logo
'I'm alarmed': With recession fears rising, jobless benefits still fall short: Report

'I'm alarmed': With recession fears rising, jobless benefits still fall short: Report

USA Today23-04-2025

'I'm alarmed': With recession fears rising, jobless benefits still fall short: Report
Show Caption
Hide Caption
Can you get unemployment if you quit? What to know about benefits.
Being out of work doesn't mean you automatically qualify for unemployment benefits. Here's what to know before applying.
During the COVID-19 recession, 22 million laid-off workers sought unemployment benefits, sparking chaos in the payment system and compounding the financial woes of jobless Americans.
Five years later, with many forecasters predicting another downturn is likely in 2025, a far less burdened benefits system remains plagued by myriad problems that could hamper payments to Americans who lose their jobs in an economic slump, according to a new report.
Nearly 1 in 5 unemployment insurance recipients say their benefits were inadequate, with a third complaining they've struggled with food insecurity despite the payments, according to a survey and study by the National Employment Law Project.
Large shares of beneficiaries also lament delayed payments, jammed phone lines, hard-to-navigate websites and incorrectly denied benefits, among other issues, according to the survey, which was conducted in partnership with online polling firm YouGov in September.
The firms surveyed 1,480 workers who were unemployed at some point from 2019 to 2024 and the results were provided exclusively to USA TODAY.
'I'm alarmed,' said Amy Traub, senior researcher and policy analyst for NELP and a co-author of the study. 'The unemployment insurance system is really falling far short in its function of supporting unemployed workers.'
The gaps exist even though Congress provided $1 billion in the American Rescue Plan of 2021 to shore up jobless benefits. Traub said the money did foster more timely payments and website improvements but there are still shortcomings in those and other areas.
States finance unemployment payments themselves while the federal government bankrolls the system's technology and infrastructure. Both are funded by payroll taxes that are generally paid by employers.
Why do we have unemployment insurance?
Besides helping workers make ends meet when they lose their jobs, jobless benefits bolster consumer demand, helping avoid – or dig the economy out of – a recession, the NELP report says. And the payments ensure that workers have enough time to find a job that best suits their skills, improving the efficiency of the labor market and economy.
Economists surveyed say there's a nearly 50% chance of a recession because of President Donald Trump's sweeping tariffs on imported goods, according to a survey by Wolters Kluwer Blue Chip Economic Indicators. JPMorgan Chase has put the odds at 60%.
Among the lingering trouble spots with the system:
Benefits fall short
Nineteen percent of the unemployment recipients polled said the money they received wasn't enough to meet their financial needs, the survey showed.
To be sure, the checks go a long way toward helping laid-off workers stay afloat. Of unemployment applicants who didn't receive benefits, 51% experienced hunger, 40% struggled to pay their rent or mortgage and 37% had a hard time paying medical bills, according to the survey. By contrast, among those obtaining payments, 33% went hungry at times, 29% had issues with housing payments and 30% couldn't pay medical costs.
Yet it's troubling that about a third of beneficiaries still had difficulty covering basic expenses, Traub said.
'During the next recession, if we have large numbers of workers who lose their jobs, we want to be sure they're not going hungry or losing their homes,' she said.
A big reason many recipients can't cover such necessities is the wide disparities among states in their benefit disbursements, Traub said.
In early 2024, for example, Alabama workers received an average benefit of $252 a week, replacing 29% of their prior wage on average, while workers in Washington state got an average $721 a week, or 49% of their previous pay.
On average across the U.S., unemployment covered 36% of a worker's previous pay.
Also, most states provide up to 26 weeks of benefits – a standard that's typically expanded in a recession – but 13 states dole out checks for 12 to 21 weeks, including Arkansas, Iowa, Michigan, Oklahoma, South Carolina, Alabama, Kansas and Florida, according to the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities.
Jammed phone lines, uncooperative websites, late payments
During the COVID-19 pandemic, an unprecedented surge of applicants struggled to obtain payments. Surprisingly, freshly laid-off workers nowadays, numbering about 200,000 each week, still face obstacles.
From 2022 to 2024, about 22% of applicants said they couldn't reach their state unemployment office by phone, the same share as during the pandemic (2020-2021); 20% complained of hard-to-navigate websites vs. 23% during the health crisis; and 17% pointed to delays receiving payments, compared to 21% during the crisis.
Many states beefed up staffing during the COVID-19 pandemic, shifting workers from other parts of state unemployment agencies to customer service, but moved them back to their old positions as the spike in applications ebbed, Traub said. In many cases, that left a reduced but still sizable share of workers struggling to access benefits.
Employers discourage workers from applying
Nearly 1 in 5 workers said an employer tried to deter them from applying for benefits, with 14% saying such steps included telling them they weren't eligible and 5% threatening retaliation if they applied.
Employers may have the incentive to dissuade staffers from filing for unemployment because the taxes they pay to support the benefits system are based on the number of their workers who successfully file claims.
'It's not really up to the employer who's eligible and who's not,' Traub said.
Incorrectly denied benefits
About 17% of applicants polled said they were improperly denied benefits since the pandemic. The question of whether applicants are entitled to payments can get thorny, hinging on whether they were laid off or fired for cause, and whether they met thresholds for the number of hours they worked and the wages they earned in previous months, Traub said
Discrimination
About 7% of applicants said they faced discrimination because of race or other reasons when they sought benefits, the survey showed.
In a related issue, a growing number of states are using new ID verification systems to detect fraud, according to the report, which was coauthored by researchers Alexander Hertel-Fernandez and Sanjay Pinto. Twelve percent of Black workers report trouble verifying their identity, more than twice the share of white employees, according to NELP's survey.
The NELP report pointed to facial recognition technology that's less accurate for people with darker skin and questions that rely on data from credit bureaus. Black workers are less likely to have substantial credit histories on file, the report said.
Workers in Southern states face more hurdles
Broadly, workers in Southern states are far more likely than those in other regions to complain of discrimination, delayed payments, low payment levels and inadequate duration of payments, the report said. It cited racism and a 'lack of adequate support for social infrastructure' that may more prevalent in the South.
Among NELP's recommendations to bolster the system:

