HSE chief tells Oireachtas group that ‘we took our eye off the ball'
Bernard Gloster
acknowledged as he sought to explain how the practice known as third-party insourcing had expanded into a multimillion euro industry living inside the public hospital system.
A report he had drawn up for
Minister for Health Jennifer Carroll MacNeill
revealed that in 27 months to the end of March this year, close to €100 million had been paid out on engaging external companies that use HSE-owned facilities and equipment after normal working hours – in many cases employing existing health service staff – to reduce public waiting lists.
The report reveals 83 serving or former health staff are acting as directors in 148 companies providing what are known as insourcing and outsourcing – another system which involves buying care in outside private facilities – arrangements to reduce waiting lists.
It says 23 of these company directors are employed by the HSE.
READ MORE
Gloster told the
Oireachtas Joint Committee on Health
that over two decades insourcing arrangements had grown from 'a small localised thing' to a level where the health system was now overly dependent on it.
'People saw opportunities, entrepreneurially,' he said, although he stressed there was nothing unlawful about being a company director.
He defined insourcing as the practice of engaging external companies or third-party providers to deliver services, often outside of normal working hours, using HSE-owned facilities and equipment.
'In many cases, these providers may employ or subcontract staff who are already directly employed by the HSE, effectively re-engaging internal staff through a separate commercial arrangement, typically at premium rates.'
The availability of such premium payments for working for insourcing companies, the HSE chief acknowledged, also made regular overtime less attractive.
Gloster told Fianna Fáil TD Martin Daly that the focus of hospitals in embracing insourcing had been a rush to do the right thing and reduce waiting lists.
However, he argued that the effective governance of insourcing arrangements became 'quite questionable'.
Over recent weeks, there have been significant controversies surrounding insourcing arrangements at Children's Health Ireland, Beaumont Hospital and – the public was told for the first time on Wednesday – at
Naas General Hospital
. Internal auditors have been sent into Naas to look at concerns over the use of National Treatment Purchase Fund financing.
Gloster concluded, following his analysis of the scale of insourcing, that it was now time to wind down the whole process.
He has recommended to the Minister that insourcing should end by June 30th, 2026.
It cannot be shelved immediately as this would leave patients relying on such services in the lurch. But in the meantime, new controls and safeguards will be introduced.
Gloster's plan is for the regular health service to carry out the work previously carried out by insourcing, using new, more flexible rosters now agreed with hospital consultants and other healthcare staff. But he warned that if a gap remains, it will have to be filled by sending more public patients to be treated in private hospitals.
Ultimately, Carroll MacNeill is expected to decide on whether to call a halt to the insourcing train – which would appear to generate close to €50 million per year for those on board – by the end of July.
However, the investigations into allegations of concern at
Children's Health Ireland
, Beaumont and now Naas arising from insourcing arrangements will likely run a lot longer.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
40 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Family of recently deceased boy Harvey Morrison Sherratt to meet Simon Harris
Tánaiste Simon Harris will meet the family of Harvey Morrison Sherratt (9) who died in recent weeks following years of suffering due to spina bifida and scoliosis. . He had been subject to delays in accessing urgent scoliosis surgery, during which time he experienced significant pain and a reduced quality of life. He underwent surgery at the end of last year. He died on July 29th, although no cause of death has been established, his mother said in a post on X last week. READ MORE Harvey's parents Gillian Sherratt and Stephen Morrison, from Clondalkin in Dublin, have been leading a social-media campaign calling for the resignation of Mr Harris following their son's death. In 2017, when he was minister for health, Mr Harris pledged that no child would wait more than four months for scoliosis surgery by the end of that year. In a post on X, Ms Sherratt called on the Tánaiste to think 'as a parent of young children'. 'While you create memories with your children, I think about how memories are all we have left, and any future memories made will always have a void. While you kiss them goodbye for the day, I think about when I kissed Harvey goodbye for the last time,' her post said. Mr Morrison said his son was 'unique', but said 'what isn't unique is the way he and other children and people with disabilities are being failed. It is up to us to stop it.' They have called for a statutory inquiry into the handling of scoliosis in Ireland. Harvey Morrison Sherratt's parents Stephen Morrison and Gillian Sherratt have called for a statutory inquiry into the handling of scoliosis in Ireland. Photograph: Collins It emerged last year that Harvey had been removed from Children's Health Ireland 's (CHI) urgent scoliosis surgery waiting list, without his family being informed. CHI was contacted for comment. It previously said it could not comment on individual cases but that waiting lists are 'constantly changing, as children and young people have their surgeries and come off the list, new patients are added'. 'Important progress is being made every month,' it said. A spokesman for Mr Harris said the Tánaiste had spoken to Ms Sherratt, Harvey's mother, on Wednesday and they 'have agreed to meet in the near future'. 'The Tánaiste has also sought, through the Minister for Health, a full multidisciplinary report on the timeline of care provided to Harvey.' During a visit to Clonmel, Minister for Finance Paschal Donohoe said Mr Harris 'did all he could' when he became aware of the needs of the family 'in terms of engaging with the Department of Health and HSE'. 'I am very conscious that we have a family who have lost a loved one, and are grieving at the moment. They have had such a difficult experience and we have to respect that, and to allow them to make the points that they believe are important,' he said. 'There are still families who need more support, there is still more progress that we need to make.' Sinn Féin health spokesman David Cullinane said the 'tragic and avoidable passing of Harvey Morrison Sherratt must bring an end to the neglect of children with significant medical needs'. 'Despite the commitment made in 2017 by Simon Harris that no child would wait longer than four months for scoliosis surgery by the end of that year, as of July there are still 38 children waiting longer than six months just for an appointment date.' Speaking to RTÉ on Wednesday, Aontú leader Peadar Tóibín called for Mr Harris to resign over his handling of the case.
