Paris cafes caught pouring cheap wine after customers pay for posh plonk
An investigation by Le Parisien newspaper found that wine fraud is ripe in the French capital, with tourists often being the victims.
The outlet claims cafes are replacing fancy wines with budget alternatives. They discovered the fraud when sending two sommeliers to taste out the deception while pretending to be tourists.
Of the wine ordered by the glass, investigators said that a pour of chablis or sancerre at around €9 (£7.65) was substituted for a sauvignon, the cheapest wine on the menu at around €5 (£4.25).
One of the undercover sommeliers, wine merchant Marina Giuberti, found a €7.50 sancerre had been replaced by a cheaper sauvignon priced at €5.60, but she was charged the higher rate.
After complaining, the waiter brought her another glass of the wrong wine.
Giuberti said: 'It's a pity for the customer and for the image of the wine appellation, for the winemaker and for the restaurant owners who do a good job.'
Staff at brasseries and cafes in Paris confirmed that the practice is often encouraged by bosses looking to maximise their profits.
Sarah, a waitress with 30 years of experience working in restaurants, told Le Parisien: 'I might put leftover wine in a single bottle for happy hour, or replace Bardolino with Chianti, which is much cheaper and tastes completely different.'
The 'repotting' technique involves switching out the wine a customer has ordered with the contents of a more budget bottle.
A former employee of a Montmartre brasserie, Tristan, added that staff were 'told off by the owner if the most expensive bottle went down too quickly', and only once did a sommelier customer discover the ruse.
According to the hospitality worker, aside from French locals, 'all other customers were getting ripped off'.
He said: 'When I saw American tourists arriving on the terrace, I knew they were going to be had.'
Experts told Le Parisien that, by law, customers can insist on having wine poured from the bottle in front of them with the label visible.
Jérôme Bauer, Alsace winemaker and leader of the National Confederation of AOC (appellation contrôlée), told the outlet: 'Cheating the customer rebounds on us, the producers, because a customer who has ordered a Côte du Rhône and gets served a Bordeaux wine will probably be disappointed and can turn away from that wine in the future.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sky News
2 hours ago
- Sky News
Miniature classic car-maker Hedley Studios revs up rescue deal
A company which makes miniaturised electric versions of classic cars has secured a rescue deal led by an American merchant banking group. Sky News understands that the future of Hedley Studios - formerly known as The Little Car Company - has been salvaged through a pre-pack administration deal. FRP Advisory is understood to have acted as administrator before selling the business to an entity controlled by Island Capital Group. Hedley Studios was founded in 2018, when luxury car-maker Bugatti approached Ben Hedley to see if he could recreate a 1920s Type 35 racing car at half-scale to mark its 110th anniversary. In a statement issued in response to an enquiry from Sky News, the company said it had built and delivered more than 500 vehicles to clients in more than 60 countries in the last 17 months. Hedley Studios manufactures its cars at three-quarters the size of the original model, with the resulting vehicles typically costing £75,000 or more. "We're thrilled to welcome Island Capital Group as a strategic partner in the next phase of Hedley Studios' growth," Mr Hedley said. "Its investment and belief in our vision mark a pivotal moment for the company as we accelerate our expansion and reach new global audiences. Hedley Studios makes its cars in partnership with a range of luxury manufacturers, including Aston Martin, Bentley and Ferrari. Andrew Farkas, founder, chairman and CEO of Island Capital, which initially backed Hedley Studios in 2023, said: "This latest investment is testament to the entrepreneurial spirit of Ben and his team in building a successful British luxury brand in a short period of time. "Automotive enthusiasts globally are increasingly keen to honour these historic icons, bringing them to new audiences in a new, fully electric way.
