MBC leaders slam new quota, caste inaccuracies in Karnataka census
Terming the newly-introduced 1B reservation category 'unscientific, unjust, and politically motivated', speakers accused the Commission of bypassing academic and employment data and educational statistics to fabricate the category for political convenience. 'This is not social justice,' declared one speaker.
MBC nomadic communities demanded their own scientific subclassification.
Actor Chetan Ahimsa said that while the Karnataka Socio-Economic & Educational Survey (SES-2015) was billed as a tool for social justice, it is looking more like caste manipulation. Ahimsa pointed to the sudden formation of 1B category in April 2025, which grants 12 per cent reservation to 80 castes, including the Kuruba community, to which Chief Minister Siddaramaiah belongs. He questioned why castes previously under Groups 1 and 2A were reshuffled, and communities like Kurubas (formerly 2A) were placed with some of the state's most vulnerable, such as Devadasis and Hallaki Vokkaligas.
'The math doesn't add up,' he said. '1B has a population of 73.9 lakh, smaller than 2A's 77.7 lakh, yet gets 2 per cent more reservation. What justifies this?'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hans India
2 hours ago
- Hans India
CM Revanth Reddy lays stone for integrated Sub-Registrar Office in Hyderabad
Chief Minister Revanth Reddy has officially laid the foundation stone for a new Integrated Sub-Registrar Office in Gachibowli, Hyderabad. The construction, backed by a Rs 30 crore allocation from Aparna Construction under the Corporate Social Responsibility Budget, is set to proceed smoothly to enhance administrative efficiency and benefit the community. During the ceremony, CM Reddy highlighted Hyderabad's rich history, noting the contributions of the Nizam Nawabs and former Chief Ministers, like YS Rajasekhar Reddy, to the development of areas such as Madhapur, Kondapur, and Vatti Nagulapalli. He referenced landmark initiatives, including Rajiv Gandhi's introduction of computers to India and PV Narasimha Rao's establishment of a Special Economic Zone. The foundation for Hi-Tech City was reportedly laid by Nedurumalli Janardhan Reddy. Expressing concern about recent flooding, Reddy stated, 'Hyderabad is at risk of submerging even with light rains.' He called for extensive cleaning of the Musi River, arguing that maintaining a clean and developed city is essential for global recognition. 'If we want to compete with cities like New York and Tokyo, we must act decisively. The Musi should be revitalised, and we must create a thriving night economy along its banks,' he urged. Reddy acknowledged Hyderabad's growing reputation, declaring, 'We are now somewhat ruling America's Silicon Valley,' and emphasised the importance of developing Telangana into a three-trillion-dollar economy by 2047. He remarked on the registration department's significant income and called for a shift in public perception towards investors, urging that they should not be viewed as offenders. In outlining the plan for the new sub-registration offices, the Chief Minister announced they will be fully operational within eight months, offering a range of facilities. Currently, 19 lakh documents are processed annually across 144 sub-registration offices, which are well-regarded internationally. Reddy insisted all government departments must improve, aiming for Hyderabad to be viewed as a future city by 2034. He stated that 11 integrated offices should be operational by June 2nd, assuring the public that the construction will be completed within the stipulated timeframe.
New Indian Express
2 hours ago
- New Indian Express
K Chandrasekhar Rao, Harish ask Telangana HC to suspend report on KLIS
HYDERABAD: Former chief minister K Chandrasekhar Rao and former irrigation minister T Harish Rao have filed separate petitions in the Telangana High Court seeking suspension of the report submitted by the PC Ghose Commission of Inquiry on the Kaleshwaram Lift Irrigation Scheme. The two leaders urged the court to restrain the state government from acting on or implementing the report, which was submitted on July 31, 2025, by the Commission. The Congress government had set up the Commission to examine alleged negligence, irregularities and lapses in the planning, design and construction of the Medigadda, Annaram, and Sundilla barrages, which form part of the Kaleshwaram Project. The Commission was also directed to identify responsibility for the alleged lapses. In their petitions, KCR and Harish said the report contained adverse findings against them and was released to the public through a press conference and PowerPoint presentation on August 4, 2025, without giving them notice as required under the Commissions of Inquiry Act, 1952. They further alleged that the government had repeatedly publicised the report without supplying them a copy.
