S&P Global revises South Africa's growth forecast down but remains optimistic on reforms
Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana will table the National Budget Review for the third attempt in Parliament on Wednesday after tensions within the Government of National Unity coalition over an increase in value-added tax (VAT) rates led to the budget being amended and re-tabled three times.
Image: File
S&P Global Ratings has lowered its economic growth forecast for South Africa while expressing cautious optimism regarding the country's reform initiatives and efforts towards fiscal consolidation, even amid ongoing tensions within the coalition government.
This comes as the government has launched the second phase of "Operation Vulindlela," which goes beyond improving energy and infrastructure to address local government issues and enhance digitalization of the economy.
The ratings agency on Friday maintained South Africa's subinvestment status, affirming the country's long term foreign and local currency debt ratings at 'BB-' and 'BB', respectively, with a positive outlook.
S&P said the positive outlook reflected the potential for stronger growth than it currently expected, despite trade- and tariff-related headwinds, alongside government debt consolidation, 'if the coalition government can accelerate economic and fiscal reforms while addressing infrastructure pressures'.
It added that the ratings on South Africa benefited from the country's sizable and sophisticated financial system that provides a deep funding base for the government.
S&P said the country also has relatively strong institutions, with good checks and balances, particularly its central bank, the South African Reserve Bank (SARB).
However, the ratings were constrained by relatively low gross domestic product (GDP) per capita and low GDP growth rates, as well as sizable fiscal deficits and high government debt.
Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana will table the National Budget Review for the third attempt in Parliament on Wednesday after tensions within the Government of National Unity coalition over an increase in value-added tax (VAT) rates led to the budget being amended and re-tabled three times.
However, S&P said the budget was likely to be passed without the earlier planned increase in the VAT rate, as well as with broadly commensurate cuts to departmental expenditure allocations, which will counterbalance the loss of the planned VAT revenue increase.
'Overall, over the medium term, we expect the government to continue efforts toward its planned fiscal consolidation, though downside risks to implementation remain,' S&P said.
S&P is now expecting South Africa's GDP growth to rise to an average of 1.5% over 2025-2028 after a subdued 0.6% in 2024, but cautioned that ongoing logistical bottlenecks and global tariff-related pressures will constrain economic activity.
'We expect real GDP growth to pick up slightly to 1.3% this year from 0.6% in fiscal 2024, as more private sector-driven electricity supply comes onstream, and last year's drought was not repeated. But growth will be limited by potential US tariffs and global tariff-related risks, both via direct and secondary effects such as slowing demand from China for key commodities,' it said.
'We forecast a slight rebound in growth from 2024 levels (but lower than our November forecast) of 1.5% on average over fiscal 2026-2028, partly supported by likely lower interest rates, as well as the recent establishment of a two-pot retirement system that allows people to partially withdraw funds from their retirement accounts, which could boost consumption.'
Despite this, S&P is forecasting gross general government debt to remain high, averaging 80% of GDP in fiscal 2025-2028, higher than the National Treasury's estimate of an all-time high of 76.2% of GDP in 2025/26.
In response to the S&P rating, the National Treasury said it was committed to a balanced fiscal strategy.
'Government's growth strategy will continue to focus on maintaining macroeconomic stability to reduce living costs and grow investment, executing reforms to promote a more dynamic economy, building state capability in core functions and supporting growth-enhancing public infrastructure investment.
'The fiscal strategy continues to strike a balance between stabilising the public finances, reducing risks in the fiscal framework, encouraging economic growth and supporting low income and vulnerable households.'
BUSINESS REPORT
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The South African
an hour ago
- The South African
3 pieces of GOOD news for the South African taxi industry
There have been three major developments in the South African taxi industry in recent weeks. Firstly, government announced it will scrap nearly 2 000 illegal/unroadworthy minibus taxis. Likewise, there is a directive to convert approximately 400 vehicles to alternative fuels, too. This progress in the South African taxi industry is all part of a 'Taxi Recapitalisation Plan' that was presented in parliament last month (Tuesday 20 May 2025). As such, government's broader mandate is to finally modernise the industry through various projects. In time, these vital industry reforms will translate into savings for the end user. Image: File Like them or loathe them, the South African taxi industry is the lifeblood of the country's economy. More than two thirds (66%) of the nation relies on public transport to get to and from work each day. As such, another piece of good news is that the South African National Taxi Council (SANTACO) won't raise fares this month. When the Minister of Finance Enoch Godongwana hiked the General Fuel Levy (GFL) for the first time in three years, it was widely anticipated that taxi fares would increase in June 2025. This would add yet more financial pressure to the country's poor. Effective from this month, the GFL increased by 16c per litre and 15c per litre for petrol and diesel respectively. As a result, the total cost of GFL is R4.01 per litre for petrol and R3.85 per litre for diesel. That taxi fares are unmoved is a remarkable turn of events when you remember that the Carbon Levy increased by 3c per litre back in April, too. We're not there yet, but cleaner, greener and safer, is what the future of the South African taxi industry is all about. Image: File Furthermore, new Liquid Petroleum Gas (LPG) conversions will lower the cost of fuel for taxis by as much 35%, reports BusinessTech . The department says LPG is the most viable alternative fuel because of the ease of conversion for minibus taxis. Better still, LPG runs cleaner, providing a longer engine lifespan and less maintenance. The option of dual systems is also viable for long-range commutes. At last count, the department says only seven taxis have converted as part of the LPG pilot project. It hopes to install 400 conversion kits. Finally, stakeholders in the South African taxi industry are once again encouraged to take advantage of the Taxi Recapitalisation Projects (TRP). Government says voluntarily surrendered unroadworthy minibus taxis will be scrapped free of charge. And owners/operators will gain access to an allowance which they can recapitalise on a new taxi. The department believes there are as many as 2 350 illegal/unroadworthy taxis still operating in South Africa. Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1. Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X and Bluesky for the latest news.
