Donated diesel generators lie idle at Wentworth Hospital
Image: File
More than 300 low-voltage diesel generators shipped from China are currently stored unused at a Durban hospital in KwaZulu-Natal, pending distribution to provinces.
This was revealed by Health Minister Aaron Motsoaledi when he was responding to parliamentary questions from Rise Mzansi leader and MP Songezo Zibi, who brought up concerns regarding the KwaZulu-Natal Department of Health seeking additional funding to procure new generators while the donated ones were disused.
The donated generators were part of the consignment received by Electricity and Energy Minister Kgosientsho Ramokgopa in November 2023 and August 2024 after they arrived at the Durban harbour.
They were meant to be used to alleviate the impacts of load shedding in the delivery of services in clinics, schools and courts whilst government continues to implement the Energy Action Plan.
Zibi noted that the KwaZulu-Natal Department of Health had received a donation of about 100 generators from the People's Republic of China to assist clinics and hospitals during inclement weather and loadshedding.
'The generators remain unused and stored at the Wentworth Hospital in Durban and noting that, amidst raising concerns about financial mismanagement,' he said.
Zibi also said the provincial department continued to seek additional funding to purchase new generators while the donated generators lay idle.
'What are the reasons that the donated generators have not been distributed and/or or utilised and is their total estimated monetary value,' he asked.
In his written response Motsoaledi said the KwaZulu-Natal Department of Health did not receive a donation of 100 generators of varying capacities from the People's Republic of China, but only 22 generators.
He said the donation was facilitated through a deal between the Ministry of the Department of Electricity and Energy and the People's Republic of China, with a total of 328 generators earmarked for the health sector inclusive of all provinces in the country.
'The reason why these generators were stored at Wentworth Hospital in KZN, was for convenience as the point of entry was the Durban harbour and the hospital provided the needed space for storage.'
Motsoaledi also said the generators have not been distributed to other provinces due to the size of generators donated from China, which was less than 6 KiloVolt-Amperes (KVA).
This was despite the minimum KVA requirement for a small size clinic being 20 KVA. 'The electrical engineers advised that these generators were not suitable for installation against existing electrical reticulation as they will immediately fail at commissioning,' he said.
Motsoaledi said the generators allocated to the health sector were estimated at R3,060,000 out of a total value of approximately R160 million for the generators donated by People's Republic of China for all sectors of government.
He confirmed that KwaZulu-Natal purchased 494 generators to the tune of R297,870,199 over the past three years.
'The purchasing of generators by the KZN Department of Health was necessary to respond to backup power needs at health facilities, especially with the ongoing loadshedding and load reduction measures being implemented by Eskom.
'The unused stock is meant to be used by other provinces, as the KZN Department of Health stock is not part of the generators stored at Wentworth Hospital,' he said, adding that KwaZulu-Natal allocated their allotment of 22 generators from the donation to their disaster management unit.
Motsoaledi stated that while the powers to institute any consequence management in the province rested with the Premier and the Heads of Department, none has taken place because no official ordered the specific generators.
'They were donated in kind,' he said.
'The national Department of Health is liaising with The Department of Electricity and Energy to facilitate a potential reallocation of the generators to a sector where they will be fit for purpose,' said Motsoaledi.
