Pricing birdsong: Farmers could earn cash for conservation as EU explores biodiversity ‘nature credits'
BRUSSELS, May 11 — Could farmers get money for protecting birds or plants? That's the hope of the European Union, which is seeking to monetise biodiversity by creating a market for 'nature credits'.
The European Commission last month launched a series of talks with financial, farming and green groups to ponder the idea, which has some environmentalists worried.
'You can make good money by razing a forest to the ground, but not by planting a new one and letting it grow old,' the EU's environment commissioner Jessika Roswall told a 'Global Solutions' conference in Berlin on Monday, adding the bloc wanted to change that.
The plan is still in its infancy and no concrete details have been put forward yet.
But the idea is to replicate the financial success of carbon credits, which launched two decades ago to help finance efforts to tackle global warming and have developed into an almost trillion-dollar global market.
Carbon credits allow a polluter to 'offset' their emissions by paying for 'avoided' emissions elsewhere.
Nature credits on the other hand would see businesses brush up their green credentials by paying for initiatives that restore or protect nature — something Roswall said cannot be financed by public coffers alone.
At a UN biodiversity summit in 2022, world nations agreed to a target of protecting 30 per cent of the planet's lands and oceans by 2030 and to provide US$200 billion (RM859 billion) a year in finance.
EU Commissioner for Environment, Water Resilience and a Competitive Circular Economy, Jessika Roswall. — AFP pic
Pricing nature
Under the EU plan, activities that protect or restore nature would be certified and the related certificate traded in a dedicated financial market.
But things get more complicated in practice.
'Putting a price tag on nature' is a 'more complex' affair than pricing carbon emissions, said an EU official.
How much CO2 is released into the atmosphere or sequestered by a specific activity is easily measurable, the official said.
The same can not be said of biodiversity, which is by definition diverse, with many varieties of animal and plants making it tricky to measure and identify value.
'Waking up to the song of birds, drinking water from a mountain spring, staring at the endless blue of the sea and of the ocean. How could you possibly put a price tag on any of this?' Roswall asked in Berlin.
'We do put a price tag on nature, every second, every day, but only by taking resources away from their natural environment,' she added.
In Europe, several pilot projects have been launched to test the concept, including in Finland, France and Estonia, where an initiative is seeking to reward forest owners for sustainably managing their plots.
The 27-nation EU is hoping these and other projects will provide farmers and foresters with an additional source of income.
'No coincidence'
It is not alone. Similar schemes were discussed at the UN COP16 nature talks in Colombia last year, and more than a dozen countries, including the United States and Germany already have a nascent market or a project underway.
Yet, striking a cautious note, pan-European farmers group Copa-Cogeca said it wanted to see a concrete proposal before commenting.
Environmental groups on the other hand are worried about a possible repeat of the many scandals that have dogged carbon credit markets, from tax fraud to the certification of projects that did nothing for the environment.
Nature credits could offer firms another opportunity for 'greenwashing' — pretending they are greener than they really are — and authorities an excuse to cut back public funding for biodiversity, some warn.
'Not even the commission knows what they want to do,' Ioannis Agapakis, a lawyer with ClientEarth, an environmental group, said of the European Commission.
Yet, it was 'no coincidence' — and 'a concern' — that the idea was being floated as the EU's executive body prepared to negotiate the future European budget, he added. — ETX Studio
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
5 hours ago
- The Star
EU pushes China to address ‘alarming' rare earth export controls
The EU has urged China to stop restricting the export of rare earth minerals and magnets, with the bloc's trade chief saying its industries are in an 'alarming situation'. The request was made during a meeting between the sides' top commerce officials in Paris on Tuesday. It comes as sectors across Europe raise the alarm about a shortage of rare earths, which are used to manufacture hi-tech goods ranging from electric cars and smartphones to military tanks and aircraft. 'I informed my Chinese counterpart about the alarming situation in the European car industry, but I would say industry as such because clearly rare earths and permanent magnets are absolutely essential for industrial production,' Maros Sefcovic said on Wednesday, briefing reporters a day after his meeting with Chinese Commerce Minister Wang Wentao. Around 90 per cent of the world's supply of rare earth minerals comes from China, which introduced export controls on their shipments in April in retaliation to US President Donald Trump's 'reciprocal' tariffs. Rare earths consist of 17 elements. On April 4, Beijing added seven of these – dysprosium, gadolinium, lutetium, samarium, scandium, terbium and yttrium – to its export control list, plus several rare earth magnets, two days after Trump announced 'reciprocal tariffs', meaning licenses are now required for their export. While such restrictions were ostensibly intended to punish the US, firms around the world have been caught in the crossfire. Business chambers and industry groups have urged European governments to push for a solution, as mineral stocks run low and some areas of production grind to a halt. European companies have complained that China's commerce ministry seemed incapable of handling the voluminous requests, with licenses being issued slowly and on a piecemeal basis. 'Some applicants are asked for sensitive information that might compromise their intellectual property so they're reluctant to hand that over, but they need to if they want to get approval,' Adam Dunnett, secretary general at the EU Chamber of Commerce in China, said. The chamber has held 'emergency meetings' with Chinese authorities in recent days after an outpouring of anxiety from across European industry. 'I haven't seen anything of this magnitude for a long time,' Dunnett said of the level of concern among EU businesses. Sefcovic said that the two sides had compared figures on the number of applications versus the licenses issued. The figures did not match, Sefcovic said, adding that the EU would supply Beijing with 'all the data and would cover all the companies which are now in an extremely difficult situation'. Sefcovic suggested that Beijing could simplify its system, which now screens all requests for 'dual use' applications, meaning the rare earths could go towards military production. 