Kerala's share in central funds sparks debate ahead of 16th Finance Commission
Agencies As the 16th Finance Commission (FC) goes about making recommendations as to how much of the aggregate revenue collected by GoI should be devolved to the states and how the collective share of the states should be distributed among the states, it would be useful to study the treatment received by Kerala at the hands of the 15th Finance Commission (FFC) as a cautionary tale.But, first, let us dispel the misperception that FC awards are handouts from GoI to the states. Taxes belong to the people of India. Different taxes are collected by different levels of the government, depending on which level can collect the tax most efficiently. Just because the tax on incomes, whether of individuals or companies, is collected by GoI, it does not follow that these are GoI's taxes. Corporate incomes and a good deal of personal incomes are derived from economic activity spread all over the country, facilitated by central and state governments.
Just because a good many companies are headquartered in Mumbai, it does not mean they derive their income from that city or Maharashtra. If Kerala were to lay claim to all the customs duty collected at the Vizhinjam port, other states and GoI would cry foul. Such taxes are best collected by GoI and shared with the states. Kerala has been an outlier, in terms of social development, and the formula used by FFC, designed to address backwardness among states, has been less than fair to Kerala. In fact, the FFC award has been less than fair to other southern states, too. The share of total devolutions each of these states receives has been below its population share: 30% below the population share in the case of Tamil Nadu and Kerala, and 28% below the population share in the case of Karnataka and Telangana.
Backwardness has to be cured, sure, but the most effective medicine is better governance. Shovelling more funds taken from relatively better-governed states to inefficient governments that leak funds is a recipe for enriching regional kleptocracies, not for removing backwardness. The 16th FC should give much greater weight to indicators of governance, in the devolution formula. FFC gave a minuscule 2.5% to a state's tax effort. This should rise to at least 15%. Introduce a weightage for development expenditure. Reduce the weightage for income distance. Poverty is a special need, of underdevelopment. A large proportion of old people is a special need, arising from development that increases the lifespan. Kerala has the highest proportion of the population aged 60+, according to Elderly in India, a GoI publication: 16.5%, double the level in UP. FFC's approach not only failed to provide for such needs, but curtailed funds that could be used for old-age pensions and extra healthcare.India is the world's largest recipient of worker remittances from abroad, $129 bn in 2024. Different states make different contributions to these receipts of scarce forex. State expenditure on building exportable skills and talent results in these remittances. Why does it not make sense to introduce weightage, in the devolution formula for state contributions to remittances?The 16th FC would do well to contain the devolution award of any state within 10% of its population share. States should not be deprived of their fair share of the nation's resources because they make good use of what they receive. Its obverse is that states should not be rewarded for governance failure.It would do well to include all cesses and other levies on income and wealth in the divisible pool. At present, GoI devolves only 32-33% of its tax collections, rather than 41% as prescribed, because it dresses up some duties and levies as cess and surcharge, which are not shared with the states. A good portion of the levies on petro fuels is cornered by GoI via this subterfuge.How is GoI to find the resources needed for defence, you might ask, if such cesses are also made shareable. By withdrawing its imperial expansion to state subjects such as healthcare and school education. Using central funds to paint the PM's picture on school walls diverts funds that should fund defence projects or go to the states, which bear the bulk of development expenditure.However, only a part of Kerala's problems can be blamed on skewed federal finance in India. The bulk of the problem is internal, generated by the state's politics, which have been hostile to capitalist prosperity.That is changing now, with ministers of the Left government hailing Adani as a partner. Political parties must educate their student, youth and worker organisations to value and promote entrepreneurship, to respect and encourage honest failure, revising entrenched attitudes to risk.Kerala has a growing startup community, which must be helped to grow, establishing