mayibongwe.maqhina@inl.co.za
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
11 hours ago
- IOL News
Donated diesel generators lie idle at Wentworth Hospital
Health Minister Aaron Motsoaledi says electrical engineers have advised that consignment of diesel-powered generators received by Minister of Electricity Kgosientsho Ramokgopa (pictured) were not suitable for installation against existing electrical reticulation as they will immediately fail at commissioning. Image: File More than 300 low-voltage diesel generators shipped from China are currently stored unused at a Durban hospital in KwaZulu-Natal, pending distribution to provinces. This was revealed by Health Minister Aaron Motsoaledi when he was responding to parliamentary questions from Rise Mzansi leader and MP Songezo Zibi, who brought up concerns regarding the KwaZulu-Natal Department of Health seeking additional funding to procure new generators while the donated ones were disused. The donated generators were part of the consignment received by Electricity and Energy Minister Kgosientsho Ramokgopa in November 2023 and August 2024 after they arrived at the Durban harbour. They were meant to be used to alleviate the impacts of load shedding in the delivery of services in clinics, schools and courts whilst government continues to implement the Energy Action Plan. Zibi noted that the KwaZulu-Natal Department of Health had received a donation of about 100 generators from the People's Republic of China to assist clinics and hospitals during inclement weather and loadshedding. 'The generators remain unused and stored at the Wentworth Hospital in Durban and noting that, amidst raising concerns about financial mismanagement,' he said. Zibi also said the provincial department continued to seek additional funding to purchase new generators while the donated generators lay idle. 'What are the reasons that the donated generators have not been distributed and/or or utilised and is their total estimated monetary value,' he asked. In his written response Motsoaledi said the KwaZulu-Natal Department of Health did not receive a donation of 100 generators of varying capacities from the People's Republic of China, but only 22 generators. He said the donation was facilitated through a deal between the Ministry of the Department of Electricity and Energy and the People's Republic of China, with a total of 328 generators earmarked for the health sector inclusive of all provinces in the country. 'The reason why these generators were stored at Wentworth Hospital in KZN, was for convenience as the point of entry was the Durban harbour and the hospital provided the needed space for storage.' Motsoaledi also said the generators have not been distributed to other provinces due to the size of generators donated from China, which was less than 6 KiloVolt-Amperes (KVA). This was despite the minimum KVA requirement for a small size clinic being 20 KVA. 'The electrical engineers advised that these generators were not suitable for installation against existing electrical reticulation as they will immediately fail at commissioning,' he said. Motsoaledi said the generators allocated to the health sector were estimated at R3,060,000 out of a total value of approximately R160 million for the generators donated by People's Republic of China for all sectors of government. He confirmed that KwaZulu-Natal purchased 494 generators to the tune of R297,870,199 over the past three years. 'The purchasing of generators by the KZN Department of Health was necessary to respond to backup power needs at health facilities, especially with the ongoing loadshedding and load reduction measures being implemented by Eskom. 'The unused stock is meant to be used by other provinces, as the KZN Department of Health stock is not part of the generators stored at Wentworth Hospital,' he said, adding that KwaZulu-Natal allocated their allotment of 22 generators from the donation to their disaster management unit. Motsoaledi stated that while the powers to institute any consequence management in the province rested with the Premier and the Heads of Department, none has taken place because no official ordered the specific generators. 'They were donated in kind,' he said. 'The national Department of Health is liaising with The Department of Electricity and Energy to facilitate a potential reallocation of the generators to a sector where they will be fit for purpose,' said Motsoaledi.
Mail & Guardian
3 days ago
- Mail & Guardian
Most people on ARVs stay on them. Does our health system know that?
How can data help the health department make the most of the R622 million extra it received for South Africa's HIV treatment programme? (Flickr) More than two weeks ago, Health Minister Aaron Motsoaledi About This extra budget is just over a fifth of the roughly So, how to get the best bang for these limited bucks — especially with the health department wanting to get By getting really serious about giving people more than one way of getting their repeat prescriptions for antiretroviral (ARV) medicine (so-called differentiated service delivery), said Kate Rees, co-chair of the A big part of South Africa's problem in getting 95% of people who know they have HIV on ARVs (the second target of the UN's 95-95-95 set of cascading goals) is that people — sometimes repeatedly — For the UN goals to be reached, South Africa needs to have 95% of people diagnosed with HIV, on treatment. Right now, the health department says, But the way many health facilities are run makes the system too rigid to accommodate real-life stop and start behaviour, says Rees. This not only means that extra time and money are spent every time someone seemingly drops out of line and then comes back in, but also makes people unwilling to get back on board because the process is so inconvenient and unwelcoming, she says. Rees and Wilkinson were co-authors of a Journal of the International Aids Society in 2024, of which the results helped the health department 'We often have excellent guidelines in place, built on solid scientific evidence,' says Rees, 'but they're not necessarily implemented well on the ground.' To make sure we track the second 95 of the UN goals accurately, we need a health system that acknowledges people will come late to collect their treatment and sometimes miss appointments. This doesn't necessarily mean they've stopped their treatment; rather that how they take and collect their treatment changes over time. The standard ways in which the public health system works mostly doesn't provide the type of support these patients need, as the resources required to provide such support is not available,' explains Yogan Pillay, the health department's former deputy director general for HIV and now the head of HIV delivery at the Gates Foundation. 