MTN faces bribery allegations as Turkcell appeals to the Constitutional Court
Image: Timothy Bernard/Independent Newspapers
MTN and some of its former employees – Phuthuma Nhleko and Irene Charnley – have headed to the Constitutional Court to fend off a local court hearing an argument by Iranian rival, Turkcell, that it was involved in bribery and corruption in that country.
At the beginning of the month, Turkcell won a landmark judgement in the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) that made it possible for Turkcell to present evidence that it believes shows that MTN committed acts of bribery and corruption to overturn the award of an Iranian GSM licence to Turkcell.
Turkcell doesn't think the apex court should hear the matter, as the SCA's majority judgment was well-reasoned and correctly applied the established legal principles regarding jurisdiction that MTN and the other defendants invoked to seek to delay the trial.
The SCA ruling set a precedent in that it was the first time a South African court had been asked to determine whether allegations of misconduct that apparently took place in another country could be heard locally.
Cedric Soule, global counsel for Turkcell, alleges that MTN's actions caused it more than $4.2 billion in damages.
Africa's largest mobile network operator has said that it has always 'maintained that the Turkcell litigation was without merit and has expressed confidence that it would successfully defend these proceedings'.
In 2012, the UK's Lord Leonard Hoffmann released a report that exonerated MTN of any shady dealings in securing the licence. In part, the report stated: 'All the allegations are a fabric of lies, distortions and inventions.' This report also cleared Charnley, then VP for the Middle East and North and East Africa, and Nhleko, who was then CEO, of any wrongdoing.
In a statement issued on Thursday, Turkcell noted the move by MTN to appeal the SCA's ruling in the Constitutional Court. 'The Constitutional Court will now decide whether to hear the appeal filed by MTN and the other defendants in this ongoing legal battle that dates back to 2013,' said Turkcell.
MTN had not informed the market that it had gone to the highest court in the land, although it previously said it may do so. Its Iranian operation has been marred by hyper inflation in that country, its quarterly update for the three months to March, released in the middle of this month, showed. Comment from MTN has been requested and will be published as soon as it is available.
Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Unmute
Current Time
0:00
/
Duration
-:-
Loaded :
0%
Stream Type LIVE
Seek to live, currently behind live
LIVE
Remaining Time
-
0:00
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque
Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps
Reset
restore all settings to the default values Done
Close Modal Dialog
End of dialog window.
Advertisement
Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Unmute
Current Time
0:00
/
Duration
-:-
Loaded :
0%
Stream Type LIVE
Seek to live, currently behind live
LIVE
Remaining Time
-
0:00
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque
Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps
Reset
restore all settings to the default values Done
Close Modal Dialog
End of dialog window.
Next
Stay
Close ✕
Turkcell's legal wrangle with MTN dates back more than a decade when it initially approached the US courts in an action it later retracted, arguing that MTN won its 49% of a telecommunications licence in Iran through paying bribes.
The Turkish operator argues that MTN paid off both Iranian and South African officials to overturn a public tender, which it lost to Turkcell, for a multi-billion-dollar opportunity to run an Iranian GSM telecom licence, it has said. 'This case has significant implications for South Africa's stance on international bribery and corruption,' it said in a statement this morning.
MTN has denied these allegations*
*This is a developing story
IOL
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
34 minutes ago
- The Citizen
How much money Dricus du Plessis won ‘by laying on the ground for 25 minutes'
The South African lost his title to Russian Khamzat Chimaev on Sunday in Chicago. He may have surrendered his Ultimate Fighting Championship (UFC) middleweight title this past weekend, but South Africa's Dricus du Plessis will receive a small silver lining in the way of a bloated bank account. Du Plessis had no answers for undefeated Russian Khamzat Chimaev's wrestling as he succumbed to a unanimous decision defeat at UFC 319 in Chicago on Sunday. Various reports online have estimated the South African will receive approximately $3 million (nearly R59 million) for essentially laying on the ground for almost 25 minutes. According to this amount includes a $1 million base purse reflecting his championship status, as well as between $1-1,5 million in Pay Per View and promotional bonuses — boosted by his star power and PPV points. Had he won the fight, this amount would have increased by a further $500,000. New champion Chimaev New champion Chimaev will earn an estimated $1.8 million — $750,000 for his base purse, $500,000 win bonus, roughly $750,000 to $1 million, driven by the event's hype and an extra $50,000 for his performance of the night bonus. Notably, Du Plessis previously banked $3.34 million at UFC 312 against Sean Strickland, per industry estimates, and $1.9 million at UFC 305 against Israel Adesanya. The combined earnings of Du Plessis and Chimaev, estimated at over $5 million, highlight the financial stakes of UFC title fights. Chimaev's amount reflects his rising star power, while Du Plessis' $3 million highlights the champion's PPV advantage. As the UFC prepares for a $7.7 billion Paramount deal in 2026, these figures spark curiosity about future fighter pay structures.
