, "It's truly the Tower of Babel." "Property taxes are going up so much that the owner of my building is saying she might just walk away.. I don't blame President Obama for all of this, but the people on his team may not have the best intentions for people in this area," Muhammed, 2026 Illinois Senate candidate, told the outlet. "It's disingenuous and hypocritical to take park space away from people and then not involve them in what takes its place. The move violates common decency." Fox News Digital has reached out to the Obama Center for comment. In May, President Donald Trump offered to help out with the development of the center and linked DEI to the construction problems. The project set out "ambitious goals" for certain construction diversity quotas, with its contracts to be allocated to "diverse suppliers," 35% of which were required to be minority-based enterprises (MBEs). "Look, President Obama, if he wanted help, I'd give him help because I'm a really good builder and I build on time, on budget. He's building his library in Chicago. It's a disaster," Trump said, adding that Obama was paying for prioritizing DEI over meritocracy. "And he wanted to be very politically correct and he didn't use good, hard, tough, mean construction workers that I love Marco," Trump said, while addressing Secretary of State Marco Rubio. A $40.75 million racially charged lawsuit filed earlier this year by a minority contractor against the project's structural engineer shined a spotlight on the DEI-driven aspect of the project. The structural engineers claimed the minority contractor lacked sufficient qualifications and experience to perform its work, resulting in delays.


Politico
2 hours ago
- Politico
Medicaid cuts' disproportionate toll
Driving the Day ADVOCATES WORRY — Medicaid cuts in President Donald Trump's tax and spending law could disproportionately harm Black women and children who depend on the program, advocates warn. And the looming changes in the One Big Beautiful Bill Act could worsen already disparate health outcomes among Black Americans, POLITICO's Cheyanne M. Daniels reports. Although Black people represent about 14 percent of the U.S. population, they account for more than 20 percent of Medicaid enrollees, according to Pew Research Center — and almost 60 percent of all Black children are enrolled in Medicaid, according to a recent analysis from the NAACP and other advocacy organizations. Why it matters: Advocates say the enacted megabill's Medicaid cuts could limit resources in schools with high percentages of students eligible for free or reduced-price lunch, exacerbate maternal mortality rates and leave Black families without critical care. 'States right now are having to make decisions on what services they're going to cut ... and their allocation of funding toward this population,' said Patrice Willoughby, chief of policy and legislative affairs for the NAACP. 'It is unconscionable that Congress would leave American children, which are the future of the country, without the supports that they need and the interventions that they need to contribute meaningfully to develop to their fullest potential.' Background: Medicaid — which is the fourth largest federal funding source for K-12 schools, according to a 2025 report by the School Superintendents Association — supports more than $7.5 billion of school-based health services each year for low-income students, including screenings for learning disabilities. Thirty-seven percent of Black students attend high-poverty schools, according to a 2023 analysis by the National Center for Education Statistics. Through Medicaid, high-poverty schools are also able to provide medical care. They can also provide insight into whether a student needs additional screening for a more accurate diagnosis. But one report from a coalition of education groups earlier this year found that the Medicaid cuts could force schools to reduce the number of school nurses, limit access to early intervention programs or impact funding for special education programs for those with learning disabilities. Zooming out: Advocates say the cuts are part of a broader pattern of the American medical system inadequately serving Black patients. 'These cuts really are continuing a pattern of forcing Black families to take care of ourselves without the proper support,' said Brittany Packnett, an equity strategist who co-founded Campaign Zero, a police reform initiative, and supported Vice President Kamala Harris in the 2024 presidential campaign. In a statement to POLITICO, HHS said the claims 'misrepresent' the One Big Beautiful Bill Act. 'The OBBB is a decisive step toward building a stronger, more resilient healthcare system,' an HHS spokesperson said. 