Indian Express
5 hours ago
- Indian Express
Karnataka govt clears 6:6:5 formula for Dalits' internal reservation after special Cabinet meeting
After a marathon special Cabinet meeting on Tuesday night, the Congress government in Karnataka arrived at a new formula to provide internal reservations for the Scheduled Caste (SC) community in jobs and education within the 17 per cent quota available to the 101 castes that fall under the category in the state. The Cabinet meeting headed by Chief Minister Siddaramaiah decided to uphold the recommendation of the Justice (retired) H N Nagamohan Das Commission to provide six per cent reservation to the most backward SCs categorised as the Dalit Left and comprising groups considered 'untouchables', like the Madigas. However, the Cabinet rejigged the quotas recommended for the Dalit Right group comprising communities like the Holeyas, who are more socially accepted, from the five per cent recommended by the Commission to six per cent. It has also done away with three sub-groups of 'touchable' castes and others, indicated by the Commission, and merged them with the 'touchable' group with five per cent quota. The 6:6:5 formula for the 17 per cent reservation is expected to be formally announced by Siddaramaiah on Wednesday during the ongoing Monsoon Session of the state legislature. The Chief Minister's Office (CMO) confirmed the new formula for internal quotas for SCs. On Tuesday night, Siddaramaiah was felicitated by Dalit Left groups for the Cabinet decision. They had been protesting over the last week seeking the implementation of the Justice Nagamohan Das Commission report. 'There will be a revolution if the internal quotas are not implemented. The government has to come up with some formula that is acceptable to all,' H Anjaneya, former minister and Dalit Left group leader, said on Tuesday ahead of the Cabinet meeting. The Congress party had promised to provide internal quotas for the SC community ahead of the 2023 state polls after Siddaramaiah had hesitated to implement internal quotas during his first tenure (2013-2018). The internal quota formulas, where the Dalit Left group got a larger share of the 17 per cent reservation, was opposed by politically stronger groups in the Congress, like the Dalit Right group which has prominent leaders like All India Congress Committee (AICC) president Mallikarjun Kharge and state Home Minister G Parameshwara. The touchable group has also opposed internal quotas. The delay in implementation of the internal quota system for Dalits had led to a freeze in government recruitments in Karnataka since October 2024. The decision to implement a new 6:6:5 quota plan is expected to restart the hiring process. The report on the social, economic, and educational situation of the SCs, prepared by a Commission headed by retired high court judge Justice H N Nagamohan Das, was presented to Siddaramaiah on August 4 and it was accepted by the government during a Cabinet meeting on August 7. A survey of SC subcastes, conducted on the recommendation of the Commission, found that the total SC population in Karnataka is 1,07,01,982. However, after removing the Budaga Jangam-Beda Jangam population (1,77,662) – regarding which there is a controversy due to a similar subcaste nomenclature among Lingayats – and the number of inter-caste married people who are not Scheduled Castes (14,449), the total population of SCs has been recorded as 1,05,09,871. As per the 2011 Census, the population of SC communities in Karnataka was 17 per cent (1.04 crore) of the total population (6.1 crore). The Commission recommended classifying the Dalit sub-castes into five categories, instead of the existing four, and to accord reservations according to their backwardness. 'Each category includes many castes. If the 17% reservation available for Scheduled Castes in the state of Karnataka is to be distributed to these categories, the reservation should be distributed according to their population,' the commission has stated in its report. 'However, if the reservation quota is distributed only according to population, the goal of social justice cannot be achieved. In addition to population, the reservation quota should be determined keeping in mind the educational, occupational, and social backwardness. It needs to be distributed,' the Commission stated in its report. The Commission recommended one per cent reservation to Category A, comprising 59 SC sub-castes with a population of 3.97 per cent; and six per cent for Category B (SC Left group), which is considered the most backward and constitutes 34.91 per cent of the SC population with 18 sub-castes. The Commission also recommended five per cent for Category C (SC Right group), who are considered less backward and politically established, and constitute 28.63 per cent of the SC population with 17 sub-castes; and four per cent for Category D (the 'touchables') who make up 26.97 per cent of SCs with four subcastes. A new Category E comprising 4.52 per cent of the SC population who have not been identified under a clear sub-caste but have been classified under three broad sub-groupings of Adi Dravida, Adi Andhra, and Adi Karnataka, has been recommended one per cent reservation. 'In the last 75 years, some Scheduled Castes have been empowered to some extent by enjoying reservation facilities. But the life of some people from these same Scheduled Castes is still miserable. The educational level of them and their children is very low,' the Commission noted. 'As a result, there is no higher education and no government jobs. The educational, occupational, and social backwardness of such castes should also be taken into consideration while distributing the amount of reservation,' the Commission stated. Further, it said that 'some castes that have received reservation facilities have seen educational, occupational, political, economic and social mobility. At the same time, some castes have not been able to get the benefit of reservation at all.' 