‘Risk of absconding high': UK judge notes ‘confidential impediment' in Nirav Modi extradition case
A London High Court judge who refused Nirav Modi's latest bail application this week has taken note in his judgment of a 'confidential impediment' in the long-drawn extradition proceedings against the imprisoned diamantaire wanted in India on fraud and money laundering charges.
Justice Michael Fordham on Thursday concluded at a Royal Courts of Justice bail hearing that there are substantial grounds for believing that if released on bail, the 54-year-old businessman would 'fail to surrender' and his risk of absconding remained high.
While Nirav's barrister argued in favour of his bail from London's Thameside prison based on the 'long passage of time' without trial, the judge highlighted the constraints of a 'confidential' process that prevented his surrender to the Indian authorities even though the legal process related to his extradition had 'run its course'.
'There is a 'legal reason' which relates to 'confidential proceedings'. The nature of this is known to the applicant (Nirav Modi), and his lawyers; it is known to the Home Office, but apart from what I have recorded, nothing is known by the CPS [Crown Prosecution Service] or by the Government of India, nor by this court,' Justice Fordham states.
CPS barrister Nicholas Hearn, appearing on behalf of the Indian authorities, confirmed to the court that he 'recognises and respects' the fact of the 'existing confidential impediment' and the fact of its confidentiality, for 'whatever reason it is being kept confidential'.
'It is appropriate, in the circumstances, that the court should proceed with the same recognition and respect. But the consequence is this: there is, as a result, a significant limitation to what this court can realistically assess, when considering the risks and implications in this case, and for that matter when considering how to characterise the now long passage of time,' the judge concluded in his ruling.
The confidential proceedings, alluded to at various previous court hearings linked with Nirav Modi, are believed to refer to an asylum application, but the exact nature of the matter is unclear.
Meanwhile, Nirav has remained in prison in London since his arrest in March 2019 and has made at least seven previous bail attempts, which have all been rejected because he poses a flight risk.
Justice Fordham said he considered the legal appropriateness for him to consider the latest bail application 'afresh' and with a 'clean slate'.
'I have had close regard to the points which have been made about the human cost of detention. That includes all of the points that have been advanced about physical and mental health, including in terms of deterioration and delays in treatment, and the concerns very properly raised in the clinicians' expert evidence,' Justice Fordham's judgment said.
'I have also taken account of the evidence about assaults and threats and the prospect of coercion… But I am not able to conclude that, when put alongside the other relevant features of the case, they can serve to displace or undermine the assessment which I have described (against bail),' it said.
There are three sets of criminal proceedings against Nirav Modi in India – the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) case of fraud in the Punjab National Bank (PNB), the Enforcement Directorate (ED) case relating to the alleged laundering of the proceeds of that fraud, and a third set of criminal proceedings involving alleged interference with evidence and witnesses in the CBI proceedings.