linkages with educational institutions and established industry that is averse to in-house R&D.Kerala's Communists organised successful cooperatives that sported brands such as Dinesh Beedi and Indian Coffee House. Why not bring that nous to bear on electronic assembly? Electronic component manufacturing is waiting to take off in India to replace suspect foreign components in infrastructure and defence, and innovate new capabilities.Encourage young engineering graduates to grab this opportunity instead of migrating to AI-threatened software or flaky Trumpland.It is time for Kerala to convert its vaunted social development into Asian- Tigerish success, shedding inhibitions about capitalist growth. (Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this column are that of the writer. The facts and opinions expressed here do not reflect the views of www.economictimes.com.) Elevate your knowledge and leadership skills at a cost cheaper than your daily tea. Coal on one hand and green on the other; this company balances both
Move over tariffs, China wields rare earths in an economic war of a different kind
Sebi, governing markets for 3 decades, in search of governance rules for itself
The answer to companies not incurring capex may lie in stock markets
Stock Radar: Pole & Flag pattern breakout pushed BEL to record highs in June; stock rallies over 20% in 1 month
Top Nifty50 stocks analysts suggest buying in this volatile week
Stock picks of the week: 5 stocks with consistent score improvement and return potential of more than 25% in 1 year
Insurance sector: Has it reached an inflection point as 'insurance for all' gets on priority list? 8 stocks with upside potential of up to 40%
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
6 hours ago
- Indian Express
‘Flood situation won't arise this year,' says Delhi CM; AAP hits back
With the monsoon nearing, Chief Minister Rekha Gupta issued a 'Flood Control Order 2025' on Wednesday. The order, said officials, will apply to all departments responsible for monsoon management and clearing drains in the Capital — Municipal Corporation of Delhi (MCD), Public Works Department (PWD), Irrigation and Flood Control Department (I&FC) and the Delhi Jal Board (DJB). The order was issued during a meeting of the apex committee on flood control, chaired by Gupta at the Delhi Secretariat, where BJP ministers, MPs, and MLAs were in attendance, along with senior officials from PWD, MCD, DDA, DJB, I&FC, and other civic agencies. 'The Delhi government is fully prepared. Two years ago, there were floods in Delhi. The gates of the barrage did not even open at that time. But I can assure you that flood situation will not arise this time. The government and all departments are fully prepared,' she told reporters after the meeting. Hitting out, the AAP said in a statement, 'CM Gupta truly represents 'Phulera ki Panchayat', as she lacks even basic knowledge about the ITO barrage. The barrage is maintained by the BJP-ruled Haryana government. In 2023, they had to suspend their Chief Engineer for failing to maintain the barrage gates… It is good that… the BJP has now accepted that the ITO barrage gates were indeed the main cause of the 2023 floods.' The order is supposed to serve as an annual guidebook for all departments in case of a flood situation. Sector committees have been formed under the leadership of Cabinet Ministers — Pravesh Sahib Singh, Ashish Sood, and Manjinder Singh Sirsa. Each committee will include three to four district magistrates (DM) responsible for flood management in their respective sectors. A Central Flood Control Room, which will function as a city-wide coordination hub, is set to start on June 15. It has been established at the office of the DM (East), where representatives from all civic bodies will be stationed 24×7. In addition, 14 wireless stations will monitor water levels of the Yamuna and other vulnerable areas continuously. Gupta said if the Yamuna crosses the warning level of 204.5 metres during the monsoon, residents in low-lying areas will be alerted and shifted to safer locations. (with PTI inputs)
The Hindu
7 hours ago
- The Hindu
Increase in anti-dumping duty by U.S. on Indian shrimp a cause for concern