Irish Times
41 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Inquest into prisoner's death delayed after DPP ‘mislaid' file, court hears
An inquest into the death of a prisoner has been adjourned for a further three months after a file for the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) was 'mislaid', a coroner's court sitting has heard. Michael Devlin absconded from the Shelton Abbey open prison in Arklow, Co Wicklow, in 2020 and remained on the run until he was detained again in January 2024. He died about a month later in Cloverhill Prison. He died from complications associated with supraglottitis, an acute bacterial infection that can cause severe airway obstruction. At a preliminary hearing at Dublin District Coroner's Court on Wednesday morning, Det Insp Brian Hanley sought a further adjournment of three months, as a file has been submitted to the DPP concerning the death. READ MORE Upon questioning from Michael Finucane, representing Mr Devlin's family, Det Insp Hanley said a file was initially submitted in hard copy form in May. 'Following an inquiry after this date, it became apparent that the file had been mislaid. It was resubmitted approximately two weeks ago,' he said. The DPP subsequently requested the postmortem report, which was not included with the file. This was requested by gardaí last week. 'I am mystified as to why a file would be submitted to the DPP in relation to a death in custody without the postmortem report,' Mr Finucane said. Mr Finucane said he had several questions relating to the 'expeditious nature of the investigation or lack thereof'. These included the delay in requesting a postmortem and the delivery and subsequent mislaying of the file for the DPP. Coroner Dr Clare Keane said the questions were 'reasonable' but would not hear such evidence during a preliminary hearing and adjourned the case until November. In a separate case, the family of a 38-year-old man who died in a workplace-related incident in December 2019 said they are 'in limbo' after a request was made for a further adjournment. Health and Safety Authority (HSA) inspector Frank Kearns sought an adjournment of six months as a file concerning Karl McKeon's death remains with the DPP. 'I understand the last time I was here, six months ago, it was also with the DPP then,' he said. Family members present said they were unaware the case would be pushed out again and expressed frustration that they have been waiting almost six years for answers. 'Karl's five and a half years dead, and it's destroying our family. We don't know why he died or how he died,' his mother, Mary, said. Noting she has been in hospital three times since her son died, she said: 'I don't know if I'm going to live to find out what happened to my son.' 'The HSA had it for a very long time and now it's been in the DPP's hands and I think at this stage, we should be having answers and maybe we'd be able to go up to Karl's grave and know why he's lying in the grave,' she said. 'I've actually rung the DPP myself,' she said, adding that she has 'given up'. 'It's heartbreaking and I can't do it any more,' she said. Dr Keane asked the HSA inspector to contact her office if updates arise, and another preliminary hearing will be listed 'immediately'. She adjourned the case for a further three months. Separately, the case of John Murphy, a 41-year-old who died after sustaining extensive burn and blast injuries in an industrial incident at the Stryker plant in Carrigtwohill, Co Cork, has been adjourned for a further six months. Mr Murphy died at St James's Hospital in Dublin almost two months after the incident in June 2023. Mr Kearns said the death is still under investigation by the HSA, but a file will be submitted to the DPP.
Extra.ie
2 hours ago
- Extra.ie
Packing for your sun holiday? Do you have your EHIC card?
Most of us, when packing for our annual sun holiday, would probably remeber to pack the essentials, like passport, money, credit card, sunscreen, but what about your medical insurance card? Your free EHIC card available from the HSE which covers you in case of a medical emergency abroad. One young Irish holidaymaker has been left with a huge hospital bill after he travelled to Spain without his European Health Insurance Card and found himself in a private Spanish hospital after collapsing on the second day of his holiday. The young man had been holidaying with his girlfriend in the Spanish resort of Playa de Las Americas in Tenerife when he found himself in the back of a private ambulance after he collapsed in his hotel room and was taken to hospital. An EHIC card covers you in case of a medical emergency abroad. Pic: Getty Images He underwent a series of examinations in the emergency room, including blood tests, and was deemed serious enough to be kept in overnight, where the hospital recommended a brain scan be undertaken the next day. However, the following morning, the hospital staff presented the young man with a bill for over €1,100 euro for tests and treatment given up to that point. A frantic phone call was made back home to family in Ireland, who immediately contacted the HSE to try to rectify the situation with the EHIC card, which they found was not only left at home in Ireland, but was also two weeks out of date. Tenerife. Pic: Shutterstock Within 24 hours the issue was sorted out and an emergency EHIC number was issued, which could be used for any future treatment needed in Spain – but only in public hospitals and clinics. Which still leaves this young couple with a bill of almost €1,200 euros for inadvertently calling a private ambulance when the young man collapsed. Speaking to the young man's mother said its quite possible her son had suffered from heatstroke after spending most of the previous day by the pool in the heat of the Spanish sun, currently experiencing a heatwave with temperatures of almost 40 degrees in places. The advice from the HSE is simple, if you have your EHIC card with you on holiday and if you need to see a GP or get treatment abroad, showing your health insurance card will make the process much easier. How you use an EHIC abroad differs from country to country. In some countries you might have to pay for treatment, while in others the card will cover you, but either way having this vital little blue and white card with you could save you a lot of heartache and worry in the event of needing a doctor or emergency room abroad.
