Uneconomical, impractical: Experts on Railway decision to cap passenger waiting list at 25 pc
The ministry, however, has justified the decision, saying less than one-fourth of the total number of waiting passengers get confirmed berths on an average and the 25 per cent cap has been placed in view of that.
New Delhi, Jun 28 (PTI) The Railway's decision to limit the passenger waiting list to 25 per cent of the capacity of each class has been flagged by reservation supervisors, ticket booking clerks and some senior commercial officers as uneconomical for the railways and inconvenient for travellers.
He highlighted that earlier, there was an allegation that the Railways allowed a lot of passengers to book berths in the waiting category which led to crowding in trains. 'It was also alleged that the Railways earned money on ticket cancellation.' Refuting the charge, Kumar stressed the Railways was more concerned about passenger comfort than monetary benefits.
The Centre for Railway Information Systems (CRIS) implemented the 25 per cent cap decision on June 16 for trains with reservation facilities. This come around two months after the ministry, through a circular, conveyed its decision on the matter to all principal chief commercial managers and the CRIS managing director.
The April 17 circular stated, 'The matter has been reviewed and it has been decided that the maximum current waiting list limit will be revised to 25 per cent of the redefined capacity of each class available at originating as well as roadside stations.' It added, 'This logic will also be applicable for issuing of waitlisted tickets from remote locations as well as tickets booked under Tatkal scheme. This waiting list limit shall, however, not be applicable to the tickets issued on concessional fares, warrants etc.' The circular directed CRIS to 'make necessary modifications in the software and inform the date of effect to all zonal Railways'.
Railway officials said such a cap was in place earlier as well but more and more people were allowed to reserve seats/berths in the waiting category.
According to a 2013 circular, the waiting list cap on AC/EC and 2 AC classes was 30 and 100 respectively. Similarly, the first class, 3AC/Chair Car and sleeper class had 30, 300 and 400 waiting limits, respectively.
Over a week after the implementation of new waiting norms, a section of experts as well as reservation officials termed the decision 'impractical'.
'Waiting lists give a demand trend based on which we make decisions to run special trains. How will we do it now when the waiting lists of all trains will be capped at 25 per cent?' said a retired senior railway commercial officer who termed waiting lists valuable data to make future decisions.
Reservation supervisors said there have been cases in which due to bulk cancellations, trains departed with some available seats and despite giving confirmed berths to all waiting list passengers, some remained vacant causing a loss to the Railways.
'On one hand seats/berths remain vacant and on the other needy people are unable to travel,' a supervisor said.
'Agents often do bulk booking on routes high on demand. They go for cancellations before 48 hours of a train's departure so that they have to pay just the nominal cancellation charges. In such cases, there is a high possibility that availability of seats/berths will be created before the train's departure,' another reservation supervisor said.
He added, 'This will create opportunities for brokers and touts operating at the current booking window at stations to mint money for passengers as they have prior information of berth positions due to their nexus with lower-level ticket booking staff.' Some experts wondered how the Railways arrived at the 25 per cent cap for roadside stations where the berth quota is two or three seats and supposed that it was decided randomly.
'It is an ill-conceived decision to minimise the perception of crowding in trains by capping the waiting limits. Even if the aim of it is to minimise crowd in AC classes, it will not help as a prospective passenger can buy a general counter ticket and travel in AC classes. Normally, E-ticket waiting list passengers do the same,' a senior commercial officer said.
