Labour Slams 'Big Tax Breaks' For Tech Giants As Government Ditches Digital Levy
The government has confirmed it is removing the bill from its legislative agenda. It would have imposed a 3 percent tax on digital services for New Zealand users starting in January this year.
Chris Hipkins told reporters at Parliament scrapping it would not have been a priority or the savings from pay equity claims in a Labour Budget.
"We already know where some of that money's going - it's going to tax cuts for landlords, tax breaks for tobacco companies; just today we found out it's hundreds of millions of dollars are going to tax breaks for multinational tech firms like Google and Facebook."
Labour, using forecasts from the Half-Year Economic and Fiscal Update in December, calculated the tax would have brought in about $479m over the next four years - starting from January 2026 - and $146m a year after that.
"Frankly, paying Kiwi women properly would be my priority," Hipkins said. "I think this government should stand up to New Zealand - I don't think giving big tax breaks to Google and Facebook is how we should be trying to ingratiate ourselves with Donald Trump's administration."
Revenue Minister Simon Watts, announcing the move in a statement on Tuesday, said the previous Labour government had introduced the bill in 2023 because of a perceived lack of progress from other countries in developing a similar measure - but the situation had since changed.
"A global solution has always been our preferred option, and we have been encouraged by the recent commitment of countries to the OECD work in this area," he said.
"New Zealand has long supported, and benefited from, collective action and the global rules-based system. By focusing on a global solution, it will enable an agreed, consistent outcome across participating countries."
Watts said a multi-lateral process would be a more enduring model.
"Our assessment is, is there a better process to deal with the underlying challenge out there, and as a basis we've made a decision to take away the DST Bill that was put on the order paper."
He said Inland Revenue remained focused on compliance and integrity, including for offshore customers.
Hipkins however said he had seen "no evidence whatsoever that there's going to be an international solution to that".
"Frankly it's not right that Google, Facebook and other big tech companies aren't paying their fair share of tax whilst other New Zealanders are being asked to pay more, and low-paid Kiwi women are basically being told that they're not going to be paid fairly."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Newsroom
an hour ago
- Newsroom
Online radicalisation and foreign interference among rising threats to NZ
Young New Zealanders are at growing risk of being radicalised online, according to a new report from one of the country's spy agencies that also highlights a rise in foreign interference activities against a background of global instability. In its latest security threat environment report, the NZ Security Intelligence Service (NZSIS) warns the country faces 'the most challenging national security environment of recent times', with increasingly unstable relationships between states as well as rising levels of polarisation and grievance. The report says there has been 'a noticeable increase' in foreign interference actors visiting the country in the last 18 months, highly likely to have asked to build relationships with specific parts of New Zealand society and conceal their links to foreign states. China is singled out as the most active nation undertaking foreign interference in New Zealand (although not the only one), with a section on the country's United Front Work Department and its efforts to build influence with individuals and organisations in countries like New Zealand. 'It is important to acknowledge that not all [United Front] activity is foreign interference and some engagements can have benefits for New Zealand organisations. However, its activities are regularly deceptive, coercive and corruptive and come with risks for New Zealand organisations.' The security report emphasises concerns about transnational repression, saying some New Zealanders are being targeted by foreign states in a bid to keep diaspora communities politically loyal even though they live in another country. The agency says it is aware of 'co-optees' monitoring social media, photographing individuals at events, or instructing other community members to collect information on behalf of foreign states, with the risk that such information could be used to coerce the person being monitored or their family back home. In one case, a foreign state asked a co-optee to collect information on a New Zealand-based person who had applied for refugee status – 'almost certainly' because they were a member of the rainbow community. The report also says it is aware of foreign intelligence officers who have travelled to New Zealand to likely support 'coercive repatriation' of people back to their country of origin. Though it does not name any states, Newsroom has previously