Bihar SIR: survey of 338 migrant workers finds that over one-third of them do not have documents sought by EC
A phone survey of migrant workers from Bihar was conducted by the Stranded Workers Action Network (SWAN), a volunteer-driven initiative that was started in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic. SWAN, in a statement, said that the survey was conducted among 338 migrant workers from their database from July 19 to July 21 this year.
In the statement, SWAN said that even though their sample 'is not a statistically representative survey', 'the findings provide strong evidence of the challenges faced by migrant workers as those who migrate away from home are most susceptible to documentation deficits'.
The Election Commission (EC) is currently in the process of finishing the special intensive revision, which was announced last month, even as the State readies to go to polls no later than November this year. The EC requires that anyone not featuring in the 2003 electoral rolls must submit one of 11 documents such as birth certificate, school-leaving certificate, caste certificate, passport, etc. This list does not include documents like Aadhaar, voter id, or PAN cards, which are accepted while applying for most of the 11 prescribed documents.
SWAN said that it found that among the respondents, there were 248 individuals who were residing elsewhere. Of this, 75% 'had not even heard of the online portal to submit the enumeration form for SIR', adding that they found just two of these people had submitted the forms online. Further, it found that out of 333 respondents, 53% said that an official had visited their homes in Bihar for the SIR, 23% said no official had visited their homes, and about 24% said they were not aware if officials had visited their homes.
Even among those who reported that officials visited their homes, around 45% said that the officials collected the forms with a copy of their Aadhaar card or voter ID, and 29% reported that the forms were collected with one of the prescribed 11 documents.
The survey further reported finding that Aadhaar and voter id were the most commonly available documents with the respondents, with 96% reporting having an Aadhaar and 84% reporting having a voter id.
Among the respondents who did have one of the 11 prescribed documents, 46% reported having a matriculation certificate, 39% said they had caste certificates, 30% said they had domicile certificates and 39% reported having their birth certificates. The SWAN phone survey concluded that anyone having even one of these documents is likely to have a few more of the prescribed documents.
SWAN said the survey's findings 'establishes more evidence' that the SIR exercise in Bihar is 'mired in chaos'.
It went on to say, 'Contrary to official claims, the majority have not heard of the online system. Notwithstanding the impracticality of such a hasty exercise, the interaction with the migrant workers leads us to believe that SIR exercise will disenfranchise millions of people in Bihar. This further pushes us to suggest that the SIR exercise must be revoked without further delay.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
38 minutes ago
- Time of India
Monsoon session: Parliament proceedings washed out again amid opposition stir
NEW DELHI: Rajya Sabha and Lok Sabha proceedings were washed out on Friday, amid opposition's protest to demand a discussion on special intensive revision of Bihar's electoral rolls. In Rajya Sabha, deputy chairman Harivansh rejected 20 notices given by members seeking suspension of listed business to discuss on five issues, including the SIR exercise, saying it "appears that notices under Rule 267 are being used as a tool to create disorder in the House". His observations resulted in a uproar from opposition. He said 56.49 hours of the House's time has so far been lost. Rajya Sabha was adjourned for the day a little after noon amid opposition protest, which highlighted Congress's allegation of "vote chori" by "BJP-EC" in elections. TMC's Derek O'Brien said, "Today, on behalf of all of us, let's make a commitment that on Monday morning, we will submit 40 notices and all will be on SIR." CPM's John Brittas said Rule 267 should be scrapped, while Congress's Pramod Tiwari said discussion on the SIR issue should be taken up. In LS, opposition raised slogans against the SIR exercise. Some were seen banging the Speaker's table, which was strongly objected to by Krishna Prasad Tenneti, who was in the chair. "Yeh dhol nahi hai (this is not a drum). You cannot bang the table like this." the TDP MP said. Despite din, five questions and supplementaries were taken up during 23 minutes of the Question Hour. Finance minister Nirmala Sitharaman withdrew Income Tax Bill, 2025. A new version of the bill will be introduced in the Lok Sabha on Aug 11.
The Hindu
an hour ago
- The Hindu
CM seeks probe into unused ₹5,200 cr. during AAP govt.
