Murder victim had skull smashed by hammer and body buried in concrete - and killers nearly got away
When a caller with a heavy French accent confessed to murdering his flight attendant flatmate four years earlier and entombing his body in concrete in his garden, police inspector Anton Sullivan listened in horror.
It sounded like the plot of a Mafia movie but, as his three year investigation proved, every word of the bizarre late night phone call made by Sebastian Bendou in 2013 - four years after his victim was reported missing by Ryanair colleagues - was true.
The murder victim - buried at the bottom of the garden in Ellesmere Port, Merseyside - was fellow Frenchman Christophe Borgye, 36. Meanwhile, a man has been crushed to death by his wife after she 'stumbled and fell on top of him'.
Now the gruesome story is being told in a new Prime Video documentary, Murder in Concrete, screening from August 31.
'The ripple effects from this crime are still going on a decade later,' Anton, who retired in January after a career spanning more than 30 years and appears in the documentary, tells The Mirror.
Christophe's love of travelling brought him to the UK, where he landed his airline job, but fell in with three men who went on to kill him.
Unemployed Dominik Kocher, a German national who was married with a family, had welcomed Christophe when he moved into the rented home opposite him, where his cousin Manuel Wagner lived with Frenchman Bendou, a paranoid schizophrenic.
Anton says Kocher left 'a trail of fraud behind him,' in Europe, before settling in Merseyside.
Somehow, the experienced conman - who also lied about having cancer - persuaded all three men to let him run their finances.
'Kocher controlled everything to do with Bendou and Wagner,' explains Anton. 'He took their money and in exchange he did their cleaning and cooking. It was like they were his children.'
Christophe soon accepted the same deal - handing over his wages.
'Kocher is a very convincing, very manipulative individual,' says Anton. 'The deal he presented was, 'I know you want to travel, I know that you work long hours and irregular shifts. I will look after everything for you, you pay the rent, and because I have cancer and don't work, I look after everybody in the house.''
Kocher was known in the area for ripping people off, according to Anton, who describes Christophe as 'a very caring person.'
Anton adds: 'He took people on face value, and if they were nice, kind, and sympathetic, he just presumed that's how they were.'
For a few years, the four men lived comfortably with the arrangement.
But in the spring of 2009, Christophe said he was moving to Belgium to advance his career.
'Kocher realises this means the tens of thousands of pounds he'd been taking off Christophe for the last two years was disappearing,' says Anton. 'He has to persuade Wagner and Bendou, who is particularly vulnerable, to get involved in getting rid of Christophe.
'Kocher starts feeding them a narrative that Christophe is a clear and present danger to the family; that he's a spy who wants to get them out of the way so he would have access to Kocher's eldest daughter.'
In April that year, Kocher bought three supermarket paring knives, together with bricks, cement and limestone chipping from a nearby builders' merchants.
On the morning of Christophe's death, the three conspirators lured him downstairs to their specially prepared 'kill room' in the kitchen, which had tarpaulin laid down for the job. Wearing plastic overshoes to minimise blood spatter, they stabbed him as he desperately tried to fight them off.
Anton explains: 'The knives were cheap and not up to the job, so Wagner produced a claw hammer he'd brought along. Those blows to Christophe's head were what killed him, there was catastrophic damage to the skull. The victim never stood a chance.'
The killers then wrapped Christophe's broken body in the tarpaulin, carrying him to an outhouse, where they built a shallow wall around his body, then filled it with concrete.
'The three of them, having cleared up the blood and mess, then decide they're a bit peckish and go to Chiquitos for lunch,' marvels Anton. 'We later find the credit card receipt from Kocher's bank. Then they continue to live their lives in that house, with what they've done, for some time after the murder.'
Kocher even sold Christophe's possessions and pocketed the money.
After Christophe's concerned colleagues reported him missing, someone - believed to be Kocher, who has always maintained his innocence - emailed the Borgye family, masquerading as Christophe, saying he'd met a Chinese girl and was moving.
Anton says: 'It's made to look as though Christophe has written it, with little elements of things he liked, like a new Wolverine film and so on.
'But then it talked about him having a midlife crisis, his phone's about to die, he's gone off-grid and when he's settled in China he'll contact them. That was out of character.'