The Citizen
2 hours ago
- The Citizen
Why some South Africans are celebrating Dricus du Plessis' UFC title defeat
While sports minister Gayton McKenzie sent his commiserations to Du Plessis for the loss, other South Africans weren't so sympathetic. Several South Africans on social media have celebrated Dricus du Plessis' loss of his Ultimate Fighting Championship (UFC) middleweight title to Russian-Emirati fighter Khamzat Chimaev. 'Dricus' loss actually made me more pro-South African. He stood for the white genocide (which has been debunked), and he's also pro-Trump (who should be debunked). 'This is a loss for the good of the country,' wrote comedian Yaaseen Barnes on X (formerly Twitter) after the fight. Dricus' loss actually made me more Pro-South African He stood for the white genocide (which has beeeen debunked), he's also pro-trump (who should be bunked) This is a loss for the good of the country. — Yaaseen Barnes (@Ya_a_seen_Him) August 17, 2025 More reactions Due to UFC's popularity, some of the biggest fights penetrate through pop culture, grabbing the attention of people who don't usually follow the sport. 'Dricus du Plessis, you made us proud as one of the great champions, and we know you will be back. You faced a tough wrestler today, but you will come back stronger,' said Minister of Sport, Arts and Culture Gayton McKenzie However, while McKenzie sent his commiserations to Du Plessis for the loss, other South Africans weren't so sympathetic. 'There is no patriotism with peddlers of fake genocide in SA and racists. Thank you, Khamzat. Free Palestine,' wrote EFF Member of Parliament, Sinawo Thambo. South Africa rallied behind Du Plessis when he first won the title from Strickland, but during his reign as champion, the South African's endorsement of US President Donald Trump left a bad taste in the mouths of his fellow citizens. Where the disdain stems from In a lead-up to defending his title earlier this year, during a press conference, a journalist asked Du Plessis about a t-shirt he wore, which read 'Trump prefers champions' with an X (formerly Twitter) logo. 'Obviously, being a champion, he said he wants champions in his team, and he said it on X in a big shout-out to fellow South African Elon Musk for also doing the right thing,' said Du Plessis. Du Plessis's comments came a few days after Trump's baseless claims about land confiscations in South Africa. Nice @dricusduplessis wearing a Trump shirt, acknowledging President @realDonaldTrump for calling out the South African government. Dricus' first fight in the UFC on ESPN, he spoke out about farmer murders on 11 October 2020. He also gave a shoutout to @elonmusk. Dricus has the… February 5, 2025 Trump accused the South African government of 'confiscating land' and treating 'certain classes of people' badly. Since then, support from some South Africans has waned. So much so that South Africans supported whoever took on Du Plessis. ALSO READ: 'Please moer this Dricus du Plessis': Support for Strickland grows after Du Plessis' endorsement of Trump's comments Du Plessis dominated Chimaev dominated Du Plessis across five consecutive rounds at UFC 319's main event held in Chicago, Illinois, in the US. The South African has held the middleweight title since January 2024, when he beat American fighter Sean Strickland. 'The man has incredible control on the top,' Du Plessis said about Chimaev. 'He was just like a blanket. It wasn't a matter of strength; it wasn't that physical; it was just almost as if he knew what your next move was going to be. He got it without using too much power, and I had to decide whether to be on my back or have him on my back. At the end, I went for it, had the back, I could almost taste that victory.' 'He deserves this 100%, he beat me fair and square tonight.' WATCH: Du Plessis interview after the fight NOW READ: Beaten Dricus says, 'Big ups to Khamzat, he deserves this 100%'
Mail & Guardian
3 hours ago
- Mail & Guardian
Pace of gender equality at tertiary education institutions painfully slow
