Here's how a wealth tax on Scotland's luxury properties could work
He argued that the current system is 'outdated and badly broken', and that as well as reforming how local authorities are funded, it would place most of the tax burden on those with more expensive homes.
Currently, Council Tax bands are based on property values from April 1991, but house prices in some areas have since surged.
The Scottish Government recently said that there is no 'political consensus' to undertake a revaluation of those bands.
READ MORE: James McMurdock MP worked for bank while 'claiming Covid loans'
Dalzell argues that instead of the current system, local authorities should tax properties on a percentage of the market value. The Property Tax would generate millions from estates and plush mansions across Scotland, as well as those who own more than one property.
And, extending this Property Tax to include estates and land could work as an additional wealth tax.
A rate of 0.63 per cent, when Common Weal produced a paper on the issue, would "have been revenue neutral compared to Council Tax", Dalzell said.
This would mean a tax cut for eight out of 10 households in Scotland, Dalzell claimed, 'as the burden of paying the tax would be placed more fairly on those who lived in the most expensive houses'.
'We calculated that the 'break even' point then would have been a house worth something like £400,000. This is based on a flat rate of tax, too,' Dalzell writes.
'We would argue that councils should have the power to add progressive rates on extremely valuable properties, such as £1 million-plus mansions or, as is the case with the current Council Tax, additional multipliers for multiple home ownership.
'This would immediately act as a wealth tax both on the most expensive properties but also on multiple property ownership.'
Council Tax is currently paid by those who occupy the property, many of whom are tenants. Dalzell argues that property owners should pay up instead and tenants would only pay a basic rate.
'Landlords would have to pay any multiple ownership surcharges themselves,' he added.
READ MORE: Inside the Scottish Greens leadership contest
Extending this Property Tax to include land around large properties could bring in an additional £450m a year, Dalzell says.
'This could be adjusted down to account for subsidies for small farms, or up to better tax the 422 people who own half of Scotland,' he said.
'One of the major advantages of both of these taxes – one that negates objections from both the UK and Scottish Government whenever taxes on the wealth have been suggested – is that they completely bypass the idea that the rich will simply leave the country.
'Recent studies have shown that the idea of 'millionaire flight' basically isn't a thing.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The National
an hour ago
- The National
John Swinney urged to act on illegal disabled toilet locks
Margaret Ellis, member of the Holyrood cross party group (CPG) on disability, spoke with The National about the locking of accessible toilets in the Highlands, which is illegal under the Equality Act 2010. Ellis, who lives in Achiltibuie, north of Ullapool, said that the nearest public disabled toilet remains locked. The facility has a sign which instructs potential users to collect a key from an unnamed post office, which is situated half a mile away and only opens for two hours four days a week. READ MORE: Expert debunks everything you've been told about Scotland's 'deficit' 'My village has a lot of excellent toilets, all of which are accessible but one', she noted. 'There is not even a bush nearby, let alone a hedge to shelter by as an 'accessible toilet'.' Former first minister Nicola Sturgeon previously helped the CPG hold a formal review into the locking of disabled toilets. Sturgeon reportedly told the group she was 'horrified' by the issue and suggested the group held another review around three years after the initial meeting, though Ellis said John Swinney has yet to engage with her. 'It is disgraceful, and it's now a question of how to get in touch with John Swinney', she said. 'We are only asking for one hour of his time, not a week in Honolulu. One hour to stop councils from breaking the law and causing misery for a massive group of people.' She recently met with Equalities Minister Kaukab Stewart, who allegedly expressed an understanding of the need for a review but said she was 'not in charge' of arrangements. Ellis said that the community council in Achiltibuie had offered to cover the costs of keeping the accessible toilet unlocked for disabled patrons, but that Highland Council rejected the proposal without explanation. When asked why it was declined, Ellis said: 'You'd have to ask them. They didn't want to speak with the community council.' She told The National that the only alternative was a 'very efficient' local Tesco which has a disabled facility on its premises. READ MORE: Chairman of Sheku Bayoh Inquiry decides against recusing himself 'The manager is also very efficient, and he told me once, 'Maggie, we can only try'', she said. The 2022 census showed there are 1.3 million people with registered disabilities in Scotland – around 24% of the population. Ellis believes that without engagement on the matter, it could cost votes for the SNP in next year's Holyrood elections. 'I'm not an overly political person, but I can well see that there are 1.3m people who won't be voting for John Swinney in the next election', she said. The First Minister and Highland Council have been approached for comment.