Christophe's worried brother and sister, Noel and Aurélie, contacted Cheshire Police, but his killers again covered up his disappearance.
For four years, Christophe's body lay undiscovered in its concrete tomb.
Kocher and the other men eventually moved to Warrington, then to Dumfries in Scotland, telling the new Merseyside tenants not to use the outhouse as it was the landlord's store.
But Bendou's 2013 call to police triggered the investigation that exposed the truth.
Bendou had become increasingly paranoid, thinking Kocher and Wagner were planning to kill him and dispose of his body in a similar way.
Arriving at the police station 'dishevelled,' Anton says: 'He hadn't washed in a couple of days and it was difficult to understand him.'
He claimed he had killed Christophe alone during a fight, in self defence.
Bendou led cops to the outhouse where he was entombed.
Retired Detective Sergeant Steve Currie, who was there, says: 'There was a brick-built structure at the back of it at the bottom which just didn't feel right.
'That's the moment for me when I thought, 'This thing's got legs'.
'It took four days to get the body out. We found Christophe wrapped in a coat, other bindings, butcher's coats and the tarpaulin sheet.'
Three knives and three pairs of shoes were found with the preserved body, indicating Bendou hadn't acted alone.
Soon after Kocher and Wagner were fingered. Both stood trial in 2014, and Kocher was convicted of Christophe's murder. Wagner was cleared of assisting an offender and preventing a lawful burial, but later convicted of murder in a separate trial, after Bendou told how he had made the first hammer blow that killed Christophe.
Bendou admitted to killing Christophe, claiming diminished responsibility, but was handed a life sentence with a minimum of 14 years.
Wagner and Kocher have never admitted guilt.
Meanwhile, Christophe's family - who have been involved with the documentary - say every life event he misses triggers their grief.
'Christophe never got to meet his nephews. He missed Aurélie's wedding,' says Anton.
'These are all important milestones for the family that Christophe has not been there to share.'
Timeline
April 2009: Christophe is killed by three 'friends' and entombed in concrete in the garden
May 2009: Ryanair colleague reports Christophe missing. Someone impersonates him in an email to his family, saying he's safe.
November 2012: Kocher and his family, Bendou and Wagner move to Warrington and afterwards to Dumfries, Scotland.
April 13, 2013: Bendou travels to Ellesmere Port and confesses to the crime, at first saying it was just him.
April 17, 2013: Wagner and Kocher questioned as witnesses. Wagner alleges Christophe is living in China.
May 2013: Bendou tells police about Wagner and Kocher's involvement. They are arrested on suspicion of murder, which they deny.
July 2013: Kocher and Bendou charged with murder.
March 2014: Kocher convicted of murder, Wagner cleared of assisting an offender and preventing a lawful burial.
May 2014: Bendou convicted of murder. Later sentenced later to life with a minimum of 14 years.
June 2014: Appeal to increase Kocher's sentence rejected. His sentence is life with a minimum of 23 years.
September 2016: Wagner, now living in Liverpool, charged with murder.
June 28, 2017: Wagner convicted of murder and sentenced to life with a minimum of 16 years.
*Murder in Concrete launches on Prime Video on August 31
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Spectator
14 minutes ago
- Spectator
Has France got what it takes to stand up to the Islamists?