A 2024 study at a South African university found female staff are concerned about their future in the workplace because of their gender. Photo: File This year, 2025, marks the 30th anniversary of International Women's Day, the Beijing Declaration and Platform for Action, an agenda for women's empowerment. On 8 March, International Women's Day was observed under the theme 'For All Women and Girls: Rights. Equality. Empowerment'. Sorry to burst the celebration bubble but, with the deadline to achieve the UN sustainable development goals just under five years away, true emancipation of women seems a distant goal. An Concerning women leaders at institutions of higher learning, the Without taking anything away from both women's achievements, it is perplexing that it took the institutions 167 and 148 years to have a woman at the helm. Several scholars have published articles about problems facing academic and support personnel in both traditional universities and universities of technology. The battle to attain gender equality at institutions of higher learning, even beyond 30 years of democracy in South Africa, is there for everyone to see. Delving into some of the scientific evidence, in their 2024 study Reforming Higher Education in South Africa by Addressing Gender Inequalities, researchers Anri Wheeler and Laurika Wiese identified the absence of ' Their research article, published in the Journal of Adult and Continuing Education , shows that the policy vacuum perpetuates the marginalisation of female students and personnel. The study was conducted with female employees from varied staff components at a university of technology and they applied the Gender and Development Theory, which asserts that 'genuine economic and social progress is hindered as long as gender inequalities endure'. Some of the study's key findings highlight the preference of some males for working only with colleagues of the same gender. Meanwhile, female staff remained concerned about their future in the workplace because of their gender. The results also highlight that the selection of female staff into higher positions often serves only to comply with filling of quotas — a tick-box exercise. Even more disturbing, some participants confirmed the existence of a 'band of brothers' mentality in institutions — a group of male colleagues indifferent to working with females and, in many instances, treating them with disrespect based on gender. Furthermore, one of the themes emanating from the study is female stereotyping, where female colleagues are undermined by labels such as 'emotional' because of their gender. The study indicates that universities can help to reduce inequities and create a more inclusive and diverse learning and working environment by addressing gender discrepancies in academic and professional contexts. Wheeler and Wiese affirm that by espousing sustainable development goal 5, higher learning institutions can simultaneously contribute to attainment of other goals such as poverty eradication; quality education; decent work and economic growth reduced inequalities. A 2022 study, Workplace Bullying and Its Implications for Gender Transformation in the South African Higher Education Sector: An Intersectional Perspective by Brightness Mangolothi and Professor Peliwe Mnguni is relevant in helping us find ways to fasttrack gender transformation. They employed qualitative semi-structured interviews wherein they targeted a sample of 25 women academics from three universities. Their research article, published in the International Journal of Critical Diversity Studies , makes a link between Mangolothi and Mnguni listed bullying behaviours directed at women such as excessive workload allocation, removal of key areas of responsibility and being given trivial tasks to replace their core duties. The researchers summarise women's academic journey through a model anchored in the elements of access, retention, development, performance, progression and exit through resignation. The authors' research findings are aligned to identified themes and point to bullying mostly affecting African, coloured and Indian women academics. Key findings include access being denied and resources withheld; not being seen or heard; shifting goalposts; recognition withheld and authorisation denied for women at institutions of higher learning. Mangolothi and Mnguni's study shows that there is a 'boys club' culture, where men support each other in bullying women, undermining and excluding them from decision-making structures. South Africa continues to grapple with the triple developmental challenges of poverty, inequality and unemployment, with women seemingly the most negatively affected. Amid the research concluding there is gender inequality, the question is whether there is a will to address the patriarchy's negative impact across society and the workplace — or will women emancipation remain an elusive dream? Shalate Davhana & Malesela Maubane are Tshwane University of Technology alumni, with the former a staff member at the university. They write in their personal capacities.