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Summer business travel is still on for many, but it might look different this year
Summer business travel is still on for many, but it might look different this year

Business Insider

time21 minutes ago

  • Business Insider

Summer business travel is still on for many, but it might look different this year

Just because some Americans are scaling back on their summer travel, it doesn't mean their employers are. Business travel demand has remained steady going into the summer season, several travel companies have said. Navan, which works with companies like Lyft, Shopify, and Box, found that summer business travel in 2025 is up by double digits compared to 2024, a representative for the company told Business Insider in May. Navan compared corporate travel bookings for the same group of companies over the same time period in 2024 and 2025 and found flight bookings were up 10% year-over-year, while hotel bookings were up 25%. The group included a mix of professional services, financial services, technology, and manufacturing firms, and ranged in size from small- and medium-sized businesses to public companies. TravelPerk, another travel-management company, found work trip bookings this summer were up 3% compared to last year. The company compared bookings for June, July, and August made by the same group of long-term TravelPerk customers in 2024 and 2025. "The month of June is the busiest month in the first half of the year, a key time for growth, industry events, and meaningful connections," Eugen Triebelhorn, a country manager at TravelPerk, said in an email. "Especially for sales teams, June is a strategic halftime for the year ahead of the quiet vacation period in July and August." Ariel Katen, consumer advocate and director of product at Engine, another corporate travel management platform, to BI last month that the company has found work travelers expect some changes to their trips this year. The company conducted a survey in April that found 71% of businesses expected to be affected in some way by shaky economic conditions, with 29% expecting increased scrutiny of travel expenses. That could mean cutting back on premium flight upgrades or booking more affordable hotels, she said. Engine has also found that a new batch of more affordable cities is becoming popular for corporate travel, including Charlotte, North Carolina, and Nashville, Tennessee. "If you had to get the entire team down somewhere, where are you going to find more affordable hotel rooms? Is that New York City or is that Tampa?" Katen said. Business travel had shown some signs of slowing earlier this year. Airlines Reporting Corp., which tracks agency bookings, reported a 6% decline in April for agencies focused on corporate or government travel. But several travel companies have recently reported an increase or a stabilization of corporate travel demand. Alaska Air Group, which includes Alaska Airlines and Hawaiian Airlines, said in late April that business travel demand had "stabilized" after a slowdown in February and March. "Total forward bookings are up low single digits, improved from where they seem to have bottomed out in March," Andrew Harrison, Alaska's chief commercial officer, said of corporate bookings during the first-quarter earnings call on April 24. Southwest Airlines said on its quarterly earnings call, also on April 24, that corporate travel demand had been "softer, but stable." American Express Global Business Travel, a travel management company, reported an increased demand for business travel on its quarterly earnings call in May, as did Choice Hotels, which includes brands like Radisson and Comfort Inn. The trends in business travel come as leisure travel demand has softened, fueled by economic uncertainty. Several airlines withdrew their outlook for the year, with United, Delta, and Southwest cutting back on routes or capacity, citing weaker demand.