Telegraph
4 hours ago
- Telegraph
Trump's strongman capitalism risks killing American enterprise
If it actually happens, no doubt the president will describe it as 'the deal of the century'. The United States government is reported to be examining buying a major stake in the microchip manufacturer Intel. It is part of a growing trend of the Trump administration becoming more and more involved in the running of the giants of American industry, with the state taking a share of Nvidia's revenues in return for export licenses to China, meddling in the management of Eli Lilly and Coca-Cola and drawing up a spreadsheet of 'pro' and 'anti' businesses in the White House. We can all understand what Donald Trump is getting at. He wants to make America more competitive and doesn't mind rolling up his sleeves to make it happen. The trouble is, state interference in business always goes horribly wrong – and in reality Trump's version of strongman capitalism will be the death of American enterprise. It was, at least, good news for Intel's long-suffering shareholders. The shares spiked by 7pc on Thursday as news leaked that the White House was looking at taking a direct stake in the business. After all, the share price has fallen by 50pc over the last five years, and after setbacks in all its major markets it was a sign that the company might soon have the full financial muscle of the US treasury behind it. We don't know yet how much it might pay for the shares, or how many it will buy, but following a meeting between Trump and Intel's chief executive Lip-Bu Tan some kind of deal looks likely. That is part of a growing trend. In his second term, Trump has not just been imposing tariffs, often haphazardly, on the rest of the world. He has been involving himself directly in the management of some of America's biggest companies. Earlier this month, the chip giants Nvidia and AMD agreed to pay 15pc of their Chinese revenues to the US government in exchange for permission to export to its main rival. Last month Coca-Cola agreed to replace corn syrup with cane sugar as a sweetener in its fizzy drink at the suggestion of the president. Eli Lilly is increasing the price of its diet injection Mounjaro after Trump complained that the 'fat drug' was cheaper in London. The White House was reported to have categorised more than 500 companies and trade associations, according to whether they were for or against his 'big, beautiful bill' that set the budget, with the clear implication there would be favours for those on the right side of the ledger, and punishments for those on the wrong side. Meanwhile, last week Scott Bessent, the US treasury secretary, argued that the 'Japanese, European and Koreans will invest in companies and industries that we direct them to, largely at the president's discretion'. The list goes on and on. At this rate, Trump will soon be on the phone to Amazon's Jeff Bezos telling him who to choose as the next James Bond, and advising McDonald's what to put on the breakfast menu (more hash browns, presumably). He is rapidly turning himself into the chief executive of USA Inc. Sure, we can see what the president is getting at. If we take microchips as an example, Trump, like his predecessor Joe Biden, wants to bring manufacturing back onshore, and he wants to protect critical supply lines in what is clearly the most strategically important industry of the 21st century. No doubt he sees Intel as the best vehicle for making that happen. Likewise, he wants to beef up the competitiveness of American industry. If that means throwing the weight and muscle of the White House behind the country's industrial champions then he doesn't mind rolling up his sleeves and getting on with it. After all, French presidents do it all the time, so there is no reason why American ones should not as well. And in fairness, if you are going to have a president who meddles in the country's corporations, Trump is probably better at it than most. At least he knows how a company works. There are two big problems, however. First, whenever the state gets too heavily involved in the management of a company it always ends up going horribly wrong. The priorities change, the management loses focus, and the other shareholders are ignored. To take just one example, look at how poorly Air France has performed since Emmanuel Macron built up a 28pc stake in the airline: its shares, despite a recent rally, are down by 25pc over the last five years, while IAG, the owner of British Airways, is up by 188pc. It is hard to believe that Intel under partial state ownership competing against fully private rivals in the micro-processor industry will fare any better, and it may well end up being completely destroyed. More seriously, it looks scarily like the version of strongman capitalism that is practised in Viktor Orban's Hungary, or which has been tried countless times in South America. It starts with some well-intentioned support for corporate champions, and it might even do some good initially. But over time it turns into a system where big money and big politics are so intertwined that markets get distorted, cosy monopolies are allowed to flourish, and innovation and competition are crushed because it doesn't suit someone who has political favours to call in with the government. It is a rotten, deformed version of capitalism, and one that always ends in failure. Trump may or may not take a stake in Intel. We will find out in the next few weeks. He may start muscling in on the management of major American companies or he may not. Either way, the blunt truth is this. The South American-style system of state-dominated crony capitalism that Trump is developing will be the death of the tradition of free enterprise – one that has made the American economy the strongest in the world.
