Sandbanks developer's plans to turn £600,000 garage into tiny £1million Airbnb thwarted for THIRD time
Peter Mullins has tried and failed to get permission to redevelop his 19 foot-wide garage in Poole, Dorset, after buying the property for £600,000 in 2021.
A planning application in 2021 to add two storeys to the garage to create a pair of semi-detached houses was dismissed at appeal. Then in 2022, a conversion and extension to create two flats was also refused.
And in his latest attempt to redevelop the property, Mr Mullins had sought to demolish the garage and turn it into a dwelling to create a £1million Airbnb to 'make his money back' on the expensive garage.
Plans submitted to Bournemouth, Christchurch and Poole Council show the home was set to be in a newly-added pitched roof and would include a double bedroom, a single bedroom, and a dining and living room.
The development would take place just a street away from the iconic Sandbanks beach, where famous residents have included Harry Redknapp, chef Rick Stein and Liam Gallagher.
But the application was rejected by planners earlier this month, who said the proposed windows would be just 1.65m from a home on Panorama Road - where houses sell for an average of £3,922,500, according to Rightmove.
Locals have previously fought against the development with the Sandbanks Neighbourhood Forum writing a letter stating that the plans are 'unacceptable.'
Speaking after the application was rejected, local Wendy Collins, 71, from Poole, Dorset, said: 'I've heard about the garage, and it's a great idea, but I'm not surprised it has been rejected. It is only little.
'It's a shame, really, because I do think it is a really cool idea, and I've never seen that before.'
Mr Mullins had hoped to turn the upstairs into a double bedroom, a single bedroom, and a dining and living room.
The only windows on this floor would be four skylights - one in each bedroom and two in the living space.
He proposed the ground floor would be a small garage with space to park a car and three bikes at the front and a narrow corridor leading to a bathroom and kitchen at the back.
The application had claimed Bournemouth, Christchurch & Poole Council has no grounds to refuse it because the footprint of the building will remain the same.
Property experts said the diminutive home would be too small for a permanent residence and will likely be a holiday bolthole or an Airbnb.
But because of its prized location it would still be worth more than £1m.
In a planning report, a council officer said: 'The gap between the proposed windows and No. 1 Panorama Road is 1.65m. This clearly presents opportunities for overlooking and loss of privacy from these windows. Furthermore, the size of the property is approximately 68 sqm.
'Nationally Described Space Standards sets out that a four-person, two-storey, two-bedroom property should, at a minimum, provide 79 sqm of space.
'This property is capable of providing a 4 person, 2 storey, 2 bedroom property and as such the space provided is not acceptable.'
In a comment submitted to the council ahead of the decision, the Sandbanks Neighbourhood Forum said: 'The Design and Access statement is also out of date, and the precedents are of no relevance. In one instance, the decision which they rely upon has been quashed.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
a day ago
- Daily Mail
Airbnb scam warning after host used computer-generated fake photos to claim £12,000 from guest for property damage
The public is being warned over a new scam after an Airbnb host used AI-edited photos to claim £12,000 from a guest for property damage. The woman had booked a one-bedroom flat in New York earlier this year for two and a half months while she studied in the Big Apple. But the London-based academic left early due to feeling unsafe in the area. But soon after, the host filed a claim accusing her of causing over £12,000 worth of damage, including urinating on a mattress and damaging a coffee table, sofa, microwave, TV, robot vacuum, and air conditioning unit. The woman denied the claims and insisted she had left the flat in good condition, adding she only had two visitors during her seven-week stay. She believes the host retaliated because she ended her stay early. When the host submitted photos to Airbnb showing a cracked wooden coffee table, the guest pointed out inconsistencies in the damage between the images, suggesting they were either digitally altered or AI-generated. When the host submitted photos to Airbnb showing a cracked wooden coffee table The guest pointed out inconsistencies in the damage between the images, suggesting they were either digitally altered or AI-generated It has brought to light how new AI software, which is cheap and easily availabl,e can be used to manipulate images to give false evidence of what has happened in consumer complaints She told the Guardian: 'This should have immediately raised red flags and discredited the host's claims if the evidence had been reviewed with even basic scrutiny, but Airbnb not only failed to identify this obvious manipulation, they entirely ignored my explanations and clear evidence that the material was fabricated.' Initially, Airbnb sided with the host, telling her she owed £5,314. She appealed, offering to provide an eyewitness statement from a friend who was present at checkout, and flagged the visual discrepancies in the images. After her story was brought to life, the platform refunded her £500, but when she threatened she wouldn't rebook with them again. When she then said she was not going to rebook with Airbnb again, the company offered an £854 refund, a fifth of the cost of her booking. She refused and was eventually reimbursed the full amount of £4,269. A negative review left by the host was also removed from her profile. The complainant is listed as a 'superhost' on Airbnb, which according to the site, is experienced and highly rated. He did not respond to a request by the newspaper. Airbnb said he had been warned for violating its terms and told he would be removed if there were another similar report. It apologised and said there would be a review into how her case was handled. Security expert Serpil Hall, director of economic crime at management consultancy Baringa, warned that manipulating images and videos is now 'easier than ever'. She added: 'There's a growing need for forensic tools and fraud intelligence models to verify visual evidence in disputes.'