'This legislation modernizes Medicaid to deliver greater efficiency and long-term sustainability, while expanding access to high-quality care for those most in need, in every community across the nation.' A spokesperson for the White House also dismissed the worries of advocates, arguing they were coming from supporters of Trump's defeated 2024 opponent. Even so: It remains to be seen what the long-term impacts of the cuts will be. Many of the cuts aren't set to go into effect for years, and Congress has a track record of approving reductions and changing eligibility rules, only to later extend deadlines or revise the law entirely. WELCOME TO TUESDAY PULSE. HHS is tracking its Make America Healthy Again wins with a new online tool. Send your tips, scoops and feedback to khooper@ and sgardner@ and follow along @kelhoops and @sophie_gardnerj. In Congress FIRST IN PULSE: MEGABILL HOSPITAL IMPACTS — Liberal nonprofit Protect Our Care is teaming with Sen. Chris Murphy (D-Conn.) to unveil a new report today that details how hospitals could be impacted by the GOP's recently enacted One Big Beautiful Bill Act. Why it matters: The megabill includes more than $1 trillion in health care cuts, mostly to Medicaid. The new law will take a $340 billion bite out of hospital budgets over a decade to pay for tax cuts and other Trump priorities — though hospitals and their lobbyists and allies on Capitol Hill are gearing up to use the next two and a half years to persuade lawmakers to rescind the provisions, most of which don't go into effect until 2028. As part of that effort, Protect Our Care is working with Murphy to relaunch its 'Hospital Crisis Watch' tracker, which monitors the impact of the megabill on hospitals and care facilities across the country, including whether they're closing or making cuts. The findings: The group highlights its findings in a report out today, shared first with POLITICO, that found more than 330 hospitals are at immediate risk of closing or scaling back their services, and more than 750 hospitals are at risk of closing in the years to come because of the new law. An estimated 477,000 health workers will lose their jobs because of the Medicaid cuts, according to the report. What's next: Murphy and Protect Our Care will present the report during a virtual press conference today at 11 a.m. At the Agencies DEFUNDING MRNA TECHNOLOGY — NIH Director Jay Bhattacharya agrees with HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr.'s decision last week to defund research into the mRNA technology that produced Covid-19 vaccines in record time, he told POLITICO in an interview. Vaccine experts argued the move would put at risk America's leading position in vaccine development and potential cures for diseases from cancer to diabetes by pulling the government's $500 million. But Bhattacharya said Kennedy's critics have the story backward. Here's some of Bhattacharya's conversation with our Axel Springer colleague Tim Röhn, edited for length and clarity. Paul Offit, the leading vaccine expert, told me the mRNA funding cuts were 'politicization of science.' Is he right? No, he's not right. In my view, the key question for any vaccine platform that we fund and support is: How acceptable is it to the public? If you have the very best science in the world, but the public doesn't trust it, then it's useless as a vaccine platform. Your boss, Robert F. Kennedy Jr., called the Covid vaccines in December 2021 'the deadliest vaccine ever made.' Couldn't statements like this be the reason for the public distrust? Secretary Kennedy's statement before he was appointed reflects the distrust of the population, rather than the cause of it. More important were the disastrous and unscientific vaccine mandates and exaggerated claims of Covid vaccine efficacy by high public health officials in power at the time. Aren't we potentially slowing our response to the next pandemic by not investing in mRNA? We have other new technologies that we're working on. Why marry yourself to a single platform when the platform has lost trust with the public? We're not saying we're not going to do vaccinations. We're saying that we're moving to a different platform that is more promising. Public Health A DECLARATION IN TEXAS — Texas's measles outbreak has ended, the state health department said Monday, Sophie reports. The outbreak, which spurred nationwide fears about a resurgence of the disease, infected at least 762 people and caused two deaths in school-age children. A third person, from a New Mexico county near the outbreak's Texas epicenter, tested positive for measles after his death. New cases haven't been reported in more than 42 days in any of the counties that had ongoing transmission, the health department said in a statement. That's twice the disease's maximum incubation period, or the longest time it can take between exposure to the virus and illness onset. Even so: The department noted it would continue watching the situation closely. 'The end of this outbreak does not mean the threat of measles is over,' the department said. 'Since there are ongoing outbreaks of measles in North America and around the world, it is likely that there will be additional cases of measles this year in Texas.' Zooming out: As of Aug. 5, the CDC has recorded 1,356 measles cases this year — more than any year since 1992. Public health experts point to waning measles, mumps and rubella vaccination rates as a factor in the high measles case count. Some blame Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. — who has spent much of his career questioning vaccine safety — for sowing distrust in the MMR vaccine. WHAT WE'RE READING The Wall Street Journal's Brianna Abbott reports on a new reality for terminal cancer. For Undark, Joanne Kenen reports on how proposed NASA cuts could affect public health research.