MARTIN GALLAGHER: Real policing cannot be delivered by officers sitting at a laptop
Sadly, some of these connections have been far from useful. Social media has evolved in some areas as a means to share evil ideas, from terrorist content to extreme right and left views.
But the evil content is far outweighed by the entertaining or useful.
While it is correct that the police are made aware of and tackle content that seeks to cause actual harm, the bar for what falls into this category has been dropping year on year.
Opinion and disagreement are not the place of the police.
We have allowed the service to become involved in areas that some may find offensive but are far from criminal - and harm no one.
This has been gradual, but with no sensible barriers put in place by the police, more and more ridiculous complaints have been received.
These complainants, had they attended at a police station, would simply have been told that straightforward disagreement is not a police matter.
Being offended is not a crime.
By taking on an increasing number of such complaints, the danger is that the police become complacent and allow the bar for what is a police matter to continue to slip.
Dealing with online arguments removes resource from where it is really needed.
Actual crime solvency is down, while violent crime, particularly amongst the young, is rising.
Policing a Twitter spat might be far easier than catching a housebreaker - but the impact of one is far greater than the other.
The police need to be far stronger around what they will, and will not, become involved in within the virtual world and refocus on actual crime, not hurt feelings.
There are finite resources available. These officers need to be directed to work of worth - not virtue-signalling.
We do need police back on the streets to but the thin blue line has become considerably thinner since Police Scotland was formed - with 1,000 fewer police officers than at formation in 2013.
Rob Hay, president of the Association of Scottish Police Superintendents, talks of avoiding the service being 'cannibalised' by looming decisions over potentially cutting police pay versus officer numbers.
Sadly, it has already happened.
Policing fills the holes other parts of the public sector have allowed to develop, while pet projects and niche topics have been prioritised rather than real impacts on lives.
The police who are left are working from fewer and fewer police stations, in fewer communities.
The Chief Constable, Jo Farrell, spoke of officers working from new premises that will improve officer and staff wellbeing.
This is all very good, but what of operational realities and the needs of the public?
It is crystal clear, too, that crime is expanding online, and it is right that resources are directed, where appropriate, to the virtual realm.
Fraud has been allowed to metastasise while policing has been absent.
However, walk down any high street in the country and it is obvious real policing is still required - and cannot be delivered at closing time by an officer sitting in front of a lap top.
Technology, such as body-worn video cameras, is freeing up officer time.
There needs to be careful consideration of where this capacity is applied.
Rushing headlong into the virtual world while the real world suffers a dearth of policing presence would be folly.
The police have made sacrifices, as numbers have dwindled and demands, many of which are not core business, have risen.
The ill-advised policy of 'proportionate response' - where minor crime is effectively disregarded - is one such trade-off, while the lack of a policing presence outside nightclubs as they close is another.
And officers are still spending too much time dealing with those with mental health problems, which prevents them from undertaking their core duties of preventing and fighting crime.
The answer lies in grasping a nettle the Chief Constable and Cabinet Secretary acknowledged but did not take hold off.
The days of politely asking Government bodies to shoulder their burden are over. They must now be told.
You have to be on the streets to police them. If the police are not freed from responsibilities that aren't theirs, this will not happen.
■ Martin Gallagher is a former superintendent with Police Scotland, who served as area commander of Paisley
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
2 minutes ago
- The Independent
Experienced skydiver deliberately fell to her death, coroner finds
An experienced skydiver deliberately fell to her death from 15,500ft the day after her relationship ended, an inquest heard. Jade Damarell, 32, did not deploy her main parachute or the reserve and switched off an automatic activation device (AAD) before she crashed on to farmland near the airfield at Shotton Colliery, County Durham, on April 27, the hearing was told. The marketing manager left instructions on the lock screen of her phone on how to access the handset and left notes and details of her finances in its Notes folder, the inquest at Crook Civic Centre, County Durham, was told. Coroner Leslie Hamilton gave a conclusion of suicide after finding that she intended to take her own life that morning. Ms Damarell, who was born in Hong Kong and lived in Caerphilly, Wales, loved skydiving and had completed more than 500 jumps. The day before she died, she had completed six jumps safely and without issues. Dr Hamilton summarised a statement from her former partner which stated that 'they had ended their relationship the night before'. The coroner did not go into further detail, except to say that they had met through a shared love of skydiving. Bryn Chaffe, co-owner of Sky-High Skydiving from where she