Ex-Treasury boss Ken Henry says ‘mind boggles' over axing of carbon tax, calls for tougher environmental reform
He said 'it still boggles the mind that we had the world's best carbon policy' and questioned: 'Why the hell did we ever drop it?'
The carbon pricing scheme was introduced by Labor in 2012 and placed on about 500 of Australia's largest polluters.
Under the policy, companies had to purchase credits to offset the amount of carbon produced, with the funds generated form the levy returned through tax cuts and increases to welfare payments.
The measure was later repealed by the Abbott government in July 2014 and replaced with an offset scheme to incentivise companies to avoid emitting CO2 by earning carbon credits.
Speaking at the National Press Club on Wednesday, Mr Henry, who was the Treasury secretary from 2001 to 2011, criticised the scrapping of the tax.
'It still boggles the mind that we had the world's best carbon policy and then, for
purely political reasons, decided that we can afford to do without it,' he said, speaking as the chair of not-for-profit Australian Climate and Biodiversity Foundation.
'A country that's capable of creating the best and then decides that it doesn't need anything at all – well, my God, of course we need a carbon tax.'
Mr Henry urged the government to not 'give up' and fix Australia's 'broken' environmental laws, taking aim at the 'not fit for purpose' and outdated Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 (EPBC).
'Report after report tells the same story. The environment is not being protected. Biodiversity is not being conserved. Nature is in systemic decline,' he said.
'Of particular concern, they are incapable of supporting an economy in transition to net zero, and they are undermining productivity.'
He noted that the government's pledge to erect 1.2 million homes by 2030 would require more land and transport, meaning more interaction with EPBC assessments.
In strong criticism, he said there was 'no point in building a faster highway to hell', and while approvals needed to be granted faster, the environment needed to be protected.
'These projects, be they wind farms, solar farms, transmission lines, new housing developments, land-based carbon sequestration projects, new and enhanced transport corridors or critical minerals extraction and processing plants, must be delivered quickly and efficiently,' he said.
Speaking more broadly about government spending, Dr Henry, who authored the Henry Tax Review in 2010 to guide tax reforms over the next 10 to 20 years, said there needed to be more 'spending discipline'.
'If the budget is to meet these growing spending pressures, then we've got two options. We either increase taxes, as a share of GDP, or we grow the economy faster,' he said, noting productivity growth had slumped from an average of 2.31 per cent in the '90s to 0.98 per cent in the last 25 years.
'That's a pretty fundamental difference.
'If we continue on that trajectory, as we said in 2002, we will have no option but to raise taxes, and quite significantly, by several percentage points of GDP … or cut spending.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News.com.au
an hour ago
- News.com.au
Over 80 per cent of Tuvalu seeks Australian climate visa as rising seas lap at nation's shores
The number of applications for a landmark climate visa to live in Australia are rising rapidly in the tiny island nation of Tuvalu, as ominously rising seas lap at its shores. More than 80 per cent of Pacific nation Tuvalu's population is now seeking refuge Down Under. Australia is offering visas to Tuvalu citizens each year under a climate migration deal Canberra has billed as 'the first agreement of its kind anywhere in the world'. 'We received extremely high levels of interest in the ballot with 8,750 registrations, which includes family members of primary registrants,' the Australian high commission in Tuvalu said in a statement. The figure is equal to 82 per cent of the country's 10,643 population, according to census figures collected in 2022. 'With 280 visas offered this program year, it means that many will miss out,' the commission said. One of the most climate-threatened corners of the planet, scientists fear Tuvalu will be uninhabitable within the next 80 years. Two of the archipelago's nine coral atolls have already largely disappeared under the waves. The figures were released hours before a landmark decision by the world's top court in The Hague laying out what legal obligations countries have to prevent climate change and whether polluters should pay up for the consequences. The case, which has been brought by Pacific nations, could reshape climate justice, with major impacts on laws around the world. 'First agreement of its kind' Australia and Tuvalu signed the groundbreaking Falepili Union in 2024, part of Canberra's efforts to blunt China's expanding reach in the region. Under that pact, Australia opened a new visa category specially set aside for citizens of Tuvalu who will be selected at random. 'Australia recognises the devastating impact climate change is having on the livelihoods, security, and wellbeing of climate vulnerable countries and people, particularly in the Pacific region,' Australia's foreign affairs department told AFP last month. 