reported on China's efforts to force alleged criminals to return from countries including New Zealand. Foreign agents have been taking control of community organisations by co-opting or replacing leaders, with the replacements sidelining those deemed to be a challenge to the foreign state's agenda and sometimes restricting government officials from speaking to the wider community. In one case, a New Zealand official who wanted to share 'important security advice' with a community was discouraged from doing so by a community leader (also a government employee) who had undertaken activity in support of a foreign state's objectives: 'Even though the intent of the security advice was to raise awareness of risks, the gatekeeper likely thought it was against the interests of a particular foreign state.' The report also raises concerns about increasingly polarised and violent rhetoric both in the real world and online, including 'a notable degree of misplaced agitation and blame for perceived societal ills' at the fringes. 'Much of this rhetoric exists solely online, and its spread is aided by algorithms that push controversial content because it generates the most engagement.' The NZ Security Intelligence Service says it has not seen any sophisticated state-backed information operations directly targeting New Zealand, but believes New Zealanders 'have almost certainly consumed foreign state-manipulated information when active online, even if they are not the target audience of that information'. Young and vulnerable Kiwis were particularly at risk of being radicalised online, with teenagers increasingly coming to the attention of security services as unfettered internet access shortened pathways to violence. 'What might have previously been considered societal risks associated with internet safety, now have the potential to pose an ongoing risk to New Zealand's national security.' In an interview with Newsroom, NZSIS director-general Andrew Hampton said the report was not intended to alarm people, but to raise public awareness about the growing threats. 'We certainly don't want to cause despair or anxiety. I actually believe that in a democracy like ours, the public are often those who are best placed to actually see concerning behaviours, report them and take steps to mitigate them.' Although much of the activity outlined in the report was not currently illegal, Hampton said the Government's foreign interference legislation – which is yet to pass its second reading in Parliament – would allow police to take action and give communities a clearer demonstration of what activities were unacceptable in New Zealand, acting as a deterrent to foreign states and the 'sympathetic individuals' they co-opted. Asked how the public should reconcile China's status as both New Zealand's largest trading partner and the most active state carrying out foreign interference here, he said the spy agency was well aware that our country's prosperity relied on its international and trade connections. 'We are not saying don't engage, and we're certainly not saying don't engage with China: what we are saying, though, is be cognisant of the risks that are associated with some of that engagement.' On the issue of young New Zealanders being radicalised, Hampton said questions around greater regulation of internet access – such as a social media ban for under-16s as suggested by Prime Minister Christopher Luxon and others – was for politicians and Parliament, but the agency wanted to draw attention to increased online engagement with grievance-based narratives. 'If you look at our current subjects of investigations – we're not talking about large numbers of people here – they're almost all young, in their teens or early 20s, they aren't part of global terrorist networks, they are people who have been largely radicalised online.' The spy agency had been speaking to school principals and other educators about what online radicalisation looked like, and had received leads as a result of that work.
NZ Herald
2 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Student loan debt hits $16 billion, most overseas borrowers aren't paying it back on time
There are Kiwi expats who took out loans as young students, often only 18 years old, and who did not understand the responsibilities and obligations, one tax barrister believes. As the debt mounts with interest, some will bury their heads in the sand. Others had settled in new home countries and forgotten they even had the debt, he says. Dave Ananth, special counsel at law firm Stace Hammond, says he has had clients so distressed by out-of-control debt, they became suicidal or had their marriages break apart – 'I've heard it many times.' Breakdown of who owes what and who's falling behind At the end of March, there were 626,728 borrowers with a student loan. More than 18% of those borrowers have overdue payments, amounting to 116,286 people. And most of those with overdue payments are overseas. More than $4b has been lent to Kiwis now overseas, and nearly $12b has been lent to New Zealanders still in the country, making