Daily Mirror
5 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
Murder victim had skull smashed by hammer and body buried in concrete - and killers nearly got away
Christophe Borgye's murder in 2009 was brutal - and his twisted killers could have got away with it for years had one of them not let slip When a caller with a heavy French accent confessed to murdering his flight attendant flatmate four years earlier and entombing his body in concrete in his garden, police inspector Anton Sullivan listened in horror. It sounded like the plot of a Mafia movie but, as his three year investigation proved, every word of the bizarre late night phone call made by Sebastian Bendou in 2013 - four years after his victim was reported missing by Ryanair colleagues - was true. The murder victim - buried at the bottom of the garden in Ellesmere Port, Merseyside - was fellow Frenchman Christophe Borgye, 36. Meanwhile, a man has been crushed to death by his wife after she 'stumbled and fell on top of him'. Now the gruesome story is being told in a new Prime Video documentary, Murder in Concrete, screening from August 31. 'The ripple effects from this crime are still going on a decade later,' Anton, who retired in January after a career spanning more than 30 years and appears in the documentary, tells The Mirror. Christophe's love of travelling brought him to the UK, where he landed his airline job, but fell in with three men who went on to kill him. Unemployed Dominik Kocher, a German national who was married with a family, had welcomed Christophe when he moved into the rented home opposite him, where his cousin Manuel Wagner lived with Frenchman Bendou, a paranoid schizophrenic. Anton says Kocher left 'a trail of fraud behind him,' in Europe, before settling in Merseyside. Somehow, the experienced conman - who also lied about having cancer - persuaded all three men to let him run their finances. 'Kocher controlled everything to do with Bendou and Wagner,' explains Anton. 'He took their money and in exchange he did their cleaning and cooking. It was like they were his children.' Christophe soon accepted the same deal - handing over his wages. 'Kocher is a very convincing, very manipulative individual,' says Anton. 'The deal he presented was, 'I know you want to travel, I know that you work long hours and irregular shifts. I will look after everything for you, you pay the rent, and because I have cancer and don't work, I look after everybody in the house.'' Kocher was known in the area for ripping people off, according to Anton, who describes Christophe as 'a very caring person.' Anton adds: 'He took people on face value, and if they were nice, kind, and sympathetic, he just presumed that's how they were.' For a few years, the four men lived comfortably with the arrangement. But in the spring of 2009, Christophe said he was moving to Belgium to advance his career. 'Kocher realises this means the tens of thousands of pounds he'd been taking off Christophe for the last two years was disappearing,' says Anton. 'He has to persuade Wagner and Bendou, who is particularly vulnerable, to get involved in getting rid of Christophe. 'Kocher starts feeding them a narrative that Christophe is a clear and present danger to the family; that he's a spy who wants to get them out of the way so he would have access to Kocher's eldest daughter.' In April that year, Kocher bought three supermarket paring knives, together with bricks, cement and limestone chipping from a nearby builders' merchants. On the morning of Christophe's death, the three conspirators lured him downstairs to their specially prepared 'kill room' in the kitchen, which had tarpaulin laid down for the job. Wearing plastic overshoes to minimise blood spatter, they stabbed him as he desperately tried to fight them off. Anton explains: 'The knives were cheap and not up to the job, so Wagner produced a claw hammer he'd brought along. Those blows to Christophe's head were what killed him, there was catastrophic damage to the skull. The victim never stood a chance.' The killers then wrapped Christophe's broken body in the tarpaulin, carrying him to an outhouse, where they built a shallow wall around his body, then filled it with concrete. 