Israeli officers admit assault on Gaza 'kills captives'
According to the report published on Friday, both the government and the military are fully aware that army attacks pose a grave risk to the captives and have, in fact, already led to fatalities.
'The manoeuvre kills captives, not theoretically, it actually kills them,' a security source told Ynet.
The source cited a specific incident in November 2023 as an example, in which an Israeli air strike killed three Israeli captives along with a senior Hamas military commander, Ahmed Ghandour.
'That's what happens when you're pursuing two conflicting objectives at the same time,' said the source, who holds a senior position in Israeli intelligence.
New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch
Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters
He stated that his main task within intelligence had become 'to save the hostages, mainly from ourselves', referring to the extreme danger Israeli military operations are believed to pose to the hostages' lives.
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, Defence Minister Israel Katz and top military officials have repeatedly insisted that continued military pressure is the only viable strategy to secure the release of captives, 59 of whom are still being held in Gaza.
'Ask any officer in the army today what the current war plan entails, beyond vague talk of 'pressure' to bring back the hostages,' the source said. 'We've been trying that for 19 months. It doesn't work.'
The source also described the planned expanded ground invasion as offering Hamas 'two options: release the hostages and we will kill you, or don't release them and we will still kill you. Of course, Hamas chooses the second option".
Captives never a priority
Haaretz reported earlier this week that securing the release of captives ranked at the bottom of six stated objectives for Israel's upcoming expanded military assault in Gaza, code-named 'Gideon's Chariots'.
The primary goals of the operation reportedly include defeating Hamas, establishing operational control over Gaza, demilitarising the Palestinian enclave, dismantling Hamas governance infrastructure and 'managing and mobilising' the civilian population - with captive recovery coming last.
According to the Ynet report, the return of the captive has not featured among the government's central military objectives since the war began, despite public declarations that both defeating Hamas and rescuing the captives were official aims.
What is 'Gideon's Chariots', Israel's latest plan for Gaza? Read More »
'A few days after the attack, [Hamas leader] Yahya Sinwar offered to release the children, women and the elderly,' the Ynet investigation stated.
However, 'Israel rushed to invade Gaza and no one thought about the hostages', a security source told the outlet, criticising the government's early decision-making.
'The claim that both goals could be achieved simultaneously was never translated into an actual plan on the battlefield,' added a senior security source involved in shaping the war strategy.
Another military official quoted in the report described a year-and-a-half-long campaign of 'psychological warfare and propaganda' within Israel, aimed at shaping public perception of the captives' issue.
According to the source, this campaign has had two main purposes: 'to give the hostages' families the impression that action is constantly being taken' and to suggest that 'if Hamas refuses a deal, the blame lies entirely with them, not with Israel'.
Captives as cover for 'war crimes'
As such, the newly announced expanded assault on Gaza, revealed last week, aligns closely with long-term Israeli strategic goals for the territory, according to the report.
The Israeli military is reportedly preparing to seize full control of the Gaza Strip, displace the entire population into a confined area in the south and restrict humanitarian aid to the bare minimum needed to prevent mass starvation - all as part of the new military phase expected to begin soon.
Netanyahu has repeatedly referred to his plan as the "final stage" of the war, despite mounting criticism from aid and rights groups that famine is threatening the entire population.
Since resuming its offensive on 18 March after reneging on a ceasefire deal, Israel has refused to allow any aid into the besieged enclave.
More than 2,720 Palestinians have been killed in Israeli attacks since then, raising the death toll since 7 October 2023 to over 52,800.
'With the help of an alibi in the form of the hostages, they will flatten all the buildings that remain standing'
- Israeli intelligence source
An Israeli intelligence source told Ynet that the military is using the captive as a pretext to justify the war.
'With the help of an alibi in the form of the hostages, they will flatten all the buildings that remain standing,' the source said.
The same source claimed the broader objective is to 'encourage 'voluntary emigration', which essentially means expelling Palestinians from Gaza to make way for settlers'.
The expanded operation has been widely condemned by governments and international organisations around the world, who have warned of its catastrophic consequences for the civilian population.
Former Israeli Defence Minister Moshe Yaalon also admitted that the plan represents a 'war crime' - whether you call it 'ethnic cleansing, transfer, expulsion'.