'Some of the car companies are already announcing that if this issue is not addressed, there might be huge production difficulties in a short period of time,' Sefcovic said. 'His information was a little bit different, and therefore we agreed that he would clarify this as soon as possible, and that we would also address the propositions I made yesterday, and this was that our strong preference here,' he added. The EU's proposals include 'not to cover ... civilian production by this very complex system', Sefcovic said. The bloc would also like to see a 'general application ... to cover it once a year for the whole production', eliminating the need for cumbersome repeat applications. Sefcovic said the EU wanted the changes to avoid 'huge paperwork delays and stress, which this presents for our industry and for our companies. 'We agree that we will come back to this issue relatively soon.' Also on Wednesday, the EU named 13 projects it would initiate beyond its borders to help improve its self-sufficiency in rare earths and critical minerals. 'The export bans reinforce our will to diversify and perhaps even strengthen the relevance of our focus on reducing dependencies,' Stephane Sejourne, the European Commission's head of industrial strategy, said in announcing the projects in Brussels. Two projects will cover rare earth minerals in Malawi and South Africa, while others focus on various raw materials in Britain, Canada, Greenland, Kazakhstan, Madagascar, Norway, Serbia, Ukraine, Zambia, Brazil and New Caledonia, a French overseas territory. The rare earth crisis adds another complication to already tense EU-China trade ties. Earlier this week, the bloc's member states voted to exclude Chinese companies from its lucrative medical devices procurement market after Beijing refused to open its tenders to the EU. In a bid to crack down on a deluge of small packages from Chinese e-tailers Temu and Shein, Brussels plans to add a surcharge of €2 (US$2.28) to small parcels imported. The EU also remains frustrated over Beijing's refusal to acknowledge state subsidies that it claims are leading to market-distorting industrial overcapacity. China, on the other hand, claims that Europe's moves to target its exporters are against the rules of global trade. - SOUTH CHINA MORNING POST
The Sun
6 hours ago
- The Sun
Indonesia expects to conclude free trade talks with EU by end of June
JAKARTA: Indonesia said on Saturday that free trade negotiations with the European Union, which have been ongoing for nine years, are expected to be concluded by the end of June. Airlangga Hartarto, the chief economic minister for Southeast Asia's biggest economy, met with EU Commissioner for Trade Maros Sefcovic in Brussels on Friday. 'Indonesia and the European Union have agreed to conclude outstanding issues and we are ready to announce a conclusion of substantial negotiations by the end of June 2025,' Airlangga Hartarto said in a statement. Indonesia will get zero tariffs for 80% of its export products to the EU and removal of non-tariff barriers, as it pushes for bigger market access for footwear, garments, palm oil and fishery products, Airlanga told a press conference later on Saturday. The EU has discussed Jakarta's rules on mandatory use of local content in products sold in Indonesian market, the automotive industry, trade of critical minerals and investment facilities, Airlangga said. Indonesia and the EU have previously disagreed on EU trade rules for products with potential links to deforestation that could affect Indonesian palm oil. Airlangga said the bloc's deforestation rules were not part of the free trade negotiations, but Sefcovic had 'promised to provide special treatment towards Indonesia regarding deforestation.' He did not elaborate. Denis Chaibi, EU ambassador to Indonesia, said that talks were ongoing and 'we will communicate in details when we have an outcome.' Chaibi did not respond to a question about the special treatment. The EU is Indonesia's fifth-biggest trade partner, with total trade between the two reaching 27.3 billion euros ($31.11 billion) last year, according to the EU. Exports from the bloc were worth 9.7 billion euros in 2024, and it imported 17.5 billion euros' worth from Indonesia. Indonesian exports to the bloc could increase by more than 50% within three to four years after the trade deal takes effect, Airlangga said. Indonesian officials have been motivated to accelerate talks on free trade agreements, keen to diversify the country's export destinations as they deal with U.S. tariff challenges.
The Sun
6 hours ago
- The Sun
Indonesia-EU free trade deal likely by end of June 2025
JAKARTA: Indonesia said on Saturday that free trade negotiations with the European Union, which have been ongoing for nine years, are expected to be concluded by the end of June. Airlangga Hartarto, the chief economic minister for Southeast Asia's biggest economy, met with EU Commissioner for Trade Maros Sefcovic in Brussels on Friday. 'Indonesia and the European Union have agreed to conclude outstanding issues and we are ready to announce a conclusion of substantial negotiations by the end of June 2025,' Airlangga Hartarto said in a statement. Indonesia will get zero tariffs for 80% of its export products to the EU and removal of non-tariff barriers, as it pushes for bigger market access for footwear, garments, palm oil and fishery products, Airlanga told a press conference later on Saturday. The EU has discussed Jakarta's rules on mandatory use of local content in products sold in Indonesian market, the automotive industry, trade of critical minerals and investment facilities, Airlangga said. Indonesia and the EU have previously disagreed on EU trade rules for products with potential links to deforestation that could affect Indonesian palm oil. Airlangga said the bloc's deforestation rules were not part of the free trade negotiations, but Sefcovic had 'promised to provide special treatment towards Indonesia regarding deforestation.' He did not elaborate. Denis Chaibi, EU ambassador to Indonesia, said that talks were ongoing and 'we will communicate in details when we have an outcome.' Chaibi did not respond to a question about the special treatment. The EU is Indonesia's fifth-biggest trade partner, with total trade between the two reaching 27.3 billion euros ($31.11 billion) last year, according to the EU. Exports from the bloc were worth 9.7 billion euros in 2024, and it imported 17.5 billion euros' worth from Indonesia. Indonesian exports to the bloc could increase by more than 50% within three to four years after the trade deal takes effect, Airlangga said. Indonesian officials have been motivated to accelerate talks on free trade agreements, keen to diversify the country's export destinations as they deal with U.S. tariff challenges. ($1 = 0.8777 euros)