'The three of them, having cleared up the blood and mess, then decide they're a bit peckish and go to Chiquitos for lunch,' marvels Anton. 'We later find the credit card receipt from Kocher's bank. Then they continue to live their lives in that house, with what they've done, for some time after the murder.' Kocher even sold Christophe's possessions and pocketed the money. After Christophe's concerned colleagues reported him missing, someone - believed to be Kocher, who has always maintained his innocence - emailed the Borgye family, masquerading as Christophe, saying he'd met a Chinese girl and was moving. Anton says: 'It's made to look as though Christophe has written it, with little elements of things he liked, like a new Wolverine film and so on. 'But then it talked about him having a midlife crisis, his phone's about to die, he's gone off-grid and when he's settled in China he'll contact them. That was out of character.' Christophe's worried brother and sister, Noel and Aurélie, contacted Cheshire Police, but his killers again covered up his disappearance. For four years, Christophe's body lay undiscovered in its concrete tomb. Kocher and the other men eventually moved to Warrington, then to Dumfries in Scotland, telling the new Merseyside tenants not to use the outhouse as it was the landlord's store. But Bendou's 2013 call to police triggered the investigation that exposed the truth. Bendou had become increasingly paranoid, thinking Kocher and Wagner were planning to kill him and dispose of his body in a similar way. Arriving at the police station 'dishevelled,' Anton says: 'He hadn't washed in a couple of days and it was difficult to understand him.' He claimed he had killed Christophe alone during a fight, in self defence. Bendou led cops to the outhouse where he was entombed. Retired Detective Sergeant Steve Currie, who was there, says: 'There was a brick-built structure at the back of it at the bottom which just didn't feel right. 'That's the moment for me when I thought, 'This thing's got legs'. 'It took four days to get the body out. We found Christophe wrapped in a coat, other bindings, butcher's coats and the tarpaulin sheet.' Three knives and three pairs of shoes were found with the preserved body, indicating Bendou hadn't acted alone. Soon after Kocher and Wagner were fingered. Both stood trial in 2014, and Kocher was convicted of Christophe's murder. Wagner was cleared of assisting an offender and preventing a lawful burial, but later convicted of murder in a separate trial, after Bendou told how he had made the first hammer blow that killed Christophe. Bendou admitted to killing Christophe, claiming diminished responsibility, but was handed a life sentence with a minimum of 14 years. Wagner and Kocher have never admitted guilt. Meanwhile, Christophe's family - who have been involved with the documentary - say every life event he misses triggers their grief. 'Christophe never got to meet his nephews. He missed Aurélie's wedding,' says Anton. 'These are all important milestones for the family that Christophe has not been there to share.' Timeline April 2009: Christophe is killed by three 'friends' and entombed in concrete in the garden May 2009: Ryanair colleague reports Christophe missing. Someone impersonates him in an email to his family, saying he's safe. November 2012: Kocher and his family, Bendou and Wagner move to Warrington and afterwards to Dumfries, Scotland. April 13, 2013: Bendou travels to Ellesmere Port and confesses to the crime, at first saying it was just him. April 17, 2013: Wagner and Kocher questioned as witnesses. Wagner alleges Christophe is living in China. May 2013: Bendou tells police about Wagner and Kocher's involvement. They are arrested on suspicion of murder, which they deny. July 2013: Kocher and Bendou charged with murder. March 2014: Kocher convicted of murder, Wagner cleared of assisting an offender and preventing a lawful burial. May 2014: Bendou convicted of murder. Later sentenced later to life with a minimum of 14 years. June 2014: Appeal to increase Kocher's sentence rejected. His sentence is life with a minimum of 23 years. September 2016: Wagner, now living in Liverpool, charged with murder. June 28, 2017: Wagner convicted of murder and sentenced to life with a minimum of 16 years. *Murder in Concrete launches on Prime Video on August 31