'This is the first agreement of its kind anywhere in the world, providing a pathway for mobility with dignity as climate impacts worsen.' It will also provide Tuvaluans the choice to live, study and work in Australia. Tuvalu citizens, including those living outside the country, were eligible to be included in the ballot if they are aged over 18 and pay a A$25 fee (US$16). The visa deal has been hailed as a landmark response to the looming challenge of climate-forced migration. The Falepili pact commits Australia to defending Tuvalu in the face of natural disasters, health pandemics and 'military aggression'. 'For the first time, there is a country that has committed legally to come to the aid of Tuvalu, upon request, when Tuvalu encounters a major natural disaster, a health pandemic or military aggression,' Tuvalu Prime Minister Feleti Teo said at the time. 'Again, for the first time there is a country that has committed legally to recognise the future statehood and sovereignty of Tuvalu despite the detrimental impact of climate changed-induced sea level rise.' The agreement also gives Australia a say in any other defence pacts Tuvalu signs with other countries, raising concerns at the time that the Pacific nation was handing over its sovereignty. Tuvalu is one of just 12 states that still have formal diplomatic relations with Taipei rather than Beijing. — with Brendan Kearns, AFP
Sky News AU
an hour ago
- Sky News AU
‘Culture of dependency' on the rise under Labor
Sky News host Danica De Giorgio discusses Australia's 'culture of dependency' on the rise under the Albanese Labor government. 'Labor is already ducking and weaving on its own tax reform agenda, ugh jeez, look, we can see where this is going, can't we, we just know it,' Ms De Giorgio said. 'Higher taxes under the guise of an economic reform roundtable.'
The Advertiser
an hour ago
- The Advertiser
HECS debt relief nears as Labor eyes further uni reform
Students and graduates will soon receive a cut to higher education debts but advocates say the government must do more to make university fees fairer. Legislation was introduced to parliament on Wednesday to slash HECS debts by 20 per cent and increase income thresholds before minimum repayments kick in. It is expected to be passed with the support of the opposition in the coming weeks. Prime Minister Anthony Albanese credited the bill as a key reason behind Labor's victory in the May election. "Because it resonated with those young Australians in particular, who are looking for intergenerational equity measures, which is what this is, saving some three million Australians an average of $5500 each," he said during question time. Federal Education Minister Jason Clare said the policy will make the system fairer. "It means you start paying off your uni degree when uni starts to pay off for you," he said while introducing the bill to the House of Representatives earlier on Wednesday. People earning between $60,000 and $180,000 will save hundreds of dollars each year under the changes. Someone on $70,000 will save the most on minimum repayments - $1300 a year - due to an increase to the thresholds for when the debts must be paid. The bill is set to sail through both houses of parliament, with Opposition Leader Sussan Ley telling Sky News: "We will be constructive where we can." Bruce Chapman, the architect of the HECS scheme, said the relief would make the system fairer by giving those on lower salaries more money in their pockets. But the top priority should be reviewing the price of each degree because humanities students finish with the highest level of debt and end up being the lowest-paid graduates. "All the prices are wrong," Professor Chapman told AAP. Mr Clare said further reforms were being looked at after the failure of the former Liberal government's job-ready program. The program aimed to fill skills shortages by making it cheaper to take courses such as teaching, nursing and psychology, while doubling the cost of popular degrees including law, communications, business, humanities and the arts. "If the intention there was to reduce the number of people doing arts degrees, it hasn't worked," Mr Clare said. "People study the courses they're interested in, that they want to do, that they love." The universities' accord final report branded the program "deeply unfair" because it punished students who followed their interests. It recommended that fees reflect future earning potential as part of 47 recommendations to reform the sector. The universities sector welcomed the HECS bill but called on the government to repeal the jobs-ready graduates scheme. "Scrapping the job-ready graduates package to make student fees fairer and expanding the Commonwealth prac payment could help shift the dial on participation, which is what the country needs," Universities Australia chief executive Luke Sheehy said. Other aspects about how HECS debts were paid off also needed to be addressed, Prof Chapman said. HECS repayments are taken from a person's pay if they earn above an income threshold. But the money isn't immediately taken off the total debt and is instead deducted as a lump sum at the end of the financial year after indexation has been applied. The university accord recommended the arrangement be changed to make the system fairer. The Australian Tertiary Education Commission has been established in an interim capacity to implement long-term university reform and will review the HECS system over the next 12 months. Mr Clare will introduce further legislation to make the commission a permanent body. Students and graduates will