He said the military would be 'directing soldiers to become war criminals' by implementing the plan.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Middle East Eye
19 minutes ago
- Middle East Eye
Iranian press review: Supreme leader's advisor reveals Mossad breach
High-ranking official shares details of Mossad infiltration Ali Larijani, an advisor to Iran's Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei and a close ally, has revealed that the Israeli spy agency Mossad carried out psychological operations and had access to senior officials in Iran during the recent war with Israel. On Monday, Larijani told the ISNA news agency that at the start of the war, he received a phone call warning him to leave Tehran within 12 hours or face the same fate as several assassinated commanders of the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC). He said that other IRGC commanders received similar threats. Larijani added that on the fourth day of the war, there was an attempt to strike a meeting of Iran's Supreme National Security Council. The attack failed, but he did not give further details. New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters He also called for a reassessment of Iran's international ties, saying: 'Iran must review its relations with international organisations and European countries. Throughout the war, they either remained silent or supported the US.' After the war, Iran's parliament passed a bill to suspend cooperation with the UN nuclear watchdog. Espionage crisis reflects deeper social divisions Ali Mojtahedzadeh, a lawyer who has represented several political prisoners in recent years, wrote in an opinion piece for the Etemad daily that the large number of alleged spies arrested by the establishment reflects a growing sense of discontent among Iranians. Israel's failure to subdue Iran shows it can no longer dictate the regional order Read More » Mojtahedzadeh warned that stopping the conflict with Israel does not mean Israel has abandoned its plans against Iran. He said the authorities must be prepared for similar actions in the future. He also addressed Israel's influence and its access to Iran's military and security information. Referring to government data, he wrote: 'Unfortunately, we know that the level of treason and espionage by some internal elements has been so great that it cannot be seen as an isolated case.' The prominent Iranian lawyer added: 'The common cause of most betrayals throughout history has been the loss of citizens' sense of belonging, a feeling created by the exclusion and marginalisation of people in social, cultural, economic, political, and security areas.' Anti-Afghan sentiment grows amid claims of Mossad ties Since the start of the war between Israel and Iran, Iranian authorities have intensified a campaign against Afghan immigrants and refugees, accusing them of assisting Israel's Mossad and accelerating the deportation of undocumented Afghans. According to the Shargh daily, over 72,000 undocumented Afghans have left Iran in the past few days, with thousands more crowding the Dogharoun border crossing, waiting to return. On Friday, Brigadier-General Ahmad Ali Goudarzi, commander of Iran's Border Guard Command, announced a threefold increase in arrests and deportations of Afghan refugees. He also declared: 'Any house or property rented to Afghans is void. The property will be sealed and confiscated.' After ceasefire, Iran is preparing for the long war with Israel Read More » During the 12-day war, state media and outlets close to the IRGC reported arrests of Afghans, claiming they were working with Mossad to target military and civilian sites. One report claimed that 400 Afghan immigrants were arrested in an underground tunnel for collaborating with Mossad. Although this report was later denied, it sparked a wave of anti-immigrant sentiment in the country. In response, Seyed Rasoul Misagh, an Afghan immigrant, questioned the truth of these claims in an article. He wrote: 'Afghan citizens in Iran are being arrested and deported by the police every day. Why would Mossad trust people who are already being hunted?' He also pointed out that Afghans in Iran face many restrictions, including bans on buying vehicles, getting a driving licence or even travelling between provinces without special permission. He questioned how anyone in such a position could be trusted with sensitive operations. Reformists call for amnesty for political prisoners Several reformist political groups, under the name of the Reform Front, have written a letter urging officials to help preserve national unity by releasing political prisoners following the unprovoked Israeli attacks. Iran: Arrests and executions soar following end of Israeli assault Read More » The letter, addressed to the head of the judiciary, who is appointed by the supreme leader, comes amid a tense political climate marked by the widespread arrest of activists and the recent execution of six people accused of espionage. Part of the letter, published by Iranian media, reads: 'The release of political and ideological prisoners will be an important step in rebuilding national trust. It will also help heal social wounds and strengthen the foundations of the republic.' Another section of the letter discusses the intentions of the political prisoners: 'These individuals acted with the aim of reforming and serving the country. They followed legal and civil methods. Keeping them in prison will not lead to a positive outcome. This situation only deepens divisions.' The writers of the letter believe that granting amnesty to these prisoners would promote 'national cohesion' and support 'civil liberties' in the country. *Iranian press review is a digest of news reports not independently verified as accurate by Middle East Eye.