In April 2021, then UK home secretary, Priti Patel, ordered his extradition to face these charges in the Indian courts after a prima facie case was established against him.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India Today
30 minutes ago
- India Today
He does this to his dad, Shashi Tharoor quips after son's curveball on Op Sindoor
In a rare and heartwarming moment during India's diplomatic outreach in Washington DC following the Pahalgam terror attack and Operation Sindoor, Congress MP Shashi Tharoor found himself fielding a question from his son, Ishaan senior Tharoor, who is part of an all-party delegation visiting key global capitals to highlight the Pahalgam carnage and India's response to it, was pleasantly surprised when Ishaan - introducing himself jokingly as asking "in a personal capacity and mostly to say hi before you go off for your next engagement" - posed a pointed query about terrorism advertisementAs Ishaan took the mic, Shashi Tharoor smiled and gestured for him to raise it properly before he responded. The question, both timely and probing, was whether any country had asked the Indian delegation for evidence of Pakistan's involvement in the Pahalgam attack, given Pakistan's repeated denials. "I'm very glad you raised this. I didn't plant it, I promise you. This guy does this to his dad," Tharoor said candidly. He stated that "no one had any doubt," and that the delegation was not asked for evidence by any foreign government. However, he acknowledged that the media in "two or three places" did raise the question."Let me say very clearly that India would not have done this without convincing evidence," he said. Citing three reasons for international understanding, Tharoor highlighted the 37-year pattern of terror attacks originating from Pakistan, each followed by habitual reminded the audience of Pakistan's disavowal of knowledge of Osama bin Laden's whereabouts, even when he was eventually found in a compound adjacent to an army camp in Abbottabad. He also mentioned Pakistan's denial of involvement in the 26/11 Mumbai attacks."So we know what Pakistan's all about. They will dispatch terrorists, they will deny they did so until they're actually caught with red hands," he also dismissed the idea of American mediation between India and Pakistan. The US has, on several occasions, taken credit for brokering a ceasefire between India and Pakistan, with President Donald Trump claiming that he strongarmed the two nuclear nations with the threat of trade and tariffs. India, however, has denied the claim on several occasions. "Mediation is not a term that we are particularly willing to entertain. You're implying an equivalence which simply doesn't exist," he said. He added, "There is no equivalence between terrorists and their victims. There is no equivalence between a country that provides a safe haven to terrorism and a country that's a flourishing multi-party democracy that's trying to get on with its business."Addressing US diplomatic engagement following the attacks, Tharoor said the PM Modi-led government had received calls at high levels from the US, and that India appreciated the concern and interest. However, he said, "They must have been making similar calls at the highest levels to the Pakistan side. Because that's the side that needed persuading to stop this process... But that's guesswork on my part."advertisementReiterating the nature of India's actions in Operation Sindoor, Tharoor drew a sharp contrast between the two nations' conduct. "India hit terror bases in Pakistan, while Pakistan hit civilians in retaliation, since there are no terror bases in India," he asserted. "There are no terrorist organisations in India listed in the UN or the State Department anywhere else. So, what do you hit? You hit civilians, innocent people. That is the asymmetry of this particular conflict."Tharoor said India's response was "precise and calibrated", and stressed that India has "systematically signalled" it is not interested in war with Pakistan. "We're not interested in attacking Pakistani civilians, ordinary people. This is about India versus terrorism," he the question of Chinese military technology and Pakistan's alleged use of it, Tharoor said India responded innovatively and effectively during the conflict. The Thiruvananthapuram MP spoke about China's interest in Pakistan, but added that despite Islamabad's use of Beijing's technology, India was able to manoeuvre its military plans to give a befitting reply to supposed to be something called a kill chain that the Chinese specialise in. We simply did things in a different way. Otherwise, we wouldn't have been able to hit 11 airfields," he explained. He acknowledged the depth of China's investment in Pakistan through the Belt and Road Initiative, particularly the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor, and said India had "no illusions" about China's strategic stake in on the broader context, Tharoor described the war as "a distraction" for India, but "fundamental" to the Pakistani military's sense of self-importance."There was a lot of chuckling in Delhi," Tharoor remarked wryly, "when the failed general became a field marshal by promoting himself, as you said, with an extra star".Tune InTrending Reel
India Today
30 minutes ago
- India Today
Amit Shah's Kolkata huddle with Bengal BJP top brass sets tone for 2026 poll push
