MI5 lied 'deliberately and repeatedly' in neo-Nazi spy case, BBC tells High Court
MI5 lied "deliberately and repeatedly" as it tried to defend its handling of a neo-Nazi agent who abused women, the BBC has told a panel of High Court judges.The corporation argued the threshold for contempt of court proceedings against MI5 and three individual officers had been met.Sir James Eadie KC, acting for MI5, issued an "unreserved apology" on behalf of the Security Service but said the "errors that had been made had not been deliberate".The three judges - England and Wales' most senior judge, Lady Chief Justice Baroness Sue Carr, President of the King's Bench Division Dame Victoria Sharp and Mr Justice Chamberlain - reserved judgement on the case until a later date.
The case, which began in 2022 with an attempt to block the BBC from publishing a story about the neo-Nazi agent, has become a major test of how the courts view MI5 and the credibility of its evidence.MI5 gave evidence to three courts, saying that it had never breached its core secrecy policy of neither confirming nor denying (NCND) that a man known only as X was a state agent.But in February, the BBC was able to prove with notes and recordings of phone calls with MI5 that this was false.An MI5 officer had confirmed the agent's status as he tried to persuade me to drop an investigation into X, a violent neo-Nazi misogynist who used his Security Service role to coerce and terrify his former girlfriend, known publicly as "Beth".At Tuesday's hearing MI5 acknowledged that the NCND policy could no longer be maintained in this case.This policy has meant significant amounts of evidence has been confined to closed hearings which neither the BBC nor Beth - who has brought a separate case complaining about MI5 - are permitted to attend.Charlotte Kilroy KC, representing Beth, said her client agreed with the BBC that the threshold for contempt of court proceedings had been met.
There had been "copious levels of dishonesty" which had not been acknowledged in MI5's investigations into how it came to give false evidence.The BBC's barrister, Jude Bunting KC, submitted to the court that it should consider contempt of court proceedings against MI5 itself, and three individual Security Service officers - including one who confirmed X's status as an agent on the phone to me and a senior officer known as Witness A who gave the false evidence to court.MI5's accounts of how it came to give false evidence "lack candour" and there is a "real concern" that the court has not been given a full explanation of what went wrong, Mr Bunting said.He said an external review by the government's former chief lawyer Sir Jonathan Jones KC did not speak to two crucial witnesses.Sir James Eadie KC, representing the Attorney General for the Security Service, offered an "unreserved apology on behalf of MI5"."Everyone from the director general downwards acknowledges the seriousness caused," he said.
MI5 director general Sir Ken McCallum immediately informed Home Secretary Yvette Cooper as soon as the matter was drawn to his attention, Sir James said.There has been "a full and comprehensive investigation" which came to the conclusion that "the errors that had been made had not been deliberate" and that "there had been no misleading or lying", MI5's barrister said.He said that contempt of court proceedings "would not be appropriate".
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
18 minutes ago
- BBC News
Ex-world darts champion Rob Cross banned as director over taxes
Former world darts champion Rob Cross has been disqualified from acting as a company director for five years after his business failed to pay more than £450,000 in Insolvency Service said it also found the darts player withdrew more than £300,000 from Rob Cross Darts Limited between 2020 and 2023 that should have gone to ban prevents him from being involved in the promotion, formation or management of a company, without the permission of the who previously lived in Hastings but was born in Pembury, Kent, has been contacted for a comment by the BBC. 'Directly impact funding' In an attempt to repay part of his debts, Cross has entered into an Individual Voluntary Arrangement, a legally binding agreement where he has committed to making regular payments to an insolvency practitioner. Rob Cross Darts Limited was set up in May 2017 for the darts player to receive his earnings and prize money, the government Insolvency Service said its investigations found the company received more than £1m from Mr Cross's earnings between the start of March 2020 and liquidation in November the time the company went into liquidation, it owed £403,896 in corporation tax, £49,071 in VAT and £12,436 in PAYE and National Insurance company had only paid £41,936 to HMRC between March 2020 and November 2023, the government said. Mr Cross's director's loan account was also overdrawn by £423,608 when the company went into liquidation with liabilities of £579, than £650,000 was also paid into the personal account of a connected party, the Insolvency Service Professional Darts Corporation (PDC) has also been contacted for a Read, chief investigator at the Insolvency Service, said: "When directors fail to pay the correct amount of tax, it directly impacts the government's ability to fund vital public services such as the NHS, schools, transport infrastructure and our national defence."
