RTÉ writes down €3.6m due to partly abandoned IT project
RTÉ has confirmed that it was forced to write down €3.6m due to a partly abandoned IT project.
In a statement, the broadcaster said it had sought to update its finance and HR systems using funds from the €107m sale of lands at its Montrose base.
The Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) project was approved in September 2016. It was intended to replace five "disparate, legacy systems that were used for finance and HR, which were at or near end of life". One had been installed in 2001, with another two installed in 2003.
The project had appointed two suppliers in 2018 following "an extensive procurement process", but RTÉ said issues arose almost immediately and the project was already behind schedule by January 2019.
"These issues were largely due to a lack of resources provided by those parties to the project, resource constraints within RTÉ, the build quality of the product in testing which did not meet expectations and over-ambitious timelines. This was compounded in 2020 with the outbreak of covid-19 and the disruption caused by same.
"As a result of issues arising, the contract was terminated with one of the appointed suppliers. This was the subject of a Settlement Agreement which is the subject of a confidentiality clause."
RTÉ said it then "engaged extensively with the other supplier to agree a plan that would facilitate the supplier delivering the maximum possible value of the contract".
In August 2022, the project restarted "following a phased approach with an initial finance implementation followed by subsequent phases for HR and other auxiliary functionality," and the finance system went live in March 2023.
However, RTÉ did not ultimately proceed with the HR modules and said that "in accordance with accounting standards" was required to "review and record impairments in respect of this project from 2019 to 2023".
A statement said that media minister Patrick O'Donovan has been alerted to the issue.
"The majority of the impairment relates to the effort to deliver the HR part of the project, amounting to €2.3m. The remaining €1.3m related to the delay and effort in delivering the Finance element of the project. Impairments were noted in RTÉ's approved Annual Accounts during the years 2020-2023, but more specific details relating to this project have been disclosed to the Minister as part of the review of capital projects.
"This impairment is very much an exception in the context of extensive projects delivered annually by RTÉ. This is evidenced by the fact that in Q1 2023 RTÉ recognised that this project was an 'outlier' and commissioned consultants (Ernst & Young) to conduct a review of it so that lessons could be learned to minimize the risk of recurrence.
"The Ernst & Young report was presented to the RTÉ Board's Audit and Risk Committee at its meeting on 20 April 2023 and discussed. It was also discussed by the RTÉ Board at its meeting on 27 April 2023.
"Furthermore, the corporate governance reforms introduced by RTÉ over the past 18 months are designed to mitigate against the risk of recurrence of such issues."
Last year, the Expert Advisory Committee's Independent Review of Contractor Fees, Human Resources (HR) and Other Matters in RTÉ was published by then-minister Catherine Martin. It recommended that RTÉ prioritise the proposed investment in new HR information systems.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
an hour ago
- Irish Independent
Irish TV tax break gets green light from Europe
RTÉ could be a major beneficiary of the €211m scheme, with The Late Late Show among the programmes that should qualify. The commission examined the plan, announced by minister Jack Chambers in last year's Budget, under EU state-aid rules. The aim is to promote the production of unscripted audiovisual programmes with either Irish or European cultural content. The measure will be introduced for a four-year period, backdated to last December and running until December 31, 2028. The aid is in the form of a tax credit of up to 20pc of the production expenditure that happens in Ireland. The maximum support cannot cover more than 16pc of the total cost of production. To be eligible, a programme must have a minimum cost of €250,000, with half of that being spent in Ireland. A 'cultural test', which will be designed by the Government, will be used to ensure that the unscripted productions 'contribute meaningfully to the promotion and expression of Irish or European culture'. Anthony Muldoon, director of strategic policy at Screen Producers Ireland (SPI), said the tax incentive is a 'transformative' investment for Ireland's creative industry. 'It will empower our producers and creators to develop and produce high-quality programmes that resonate with both domestic and international audiences,' he said. Members of SPI had joined together to campaign for the tax credit, forming an Unscripted Working Group, and had co-operated with the Department of Finance and Revenue, as well as with the Department of Arts and Media. Stuart Switzer, chair of the Unscripted Working Group, said he was thrilled that the European Commission had decided to approve the aid package. 'This is a first in Europe, and a recognition that the creative unscripted sector in Ireland has the potential to emulate the success of our scripted colleagues,' he said. 'The challenge will be to ensure the benefits of the incentive are retained within the independent production sector to build companies of scale.' According to an analysis included in the Tax Strategy Group papers last year, spending on unscripted TV productions could increase from about €90m a year to €300m if a tax credit was introduced. It referred to two similar schemes in Europe, operated by Malta and Cyprus. "If introduced, such a relief could have the potential to support additional employment in the sector and increase demand for studio space,' the report said.
