Auckland mental health facility Segar House to close
Photo:
Google Maps Street View
An Auckland mental health programme catering for people with long-standing or chronic problems will shut down.
On Thursday afternoon, Health NZ told patients and staff of Rauaroha Segar House the service would close its doors.
Operating from its central-city Khyber Pass Road base,
Segar House
is a publicly-funded, intensive programme that involves group therapy and is focused on allowing people to function in society.
The service had an allocation of seven full-time equivalent staff members, although RNZ was told it had been operating below that, and 10 patients at any given time.
Health NZ has been consulting on its proposal to shut Segar House since April and, in its change proposal, said not enough people were treated there and staff would be better deployed elsewhere.
Public Service Association national secretary Fleur Fitzsimons said the union "strongly objects" to the closure.
"Despite the critical life-saving work done at Segar House, Health New Zealand has today announced its decision to shut this unique, much-needed service," she said.
"This is terrible news for staff, those who rely on the specialist support offered at Segar House, and their loved ones."
The union called on Health NZ and the government to reverse the decision and instead "commit to properly funding Segar House".
"The team working at Segar House are devastated. They know this decision will have tragic consequences," Fitzsimons said.
She said people who used Segar House's services included those with horrific trauma and complex health histories.
"They can only come to Segar House when they've already exhausted all other options - it's the last option for these mental health patients."
The Public Service Association says it "strongly objects" to the closure.
Photo:
123RF
Labour spokeswoman for mental health Ingrid Leary also said news of the closure was devastating.
"It's very specialised and there isn't actually an alternative. People should be able to get the care they need in the community, so what's going to happen to those people now?"
She criticised the government for focusing on cuts, and Minister for Mental Health Matt Doocey for not showing leadership.
Doocey has been contacted for comment.
"It's painfully short-sighted as all communities need primary, secondary and tertiary levels of mental healthcare to some degree, and reopening facilities like this is much harder to do once they've been shut down - as the UK has discovered recently when trying to reverse similar decisions," Leary said.
Staff and many patients have said no other programmes offered the same treatment.
Staff proposed an alternative plan to keep Segar House open, and widen the criteria for those who could use the service, but this has not convinced Health NZ.
Changes introduced six years ago meant only people who had failed in other settings were eligible, although the PSA said a recent trial with lower admission criteria was successful.
Less than a week ago the PSA sent Health NZ a lawyer's letter asking officials to reopen consultation on the proposed closure. The PSA said it was still seeking legal advice about this.
This came after
Leary obtained correspondence
that showed Segar House's lease was to expire last year, before a last-minute extension, and no discussion about alternative venues.
Health NZ said lease arrangements had nothing to do with its closure plan.
Leary said today she was disappointed consultation was not reopened.
Health NZ has been contacted for comment.
An online petition run by the PSA, calling for Segar House to remain, has more than 2600 signatures.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
34 minutes ago
- RNZ News
Mayoral hopeful's website condemned as 'horrendous'
Photo: RNZ / Nate McKinnon An Invercargill mayoral hopeful has been slammed by fellow candidates after his party website looks to have posted "dangerous" and sexually disturbing content online. Gordon McCrone is standing for the top job under an unofficial party for which he is listed as the only staff member. His nomination is listed as pending approval on the Invercargill City Council website. The website, whose domain is registered to Gordon McCrone, refers to the party leader as an unregistered, self-appointed child sex psychologist. It includes sexually disturbing content. Local Democracy Reporting has chosen not to publish the website's name. It makes claims that McCrone is a leading cancer researcher who expects to find a cure for the disease. It also says he advises "President" Joe Biden on internal and external affairs, and proposes beneficiaries are given free Lotto tickets. McCrone was approached for comment to validate these claims but chose not to address the questions in his emailed reply. The website content has been condemned by a number of sitting councillors running for mayor in the southern city. McCrone's beliefs have been condemned by Invercargill councillors (from left) Ria Bond, Tom Campbell and Alex Crackett. Photo: Supplied via LDR Ria Bond was concerned about a lack of candidate safety checks prior to entering local politics and would like to see a robust system to ensure people meet the standard. "I'd recommend that that candidate pull himself from the election, because he clearly has behaviours and beliefs that don't fit with our community whatsoever," she said. Deputy mayor Tom Campbell disagreed with filtering candidates but condemned the party website messaging. "It's terrible. It's horrendous. It's awful. Any right-minded person would be nauseated by it," he said. Alex Crackett described the content as "appalling" and "dangerous", adding there would need to be protocols at candidate events for the health and safety of those attending. McCrone has already been barred from a Southland Business Chamber debate on 19 August, with president Chris Hughes saying they were "deeply concerned" by the commentary. "Given his very public views, we feel it's appropriate to take this stance in the best interests of the chamber and the wider Southland community," Hughes said. He said the website content "makes clear why this decision is reasonable". The chamber received strong support for its decision after it was made public, he said. Councillor Ian Pottinger is also running for mayor but did not wish to comment on McCrone. He too supported the chamber's decision. Police would not say if any complaints had been received about the website or whether they were investigating. "In general, police cannot respond to queries which seek to establish whether specific individuals or organisations are, or have been, under investigation," a spokesperson told Local Democracy Reporting. Invercargill City Council deputy electoral officer Michael Morris said the rules for candidacy were set out in legislation with very few restrictions for running. The two key rules were that candidates needed to hold citizenship and be enrolled to vote. "The electoral officers or council cannot have any role in determining who stands or not, as long as the requirements are met," Morris said. Election day is set for 11 October. LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air.