In the early 1990s, an underground organisation was launched called the Barbie Liberation Movement (BLM). Its mission statement was a 'commitment to challenging malign systems', by which it meant the patriarchy. The BLM was inspired by a talking Barbie doll, launched in 1992, who had 270 platitudes, one of which was 'math class is tough'. Outraged feminist groups forced Mattel Inc, the makers of Barbie, to remove what they described as a sexist slur. Now, though, may be the hour for the Barbie Liberation Movement to reform and once more fight the patriarchy. This time, however, the patriarchy is different. It no longer consists of ageing white men with their outdated views that science and maths are subjects best left to boys; it's Islamists, whose view on women make the men of Mattel in the early 1990s seem positively progressive. Last week, an Islamist mob forced the mayor of Noisy-le-Sec, a Parisian suburb run by the Communists, to cancel a screening of Barbie, the Hollywood blockbuster starring Margot Robbie and Ryan Gosling. They liked neither the feminist nor the homosexual elements in the film and threatened the mayor that there would be trouble if the open-air screening went ahead. The mayor succumbed to the threats, provoking an angry backlash among France's political class. Aurore Bergé, the minister for gender equality, said it was more than just a thuggish threat from a group of young men: it was an attempt by Islamists to 'infiltrate' society and impose their values at the expense of the Republic's. Bruno Retailleau, the interior minister, also used the word 'infiltrate' and said the objective of the Islamists is 'to tip the whole of French society under sharia law'. In the face of such dedicated fanaticism, said Retailleau, 'the slightest retreat…is unacceptable'. The mayor of Noisy-le-Sec has promised to show the film – which was requested by residents of his district – at a later date; but rather than admit he was wrong to cave in to the Islamists, Mayor Olivier Sarrabeyrouse has tried to blame the furore on his political adversaries. At a press conference he declared: While I continue to condemn in the strongest terms the acts that I have described as obscurantism and fundamentalism, I condemn even more strongly the political exploitation and speculation, the racist and Islamophobic hatred that has been pouring out of the right and the far right. Sarrabeyrouse also pointed a finger at journalists, suggesting there were more important matters in the world than Islamists curtailing freedom of expression. I regret that you journalists are still arguing about our local issue, even though a few days ago, several of your colleagues were cowardly murdered by the Israeli army. Sarrabeyrouse doesn't appear to understand what is at stake; or perhaps he does and he knows, like others on Europe's political left, that pandering to elements of the Muslim vote is the only way to be re-elected, as they have long since lost the support of the white working class. The French call this 'clientélisme'. In June this year the official magazine for all France's elected mayors published a warning ahead of next May's municipal elections. Headlined 'Muslim Brotherhood: the risk of 'clientelist deals' in municipal elections', the article relayed the key findings of a recent government report about the Muslim Brotherhood in France. The secretive Islamist organisation had embarked on a new strategy, warned the report, which they described as 'municipal Islamism'. The Brotherhood would stand some of its members in next year's elections while also organising ''clientelist transactions' aimed at satisfying certain specific segments of the Muslim electorate'. Mayor Sarrabeyrouse will have a hard time trying to convince France that his critics are 'Islamophobic'; the threats made against Barbie are just the latest in a series of ugly incidents this summer. In June, a pop-up store opened in Lyon selling Islamic clothing. Stating that it catered to 'modest Muslim women', the shop refused entry to any customer whose head was uncovered. In July, a cinema in Saint-Ouen, just north of Paris, cancelled at late notice a documentary about freedom of expression inspired by the murder of the Charlie Hebdo staff a decade ago. It was reported that the cinema felt that the film violated its 'welcome charter', which 'prohibits political events'. This hadn't prevented the cinema from showing a film a week earlier about environmental activism. At the end of July, a 28-year-old woman was beaten up at a station south of Paris by a man who called her a 'dirty whore' for wearing a short skirt. The man's wife, who was wearing a North African djellaba, joined in the attack. Nine years ago this month, I wrote an article for Coffee House headlined 'France is right to ban the burkini'. That summer, young women had begun appearing on French beaches wearing the Islamic burkini; coming only days after an Islamist had murdered 86 people at Nice, the authorities banned the garment for fear it would provoke a wider French public still in shock after the massacre. I argued that the French were right because the burkini was just one strand of an Islamist strategy of intimidation. I referenced the case of a Muslim waitress in a Nice bar who had recently been assaulted by two men for serving alcohol during Ramadan. I also mentioned the young woman in Reims, beaten by a pack of furious teenage girls who objected to her sunbathing in a bikini in a public park. At the time Nicolas Sarkozy, the former president, warned of the emergence of a police of morality, and said: 'If we do not put an end to this, there is a risk that in ten years, young Muslim girls who do not want to wear the veil or burkini will be stigmatised and peer-pressured.' Last year in Montpellier a 13-year-old Muslim girl was beaten unconscious outside her school gates in Montpellier by a fellow pupil who felt she dressed too liberally. The Islamists haven't mellowed since 2016. Quite the opposite. They sense that France, and Europe in general, is weakening. They haven't the stomach for a fight. Most European politicians, like the mayor in Noisy-le-Sec, just want a quiet life. Better to submit than to stand up to the Islamists.