soon receive a cut to higher education debts but advocates say the government must do more to make university fees fairer. Legislation was introduced to parliament on Wednesday to slash HECS debts by 20 per cent and increase income thresholds before minimum repayments kick in. It is expected to be passed with the support of the opposition in the coming weeks. Prime Minister Anthony Albanese credited the bill as a key reason behind Labor's victory in the May election. "Because it resonated with those young Australians in particular, who are looking for intergenerational equity measures, which is what this is, saving some three million Australians an average of $5500 each," he said during question time. Federal Education Minister Jason Clare said the policy will make the system fairer. "It means you start paying off your uni degree when uni starts to pay off for you," he said while introducing the bill to the House of Representatives earlier on Wednesday. People earning between $60,000 and $180,000 will save hundreds of dollars each year under the changes. Someone on $70,000 will save the most on minimum repayments - $1300 a year - due to an increase to the thresholds for when the debts must be paid. The bill is set to sail through both houses of parliament, with Opposition Leader Sussan Ley telling Sky News: "We will be constructive where we can." Bruce Chapman, the architect of the HECS scheme, said the relief would make the system fairer by giving those on lower salaries more money in their pockets. But the top priority should be reviewing the price of each degree because humanities students finish with the highest level of debt and end up being the lowest-paid graduates. "All the prices are wrong," Professor Chapman told AAP. Mr Clare said further reforms were being looked at after the failure of the former Liberal government's job-ready program. The program aimed to fill skills shortages by making it cheaper to take courses such as teaching, nursing and psychology, while doubling the cost of popular degrees including law, communications, business, humanities and the arts. "If the intention there was to reduce the number of people doing arts degrees, it hasn't worked," Mr Clare said. "People study the courses they're interested in, that they want to do, that they love." The universities' accord final report branded the program "deeply unfair" because it punished students who followed their interests. It recommended that fees reflect future earning potential as part of 47 recommendations to reform the sector. The universities sector welcomed the HECS bill but called on the government to repeal the jobs-ready graduates scheme. "Scrapping the job-ready graduates package to make student fees fairer and expanding the Commonwealth prac payment could help shift the dial on participation, which is what the country needs," Universities Australia chief executive Luke Sheehy said. Other aspects about how HECS debts were paid off also needed to be addressed, Prof Chapman said. HECS repayments are taken from a person's pay if they earn above an income threshold. But the money isn't immediately taken off the total debt and is instead deducted as a lump sum at the end of the financial year after indexation has been applied. The university accord recommended the arrangement be changed to make the system fairer. The Australian Tertiary Education Commission has been established in an interim capacity to implement long-term university reform and will review the HECS system over the next 12 months. Mr Clare will introduce further legislation to make the commission a permanent body. Students and graduates will soon receive a cut to higher education debts but advocates say the government must do more to make university fees fairer. Legislation was introduced to parliament on Wednesday to slash HECS debts by 20 per cent and increase income thresholds before minimum repayments kick in. It is expected to be passed with the support of the opposition in the coming weeks. Prime Minister Anthony Albanese credited the bill as a key reason behind Labor's victory in the May election. "Because it resonated with those young Australians in particular, who are looking for intergenerational equity measures, which is what this is, saving some three million Australians an average of $5500 each," he said during question time. Federal Education Minister Jason Clare said the policy will make the system fairer. "It means you start paying off your uni degree when uni starts to pay off for you," he said while introducing the bill to the House of Representatives earlier on Wednesday. People earning between $60,000 and $180,000 will save hundreds of dollars each year under the changes. Someone on $70,000 will save the most on minimum repayments - $1300 a year - due to an increase to the thresholds for when the debts must be paid. The bill is set to sail through both houses of parliament, with Opposition Leader Sussan Ley telling Sky News: "We will be constructive where we can." Bruce Chapman, the architect of the HECS scheme, said the relief would make the system fairer by giving those on lower salaries more money in their pockets. But the top priority should be reviewing the price of each degree because humanities students finish with the highest level of debt and end up being the lowest-paid graduates. "All the prices are wrong," Professor Chapman told AAP. Mr Clare said further reforms were being looked at after