Andhra Pradesh has requested the Government of India (GoI) to solve the problem caused by an increase in anti-dumping duty imposed by the U.S. on Indian shrimps from 1.35% to 3.96% with retrospective effect from 2023-24, which entails a burden of ₹600 crore on seafood exporters from the State. Addressing a press conference here on Wednesday, AP Legislative Assembly Deputy Speaker and State Aquaculture Advisory Committee (SAAC) member K. Raghu Ramakrishna Raju and AP State Aquaculture Development Authority (APSADA) Co-Vice-Chairman Anam Venkata Ramana Reddy said Chief Minister N. Chandrababu Naidu requested the Union Ministers of Finance, and Industry & Commerce to resolve the issues faced by seafood exporters in India by diplomatically engaging with the shrimp importing countries, particularly the U.S. He insisted on inclusion of harmonised system codes of Indian shrimp under the exemption list in order to protect the livelihood of lakhs of farmers and workers, and prevent the collapse of the sector that significantly contributed to the Gross State Domestic Product. SAAC recommendations They said the SAAC studied the issues that cropped up after the U.S. imposed the reciprocal tariffs on seafood exports from India, and came up with short, medium and long-term strategies for sustainability of the sector. The short-term measures included a reduction in the input costs such as lowering the power tariffs, waiver of import duties on brood-stock and feed to ease production pressure, waiver of 5% GST on packaged shrimp to unlock local consumption, stabilising farm gate prices, securing access to the European Union (EU) and small markets, enhancing export compliance by ensuring strict implementation of traceability for the sake of reducing export rejections, and leveraging re-export potential by activating fish re-export hubs and streamlining the port clearances. Mr. Ramakrishna Raju said the medium-term strategies recommended were to enforce 100% registration of farms, tackle trade barriers, promote cluster farm management, and expand product lines by incentivising ready-to-eat / cook shrimp for premium global markets. The long-term strategies included achieving brood-stock sufficiency, species and market diversification, and strengthening bio-security institutional reforms quality compliance. Mr. Venkata Ramana Reddy said the department had completed geo-tagging of all the existing 2.07 lakh aquaculture ponds and 3,800 aquaculture business units in the State and assigned 11-digit unique codes. A traceability app intended to create a digital platform with a central dashboard, real-time monitoring and analytics was in the process of development. APIIC Chairman M. Rama Raju was among others present.
Economic Times
10 hours ago
- Economic Times
Conditioning a cool behavioural move
Agencies In a warming India, ACs are a necessity. Yet, only about 7% of households own one. That's changing fast. 14 mn units were sold last year alone, and residential ownership is projected to grow 9x by mid-century. This surge could require tripling electricity production. But before that, the grid needs protection. In a welcome step, GoI announced on Tuesday that it plans to soon mandate temperature settings between 20° C and 28° C for all ACs - residential, commercial, and even those in vehicles. The move aims to improve energy efficiency, smooth out demand spikes and cut consumer power bills. Many ACs allow settings as low as 16° C and as high as 30° C, encouraging energy 2050, air conditioning could account for a quarter of India's GHG emissions and nearly half of nationwide peak electricity demand, according to UNEP's Cool Coalition. Yet, India has so far declined to sign the coalition's Global Cooling Pledge, which seeks to reduce the sector's climate impact. There is, however, some good news. Consumers are increasingly opting for energy-efficient, star-rated ACs. But high prices remain a significant barrier, especially for lower- and middle-income buyers. A CEEW report, 'Do Residential AC Buyers Prioritise Energy Efficiency?', recommends measures like tax breaks, bulk procurement and cross-brand incentive programmes to improve affordability and encourage wider adoption. The report also highlights another crucial, but often overlooked, factor: good servicing practices (GSPs). Buying an energy-efficient AC is not enough. Without regular servicing, performance declines over the unit's 7-10-year lifespan, undermining expected energy and cost savings. To promote GSPs, awareness campaigns must stress their impact on efficiency. Without this behavioural nudge, tech and policy efforts may not deliver their full potential. Elevate your knowledge and leadership skills at a cost cheaper than your daily tea. Benchmarked with BSE 1000, this index fund will diversify your bets. But at a cost. Yet another battle over neem; this time it's a startup vs. Procter & Gamble Warren Buffett-fan Pabrai is betting big on Edelweiss' Rashesh Shah. Will it pay off? Move over tariffs, China wields rare earths in an economic war of a different kind Stock Radar: MGL trades above upwards sloping trendline, reclaims 100-EMA; check target & stop loss F&O Radar | Deploy Bull Call Spread in GAIL to play a bullish bet These 7 banking stocks can give more than 20% returns in 1 year, according to analysts Being an Amul shareholder is not possible; the next best dairy sector bets: 4 stocks, different market caps, upside potential is incidental