the total balance just over $16b. Just over 18% of student loan debtors are abroad, with 114,347 overseas-based borrowers listed in the latest dataset from the Inland Revenue Department (IRD). Of those, 85,911 were overdue on repayments. This means more than 75% of overseas-based borrowers have overdue payments. And those tens of thousands of overseas debtors collectively owe repayments worth $2.3b, meaning they hold 92% of the overdue student loan balance. A breakdown of overdue loan repayments splits the debt between penalties and interest, and the principal loan. And more than half of overseas-based borrowers' debt is just interest and penalties: $1b worth of interest and penalties, and $1.3b of assessed principal. New Zealand-based debtors, meanwhile, are overdue on $18 million, 7% of the total $2.5b worth of overdue payments. And of the 512,381 borrowers in the country, 30,375, or 26%, had overdue payments. About 39% of domestic-based borrowers' debt is made up of penalties and interest. How do loan repayments work while overseas? Anyone outside New Zealand for more than six months is categorised as overseas-based. Interest will be charged on the loan from the day the borrower leaves the country. And loan repayments from overseas-based borrowers are based on the loan balance at the time the borrower left the country. In the year to April 2026, the annual interest rate was 4.9%. A late payment interest rate, applied to the outstanding payment for every day it goes unpaid, is set at 8.9%. Rates are set every April. Minimum annual repayments are set progressively, so borrowers with a balance of between $1000 and $15,000 must repay $1000; a balance of up to $30,000 will see $2000 required in repayments; up to $45,000 will require $3000; up to $60,000 requires $4000, and any loan over $60,000 will need $5000 worth of repayments. There are several reasons the IRD would consider keeping a loan interest-free while the borrower is overseas. Borrowers can apply through their MyIR account online and will need to provide evidence of their situation. The IRD did not respond to a request for comment, instead pointing the Herald to information available on its website. 'I'm scared of opening IRD letters': Kiwi expat A 29-year-old Kiwi expat in Berlin, Germany told the Herald the weight of his loan repayments was difficult to handle while he was doing odd jobs on his overseas experience (OE). 'I'm scared of opening the online letters from IRD to see how much I owe on my student loan while overseas,' the man, who wanted to remain anonymous, said. 'It's stressful enough having to learn a new language and find a job in a foreign country, let alone leaving your home and familiarity. 'Obviously, student loans should be paid back – and mine will be repaid as my income returns to normal.' A 49-year-old woman was arrested last Monday while trying to leave the country at Christchurch International Airport. Te Amo Matangi, who has called Australia home for the last 21 years, had a balance of $13,000 balloon to $58,000 in interest and penalties. As she tried leaving the country, a ticket scan triggered an alert and a police officer seized her passport, informed her she had a warrant out for her arrest then took her into custody. 'I don't think that I needed to be put in jail, and that's what the police officers were reiterating as well,' Matangi said. 'I just feel like [the IRD] is really trying to make a statement.' She urged other Kiwis living overseas to take the time with the IRD in order to not make the same mistake. IRD says crackdown is changing borrowers' attitudes The coalition Government poured $29m a year into the IRD for compliance and collection work in Budget 2024. In this year's Budget, the Government allocated a further $35m for compliance and collection. The IRD says this funding has driven its jump in collecting repayments from overseas-based borrowers. In the nine months from July last year, the IRD collected $207m from overseas debtors. That figure was 43% higher than the amount collected in the same period the previous year. 'As a result of the work we've been doing, we're also starting to see a more positive attitude by new borrowers, most of whom are meeting their payment obligations,' the IRD said. The IRD's customer segment lead, Jane Elley, said in May: 'We've contacted more than 12,000 borrowers, 1320 have entered repayment plans, and 960 people have fully repaid their overdue amounts. 'Three hundred and four overseas-based borrowers own property here, and during the first six months of our increased compliance work, they paid up $1.7m. 'For defaulters within this group who have refused to engage and resolve their default, further legal enforcement action will be taken, which may include NZ-based bankruptcy or charging orders over their properties,' Elley said. 