We're saving almost enough in our 401(k) retirement plans. Here's the magic number.
We're saving almost enough in our 401(k) retirement plans. Here's the magic number.

USA Today

timean hour ago

  • USA Today

We're saving almost enough in our 401(k) retirement plans. Here's the magic number.

We're saving almost enough in our 401(k) retirement plans. Here's the magic number. Show Caption Hide Caption How are tariffs and your 401(k) retirement savings intertwined? Experts say a rise in tariffs can lead to several factors that impact your retirement savings. After years of fitful progress, Americans with 401(k) accounts are finally saving enough for retirement – almost. That's the takeaway from the latest retirement savings report from Fidelity, a leading plan manager. In the first three months of 2025, the total 401(k) savings rate on Fidelity plans reached 14.3%. That's an all-time high, and it approaches the 15% benchmark that many financial advisers set for optimal retirement savings. A decade ago, in the first quarter of 2015, employees contributed 8.1% of their pre-tax pay to 401(k) plans, according to Fidelity data. Employers kicked in 4.4% in matching contributions, for a total savings rate of 12.5%. In the first quarter of 2025, by contrast, employees saved 9.5% of their salaries, and employers matched 4.8%, for a total savings rate of 14.3%. How much should you contribute to a 401(k)? Retirement planners recommend a 15% contribution rate to 401(k) plans on this theory: If you save at least that much throughout your working years, you'll have enough to live comfortably in retirement. 'It's basically the rate that we recommend that will allow you to live the same lifestyle in retirement that you did before you retired,' said Mike Shamrell, vice president of thought leadership at Fidelity Investments. The gradual ramp-up in 401(k) contribution rates reflects several positive trends in the retirement savings industry, Shamrell said. The 4.8% employer match is an all-time high. Employers increasingly offer to match at least 5% of a worker's pay in 401(k) contributions, as a way to attract and retain good employees. A common formula matches the first 3% of salary dollar for dollar, and 50 cents on the dollar for the next 2%. 'That's basically free money for saving for retirement, and that is something that employees value,' said Mindy Yu, senior director of investing at Betterment, the online investment manager. Big 401(k) trends: Auto-enrollment, auto-escalation Another big trend to influence 401(k) contribution rates is auto-enrollment. Starting in 2025, most new 401(k) plans must automatically enroll employees, rather than leave the decision to workers. Many older 401(k) plans are voluntary, meaning that employees must sign up to participate. Under auto-enrollment, an employee who does nothing opts in. More than one-third of Fidelity plans now auto-enroll employees in 401(k)s at a contribution rate of 5% or higher. 'Unless a new hire takes action, they're going to be saving for the plan,' said Rob Austin, head of thought leadership at Alight Solutions, a human capital technology and services provider. 'That's much different than how 401(k)s first started, and you had to enroll on your own.' Another evolving feature allows employees to automatically increase 401(k) contributions from year to year. Nearly three-quarters of Fidelity plans now have an auto-escalation feature. Is retirement savings finally catching on? Retirement plan contributions are rising at a moment when tax-advantaged retirement savings seems to be catching on in the American workplace. Half of all private-sector workers now participate in 401(k)-type plans, up from about two-fifths of employees in 2010, federal data shows. Some retirement experts see 50% participation as a retirement-savings tipping point. More private-sector Americans are participating in 401(k) plans, at least in part, because more employers are offering them. Between 2014 and 2024, employee access to 401(k)-style plans rose from 60% to 70%, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. Those positive signs are important, retirement experts say, because many Americans fail to save for retirement. Wealthy workers amass more retirement savings The wealthiest Americans are the most likely to amass retirement savings. For households in the top 10% by income, the median retirement account held $559,000 in 2022, according to the federal Survey of Consumer Finances. An overwhelming 93% of those households held retirement accounts. For middle-income Americans, those in the 40th to 60th percentile by income, the median retirement plan held just $39,000, and nearly half of that group had no retirement accounts. Many smaller employers don't offer 401(k) plans. Nearly half of workers have no access to any retirement plan at work, according to an AARP analysis. Americans achieved a record rate of 401(k) savings at a time when their account balances were slipping. Average 401(k) balances fell by 3% from late 2024 through early 2025, to an average value of $127,100, Fidelity reports. The decline came during a span of market volatility as President Trump took office and launched a trade war. Gen Z has good retirement savings habits If 401(k) contribution rates continue to rise, investment experts say, one reason will be good savings habits among younger workers. The total 401(k) savings rate for Generation Z workers is 11.2%, Fidelity reports, not far behind the savings rates for Millennials (13.5%) and Generation X (15.4%). The savings rate for young adults is significant, because Gen Z is decades away from retirement. 'I think most of the newer, younger cohorts are in this environment where they learn that they need to be saving a lot,' Austin said. Younger workers know about the decline of pensions as a source of retirement income, and the possibility that Social Security will face a shortfall when they retire. 'Shortfall risk is very real,' Yu said. Younger workers are more likely than older workers to contribute to a Roth 401(k), Fidelity data shows. Those workers are effectively contributing at a higher rate, Austin said, because Roth contributions have already been taxed.