North Wales Chronicle
an hour ago
- North Wales Chronicle
Scotland's deficit grows by £5.1bn, Gers figures show
The latest Government Expenditure and Revenue Scotland (Gers) figures reported 'overall public finances in Scotland weakening, as expenditure grew faster than revenue'. For 2024-25, Scotland has a net fiscal deficit of minus £26.5 billion – an increase of £5.1 billion from the previous year – with this the representing minus 11.7% of the country's GDP. The UK deficit for 2024-25 was minus 5.1% of GDP, less than half the rate of Scotland. The Scottish Government report said the 'deterioration' between this year and last was in part linked to a fall in North Sea revenue, but it added: 'The difference is primarily explained by movements in non-North Sea revenue and spending, with Scottish revenue growing more slowly and Scottish expenditure growing more quickly than the UK.' Revenue in Scotland grew by 1.5% in 2024-25 to £91.4 billion. Spending increased to £117.6 billion in 2024-25, up from £111.4 billion in 2023-24. 'As a share of GDP, public spending remained at historically high levels in 2024,' the report noted. Scottish Secretary Ian Murray said the figures show Scots benefit from higher public spending than the UK average – with this £2,669 more per person north of the border. He said this 'means more money for schools, hospitals and policing, if the Scottish Parliament chooses to invest in those areas' – although he also claimed 'people in Scotland will rightly expect to see better outcomes' for these higher spending levels. Mr Murray said: 'These figures underline the collective economic strength of the United Kingdom and how Scotland benefits from the redistribution of wealth inside the UK. 'By sharing resources with each other across the UK, Scots benefit by £2,669 more per head in public spending than the UK average. 'It also means that devolved governments have the financial heft of the wider UK behind them when taking decisions.' Scottish Finance Secretary Shona Robison said decisions taken by ministers at Holyrood 'are helping support sustainable public finances'. She said: 'For the fourth year in a row, devolved revenues have grown faster than devolved expenditure. 'Scotland's public finances are better than many other parts of the UK, with the third highest revenue per person in the UK, behind only London and the South East.' She also stressed the Gers statistics reflect the current constitutional arrangements, with Scotland part of the UK and 'not an independent Scotland with its own policy, decisions on defence spending and the economy'. Arguing the figures highlight the 'limit' of devolved powers, Ms Robison said while the Scottish Government is responsible for more than 60% of public expenditure north of the border, it only controls 'around 30% of revenue'. The Finance Secretary told journalists: 'As an independent Scotland we would have the powers to make different choices, different budgetary results, to build a stronger economy and enable Scotland to be a fairer, wealthier and greener country.' She pointed to Ireland, saying GDP there had grown 12.5% over the last year, with a budget surplus of 24 billion euros (£20.7 billion) in 2024. Ms Robison hailed that as an example of 'what a small independent country, one of our nearest neighbours, is able to do with the full powers of independence'. She said: 'What we want, through the powers of independence, is to be able to make our own decisions. 'If you look at Ireland and what they have been able to do with the powers they have, it's like night and day compared to the economic conditions of the UK economy or the Scottish economy. 'Independence is the direction we want to take because we believe it will unleash the potential, from day one, to be able to emulate some of the economic performance of many of our neighbours, whether it is Ireland, or some of our Scandinavian neighbours.'
Rhyl Journal
an hour ago
- Rhyl Journal
Scotland's deficit grows by £5.1bn, Gers figures show
The latest Government Expenditure and Revenue Scotland (Gers) figures reported 'overall public finances in Scotland weakening, as expenditure grew faster than revenue'. For 2024-25, Scotland has a net fiscal deficit of minus £26.5 billion – an increase of £5.1 billion from the previous year – with this the representing minus 11.7% of the country's GDP. The UK deficit for 2024-25 was minus 5.1% of GDP, less than half the rate of Scotland. The Scottish Government report said the 'deterioration' between this year and last was in part linked to a fall in North Sea revenue, but it added: 'The difference is primarily explained by movements in non-North Sea revenue and spending, with Scottish revenue growing more slowly and Scottish expenditure growing more quickly than the UK.' Revenue in Scotland grew by 1.5% in 2024-25 to £91.4 billion. Spending increased to £117.6 billion in 2024-25, up from £111.4 billion in 2023-24. 'As a share of GDP, public spending remained at historically high levels in 2024,' the report noted. Scottish Secretary Ian Murray said the figures show Scots benefit from higher public spending than the UK average – with this £2,669 more per person north of the border. He said this 'means more money for schools, hospitals and policing, if the Scottish Parliament chooses to invest in those areas' – although he also claimed 'people in Scotland will rightly expect to see better outcomes' for these higher spending levels. Mr Murray said: 'These figures underline the collective economic strength of the United Kingdom and how Scotland benefits from the redistribution of wealth inside the UK. 'By sharing resources with each other across the UK, Scots benefit by £2,669 more per head in public spending than the UK average. 'It also means that devolved governments have the financial heft of the wider UK behind them when taking decisions.' Scottish Finance Secretary Shona Robison said decisions taken by ministers at Holyrood 'are helping support sustainable public finances'. She said: 'For the fourth year in a row, devolved revenues have grown faster than devolved expenditure. 'Scotland's public finances are better than many other parts of the UK, with the third highest revenue per person in the UK, behind only London and the South East.' She also stressed the Gers statistics reflect the current constitutional arrangements, with Scotland part of the UK and 'not an independent Scotland with its own policy, decisions on defence spending and the economy'. Arguing the figures highlight the 'limit' of devolved powers, Ms Robison said while the Scottish Government is responsible for more than 60% of public expenditure north of the border, it only controls 'around 30% of revenue'. The Finance Secretary told journalists: 'As an independent Scotland we would have the powers to make different choices, different budgetary results, to build a stronger economy and enable Scotland to be a fairer, wealthier and greener country.' She pointed to Ireland, saying GDP there had grown 12.5% over the last year, with a budget surplus of 24 billion euros (£20.7 billion) in 2024. Ms Robison hailed that as an example of 'what a small independent country, one of our nearest neighbours, is able to do with the full powers of independence'. She said: 'What we want, through the powers of independence, is to be able to make our own decisions. 'If you look at Ireland and what they have been able to do with the powers they have, it's like night and day compared to the economic conditions of the UK economy or the Scottish economy. 'Independence is the direction we want to take because we believe it will unleash the potential, from day one, to be able to emulate some of the economic performance of many of our neighbours, whether it is Ireland, or some of our Scandinavian neighbours.'