The Herald
4 hours ago
- The Herald
Godongwana declares contentious Budget the new normal as parly adopts fiscal framework
While finance minister Enoch Godongwana did not run this past weekend's Comrades marathon, his 2025 Budget finally reached the last mile of its race for adoption, after three lockups, two tablings and a court challenge. The National Assembly voted to adopt the 2025 fiscal framework and revenue proposals as well as the committee report thereof on Wednesday afternoon, with 268 voting in favour of the adoption, 88 voting against the adoption, and two abstentions. Godongwana told the National Assembly sitting that he suspected that over the next four years, the management of the Budget as well as the fiscal framework would be similar to how it was handled this year. 'We have had a painful journey to arrive at this date, where the fiscal framework is being approved. It has been a very painful journey. Definitely, from the Treasury perspective, we've drawn a number of lessons, but I suspect, also members of this house, must draw a number of lessons as to how, in practice, are we going to manage the debates around the fiscal framework moving forward?' Parliament's February sitting to table the Budget was postponed over resistance at a cabinet level to a VAT hike proposal. Godongwana returned to parliament in March with a revised VAT hike proposal, and the fiscal framework was challenged in court. He finally tabled a Budget in May with a fuel levy hike in place of the scrapped VAT hike. He challenged the assertion that his 2025 Budget was an austerity budget. 'This budget is not austerity. We are increasing taxes, not to focus on debt, but to focus on funding social services. Education, health and so on.' ANC MP and standing committee on finance chair Joe Maswanganyi moved for the adoption of the fiscal framework and revenue proposals report, saying that processing a budget within a coalition government can be complex due to the competing interests involved. In Godongwana's defence, Maswanganyi said anyone calling for Godongwana's head was out of tune with the realities facing coalition governments around the world. 'Considering these realities, particularly the tariffs and trade tensions initiated by the US , it is prudent to pay attention to the five-year plan ... This is not an austerity budget. The Budget has garnered praise for being pro-poor and pro-growth.' He said stakeholders welcomed the scrapping of the proposed VAT hike ahead of its effective day of May 1, but raised concerns over the financial impact of the fuel levy hike on business as well as middle-to-low-income households around the country. MK Party MP and former finance minister Des van Rooyen said his party rejected the committee's report on the 2025 budget as a 'sell-out pact' led by the parties that came together to form the government of national unity after last year's election. 'It is in this report that the ANC, DA, IFP, FF Plus, Action SA, and other GNU beneficiaries agreed that the majority of our people should be subjected to the fuel levy hikes and personal income tax. Think-tanks are in agreement that the fuel levy is the most regressive tax: even worse than VAT.' South Africans will pay more for work, school and travel expenses, and the buying power of people's income will be whittled away due to bracket creep. He said the report sought to protect the interests of a wealthy few. DA MP Wendy Alexander said for the first time in years, the budget process included ordinary South Africans rather than being rubber-stamped by a legislature where the ANC enjoyed a strong majority. She called the scrapping of the VAT hike a victory for democracy and South Africans. 'When citizens watch, comment and engage the budget process, the democracy grows, and this is precisely what the constitution envisioned — a government accountable to the people and not the other way around.' She said the GNU must prove that government can function across spheres when the stakes demand it. She said the projected 77% debt-to-GDP ratio was unsustainable and that the country could not be expected to build more schools and hospitals on the back of untenable debt levels. EFF MP Omphile Maotwe said her party rejected the fiscal framework and revenue proposal report as a project which would condemn South Africans to considerable tax burdens, courtesy of the 'former liberation movement', the ANC. 'It took the EFF to approach the Western Cape High Court to stop the VAT increase. If it were not for the EFF South Africans would already be paying 15.5% VAT today. The people of South Africa know now without any doubt that the EFF is the only dependable tool in the hands of the poor and the working class.' She said the fuel levy increase was an attack on motorists, the poor and the working class, who were already facing rising costs before the proposal was tabled. IFP MP Nhlanhla Hadebe said his party accepted the report. Supporting the report, Patriotic Alliance MP Ashley Sauls said the 2025 budget process tested the GNU's resolve as the government remained intact through an ordeal that has collapsed coalition governments elsewhere in the world. Freedom Front Plus MP Wouter Wessels pointed out that MPs calling for a wealth tax were calling for a deeper tax on themselves and their steep salaries. He said a credible budget was one where every rand and cent was channelled towards the benefit of ordinary South Africans. Action SA Alan Beasley said his party was among the first to oppose the proposed VAT hike, saying it was immoral to ask the poor to pay more for essentials while corruption goes unchecked. 