He added, 'The Railways should introduce more trains on busy routes rather than bringing all these measures to hide actual demand of travellers.' PTI JP JP NSD NSD
This report is auto-generated from PTI news service. ThePrint holds no responsibility for its content.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scroll.in
an hour ago
- Scroll.in
Pune: FIR against 7 for harassing Kargil veteran's family over citizenship
The Pune Police on Wednesday filed a case against seven persons for unlawful assembly after a Hindutva group allegedly barged into a house belonging to the family of a Kargil War veteran and accused them of being undocumented migrants from Bangladesh, the Hindustan Times reported. The family claimed that a mob of about 80 persons allegedly affiliated to a Hindutva group forcibly entered their home on Saturday night and accused them of being 'illegal' migrants. Irshad Shaikh, whose elder brother Hakimuddin Shaikh served in the Indian Army during the 1999 Kargil War and currently lives in Uttar Pradesh, said that his family had been living in Pune for more than six decades, the newspaper reported. 'We tried to explain that our family has deep roots here, and several of us have served in the armed forces, but they continued hurling accusations,' the Hindustan Times quoted Irshad Shaikh as saying. The mob abused the family and demanded to see Aadhaar and other identity documents to prove their Indian citizenship, the family claimed, adding that some of them alleged that their papers were fake. Women and children were also allegedly forced to produce documents. Irshad Shaikh also claimed that two men in plainclothes had identified themselves as police officers but did not intervene when the mob allegedly harassed the family. The family said that they were taken to the Chandannagar Police Station and made to wait for hours. Eventually, they were told to return the next day or risk being declared as 'Bangladeshi nationals'. After seeking support from social activists and lawyers, the family met Pune Police Commissioner Amitesh Kumar on Wednesday and demanded action against the mob, the Hindustan Times reported. 'He [Kumar] assured us that stringent action is being taken against anti-social elements,' the newspaper quoted Irshad Shaikh as saying. Kumar told the Hindustan Times that a first information report had been filed for unlawful assembly. 'On receiving a call about suspected Bangladeshi nationals, police found people raising slogans outside the house,' he said. 'The mob's actions are under scrutiny, and based on fresh statements, more sections may be added or a separate FIR may be filed.' Deputy Commissioner of Police Somay Munde also told The Indian Express that information had been received on Saturday about 'suspected illegal Bangladeshi nationals' in the area. 'So we went to the spot [on Saturday],' Munde said. 'Some of their documents were checked and some were brought to the police station. They were released as it was getting late and were called back the next morning.' The officer claimed that the action was taken at night 'as sometimes in these combing operations suspects flee'. Kumar also claimed that most police personnel were in uniform when the incident took place but did not rule out the possibility that some were in plainclothes. The family's documents were verified and found to be in order, he added. Irshad Shaikh said that his family had valid documents to prove their citizenship, adding: 'If necessary, we can trace our citizenship back 400 years.' He also told The Indian Express that his family had a 130-year history of serving in the Army. 'My own brother Hakimuddin joined the Bombay Sappers in 1982 in Pune and was posted across India after his training,' the newspaper quoted Irshad Shaikh as saying. 'He fought in the Kargil War and retired in 2000. He resides in Pratapgarh in Uttar Pradesh.' Meanwhile, Hakimuddin Shaikh told the Hindustan Times that it was 'disheartening' that a family with a history of military service had to face such humiliation. 'If required, I'll personally speak to the authorities to seek accountability,' he added. Since the April 22 Pahalgam terror attack, Bengali-speaking migrant workers have been rounded up by the police in several states ruled by the Bharatiya Janata Party and asked to prove that they are Indian citizens. In some cases, individuals who were mistakenly sent to Bangladesh returned to the country after state authorities in India proved that they were Indians. In May, the Union home ministry directed the states and Union Territories to verify the credentials of persons suspected to be undocumented migrants from Bangladesh and Myanmar.
