
Perhaps, This is Why The Innocent Men-Tourists Died in Pahalgam
हिंदी తెలుగు اردو
Home Politics Economy World Security Law Science Society Culture Editor's Pick Opinion
Support independent journalism. Donate Now
Opinion
Perhaps, This is Why The Innocent Men-Tourists Died in Pahalgam
Badri Raina
13 minutes ago
The historical-cultural point is unmistakable: it is the women who always spoil the broth, both within the kitchen and on the battlefield.
Illustration: Pariplab Chakraborty.
Real journalism holds power accountable
Since 2015, The Wire has done just that.
But we can continue only with your support.
Contribute now
Now, at last, we know why 26 innocent men, mostly tourists, died at the hands of terrorists in Pahalgam: it was not because there was an intelligence failure, nor because no policemen patrolled the fatal site. It was because their women did not fight to save them.
Had these women studied the life and work of Ahilyabai Holkar, they would have become Viranganas (warrior women).
Never mind that the cited Ahilyabai was not a warrior woman but an educationist and social reformer.
A spokesperson of the ruling BJP further illuminated us (Breaking With Agenda, News 24, 10 AM, May 25) as to how women warriors like the Rani of Jhansi had 'fought the Muslims' and the women visiting Pahalgam apparently lacked such motivation
Never mind that Rani of Jhansi actually did not fight against the Muslims, but alongside Muslims, against the British.
It would have helped, according to Ram Chander Jangra, the BJP member of parliament, if the men who were killed had taken some 'Agniveer' training; still, the fault lay primarily with the women who did not strike it hot against the gun-wielding terrorists.
It must be Jangra's view that women are far too strong to have needed 'Agniveer' training either.
The historical-cultural point of this is unmistakable: it is the women who always spoil the broth, both within the kitchen and on the battlefield.
This despite the fact that no country in the world worships as many goddesses as we do in India, which also we lovingly have christened 'Ma Bharti' too.
Yet, rue the failure of these women to rise to the appellation we bestow on the nation.
Despicably trashy as this read of the killings in Pahalgam is that India's mass mind has come to be so addled that there will be no dearth of men and women too, both among the populace and the electronic media who will know how to filibuster the gutter-speak of the parliamentarian away from the condemnation and chastisement it deserves.
Quite recently, India's dashing minister of external affairs stoutly defended democracy as a system of government, and then the great strengths of Indian democracy in particular.
What better proof of the strength of his thesis may be provided than that such voices like that of Jangra – along with Vijay Shah, who dubbed Colonel Sofia Qureshi as sister of Pakistani terrorists, and Jagdish Devda, who gloated how the Indian armed forces now bow at Modi ji's feet – are free to go berserk with criminal speak while voices that would curb their fulminations are reminded of limits on free speech.
Who knows the truth of that conundrum better than Ali Khan Mahamudabad, now gagged from sense and sensibility?
Badri Raina taught at Delhi University.
Make a contribution to Independent Journalism
Related News
BJP Leadership, Haryana Women's Commission Silent on MP Blaming Women for Not Fighting Back in Pahalgam
'Mastered the Art of Degrading Women': Outrage as BJP MP Blames Women for Not Fighting Back During Pahalgam Attack
Watch | Does the SC Have the Power to Gag Ali Khan Mahmudabad or Has it Overreached Itself?
Ali Khan Mahmudabad Presented Before Court, Sent to Judicial Custody Till May 27
Learning Against The Grain: Perspectives from Ali Khan Mahmudabad's Former Students
Ashoka Prof Arrested For 'Endangering Sovereignty' Over Post Criticising Jingoism, Sent to Custody Till May 20
Full Text | Ashoka University Professor Ali Mahmudabad's Posts that Haryana Police Calls 'Sedition'
The Sole Reason Behind Ali Khan Mahmudabad's Arrest Is That He Is a Muslim
The 'Statement of Objection' by Academics Against Mahmudabad Erodes India's Democratic Fabric
View in Desktop Mode
About Us
Contact Us
Support Us
© Copyright. All Rights Reserved.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