'We welcome the minister's decision to scrap the VAT increase and are proud of the role we played in securing this outcome. We also welcome the R7.5bn n allocated to Sars over the medium term, an investment ActionSA championed.' He said that while Action SA rejected the R22bn raised through regressive taxes like fuel levy hikes and bracket creep, strengthening Sars is essential. 'Properly funded, Sars can close the tax gap, tackle illicit trade and boost revenue collection by a conservative R50bn annually. We are encouraged that the minister has committed to monitoring Sars's performance and will provide tax relief in next year's budget if revenue exceeds targets.' ACDP MP Steve Swart said the National Treasury should produce the fuel levy review that was promised to the legislature. He said while the ACDP believed in miracles, it appeared to be a remote possibility that South Africa's GDP would grow well beyond 2% in the coming years. UDM MP Nqabayomzi Kwankwa said the fuel levy was worse than VAT as there was no way of mitigating its regressive impact on low-income households, and anyone who considered the scrapping of VAT a victory for these households was being 'hypocritical'. Supporting the report, RISE Mzansi MP Songezo Zibi said the national balance sheet remained unsustainable as over 80% of the revenue collected by the SA Revenue Service (Sars) pays for over R820bn in salaries, R420bn in debt service costs and R440bn a year to the social security package. 'That leaves very little money to invest in the things we need to unlock economic growth and create sustainable jobs. [Dated] national and local infrastructure continues to choke our economy, together with policy assumptions that still assume we live in the 1960s.' BOSA MP Mmusi Maimane said one of the grimmest realities in the Budget's fiscal framework was that the rate of investment remained low, leaving the government with little funding for its spending programmes. 'I fear it is a missed opportunity for us to really speak about reform. The question we should be obsessed about is not just GDP growth or actually looking at debt. It should be the rate of investment in this country. And on the same budget, it proposes that our rate of investment is at 4.2%.' TimesLIVE
IOL News
5 hours ago
- IOL News
South African ministers spend over R200 million on travel in a time of crisis
Deputy President Paul Mashatile's trip to Japan trip has sparked debate over the R900,000 accommodation costs which has drawn scrutiny amid rising concerns over government travel spending. "A DISTURBING pattern of unchecked luxury", is what ActionSA accused the ministers in the Government of National Unity for having spent over R200 million on travel since stepping into office a year ago. The party was reacting to supposed spurge of the government officials in question, having considered data provided by the party's GNU Performance Tracker, based on replies to parliamentary questions. The questions were posed to all ministers - including President Cyril Ramaphosa, Deputy President Paul Mashatile, and the Minister of Sport, Arts and Culture, Gayton McKenzie, who emerged as the big hitters. "This paints a damning picture of executive indulgence at a time of deep economic crisis,' ActionSA said in a statement, calling the trend 'a disturbing pattern of unchecked luxury and weak oversight.' At the centre of the controversy is Mashatile, whose office confirmed spending over R2 million on transport and accommodation for official duties. Four international trips undertaken on behalf of Ramaphosa have cost the state more than R7.9 million, including visits to Ireland, the UK, Botswana, Zimbabwe, and Japan. One trip, a four-night visit to Tokyo in March 2025, drew particular criticism after it was revealed that accommodation alone cost more than R900,000 - approximately R225 000 a day. McKenzie and his department have spent around R6.6 million on international travel, including a R164,556 payment for a cancelled trip to Burkina Faso, raising questions about financial oversight. Amid ongoing public debate, IOL News compiled a detailed breakdown of luxury hotel costs in Tokyo. While the R900,000 figure raised eyebrows, analysis suggests such expenses are possible in one of the world's most expensive cities, especially when top-tier hotels and executive suites are involved. However, the costs have fuelled public concern over whether officials are appropriately balancing international representation with fiscal responsibility.