RNZ News
4 hours ago
- RNZ News
Older patients stuck in hospitals due to limited aged care spaces
Many hospitals faced similar problems to North Shore Hospital, with elderly, medically discharged patients unable to move out because there was no where to send them. Photo: 123RF Aged care homes are getting daily calls from hospitals or tearful family members, desperate to find a place for older patients who cannot be in their own homes. Care homes are calling for an infrastructure grant to help stop situations like at North Shore Hospital where there was a ward of people ready to leave but with nowhere to be discharged to for longer term care. Joe Asghar oversees 13 homes in the lower North Island as chief executive for Presbyterian Support Central. "Every day we have families on the phone to our care managers, quite often in tears trying to find a space and of course we are quite often the place of last resort for hospitals who have particularly complex residents who need that higher level of nursing care," he said. "It's heartbreaking. We only have 800 beds. We would love to have more beds so we could meet our obligation of caring for those that are needy and vulnerable." Australia has introduced an infrastructure grant largely aimed at small, regional, or charity-run aged care facilities to help them upgrade to allow higher levels of care. The Aged Care Association was calling for the same thing here and Asghar said it was badly needed. The homes he looked after needed $10 million for basic upgrades it could not afford to do on the spot - like roof or boiler repairs, he said. Without that work, the worst case scenario would be homes were not up to scratch and would have to close, he said. Even though the infrastructure grants would be very welcome, they were only one part of the solution. More funding was needed to help provide care for the more complex patients homes were now seeing, Asghar said. "They are coming much more frail, much more unwell, and needing higher levels of care," he said. "I think the days are long gone where we see our residents coming in without needing assistance." Many hospitals faced similar problems to North Shore Hospital, with elderly, medically discharged patients unable to move out because there was nowhere to send them. North Shore's dedicated ward was praised as a practical solution by health worker unions, but needing an entire ward illustrated how big the problem was becoming. Asghar said hospitals were not the best place for those who no longer needed to be there. They needed support to live well, including social connection. "Talking with other residents and doing activities, even if it's just the 10 minute quiz everyday," he said. The Aged Care Minister Casey Costello has said the government is looking into improvements to the aged care system including providing for better transitions between levels of care. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
5 hours ago
- RNZ News
Hospital security guards want handcuffs, powers to detain violent people
Hospital security guards want more powers to deal with rising violence. Photo: RNZ / REECE BAKER Security guards in hospital emergency departments want more powers to deal with rising violence and the increasing number of people confronting them with knives. Head of the Security Association, Gary Morrison, said there had been a marked increase in physical and verbal abuse in recent years and, increasingly, weapons were coming into hospitals. "What we're hearing is a lot of knives being carried, weapons being present, and just a lifting in the aggressive nature and feeling in those areas." Morrison said the abuse in emergency departments was often fuelled by drugs and alcohol, and reflected wider trends across society - but guards could do little in response under the current law. Security guards were trained to de-escalate and avoid confrontation, he said, but in certain environments, such as hospitals, greater powers to intervene were needed. Morrison said security guards went to work with stab-proof vests and some increasingly wore body-cameras, however, he also wanted to see handcuffs included in the uniform. "What we would like to see is that security staff have the power to detain offenders pending the arrival of police, but we'd only advocate for that where there was a very stringent training and licensing regime built around it. "Where it's safe to do so, where staff are adequately trained and the opportunity is there to keep the scene safe afterwards, it is a deterrant if security can actually detain an offender." He said such powers would be beneficial in areas such as retail, hospitals and anywhere with potential violent behaviour and thefts. Morrison said the group was strongly advocating for a law change that would allow security guards to detain people, in line with proposed changes to citizen arrest legislation . Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
