'Smoke' showrunner reveals why he dropped that major twist in Apple TV Plus' new true crime thriller
Apple TV Plus just dropped the first two episodes of "Smoke," its new true crime thriller starring Taron Egerton and Jurnee Smollett, this morning.
So there's a good chance you haven't seen it yet. If you haven't, then be warned — there are spoilers ahead.
But if you have seen the two-episode premiere or listened to "Firebug," the true crime podcast this show is loosely adapted from, then you know the shocking reveal from the end of episode 2:
Taron Egerton's character, David Gudsen, is an arson investigator who is also a serial arsonist.
To be fair, the show's official trailer doesn't entirely hide this. It avoids showing the reveal directly, but it's clear that Detective Calderone (Jurnee Smollett) thinks her new partner could be a prolific arsonist.
So when I had a chance to sit down with showrunner Dennis Lehane ("The Wire," "Black Bird") to discuss the true crime limited series, I asked him about the choice to drop what would normally be a major reveal so early on in the show.
For his part, Lehane simply doesn't want to deceive audiences just for the sake of shock value. Especially when, if you've already listened to "Firebug" anyway, you know who the arsonist in "Smoke" is likely to be.
We tried the third episode. We tried the second. We tried the first. And second just worked. Because it's not about the twist at all. It's about how deep does this rabbit hole of this guy's mind go, and what are we going to find at the end of it?
"Smoke" showrunner Dennis Lehane
"Audiences are so smart now, man," Lehane rightly pointed out. "I hate shows when I'm sitting there, and I figured it out — I figure [it] out in episode 2, and you're telling me in episode 6? It's annoying."
However, that doesn't mean that the plan was always to go with a reveal at the end of the two-episode premiere. In fact, Lehane and the show's creative team tried multiple options.
"We tried the third episode. We tried the second. We tried the first. And second just worked. Because it's not about the twist at all. It's about how deep does this rabbit hole of this guy's mind go, and what are we going to find at the end of it?"
As someone who has seen "Smoke" and certainly thinks there are more than a few missteps in the miniseries' nine-episode run, I have to agree with the decision to go with a reveal at the end of episode 2.
For starters, any further really would feel like the show is just dragging it out.
But given the premiere's two-episode structure, it also leaves you on a high note. You walk away from the episode desperate to see what's next now that you know the cat-and-mouse game between Calderone and Gudsen is afoot.
As I've already mentioned on more than one occasion, "Smoke" is a true crime thriller miniseries based on the true crime podcast "Firebug."
That podcast examined the life and crimes of John Leonard Orr, one of the most prolific arsonists in history.
In this show, showrunner Dennis Lehane has opted for a fictional stand-in, Pacific Northwest arson investigator Dave Gudsen (Taron Egerton). Along with Detective Michell Calderone (Jurnee Smollett), he's part of a team chasing down a pair of serial arsonists.
But as you now know, one of the people they're chasing is really Gudsen, and the show is, to quote Lehane, "not about the twist at all." Instead, this show is a deep dive into the mind of more than a few twisted individuals as they investigate a spate of arson cases that lead to more than a few deaths.
Stream the first two episodes of "Smoke" on Apple TV Plus now
'The Life of Chuck' star discusses screening film with director Mike Flanagan, his favorite performances from the Stephen King adaptation and more
I just saw one of my favorite movies in theaters for its 40th anniversary — but you can stream it for free right now
Tom Hardy's 'MobLand' just wrapped up with a stunning finale — and I can't wait for a season 2
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBS News
19 minutes ago
- CBS News
North Philadelphia shooting leaves 26-year-old man dead, police say
A 26-year-old man was shot multiple times and killed in North Philadelphia on Sunday afternoon, police said. The shooting happened on the 2400 block of North Reese Street at around 2:30 p.m., according to police. Police said the 26-year-old was shot multiple times and taken to Temple University Hospital, where he was pronounced dead at 3:01 p.m. So far, no arrests have been made, and the motive for the shooting remains unclear. The shooting is under investigation.
Yahoo
19 minutes ago
- Yahoo
TikTok Publishes New Guide for Home Decor Marketers
This story was originally published on Social Media Today. To receive daily news and insights, subscribe to our free daily Social Media Today newsletter. TikTok has published a new guide to home décor trends in the app, and how marketers can tap into discovery behaviors to maximize their home living promotions. The 16-page guide includes overviews of rising trends, as well as usage statistics that relate to home décor engagement in the app, as well as info on TikTok ad products that can help you reach the right audience at the right time. You can download the full guide for yourself here (with e-mail sign-up), but in this post, we'll take a look at some of the key notes. First off, the guide looks at rising home décor trends: As explained by TikTok: 'TikTok has become more than a source of home inspiration - it's where decisions are made and purchases happen. Research shows that 77% of users have recently bought household care items, and nearly half say they're open to buying consumer packaged goods directly on the platform. The timing couldn't be better for brands. Major life moments like moving, renovating, or reorganizing often result in new habits, and TikTok users going through these transitions are especially receptive to discovering and trying new products.' The guide also looks at TikTok's various promotional offerings on this front: While there's also a timeline overview of the optimal times to launch your TikTok ad campaigns: There's also a listing of key creative tips for your home décor videos, which also relate to pretty much any TikTok clip: These are some handy notes and pointers, which could help you refine your TikTok marketing strategy, with, again, most of these notes relating to pretty much any niche and product. Some interesting considerations either way. You can download TikTok's full 'Home Refresh with TikTok' guide here.