'Understanding the situation, those who are better off have to make sacrifices for those who are less fortunate than them. The hungry should be fed first. Those who are well-fed should make some sacrifices. In accordance with this policy, the quota of reservation should be distributed on priority,' the Commission said, while justifying its division of the 17 per cent SC quota. Since the Karnataka government has halted recruitments in government services since October 2024 on account of the pending decision on internal quotas for SCs, the Commission said age relaxations should be extended to people from the SC community who have lost out on job opportunities in the last 10 months. In January 2025, the Karnataka government constituted the Justice Nagamohan Das Commission to study and submit a report on internal reservation for Scheduled Castes in the state. The Commission submitted an interim report on March 27 and requested a fresh survey of numbers due to the lack of accurate data. The door-to-door survey was conducted from May 5 to July 6, 2025. The survey covered 27,24,768 Scheduled Caste families and 1,07,01,982 people, the report said, noting poor response in urban areas. The survey also saw leaders of various SC communities directing community members to clearly state their sub-castes. As per the Supreme Court, classification of sub-castes can be done on the basis of educational backwardness, lack of representation in government employment, and social backwardness. The survey of sub-castes is part of the Congress government's efforts to fulfil an electoral promise to provide internal reservations for socially weaker sub-castes within the SC quota in the state. In Karnataka, the SC community is currently classified under four broad heads – the SC Left (the most backward like the Madigas who were considered untouchables in the caste system); the SC Right (like the Holeyas, who are less backward and accepted by other castes); the 'touchable' communities such as Banjaras and Bhovis (who are tribes in other states); and dozens of small communities who are classified as Others. The Dalit community has long demanded the caste survey to ascertain the numbers in each of the sub-castes to decide the division of quotas in government jobs, education, and political representation, which is now allegedly hogged by upwardly mobile social groups among the SCs like the Holeyas, and the Banjaras and Bhovis. The Justice Nagamohan Das Commission was set up by the Congress government after the previous BJP government (2019-2023) arrived at an ad hoc sub-quota number. During its tenure between 2019 and March 2023, the BJP government had enhanced SC quotas in the state from 15 per cent to 17 per cent in 2022, and announced internal reservation for SC communities in March 2023 by providing six per cent of the total of 17 per cent quota for the community to the SC Left group, 5.5 per cent to the SC Right group, 4.5 per cent to the touchables and one per cent to other SC groups. The BJP government fixed the internal quota on an ad hoc basis by considering the 2011 caste census numbers and by considering certain aspects of the 2012 Justice A J Sadashiva Commission report on internal quotas, while rejecting the Sadashiva Commission report itself. The most backward Dalit groups, like the Madigas, have been demanding the implementation of the Justice Sadashiva Commission report on account of the Commission recommending six per cent for the SC Left group, five per cent for the backward SC Right, three per cent for the 'touchable' group (Lambani, Bhovis, Korachas, Kormas), and one per cent for others. The Commission found that the majority of the reservation for the 101 sub-sects of Dalits in Karnataka was being cornered by the Dalit Right, including the Holeyas, and new SC groups like Bhovis and Lambanis, while the most backward groups, like the Madigas, remained deprived. The BJP's internal quota scheme backfired on the party to some extent, with the 'touchable' groups like the Bhovis and Banjaras expressing their displeasure against the party during the 2023 polls over the reduced internal quota of 4.5 per cent (against the previous 15 per cent) available to them. The BJP's scheme was, however, not implemented since the mandate for changing internal quotas was vested with the Union government at the time. In August 2024, a Supreme Court ruling said the granting of internal reservation is a constitutional measure and states can implement it on the basis of empirical data. While constituting the Justice Nagamohan Das Commission, the government felt that internal reservations for SCs based on population numbers – like in the Sadashiva Commission report – could possibly be struck down by courts for want of proper data as ordered by the Supreme Court. 'In the wake of three decades of continuous demands and pressure for internal reservation in the state, the Cabinet has agreed in principle to provide internal reservation for Scheduled Castes. There are 101 sub-castes…and the government has decided to take all of them into confidence and scientifically implement internal reservation,' Siddaramaiah said in 2024 when the Cabinet decided to set up the new Commission. The chief minister indicated that the Telangana government had already constituted a Commission along the same lines for the implementation of internal reservation, and that data is required for the scientific implementation of internal reservation as directed by the top court. Politically, the SC internal quota issue is a tricky subject for the Congress in Karnataka which has traditionally drawn its support from the SC Right group to which many of its prominent leaders belong. While the SC Left has supported the Congress in the past, many of these communities have moved towards the BJP in recent times on account of alleged neglect by the Congress in terms of political representation and opportunities. The most prominent SC Left leader in the Congress at present is K H Muniyappa, a seven-time MP and former Union minister. The SC Right group and the 'touchables', who have reportedly enjoyed the most access to the entire 15 per cent SC quota available in the state until now, are expected to resist any move by the Siddaramaiah-led Cabinet to divide the SC quota in the state since these two politically powerful groups will get reduced shares of five per cent and four per cent, respectively. Total population- 1,05,09,871 Total subcastes – 101 Total reservation – 17%