Hindustan Times
3 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
FIR filed against 7 for harassing Kargil veteran's family over citizenship
The Pune police on Wednesday filed a first information report (FIR) against seven individuals and others for alleged unlawful assembly after a group of members belonging to a right-wing group barged into the house of a family of Kargil War veteran. According to the family, the mob forced its way into the residence around midnight, abused the occupants, and insisted on identity verification. (MAHENDRA KOLHE/ HT) The police action came a day after the war veteran's family in Pune alleged that a mob of around 80 individuals, allegedly affiliated to a right-wing group, forcibly entered their home in Chandannagar late Saturday night and accused them of being illegal immigrants from Bangladesh. The group allegedly demanded Aadhaar cards and other documents to prove their Indian citizenship. According to the family, the mob forced its way into the residence around midnight, abused the occupants, and insisted on identity verification. Some members of the group allegedly claimed the family's documents were fake, despite being shown valid Aadhaar cards. Women and children were also allegedly coerced to produce ID documents. Irshad Shaikh, 48, whose elder brother Hakimuddin Shaikh served in the Indian Army during the Kargil War, said that their family has lived in Pune for over six decades. 'We tried to explain that our family has deep roots here, and several of us have served in the armed forces, but they continued hurling accusations,' he said. He alleged that two men in plainclothes identified themselves as police personnel but did not intervene while the group harassed the family. After being taken to the Chandannagar Police Station, the family claims they were made to wait by officials for hours and told to return the next day or risk being declared 'Bangladeshi nationals'. 'We met Pune Police Commissioner Amitesh Kumar on Wednesday and explained him chain of events and how our family was harrassed and intimidated by a group of people. He assured us that stringent action is being taken against anti-social elements,' said Irshad after visiting the police commissionerate. He claimed that the family has all valid documents to prove citizenship. 'If necessary, we can trace our citizenship back 400 years,' he said, adding that multiple family members had served in the army across various wars. Kumar said an FIR has been registered under sections related to unlawful assembly. 'On receiving a call about suspected Bangladeshi nationals, police found people raising slogans outside the house. The mob's actions are under scrutiny, and based on fresh statements, more sections may be added or a separate FIR may be filed,' he said. On the family's claim that police in civvies stood by during the incident, Kumar said most personnel were in uniform but did not rule out the possibility that some were in plainclothes. He added that the family's documents were verified and found to be in order. The family has sought support from social activists and lawyers, who accompanied them to a meeting with the police commissioner on Wednesday evening, demanding strict action against those involved. Hakimuddin, now living in Pratapgarh, Uttar Pradesh, said, 'It's disheartening that a family with a history of military service has to face such humiliation. If required, I'll personally speak to the authorities to seek accountability.'
Hindustan Times
4 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
Uttar Pradesh govt refuses to bow to pressure, merges nearly 10,000 schools
Despite protests by political parties and opposition from a number of teachers, parents, students and a legal battle, the state government has refused to buckle under any pressure and gone ahead with the school merger plan, pairing close to 10,000 primary, upper primary schools this month. The exact number will be made known in the first week of August when the entire process is completed after addressing stakeholders' complaints. The exact number of schools merged will be made known in August. (SOURCED) Talking to Hindustan Times, additional chief secretary, basic education, Deepak Kumar said about 9000 to 10,000 government-run primary and upper primary schools have been merged (or paired) and added that exact number will be shared with the press in August when the process is completed. 'It is a long exercise given the size of the state and needs to be handled with care as it concerns students,' Kumar said ahead of basic education minister Sandeep Singh's proposed press conference scheduled for Thursday. There has been some misinformation in circulation that schools with more than 50 students have been merged which is not true, he said, adding that one must look at the larger picture. 'We are doing this exercise keeping in mind the larger interest of students so that they get better infrastructures and facilities on bigger school premises,' he said. He clarified that due to some unavoidable circumstances, a few schools with more than 60-70 students or even more have been merged because the parent school building either got swept away in floods or they are being run in dilapidated structures and have been shifted to a nearby building till the old one is bulldozed and a new structure comes up. When asked whether there is any fixed criteria for the number of children for pairing of schools, the ACS said, 'Yes, we have said that schools with less than 50 students will be merged. Yes, from some places it has been reported that even schools with 70 children are being closed but as I have told you that those were special cases where school buildings either got washed away or in bad shape. Hence students were shifted to nearby schools.' Mentioning the student-teacher ratio once the schools are paired, he said, 'We think it should be around 1:30 to 1:35, which is an ideal situation.' When told that in several parts of the state, primary schools are closed temporarily due to flooding, he said basic education department officials are working on all parameters in the larger interest of the students. The state government has initiated the exercise of conducting audits of safety mechanisms and facilities for children in schools. The initiative is a part of the missive from the ministry of education that issued a directive to all states and Union Territories, requiring them to carry out an audit of safety mechanisms. 'A majority of the government-run schools have been renovated under the Operation Kayakalp initiative and there would be few schools only that need to be restored. On that front, our government schools are in better condition. Safety of the students is our top priority,' he said. In connection with the pairing of schools, a number of students and parents alleged that now their kids have to travel a long distance to reach their school. At this, ACS said the basic education department officials were told to look into the complaints and if there are any genuine issues, problems should be resolved.