The Hindu
5 minutes ago
- The Hindu
West Bengal migrant worker repatriated from Bangladesh after family moves Calcutta HC
Amir Sheikh, a 19-year-old migrant worker from Kaliachak in West Bengal's Malda district who was allegedly detained from Rajasthan in May and 'pushed back' into Bangladesh, was reunited with his family on Wednesday. Mr. Amir's family members said the Border Security Force (BSF) personnel handed him over to the Basirhat police in the State's North 24 Parganas district. Earlier this month, Ziyem Sheikh, the father of Mr. Amir, had filed a habeas corpus petition before the Calcutta High Court. The matter was heard before the Division Bench of Justices Tapabrata Chakraborty and Reetobroto Kumar Mitra. The counsel appearing for the BSF said Mr. Amir attempted to cross over to Indian territory on Tuesday and since he could not produce appropriate identification documents, he was apprehended and handed over to the officer in charge of the Basirhat police station. Speaking to The Hindu, his family contested the BSF's claims. 'I got a call this morning asking me to pick up my son from Basirhat. All this is happening because we approached the court,' Mr. Ziyem said. Refuting BSF's claims Trinamool Congress MP and chairperson of the West Bengal Migrant Welfare Board Samirul Islam also refuted the BSF's claims of the migrant worker 'inadvertently crossing the border'. He said an attempt was being made to 'cover up the pushing back of the migrant worker into Bangladesh by the BSF and the Union government by repatriating him'. 'Amir Sheikh from Kaliachak in Malda was deported to Bangladesh by the Rajasthan police with the help of the BSF. From the very beginning, we stood by his family. We helped Amir's father file a habeas corpus petition in the Calcutta High Court. Under pressure, the BSF has brought Amir back to West Bengal,' the MP said, adding that they even have the video Mr. Amir had recorded from Bangladesh. 'He was deported' 'We will legally prove that Amir was deported by the BSF and that he did not go there voluntarily,' Mr. Islam said. He also pointed out that the migrant worker was in the custody of Bangladeshi authorities and had the family not approached the court, he would have continued to languish in detention in the neighbouring country. The matter will come up for hearing on August 27. Hundreds of Bengali-speaking migrant workers have faced alleged detention and harassment in different States and asked to produce documents to prove they are not Bangladeshi nationals. Some migrant workers from West Bengal have claimed that they were 'pushed into' the neighbouring country but later repatriated with the help of Indian authorities.


Time of India
20 minutes ago
- Time of India
Cops make citizens aware of ‘digi arrest' frauds
1 2 Lucknow: Lucknow Police south zone has launched a special cyber safety initiative aimed at tackling emerging online fraud techniques, particularly the so-called 'digital arrest' scams. The drive was integrated into Peace Committee meetings held ahead of upcoming high-footfall events — Chehlum (Aug 14), Independence Day (Aug 15), and Janmashtami (Aug 16) — to ensure both security preparedness and public cyber awareness. Officials highlighted that cybercriminals are increasingly using deceptive tactics — including 'digital arrest', where victims are falsely told that they are under legal detention through fake calls or video chats by imposters posing as police or govt officers. Police clarified during the session that no such legal provision as 'digital arrest' exists under Indian law, and members of the public should treat such communications as fraudulent. "The Peace Committee meeting, attended by local representatives, community elders, women, journalists, students, and committee members, included the distribution of pamphlets outlining ten key points on cyber safety. These covered verifying the identity of callers, avoiding unsolicited financial transactions, recognising phishing attempts, and reporting fraud to the cyber helpline 1930. Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like The world's top 15 most luxurious and comfortable airports Learn More Undo by Taboola by Taboola Through this meeting alone, 700–800 residents of the South Zone were reached directly," said Vasanth Kumar, Additional DCP, South Zone. Police have been directed to carry out ongoing awareness programmes in schools, colleges, community centres, public gathering spots, and rural areas. The campaign will include live demonstrations, case studies of recent scams, and guidance on reporting procedures. Awareness materials relating to safeguard from cyber fraud was also distributed, the officer said. Stay updated with the latest local news from your city on Times of India (TOI). Check upcoming bank holidays , public holidays , and current gold rates and silver prices in your area.


India Today
an hour ago
- India Today
Dharmasthala mass burial row: SIT probe finds few remains, BJP alleges conspiracy
In this episode of Super 6, the focus is on the controversy surrounding Dharmasthala in Karnataka. Allegations by a former sanitation worker claimed the burial of hundreds of bodies at the holy site. A Special Investigation Team (SIT) probe was initiated, identifying 15 spots for exhumation. Authorities have completed the exhumation process up to spot number 13. So far, "human remains have been found only at one site and another site slightly afar, they found a few remains. But that's about it." This finding has led to Hindu groups and the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) alleging a conspiracy to target the temple administration. BJP legislators are scheduled to visit Dharmasthala on August 17th amidst the ongoing SIT investigation.