'But with AI-supported digital health solutions and the high penetration of mobile phones, such support can now — and should be — be provided at low cost and without the need to hire additional human resources.' We dive into the numbers to see what the study showed — and what they can teach us about making the system for HIV treatment more flexible. Does late = stopped? Not necessarily. Data from three health facilities in Johannesburg that the researchers tracked, showed that of the 2 342 people who came back to care after missing a clinic appointment for collection medication or a health check, 72% — almost three-quarters — showed up within 28 days of the planned date. In fact, most (65%) weren't more than two weeks late. Of those who showed up at their clinic more than four weeks after they were due, 13% made it within 90 days (12 weeks). Only one in 14 people in the study came back later than this, a period by which the health department would have recorded them as The data for the study was collected in the second half of 2022, and at the time 'But it's important to distinguish between showing up late and interrupting treatment,' notes Rees. Just because someone was late for their appointment doesn't necessarily mean they stopped taking their medication. Many people in the study said they either still had pills on hand or managed to get some, despite not showing up for their schedule collection. Sending back a parcel of uncollected medicine after just two weeks — as was the case at the time of the study — would therefore add an unnecessary admin load and cost into the system. ( Does late = unwell? Not always. In fact, seven out of 10 people who collected their next batch of medication four weeks or more late had no worrying signs, such as possible symptoms of tuberculosis, high blood pressure, weight loss or a Moreover, given the large number of people without worrying health signs in the group for whom data was available, it's possible that many of those in the group with incomplete data were well too. When the researchers looked at the patients' last viral load results on file (some more than 12 months ago at the time of returning to the clinic), 71% had fewer than 1 000 copies/mL in their blood. A viral count of <1 000 copies/mL tells a health worker that the medicine is keeping most of the virus from replicating. It is usually a sign of someone being diligent about taking their pills and managing their condition well. Yet clinic staff often assume that people who collect their medicine late are not good at taking their pills regularly, and so they get routed to extra counselling about staying on the programme. 'Most people don't need more adherence counselling; they need more convenience,' says Rees. Offering services that aren't necessary because of an inflexible process wastes resources, she explains — something a system under pressure can ill afford. Says Rees: 'With funding in crisis, we really have to prioritise [where money is spent].' Does late = indifferent? Rarely. Close to three-quarters of people who turned up four weeks or more after their scheduled medicine collection date said they had missed their appointment because of travelling, work commitments or family obligations. Only about a quarter of the sample missed their appointment because they forgot, misplaced their clinic card or for some other reason that would suggest they weren't managing their condition well. Part of making cost-effective decisions about how to use budgets best is to offer differentiated care', meaning that 'not every patient coming back after a missed appointment is treated the same way', says Rees. Health workers should look at how much the appointment date was missed as well as a patient's health status to decide what service they need, she explains. Giving people who've been managing their condition well enough medicine to last them six months at a time can go a long way, Wilkinson told Bhekisisa 's Health Beat team According to the health department South Africa will start rolling out six-month dispensing in August. 'But not everyone wants this,' explained Wilkinson, pointing out that experiences from other countries show that 50% to 60% of people choose six-monthly pick-ups. It speaks to tailoring service delivery to patients' needs, says Rees, rather than enforcing a one-size-fits-all system when more than one size is needed. Says Rees: 'Facing funding constraints, we really need tailored service delivery to keep the [HIV treatment] programme where it is.' This story was produced by the . Sign up for the .
The Star
3 days ago
- The Star
National Health Minister calls for a shift in tobacco perception
The fight against tobacco is on, according to National Health Minister Doctor Aaron Motsoaledi. Speaking at the KwaZulu-Natal Doctors Healthcare 29th Annual Medical Conference in Durban recently, Motsoaledi said it was time governments viewed tobacco as a health issue and not an economic one, as ultimately it did more harm than good. He offered a global perspective, pointing to countries that had made strides in combating infectious diseases while failing to curb non-communicable diseases like cancer, diabetes, and heart disease. During his address to medical specialists, the minister said they all would concur that even at university exams, when one didn't know the answer to what the causes of a particular condition were, if they wrote down smoking, they had a chance of being correct and gaining a mark. He said a comprehensive Tobacco Bill would impact chronic condition numbers in South Africa and even lighten the load on our healthcare system as NHI gets underway. The medical conference also recognised outstanding medical professionals. Among the award winners were specialists from Lenmed: Ethekwini Hospital and Heart Centre, who were acknowledged for their TAVI (Transcatheter Aortic Valve Implantation) programme.