Yahoo
20 minutes ago
- Yahoo
"You see him look like a homeless person and then the next game a rockstar" - Robert Parish on why playing with Dennis Rodman bizzare
"You see him look like a homeless person and then the next game a rockstar" - Robert Parish on why playing with Dennis Rodman bizzare originally appeared on Basketball Network. Everyone who encountered Dennis Rodman during his active years in the NBA will have different ways of describing him. But one thing that will stick out is that he was a wildcard, unpredictable and impossible to figure out. Advertisement Whether on the court or off it, Rodman existed in his own chaotic orbit, and for a player like Robert Parish, whose game and lifestyle thrived on structure, silence and dependability, those few months they shared in Chicago left an unforgettable mark. Rodman's personality Parish joined the Chicago Bulls in the 1996–97 season, at age 43, already a three-time champion with Boston and a nine-time NBA All-Star. He was near the twilight, content to anchor the bench behind Luc Longley, offer leadership and quietly chase a fourth ring. Rodman, on the other hand, was deep in the most colorful chapter of his post-Detroit Pistons life, swerving from court dominance to Vegas trips between games, with hair changing almost every week. The two coexisted on one of the greatest teams in NBA history, yet their personalities couldn't have been more distant. Advertisement "He looks like a homeless person," Parish said of Rodman. "You never know that though. People on the outside never knew that. You see him look like a homeless person and then the next game a rockstar … He's one of the strangest personalities to ever be around." That was his description, delivered years later with the kind of baffled respect that follows a man like Rodman wherever he goes. It was never about basketball IQ or toughness; Rodman had both in spades. But for veterans like Parish, who had come up in an era ruled by order and repetition, being around Rodman's mercurial energy was like learning a new language on the fly. Rodman would arrive at practice looking like he had been sleeping in a subway tunnel, clothes askew, hair wild and eyes unreadable. But once the game tipped, he'd rebound like a man possessed, log 40 minutes with elite defensive rotations and dive into the crowd with zero concern for his limbs. Advertisement In that 1996–97 season, The Worm led the NBA in rebounds for a sixth straight year, averaging 16.1 per game. He was 35 years old and still out-jumping 25-year-olds, still creating second-chance possessions, still wreaking havoc in the paint. His contribution to that Bulls squad, which finished with a 69–13 record and went on to win its fifth title, was monumental. But the cost of that brilliance was often absorbed in the locker room, where the team had to endure his quirks, his abrupt absences and the sheer unpredictability of his presence. Related: "After much consideration, I am now prepared to rule" - When Utah judge ruled Michael Jordan pushed off in his final shot in '98 The calm giant and the chaos storm For Parish, who had a stoic demeanor and ability to lead without speaking much, adjusting to Rodman's rhythm was tough in all senses. Advertisement The Boston Celtics icon had shared locker rooms with Larry Bird and Kevin McHale and helped shepherd a young Golden State Warriors squad before that. But nothing quite prepared him for the circus that followed Rodman, whose off-court choices often made headlines faster than his rebounds. Whether it was the high-profile relationships in the early '90s, the impromptu wedding dress photoshoot to promote his autobiography, "Bad As I Wanna Be," or the 1997 mid-Finals Vegas bender with Hulk Hogan, he was constantly pushing the boundaries of what the league and teammates could tolerate. Yet the brilliance never faded. Rodman knew how to get under opponents' skin without fouling out, how to front-post players twice his size and still win the rebound battle, how to screen and cut and disappear into the margins of a play until it mattered. He was a master of the little things and that's where Parish had no choice but to respect him. Advertisement But it was also draining. The Bulls had veterans. Scottie Pippen knew how to navigate Rodman's mood swings. Jordan, by then on his fifth title mission, had already accepted that Rodman was a necessary inconvenience. But for Parish, who was new to that Bulls ecosystem, it took some recalibrating. He wasn't alone. Even Phil Jackson would find ways to work Rodman's instability into his triangle offense and mindfulness rituals. And still, the team kept winning. Parish played just 43 games that season and saw limited minutes in the playoffs. But he got his fourth and final ring, an elegant bookend to a Hall of Fame career. Rodman, true to form, got another championship, another year of leading the league in rebounds and another reason to believe that his methods, however bizarre, worked. Advertisement Related: "One of the most interesting personalities" - Robert Parish on how playing with Dennis Rodman made the Chicago dynasty feel a lot different than Boston's This story was originally reported by Basketball Network on Jul 6, 2025, where it first appeared.