Middle East Eye
19 minutes ago
- Middle East Eye
Secret Trump letter would let Israel resume war despite ceasefire: Report
Israel is reportedly seeking written assurances from US President Donald Trump that it will be allowed to resume military operations in Gaza if its demands are not met, even as talks over a 60-day ceasefire continue. Citing a "member of the political echelon" - a phrase often used to signal deliberate leaks by the Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu - Israel's Channel 14 reported on Wednesday that the current proposal includes a side letter from Trump. The document would give Israel the green light to "renew the fire if our demands with regards to the disarmament of Hamas and the exile of its leaders are not met". Israel would be able to interpret, define and make a judgment call on these terms. In March of this year, Israel broke the ceasefire agreement and resumed military operations. However, many analysts at the time noted that Tel Aviv did not want the negotiations to continue. The latest developments come despite claims of public optimism from both Israeli officials and Trump. New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters On Tuesday, the US president said Israel had accepted the necessary terms for a 60-day ceasefire and that during this pause, the parties would "work on ending the war". "The Qataris and Egyptians, who have worked very hard to help bring peace, will deliver this final proposal," Trump said. But Israeli media reports suggest the talks remain fraught. Serious challenges persist behind the scenes, especially over what will happen after the truce. 'New Middle East' Israeli military reservist, Amit Yagur, formerly deputy head of Palestinian affairs in Israel's military, told the pro-Netanyahu Channel 14 that Trump's broader push for a 'new Middle East' was increasing pressure on regional actors - particularly Qatar, where many senior Hamas officials are based. Israel using starvation and aid to inflict genocide in Gaza: Amnesty Read More » "The focus must be on the new Middle East," Yagur said. "The new regional architecture being discussed creates pressure among all the players. Its power lies in shaping a new reality on the ground, including the deal and how far Hamas will agree." During a cabinet meeting on Tuesday evening, Netanyahu vowed that any deal would guarantee the destruction of Palestinian resistance. "[We] have to kill anyone who is holding a weapon," he said. Military analyst Amos Harel wrote in the Israeli daily Haaretz that Netanyahu may be staging the appearance of compromise for Washington, while signalling to Hamas that his core demands remain unchanged. "For Hamas, the most critical demand is ending the war," Harel wrote, adding the group wants US guarantees to prevent Israel from sabotaging any future phase of the deal. Netanyahu, he said, remains caught between striking a truce and maintaining support from his far-right coalition allies.
The National
an hour ago
- The National
Hamas set to accept Gaza truce terms but seeks 'assurances'
Hamas has accepted a deal for a Gaza ceasefire and hostage release, but is seekingassurances from mediators that some of its additional demands will be met, sources told The National on Friday. US President Donald Trump said earlier in the day that it would probably be known within 24 hours whether Hamas would agree to a 'final proposal' for a ceasefire. He said on Tuesday that Israel had accepted the conditions needed to finalise a 60-day ceasefire agreement, during which the parties would work to end the conflict. The sources said Hamas would convey its acceptance of the proposed deal along with a request for assurances from US, Egyptian and Qatari mediators about the implementation of some of its 'unpublicised' clauses. These include the return by Israel of the bodies of some of the group's leaders killed during the Gaza war, including Yahya Sinwar and his brother Mohammed. They also cover the laying down and storing of the group's arms and the guaranteed return to Gaza of wounded Palestinians, who will be allowed under the deal to leave the strip for treatment abroad, the sources said. The clauses also include the creation of a 1km-deep safe zone on the Palestinian side of the entire Gaza-Israel border, which will be free of human habitation or any economic activity, including farming. According to these clauses, an unnamed Arab nation will supervise the storage of Hamas's weapons, and Israel will be prevented from excluding any area of Gaza from the distribution of badly needed humanitarian resistance. According to a two-page draft text obtained by The National on Friday, the proposed truce will last 60 days, during which Hamas will hand over in stages 10 living hostages and the remains of 18 others who died in captivity. This handover will start on the first day of the truce and end on the final day, according to the text. In return, Israel will release more than 1,000 Palestinians held in Israeli prisons, including scores serving long terms. On the 10th day of the truce, Hamas is expected to provide 'comprehensive information' on the remaining hostages. In return, Israel will provide information on Palestinians it has detained since October 7, 2023, the day the Gaza war began with an attack on southern Israel communities by Hamas and its allies. 'The [US] President is serious about the commitment of the parties to the ceasefire and insists that negotiations begin during the temporary ceasefire,' the draft text reads. 'If successful, the negotiations will lead to a lasting resolution of the conflict.' The deal also provides for the flow of sufficient humanitarian assistance into Gaza, distributed by groups to be agreed upon, including the UN and the Palestinian Red Crescent. It also provides for the two-stage deployment of Israeli forces away from proposed aid delivery routes in the south and north of Gaza, on the first and fifth day of the truce, following the release of eight living hostages and the remains of five others, respectively. Negotiations on a permanent ceasefire and the release of the rest of the hostages will begin on the first day of the truce, according to the text. Final "redeployment" of Israeli forces in Gaza will be part of the negotiations. The mediators will ensure that the negotiations are serious and will be extended past the 60-day truce period if they do not produce a deal by then. 'The President will personally make the announcement of the ceasefire. The United States and President Trump are committed to working towards guaranteeing the continuation of the negotiations in goodwill until a final agreement is reached,' the text states. Hamas-led militants killed about 1,200 people and took about 240 hostage during their attack on southern Israel. About 50 hostages are still being held in Gaza, with fewer than half of them thought to be alive. The Hamas attack prompted a devastating military assault by Israel that has so far killed more than 57,000 Palestinians, according to health authorities in Gaza. The war has displaced the majority of the enclave's estimated two million population, with many having to flee more than once, and destroyed swathes of built-up areas. Mediators from Egypt, Qatar and the US have been trying in vain since March to broker a deal for a ceasefire and the release of hostages.