BBC News
28 minutes ago
- BBC News
Dad diagnosed with incurable lung cancer denied life-extending drug
A terminally ill father has said he was forced to pay privately for a potentially life-extending drug which could have given him an extra "invaluable" six months with his Maxwell, 41, was diagnosed with incurable lung cancer in July 2023 and has since raised £1.6m to support others with the drug, amivantamab - costing over £20,000 - is not yet approved in the UK, despite trial data suggesting users have a 50% better chance of halting the progression of the and Vale University Health Board said it "deeply sympathised" with Mr Maxwell, adding that "all requests" for funding are supported by the Individual Patient Funding Request (IPFR) panel. Mr Maxwell, from Penarth, is the former chief commercial officer for the Six Nations rugby tournament and Welsh Rugby Union's former head of he said he was "one of the lucky ones" to benefit from targeted therapy with minimal side effects, his cancer developed resistance, forcing him to undertake more toxic chemotherapy and the new drug is currently going through the NHS approval process in the UK, but Mr Maxwell said he could not wait "because my cancer is spreading".He applied to the IPFR panel for support in October, but was declined - he paid £20,000 himself for the first quarter of treatment."My results have come back and my cancer's stable and has stopped growing, which is fantastic news," he said. However, the panel recently rejected his application again. Mr Maxwell said: "They feel it's not making a considerable benefit to my quality of life versus the cost.""I've found that hard to accept, because in my position, six to nine months is invaluable."There's no cost you can put on that, to have six or nine months with my family."Mr Maxwell said some private donors had offered help, but he planned to go through the appeals process to overturn the decision."The IPFR panel exists to support patients like me in Wales," he added. Mr Maxwell has raised more than £1.6m to support the cancer pathway in Wales with his latest challenge, a 72-mile (115km) row from Tenby to Cardiff, taking place only a few weeks ago."We feel desperately strongly about supporting cancer pathway in Wales, regardless of what the funding decision is," he Maxwell said, despite the cost of the drug, he did not understand the reason for the panel's rejection."I understand the drug is very expensive," he said. "But is the best thing for me at the moment and it was recommended to me by multiple professionals." Mr Maxwell said he didnot think there is a crisis in cancer care for Welsh added that there "needs to be more" investment in the cancer pathway."It's made me realise how important fundraising is, not just for me, but for future patients."Mr Maxwell said his family are trying to enjoy and laugh together recognising that "staying close is important"."There have been some amazing moments and experiences throughout this journey and I have to savour them," he said. Cardiff and Vale University Health Board said it had "worked extensively" with Mr Maxwell to raise awareness of his condition."We are unable to comment further on individual patient cases," the health board added.
BBC News
28 minutes ago
- BBC News
No assurances over England number three
England selector Luke Wright stopped short of backing incumbent number three Ollie Pope after Jacob Bethell was included in the squad for the first Test against 21, returns after missing the defeat of Zimbabwe while at the Indian Premier League with Royal Challengers that match, Test captain Ben Stokes appeared to suggest Bethell would make an immediate return to the XI when available. After vice-captain Pope made a sparkling century at Trent Bridge, Stokes clarified that he was referring to Bethell returning to the squad and claimed his earlier comments had been "twisted to suit an agenda".Although Pope is still expected to retain his place at Headingley, Wright said: "We'll get together when we get up to Leeds and announce that two days out from the Test."We'll consider everything: conditions, what has gone before. All of those considerations go into the melting pot."Left-hander Bethell made three half-centuries in New Zealand at the end of last year, batting at number three after Pope slid down the order to stand in as he opted to miss the Zimbabwe Test in order to play at the IPL, he further impressed in the first one-day international against West Indies last week with 82 at the prospect of Bethell playing in the first Test, Wright said he is "very close".Wright added: "It's a great option to have. What a talent we all see in him. It's a great issue to have, to have that depth in the squad." Bethell could pressure opener Zak Crawley or frontline spinner Shoaib Bashir for a place in the XI but realistically it is a choice between the Warwickshire man and England all-rounder Wright rejected the suggestion that the lack of clarity around Bethell's position could unsettle the established members of the squad."Everyone knows before you go into any game there are always places up for grabs," said Wright. "I don't think anyone takes it for granted in international cricket. That's the way it always should be."You want a strong squad. They are all big lads who know what it is all about. There will always be speculation about what that XI will be. I'm sure the players will be very aware of what's going on and how it's going to look before that first Test."Elsewhere, Jamie Overton returns to the Test squad for the first time in three years, but Matthew Potts misses explained that England wanted the option of Overton's extra pace, while Potts had fallen behind Sam Cook in the role of Chris Woakes' new-ball was also confirmed that Jofra Archer is planning to play for Sussex in their County Championship match at Durham, beginning on 22 has not played red-ball cricket for more than four years because of a string of would have played for England Lions against India A at Northampton on Friday had it not been for a thumb he will look to play for the Sussex second XI, then the first team at Chester-le-Street, with a view to being available for the second or third Test against India.