Donald Trump's Approval Rating Plunges With Millennials
Donald Trump's Approval Rating Plunges With Millennials

Newsweek

timean hour ago

  • Newsweek

Donald Trump's Approval Rating Plunges With Millennials

Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. President Donald Trump's approval rating has collapsed with millennials, according to a new poll. According to the latest YouGov/Economist poll, conducted between June 6-9 among 1,533 adults, Trump's approval rating among millennials sits at 40 percent, while 53 percent disapprove. That is down from the previous poll, conducted between May 30-June 2 among 1,610 adults, when 48 percent of millennials approved of Trump's job performance and 46 percent disapproved. Both polls had a margin of error of about +/- 3 percentage points. Why It Matters Millennials, typically defined as people born between 1981 and 1996, represent the largest bloc of the U.S. electorate. Trump had reduced the Democrats' lead among voters aged 30 to 44 by 9 points between 2020 and 2024, from 12 points to 3. The latest shift in poll numbers appears to be linked to Trump's deployment of the National Guard in Los Angeles following reported violence against law enforcement, specifically Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents carrying out deportation raids in the city. Local Democratic leaders had opposed the move, accusing the Republican president of fueling the disorder. What To Know Trump's slipping approval rating among millennials appears to be driven by growing discontent over his handling of key issues like the economy and immigration, according to new polling data. The latest YouGov/Economist survey shows that Trump's economic approval among millennials fell 5 points in the past week—from 43 percent to 38 percent. His rating on inflation and prices also declined, dropping from 39 percent to 33 percent. This marks a break from a broader trend of modest recovery in Trump's economic numbers, which had begun rebounding after a sharp dip in April caused by the announcement of his "Liberation Day" tariffs. That policy initially rattled financial markets, leading to a sell-off before stabilizing in subsequent weeks. However, millennials remain unconvinced. According to the poll, 45 percent of millennials now say they believe the economy is getting worse. The latest inflation data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics, released Wednesday, suggests that price growth remains under control. Both overall and core consumer prices rose just 0.1 percent in May—slower than in April. Year-over-year inflation ticked up slightly to 2.4 percent, but still came in below expectations. President Donald Trump speaks to reporters after arriving on Air Force One, Tuesday, June 10, 2025, at Joint Base Andrews, Md. President Donald Trump speaks to reporters after arriving on Air Force One, Tuesday, June 10, 2025, at Joint Base Andrews, Md. Alex Brandon/AP On immigration, Trump's support among millennials has also slipped, falling from 51 percent to 47 percent over the past week. The shift comes as Trump deployed the National Guard and later 700 Marines to Los Angeles, responding to reports of violence targeting law enforcement—particularly Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents carrying out deportation raids. California Governor Gavin Newsom and L.A. Mayor Karen Bass said state and local authorities could handle the situation without the National Guard, but Trump said he was reestablishing law and order after failures by local and state leadership. The move is part of Trump's pledge to carry out the largest mass deportation operation in U.S. history, which has included sweeping ICE raids nationwide. Protests have erupted in major cities including Los Angeles, New York, Atlanta, Dallas, and Washington, D.C., in response. Despite the backlash, polling shows Trump's tough-on-immigration stance is resonating with much of the electorate. In a striking reversal from his first term, Trump now holds a net-positive rating on immigration—a shift from -21 in June 2017 to +1 today—his largest net gain on any issue, according to CNN's Harry Enten. Millennials, however, appear less receptive. The YouGov/Economist poll found that 48 percent of millennials believe Trump's approach to immigration is too harsh. Experts say declining millennial support for Trump may reflect both unmet expectations and growing unease with his second-term policies. Thomas Gift, a political science