Irish Examiner
3 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Caitríona Redmond: Is your membership worth it? — how to be subscription savvy and save money
From gym and cinema memberships, and even a newspaper subscription, many businesses rely on payments made on recurring basis, but how can you tell if they offer value for money or stealthily drain your bank account? For the business, a subscription model can improve cash flow on a monthly or annual basis, it's a chance to connect with their customers regularly, and build brand loyalty. After all, if you sign up for a gym in the Mallow Rd area, you're unlikely to want to also pay for and frequent another gym in Maryborough. For consumers, signing up for a subscription can save money. Take a movie pass for example. Most cinema chains in Ireland charge €14.99-€20 per person per month which allows the passholder to visit the cinema frequently during a calendar month. Considering the cost of a cinema ticket begins at €7 per adult, a passholder that visits more than three times a month will save money compared to buying tickets each time. That said, several cinema chains charge a monthly subscription fee that is mired in additional charges for booking a new release and reserving seats. The seats available without a fee tend to be the cheap front-of-house seats and make for an uncomfortable watching experience. It's a Ryanair-style model of making cross-selling that is designed to bring in more revenue for the businesses but also increases the overall cost of a subscription for the consumer. Ultimately, a movie fan who likes to sit at the back of the cinema may not save money on a monthly membership due to the additional charges. Dropping in and out of memberships or subscriptions can save you money. Where a TV streaming service launches a new series, wait until all the episodes have been published before signing up. If you can binge on the series within a month, lapse the subscription again until you see something else that you like. There are plenty of free TV services available, even digitally, and these include the much-maligned RTÉ player, Channel 4 (yes it's free and available in Ireland), Virgin Media Player, and you can also rent movies and listen to music for free thanks to a library card. Considering the big screen experience can often be coupled with popcorn and drinks, that monthly subscription could be costing you more than you think. If you enjoy new movie releases but not the high cost, consider renting that film online and enjoying some homemade popcorn, a comfy sofa to enjoy the movie from, sharing the movie with your family, and the ability to press pause if you need to. Renting a recent release from Sky Cinema, for example, costs €15.99. I'd easily spend four times that cost if I took my family of four to the cinema. This represents a significant saving on my part. There's one annual subscription I pay without hesitation. Every January my allotment fees fall due, costing €210 per year for 200sq m of land that I rent from my local authority. To me, this fee is an absolute bargain considering the hours of pure enjoyment and the food I grow in 'my happy place'. My plot is just over a mile away from my house, but I previously rented an allotment four miles away and I didn't frequent it as much. When choosing an in-person subscription factor in your time and distance before signing up. A yoga class membership, for example, might sound amazing but if you live 20 minutes' drive away it will require more effort and cost fuel to take part regularly. Look for a similar class closer to home to save money overall and increase your likelihood of getting the benefit from the subscription. That cinema membership may be well worth the money during the summer when the big screen is a 30-minute stroll, but in winter that 30-minute stroll could become a slog in bad weather. You won't be surprised to learn that I have several online newspaper subscriptions. If I did buy the physical papers, I'd not only be filling my recycling bin with quite the weight every week, but I'd also be spending more than my food budget. Instead, I sign up for digital subscriptions and yes, I absolutely read them all daily, although I confess that I may skip over the sports pages a little. Those who pay for a subscription, but don't use it, are the subscribers who benefit a business most. This is fantastic for the company, but not so good for subscribers' bank accounts. I can guarantee you that this money could be put to good use elsewhere. When signing up for a service, consider using a bank card or account that tracks your subscription costs. This makes it simple to see what your monthly charges are, plus it's easier to make sure that your membership has been cancelled both by your payment provider, and the service you originally signed up to. I find both PayPal and Revolut excellent in this regard, and I particularly like the pop-up reminders that a monthly payment is due. Being more subscription savvy will save you money. Read More Caitríona Redmond: Teaching kids to put money into savings after a season of holy sacraments
Irish Independent
a day ago
- Irish Independent
Des Cahill at centre of RTÉ's €11m PRSI court case
RTÉ sports presenter Des Cahill is at the centre of a landmark High Court case that could have an €11m cost to the national broadcaster. Cahill is one of two high earners at the broadcaster whose cases have led the Department of Social Protection to determine RTÉ was obliged to make extra PRSI payments on their salary. The former Sunday Game host's case has been examined as part of a department review into whether presenters' employment at RTÉ was more akin to that of employees than independent contractors. Cahill, who has non-staff contractor position at RTÉ despite working there for over 40 years, is the subject of one of two cases RTÉ has appealed to the High Court arising from the department's inquiry into alleged bogus-self employment at the station. The two High Court cases have been brought by RTÉ against the Social Protection Minister and an appeals officer in the social welfare appeals office. Both are listed for mention in the Master's Court on July 8.