the failure of the former Liberal government's job-ready program. The program aimed to fill skills shortages by making it cheaper to take courses such as teaching, nursing and psychology, while doubling the cost of popular degrees including law, communications, business, humanities and the arts. "If the intention there was to reduce the number of people doing arts degrees, it hasn't worked," Mr Clare said. "People study the courses they're interested in, that they want to do, that they love." The universities' accord final report branded the program "deeply unfair" because it punished students who followed their interests. It recommended that fees reflect future earning potential as part of 47 recommendations to reform the sector. The universities sector welcomed the HECS bill but called on the government to repeal the jobs-ready graduates scheme. "Scrapping the job-ready graduates package to make student fees fairer and expanding the Commonwealth prac payment could help shift the dial on participation, which is what the country needs," Universities Australia chief executive Luke Sheehy said. Other aspects about how HECS debts were paid off also needed to be addressed, Prof Chapman said. HECS repayments are taken from a person's pay if they earn above an income threshold. But the money isn't immediately taken off the total debt and is instead deducted as a lump sum at the end of the financial year after indexation has been applied. The university accord recommended the arrangement be changed to make the system fairer. The Australian Tertiary Education Commission has been established in an interim capacity to implement long-term university reform and will review the HECS system over the next 12 months. Mr Clare will introduce further legislation to make the commission a permanent body. Students and graduates will soon receive a cut to higher education debts but advocates say the government must do more to make university fees fairer. Legislation was introduced to parliament on Wednesday to slash HECS debts by 20 per cent and increase income thresholds before minimum repayments kick in. It is expected to be passed with the support of the opposition in the coming weeks. Prime Minister Anthony Albanese credited the bill as a key reason behind Labor's victory in the May election. "Because it resonated with those young Australians in particular, who are looking for intergenerational equity measures, which is what this is, saving some three million Australians an average of $5500 each," he said during question time. Federal Education Minister Jason Clare said the policy will make the system fairer. "It means you start paying off your uni degree when uni starts to pay off for you," he said while introducing the bill to the House of Representatives earlier on Wednesday. People earning between $60,000 and $180,000 will save hundreds of dollars each year under the changes. Someone on $70,000 will save the most on minimum repayments - $1300 a year - due to an increase to the thresholds for when the debts must be paid. The bill is set to sail through both houses of parliament, with Opposition Leader Sussan Ley telling Sky News: "We will be constructive where we can." Bruce Chapman, the architect of the HECS scheme, said the relief would make the system fairer by giving those on lower salaries more money in their pockets. But the top priority should be reviewing the price of each degree because humanities students finish with the highest level of debt and end up being the lowest-paid graduates. "All the prices are wrong," Professor Chapman told AAP. Mr Clare said further reforms were being looked at after the failure of the former Liberal government's job-ready program. The program aimed to fill skills shortages by making it cheaper to take courses such as teaching, nursing and psychology, while doubling the cost of popular degrees including law, communications, business, humanities and the arts. "If the intention there was to reduce the number of people doing arts degrees, it hasn't worked," Mr Clare said. "People study the courses they're interested in, that they want to do, that they love." The universities' accord final report branded the program "deeply unfair" because it punished students who followed their interests. It recommended that fees reflect future earning potential as part of 47 recommendations to reform the sector. The universities sector welcomed the HECS bill but called on the government to repeal the jobs-ready graduates scheme. "Scrapping the job-ready graduates package to make student fees fairer and expanding the Commonwealth prac payment could help shift the dial on participation, which is what the country needs," Universities Australia chief executive Luke Sheehy said. Other aspects about how HECS debts were paid off also needed to be addressed, Prof Chapman said. HECS repayments are taken from a person's pay if they earn above an income threshold. But the money isn't immediately taken off the total debt and is instead deducted as a lump sum at the end of the financial year after indexation has been applied. The university accord recommended the arrangement be changed to make the system fairer. The Australian Tertiary Education Commission has been established in an interim capacity to implement long-term university reform and will review the HECS system over the next 12 months. Mr Clare will introduce further legislation to make the commission a permanent body.