Union Home Minister Amit Shah's recent visit to Kolkata included a closely guarded meeting with senior BJP leaders, signalling a renewed push to wrest control of West Bengal in the 2026 assembly elections. According to sources, Shah held a closed-door session with Leader of Opposition Suvendu Adhikari and BJP state president Sukanta meeting, lasting over two hours, was centred around fine-tuning the party's roadmap for the high-stakes 294-seat assembly battle, with 148 seats required for a simple majority, sources the meeting, Adhikari submitted a comprehensive report on the BJP's organisational standing across Bengal. Discussions revolved around vote share calculations and electoral arithmetic, with Adhikari reportedly informing Shah that the BJP trails the ruling Trinamool Congress by around 4-5 percent in over 150 seats, based on trends observed between the 2019 and 2024 Lok Sabha polls. With the BJP holding a steady 40 percent voter share statewide, Adhikari argued that a swing of just 3-4 percent could enable the party to outpace the TMC in these key constituencies and form the next government.A significant portion of the strategy focusses on strengthening booth-level organisation. West Bengal has close to 80,000 polling booths, of which 14,000 are Muslim-majority areas where the BJP does not currently plan to set up booth the party is concentrating efforts on building robust teams in approximately 57,000 other booths, despite concerns over what leaders describe as an "atmosphere of terror" in several regions, sources said. BJP leaders Bansal and Pandera have reportedly been assigned the task of enhancing their grassroots presence as part of this focused organisational from the political strategy session, Shah also addressed a gathering of around 150 saints at Swami Vivekananda's house, where he outlined a broader ideological framework for the BJP's Bengal he avoided naming specific nations, Shah reportedly spoke of the need for a distinctly Indian "national mindset," in contrast to neighbouring countries - a comment widely interpreted as a reference to Bangladesh. He emphasised that the party's Bengal strategy is not just political but also linked to national security behind-the-scenes meetings and the ideological outreach are seen by insiders as key components of the BJP's evolving campaign architecture aimed at consolidating its base and expanding its appeal across a politically charged Watch
Time of India
33 minutes ago
- Time of India
API prices fall sharply, easing pressure on India's pharmaceutical industry
India's pharmaceutical industry is experiencing relief as active pharmaceutical ingredient (API) prices plummet due to overcapacity and aggressive pricing strategies from Chinese suppliers. Increased domestic API production, driven by government incentives and reduced raw material costs, further contribute to the decline. This trend is expected to continue, boosting profit margins for Indian pharma companies. Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads New Delhi: Prices of active pharmaceutical ingredients (API) used for manufacturing drugs are seeing a significant drop, bringing relief to India's pharmaceutical pharma industry depends largely on China for sourcing APIs, intermediates and bulk drugs. API prices had shot up during the Covid period and stayed elevated until last year. The situation has now started to change, reducing raw material cost and boosting profit margins for pharma instance, the price of paracetamol API has dropped from ₹900 per kg during the pandemic and ₹600 immediately after to ₹250 now, market sources told ET. The API for antibiotic meropenem has become cheaper at ₹45,000 per kg compared with ₹75,000."Prices of APIs have gone down significantly. It's largely due to over-capacity. We are seeing a huge impact on the prices of antibiotics, steroids, hormones, statins, among others," said Mehul Shah, who tracks the Chinese pharmaceutical expects this trend to continue through this industry expert said the prices have come down because of the aggressive strategy of Chinese suppliers to maintain market dominance. "This aggressive pricing has made Chinese APIs more attractive to Indian pharmaceutical companies, leading to increased imports when prices are low," he said on the condition of anonymity. Dinesh Dua , former chairman of the Pharmaceutical Export Promotion Council, said there were several factors that led to the price decline."While China scaled up significantly after Covid-19, the demand for APIs has gone down too as India has taken steps to become self-reliant," he said. "India's government has implemented the production-linked incentive scheme to boost domestic API production. As a result, companies like Aurobindo Pharma and Torrent Pharmaceuticals have initiated local production of APIs such as penicillin-G. This increased domestic output has contributed to a surplus in supply, exerting downward pressure on prices."Dua said a decline in the prices of raw materials, such as acetic acid and para-aminophenol, essential for API production, has also contributed to lower costs. "Additionally, easing geopolitical tensions and improved logistics have reduced freight charges, further decreasing the overall cost of API," he to industry experts, a gradual return of demand to pre-pandemic levels has also contributed to this situation.