'There were also 151 overseas-based borrowers with NZ-based investments, and between July and December last year, we received payments totalling $84,000 from some of them. Again, there could be legal action ahead, including taking deductions from their investments or bank accounts receiving interest income.' The IRD can apply to the courts for a warrant to arrest overseas debtors who 'knowingly default' on their repayments, Elley said. She said Customs and airlines helped the IRD keep track of debtors by handing over information and alerting it to travel information or border crossings. 'We apply to the District Court and the police make the actual arrest. Once arrested and taken before the courts, a judge can order the defaulter to make reasonable efforts to arrange repayment to Inland Revenue,' Elley said. Nation of Debt series Monday: NZ nears trillion-dollar debt burden Tuesday: Are higher taxes inevitable? Wednesday: Consumer debt dips but 470,000 Kiwis behind on payments Raphael Franks is an Auckland-based reporter covering business, breaking news and local stories from Tāmaki Makaurau. He joined the Herald as a Te Rito cadet in 2022. Sign up to The Daily H, a free newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
NZ Herald
2 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Letters: Council's ‘Robin Hood' rating system verges on socialism
This pattern of rates collection can only be explained by a 'Robin Hood' council that is robbing the well-off to give to the poor, which I label as socialism. Is this the job of a council? No council should adopt this mandate. Its function is to provide quality services to the public at acceptable prices, and not do this via a wealth tax, because that is what our rating system has become. Trevor Smith, Takapuna. The languages of real life I was lucky to have something of a natural talent for assimilating language. When I started school in 1950, Māori was forbidden to be spoken and the small number of Māori kids were forbidden to use their native tongue. When I got to secondary school at the age of 11, I was put into 3L1, and was taught Latin, French, and English, but not a word of the only other language that was spoken by numerous New Zealanders. Now these accursed philistines in charge are winding the clock back again. This is an international humiliation and disgrace, and a terrible blot on our collective copybook. The more language you learn while you are young, the better prepared you are for real life. Real life almost universally includes more than one language. Bruce Rogan, Mangawhai. Not my kind of rugby The letter by Gary Carter (Aug 19) enthuses 'this rugby championship is a must-watch for spectacular, world-leading excitement'. I am not sure if the writer has his head in the clouds or the sand but the current version of rugby is almost unwatchable. Crash-bang dangerous tackles, late TMO rulings, whistle-happy refs, rolling mauls all add up to a stop-start game going backwards. With 10 minutes of running rugby in an 80-minute game, wouldn't there be more 'excitement' watching Donald Trump and our Prime Minister playing noughts and crosses? Graham Fleetwood, Tauranga. Retain the moral high ground The idea that New Zealand should consider losing its moral high ground and its nuclear-free status as contemplated by Matthew Hooton (Aug 15) gets a big Yeah, Nah. How could he suggest such a thing after all the work put in by activists of the past? We should reaffirm our non-aligned status and spend our defence on firefighting drones capable of defending us against any threat. If we can build America's Cup yachts, surely we can do that here, and probably better than elsewhere. We could also take a leadership role in reforming the UN Security Council so we (the whole world) can feel safe with genuine collective security, and put our energy into the real threat to the world - anthropogenic climate change. Dennis Worley, Birkenhead. Performative, not informative Jeremy Coleman (Aug 19) is right. Demands for Dame Jacinda Ardern, Grant Robertson, Aysha Verrall and Chris Hipkins to present in person at the Covid inquiry are pointless. During lockdown, as we silently watched the countless dead being loaded on to refrigerated trucks around the world, as we listened to clear messages from our leaders about what was happening, and as we learned that subsidies were helping people to put food on the table, I for one felt grateful to these people and proud to be a New Zealander. It needs to be understood that these former leaders have already responded to hours of questioning on the Covid response for the commission. Appearances by them would be merely performative, not informative, as others have said. This inquiry runs the risk of becoming less about how to do things better next time, and more of a political witch hunt. The money would have been better spent on social housing and equal pay. Christine Hart, St Mary's Bay. Keeping up with AI Writing is going to be the future for school kids. Really? Having just used AI to transcribe handwriting to text and found it recorded my statement about it being 'absolutely amazing', it is no surprise that Education Minister Erica Stanford needs a distraction. Perhaps our kids could learn a few Māori words like tūī and kererū. Our manu/bird names are part of our vernacular. Steve Russell, Hillcrest.