The Hindu Bureau NEW DELHI Chief Minister Rekha Gupta on Friday accused the previous Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) government of having an 'anti-worker mindset' and demanded a probe into why ₹5,200 crore in the labour welfare fund was left unused while thousands of construction workers awaited essential benefits. Speaking in the Delhi Assembly, she urged that the matter be referred to the Public Accounts Committee (PAC) and called for strict action against all officials and ministers responsible for the lapse. 'The ₹5,200 crore remained idle while the working class waited for relief,' Ms. Gupta said during a discussion on the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) report for the year ending March 31, 2023, on the 'Welfare of Building and Other Construction Workers'. She alleged that despite workers' rightful access to welfare schemes, lakhs were deprived of entitlements. Assembly Speaker Vijender Gupta referred the report, along with two other CAG reports presented in the House on August 4, to the PAC. Fee imposed Ms. Gupta noted that while the Central government provides registration and renewal services for workers free of charge, the previous Delhi government imposed a ₹25 fee for registration and a ₹20 fee for renewal. 'This unnecessary burden led to a situation where only 7% of workers' data was renewed annually in Delhi, compared to 100% renewal at the national level,' she said. Quoting the CAG report, Ms. Gupta pointed out that funds earmarked for maternity benefits, disability support, tool purchases, housing assistance, family pensions, accident compensation, and skill development remained either unutilised or grossly underutilised for several years. AAP defense Responding to the criticism, AAP MLA Virendra Kadian accused the BJP of selectively quoting those paragraphs of the CAG report that criticised the previous government. He said the report covered a four-year period affected by the COVID-19 pandemic, during which many migrant workers had returned to their home States. He added that the Kejriwal government had provided ₹5,000 each in financial assistance to registered workers during the pandemic.
NDTV
an hour ago
- NDTV
"More Corrupt Than Lalu": Prashant Kishor's Jibe On BJP Leaders In Bihar
Patna: Jan Suraaj Party founder Prashant Kishor on Friday flagged "serious irregularities" in the health department of Bihar, a portfolio held by the BJP all through the NDA rule, and alleged that leaders of the saffron party in the state are "more corrupt" than RJD president Lalu Prasad. Addressing a press conference, Kishor launched a frontal attack on state Health Minister Mangal Pandey, who is also a former Bihar BJP president, accusing him of "quid pro quo" with current state unit chief Dilip Jaiswal, whom the Jan Suraaj Party founder has been targeting for some time. Kishor alleged that the health department had placed an order for '1,200 ambulances' priced at around Rs 28 lakh each, which was almost twice as what states like Odisha and Uttar Pradesh were paying. He also claimed that in the thick of the COVID-19 pandemic, Pandey had purchased a flat in Delhi in his wife's name and Jailswal helped him in the transaction. The BJP has rubbished the allegations. "Pandey showed his gratitude by granting the status of deemed university to a medical college in Kishanganj in which Jaiswal has huge stakes," said Kishor. "Jaiswal transferred Rs 25 lakh to the account of Pandey's father on August 6, 2019 and that money was used in the purchase of a flat in the name of the then health minister's wife. Jaiswal even signed as a witness in the document of the flat purchased in Delhi's Dwarka," he claimed. Even if Pandey borrowed this amount from Jaiswal, why did he not mention it in his election affidavit in the 2020 assembly polls in the category of unsecured loan, Kishor said. "BJP leaders in Bihar claim to be unblemished, but in reality they are more corrupt than even RJD president Lalu Prasad, whom they like to attack over conviction in fodder scam cases and alleged involvement in railway scams like land for hotels and land for jobs," he asserted. The former poll strategist said Chief Secretary designate Prataya Amrit, who was holding the crucial post in the health department when the contract for the ambulances was finalised, also 'needs to explain the reason behind finalising the deal to a particular firm at an exorbitant price'. The deal must have been finalised after his (Amrit) signature, he said. Pandey and Jaiswal were not available for comments. Reacting to Kishor's charges, Bihar BJP spokesperson Niraj Kumar told PTI, 'Whatever allegations he has levelled are baseless and far from reality. He is talking about Rs 25 lakh that Jaiswal ji gave to Mangal Pandey's father, which was in fact a loan and returned to the former. 'Second, he mentioned about the deemed university status granted to a medical college in Kishanganj by the then state health minister, which is also far from reality. It is the education department that grants deemed university status to a medical institute, and not the health department.' On 'irregularities' in the purchase of ambulances by the health department, Kumar said 'not even a single penny has been paid to the supplier by the health department'. 'The matter... pertaining to the quoted price of ambulances, is pending before the competent court. Kishor is simply levelling baseless charges for publicity,' he added. The Jan Suraaj party founder also raked up a recent Rajasthan court order in which another BJP leader and Bihar minister Jibesh Mishra was held guilty of involvement in manufacture of spurious medicine. "The BJP leader continues to be in the Nitish Kumar cabinet despite the opposition's demand that he be sacked or asked to resign in the wake up of the court order," Kishor said. The court has not awarded a prison sentence to the Bihar minister, but ruled that he be under probation for a certain period. Kishor also deplored the police action against students in Patna a day ago and claimed that the CM may be "unwell, physically and mentally". "I have had personal relations with him, yet a chief minister who lets boys be kicked by police personnel bearing heavy boots deserves no sympathy," he said. Kishor also demanded action against those involved in the assault on a Bihari labourer in BJP-ruled Haryana. "The labourer was mercilessly beaten by his employer in Haryana. His hands were amputated, and he is currently undergoing treatment at a hospital in Ambala. Why have the accused not been arrested by the Haryana Police so far?" he asked. PTI NAC PKD RBT