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
The wild tale of a multimillion-dollar CEO who got thrown in jail: best podcasts of the week
Following her hit podcast Scamanda, host Charlie Webster follows another twisty scandal. Candace Rivera built a flawless online brand as a divorced single mother, nurse and CEO of multimillion-dollar companies. But was any of it actually real? Webster unpicks what was happening behind the scenes and the events that ultimately led to this 'unicorn girl' being sentenced to a minimum of three years in prison. Hollie RichardsonWidely available, episodes weekly This collaboration between BBC Studios and American giants iHeart tells the true story of a grim murder in Texas and a woman, Sandy Melgar, wrongfully convicted for the death of her husband, Jim. In a genre where grieving relatives are often bit-part players, the presence of their daughter, Lizz, pushes it above the competition. Hannah J Davies Widely available, episodes weekly It's an uncertain moment for the podcast world, as Wondery's true-crime treats may soon be absorbed into the Amazon stable. In the meantime, enjoy what it does best: a ripped-from-the-headlines hoot about a French town where the mayor devolved his power to the local psychic. Mon dieu! Anna Richardson and Leo Schick host. HJDWidely available, episodes weekly Sign up to What's On Get the best TV reviews, news and features in your inbox every Monday after newsletter promotion The Atlantic's podcast about Hurricane Katrina and its aftermath returns for a special 20th anniversary episode, and it's a stirring portrait of one family. Le-Ann Williams wants a better life for daughter Destiny, but – as host Vann R Newkirk II notes – 'maybe she's got it backwards … maybe they've got what other people are searching for'. HJDWidely available, out now Kavita Puri hosts a three-part series marking the 80th anniversary of VJ Day, and considering the events that preceded it – namely, Britain's often downplayed role in the war against Japan on the Asian front. There are even eyewitness testimonies, which are all the more impressive given just how long ago these events took place. HJDWidely available, episodes weekly
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Aussie dad dies after German backpacker's tragic mistake - leaving his young son without a father
A young dad who was the sole breadwinner for his family has had his life tragically cut short in a horror head-on crash. Jack Beaton, 26, was on his way home on August 10 when a German tourist, 19, driving a Suzuki campervan allegedly crossed to the wrong side of the road and struck the oncoming Holden Commodore in Simpson, in Victoria's western district. Mr Beaton, who was in the front passenger seat of the Holden, died at the scene, just 20km from his home in Cobden. He is survived by his partner, Toni, and their two-year-old son, Hudson. Mr Beaton's death has rocked the local community, which has rallied around his grieving loved ones ahead of the funeral this Thursday. He has been remembered by loved ones as an amazing father and partner. Mr Beaton, who turned 26 a fortnight earlier, worked for a local fencing company and was the sole provider for his young family. Relatives have set up a fundraiser to help with Hudson's upbringing and allow Toni to return to work soon on hold. The young father is survived by his partner Toni and their son Hudson (pictured together) 'Jack loved life and lived it to the full but most of all he loved his family,' the fundraiser states. 'Toni has had to cease work while they come to terms with their loss, and Hudson adjusts to Daddy never coming home again. 'Funds raised will help Toni raise Hudson without the love and support of his dad and her soulmate.' The fundraiser has already raised almost $20,000 within days. Mr Beaton's death sparked an outpouring of tributes led by his workplace and local sporting clubs. 'We have no words to describe how devastated we are,' South West Rural Fencing posted online. 'Jack wasn't just someone we worked with, he was a best mate. Always up for a laugh, always up for some banter and someone you could count on no matter what. 'We will miss your contagious laugh and cheeky grin, and how you were always so eager to catch up for a longneck.' Jack worked for a local fencing company and was the sole provider for his young family Both drivers and a passenger in the Suzuki camper van were hospitalised after the crash. A German national, 19, was later charged with dangerous driving causing death. The court heard that Reto Bernhard had been travelling across Australia on a holiday visa after finishing high school. He will remain in custody until his next court appearance in January.