Daily Mirror
2 days ago
- Daily Mirror
Spanish beach bars demand urgent action as they reveal cost of Brits staying away
The president of the Association of Entrepreneurs of Concessions has demanded that the Balearic government take urgent action to head off this summer's negative results before more businesses and jobs are lost Beach bar owners in one of Spain's most popular resorts say they are facing a dire August and are attributing a lot of the blame to what they call "tourism‑phobia". The lobby group has warned that August, normally a busy month for Majorca, will not produce any sort of boom as tourists watch their spending and stay away from the island en masse. The president of the Association of Entrepreneurs of Concessions has demanded that the Balearic government take urgent action to head off this summer's negative results before more businesses and jobs are lost. The president, Onofre Fornés, says that "results are far below expectations, with July closing with a 20% drop in turnover compared to 2024 and August not looking any better." He argues that high visitor numbers this summer hide the reality, which is a slump caused in part by tourists' falling spending power. The intervention came after some locals said holidaymakers had been 'scared away' from Majorca. Have you been put off taking a holiday in Spain? We'd love to know why. Em ail webtravel@ "The authorities must adopt urgent measures to control the rise in tourist prices, counteract tourism‑phobia and preserve the purchasing power of traditional tourists," Mr Fornés said. "Incomes are not buoyant, costs are rising and the demand for essential services for them such as hammocks and sun loungers is contained." The two key resorts of Playa de Muro and Can Picafort are being singled out as suffering the most. In March, visitors from Majorca's third-largest market, the UK, were down 23.2 % to 48,741. For the Balearics as a whole, the UK fell 25.3 % to 52,170. Other markets showed notable decreases as well, with France down 39.4 % in Majorca and Italy 40.1 %. Mr Fornés has blamed "irresponsible" protestors who send out "negative messages against tourism, "deteriorating the perception of the destination and having a direct impact on the sector's income." Those protesters may not agree with the lobbyist's arguments, however. They have long stressed that the cost of living in Spanish resorts such as the Balearic Islands, as well as the Canary Islands, is too high and the wages they can earn too low. In their eyes, a major part of the problem is the cost of housing, which has been aggravated by the demand for holiday lets such as Airbnbs. Tourism is booming across Europe. George Washington University revealed that in 2024, 747 million travelers visited Europe, more than the population of Europe itself, and this inevitably puts a "strain on local infrastructure, environment, and communities." In Spain, the government is acting. Already this year, it has called for the removal of nearly 66,000 unregulated Airbnb listings and pulled back on social media influencer campaigns that bring selfie tourists to its small and easily overwhelmed beaches. Jessica Harvey, head of press at the Spanish Tourist Office, told the BBC: "We are working with a sustainable tourism model leading with smart technology. We have developed a digital platform that monitors how many people are on beaches, as well as the air quality, sea temperatures, weather and even jellyfish in the water."
Reuters
2 days ago
- Reuters
Airbnb dips as slower growth outlook renews fears of travel demand slowdown
Aug 7 (Reuters) - Shares of Airbnb (ABNB.O), opens new tab slumped 6% before the bell on Thursday after the company forecast slower growth in the second half of the year, disappointing investors of the sector expecting a rebound in travel demand after strong outlooks from major travel firms. The vacation home rental's gloomy outlook came as setback to the industry, which saw a rebound in consumer sentiment in July, and was expecting budget-conscious Americans to return to vacations despite tariffs and inflation. United Airlines (UAL.O), opens new tab and Hilton Worldwide (HLT.N), opens new tab last month forecast an uptick in bookings and strong fourth-quarter revenue growth. Last week, online travel agency Booking Holdings (BKNG.O), opens new tab also posted upbeat quarterly results. "The company (Airbnb) sees tariffs having an impact on margins in the third quarter, with the initial tariffs shock in April leading to a big drop in bookings," said Danni Hewson, head of financial analysis at AJ Bell. Investors will now focus on results from Expedia Group (EXPE.O), opens new tab, due after the bell, to better gauge the health of the travel industry in the United States. Airbnb attributed its weak growth outlook to tough comparisons with the year-ago period, when strong bookings in Asia and Latin America had helped earnings. The company expects night bookings growth to moderate year-over-year going into the fourth quarter. It expects the implied take rate, or the ratio of revenue to gross bookings, to remain flat in the third quarter. So far this year, Airbnb and Expedia shares have both fallen 0.6% each compared with an 11.4% rise in Booking Holdings during the same period. Airbnb commands a higher forward price-to-earnings multiple of 28.41, compared with Booking that's trading at a more modest 22.69 and Expedia at 11.57.