jumped, gave a statement in which he said he saw Ms Damarrel eating toast in the base's cafe before she jumped and nothing seemed out of the ordinary. A post-mortem found she died from blunt trauma injuries and toxicological tests were negative for drink or drugs. Her GP reported that she was not on medication at the time. A report for the coroner by British Skydiving, which investigated her fatal freefall, found that all the equipment was in working order. Ms Damarell would normally wear a camera on her helmet but did not have one on when she fell, the organisation said. She confirmed she had an AAD, which was designed to deploy a parachute if a certain speed or altitude was met, but it was later found she had switched it off. She was aware that she had to deploy a parachute before her altitude dropped below 2,500ft, the inquest heard. Detective Inspector Andrew Stephenson, of Durham Police, attended the scene and found Ms Damarell had landed on her back. He later recovered Ms Damarell's phone and found she had left instructions on its lock screen on how to open it and to look in its Notes folder. The detective's report said she left a note for her family 'apologising and thanking them for their support'. Dr Hamilton concluded that the 'very experienced' skydiver chose not to deploy either of her parachutes or use the AAD and that she did intend to take her own life. Jeff Montgomery, head of safety and training at British Skydiving, attended the hearing and said afterwards: 'We extend our deepest condolences to the family and friends of Jade Damarell and it is an extremely tragic incident.' Her parents Liz and Andrew Samuel observed the hearing remotely. After the inquest, her family said: 'Our beloved daughter Jade was a brilliant, beautiful, brave and truly extraordinary person. 'A bright, adventurous, free spirit, she lived with immense energy, passion and love and touched countless lives with her warmth and kindness.'
The Independent
2 minutes ago
- The Independent
Stark number of people have left Labour party
Labour 's membership has significantly declined, falling to 333,235 at the end of last year from a 2019 peak of 532,046, with 37,215 members leaving in 2024. This downturn means over a third of Labour members have left since 2019, attributed partly to criticism over the party's positions on issues such as Gaza, welfare, and trans rights. Despite the losses, Labour remains the UK's largest party by membership, though Nigel Farage 's Reform claims 234,460 supporters and a new party led by Jeremy Corbyn has over 800,000 registered. Financial reports show Labour recorded a £3.8 million loss and the Conservatives a £1.9 million loss, while the Liberal Democrats, Reform UK, and Greens all reported surpluses. Labour faced scrutiny for the late submission of its financial accounts to the Electoral Commission, which is now reviewing the party's failure to meet the deadline.
The Independent
2 minutes ago
- The Independent
Culture minister says ‘biggest anxiety' is public service broadcasters' budgets
Culture minister Sir Chris Bryant has said his 'biggest anxiety' when it comes to the British TV industry is the reduced budgets of public service broadcasters (PSBs). The commissioning budgets of PSBs have been 'squeezed by the real-terms reduction of the BBC licence fee', as well as a reduction in advertising revenue, according to a report from the Culture, Media and Sport (CMS) Committee published earlier in the year. The MP also spoke about the Government's rejection of a streamer levy, after the report called for platforms, such as Netflix, Amazon, Apple TV+ and Disney+, to commit to paying 5% of their UK subscriber revenue into a cultural fund which would help PSBs through financing drama with a specific interest to British audiences. Speaking at the Edinburgh TV Festival, he said: 'We want to get a mixed economy. I love the fact that the streamers and big Hollywood houses make lots of shows in the UK … I want to mix it, to be making our own stuff.' Speaking about the importance of 'a mixed economy', he said: 'Film and TV, and high-end television in particular is fundamentally an international thing. 'I think that some politicians in the world don't seem to fully understand us, but one of the things I've been trying to achieve in the UK is, yes, it's great that the streamers do make fabulous stuff here, and lots of wonderful films made here. ' Tom Cruise is probably one of the biggest investors in the UK economy over the last decade. Brilliant. 'I really want to celebrate that, but I don't want everything that is made in the UK, all the IP (intellectual property), simply to go back to the West Coast of the United States of America. 'I'd like us to have some IP that remains here so that we can continue making investments and have strong UK production companies, which also make stuff which maybe sometimes is specifically made for a UK audience as well as for a wider audience. 'So I've been trying to make that mixed economy.' Cruise's blockbuster Mission Impossible films, particularly recent instalments, have frequently filmed in the UK, with locations including London, Derbyshire and the Lake District. Sir Chris added: 'My biggest anxiety is the state of public service broadcasting budgets, and if they haven't got any funding, they're not going to be making any progress.' After the report into British film and high-end television, chairwoman of the CMS committee, Dame Caroline Dinenage, said 'there will be countless distinctly British stories that never make it to our screens' unless the Government intervenes to 'rebalance the playing field' between streamers and public service broadcasters (PSBs).