professor at University College London, told Newsweek millennial voters may simply be "reverting to the mean in expressing more progressive positions on issues." He noted that while Trump made gains with millennial voters, "most favored [Democratic candidate Kamala] Harris on net." Gift added that many younger voters may now be feeling "buyer's remorse," as the president's promises of "sweeping national renewal, lower prices for everyday items, and an explosion in jobs" have gone largely unfulfilled. Lucas Walsh, a youth political behavior expert at Monash University, pointed to "a struggling economy, uncertainty and unrest on some university campuses and the chaotic world of the second Trump term" as key drivers. He told Newsweek that "uncertainty is a through line across these factors," and said a broader distrust in government—"preceding Trump but…inflamed by his intervention in California"—may be deepening youth disillusionment. Trump's overall approval rating slightly mirrors the downturn. The same poll found his approval rating has dropped to 43 percent (from 45 percent the previous week), while disapproval rose to 52 percent (up from 49 percent). In other polls, Trump's approval rating appears stable—or even improving. The latest ActiVote poll shows Trump with 46 percent approval and 50 percent disapproval, up slightly from 45–51 in May. This uptick breaks a steady monthly decline that had persisted since January. Notably, Trump's May numbers outperformed his own first-term average (41 percent) and surpassed Joe Biden's full-term average (41 percent) and final-year rating (40 percent). The ActiVote poll has a margin of error of ±4.4 points. The Trafalgar Group, in a poll conducted May 30–June 1, gave Trump a net approval of +8 (54 percent approve, 46 percent disapprove). That's up from 46–44 in an Insider Advantage survey conducted April 30–May 1. Newsweek's poll tracker also shows upward momentum: Trump's average approval stands at 48 percent, while 50 percent disapprove. A week ago, those numbers were 47–49; a month ago, 44–mid-50s. The latest Quantus Insights poll puts Trump at 49 percent approval—up one point from last month—with disapproval steady at 48 percent. In the most recent Morning Consult survey, Trump's approval rose to 47 percent (up from 46 percent the prior week), while 51 percent disapprove—for the third week in a row. The latest CBS/YouGov poll shows no change: 45 percent approve, while 55 percent disapprove—unchanged for the second consecutive month. What People Are Saying Thomas Gift, an associate professor of political science and director of the Centre on U.S. Politics at University College London, told Newsweek: "It's important to remember that while Trump made significant progress in courting young voters, most favored Harris on net. What we could be seeing is simply young people reverting to the mean in expressing more progressive positions on issues. "That's likely exacerbated by unfulfilled expectations. Trump promised sweeping national renewal, lower prices for everyday items, and an explosion in jobs from day one of him taking office. When those promises go unfilled, voters—including the under 30 crowd—will inevitably feel buyer's remorse." Lucas Walsh, a youth political behavior expert and a professor at Monash University in Australia, told Newsweek: "A combination of factors could explain the downturn in support. A struggling economy, uncertainty and unrest on some university campuses and the chaotic world of the second Trump term will be playing their part. Uncertainty is a through line across these factors as a major concern of young people (just like many older folk). "A second through line is a long term, declining distrust in governments in general. This precedes Trump, but might be inflamed by his intervention in California. We're seeing brute, masked forces taking people off the streets without due process, plus the additional federal intervention of the National Guard. "The youth vote has, to a limited extent, swayed more liberal on immigration in the past. But I wonder if more is going on here; namely, young people might be asking: "could this happen to me or someone I know?" What Happens Next Trump's approval rating among millennials could fluctuate in the coming weeks, depending on the outcome of key events, namely how expected upcoming demonstrations against ICE actions unfold in Los Angeles and in other major cities.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store