logo
A Study Reaffirms Opinion Trading on Platforms like Probo is a Game of Skill

A Study Reaffirms Opinion Trading on Platforms like Probo is a Game of Skill

Hindustan Times20-05-2025

Gaming Industry Booms : India's online gaming market, valued at USD 4 billion in 2023, is projected to reach USD 7.6 billion by 2028, growing at a CAGR of 14.5%—with real-money games accounting for over 80% of the market share.
Opinion Trading on the Rise : With nearly 50 million users and annual transactions exceeding USD 6 billion, opinion trading is gaining momentum—yet misconceptions persist.
New Study Breaks Myths: Using empirical testing and real-world platform data, the report concludes that opinion trading is a skill-dominant format, not governed by chance.
A study conducted by Evam Law & Policy has concluded that opinion trading is a game of skill. The Question of Skill in Opinion Trading Study, draws upon gameplay data from three leading Indian opinion trading platforms to present robust statistical and behavioral evidence that opinion trading demands informed decision-making, cognitive adaptability, and strategic execution. This study is backed by some reputed personalities including IIT Delhi Professor Dr. Saptarshi Mukherjee, Dean of Vinayaka Mission's Law School Dr. Ananth Padmanabhan, and has been reviewed by Dr. Justice Balbir Singh Chauhan - retired as a justice of the Supreme Court of India, and former Chairman of the 21st Law Commission of India.
This comes at a time when the Indian gaming industry is seeing exponential growth. With over 568 million gamers, India is the second-largest gaming community in the world. Real Money Games (RMGs) dominate this space, and new formats like opinion trading have already reached impressive scale, USD 120 million in projected revenues for FY 2024–25 and backing from over 35 global investors.
Yet, the report observes misconceptions that persist around opinion trading, often equating it to games of chance or speculative betting. To address this, the study applied three key statistical tests commonly used to determine skill presence in online games: Key Findings from the study: Persistence of Skill : Players who performed well in one month continued to perform well in subsequent months across platforms. For example, on Probo, win rate and ROI correlations across months showed p-values less than 10^-100, indicating extraordinarily strong consistency—something not possible in games of chance.
: Players who performed well in one month continued to perform well in subsequent months across platforms. For example, on Probo, win rate and ROI correlations across months showed p-values less than 10^-100, indicating extraordinarily strong consistency—something not possible in games of chance. Exemplary Skill : Statistical distributions showed heavy right-skewness, suggesting the presence of a small group of highly skilled users consistently outperforming others. For example, on an opinion trading platform, 12.7% of users exceeded a 79%-win rate, while a chance-based simulation showed only 0.01% doing the same. A Z-test confirmed this difference to be statistically significant.
: Statistical distributions showed heavy right-skewness, suggesting the presence of a small group of highly skilled users consistently outperforming others. For example, on an opinion trading platform, 12.7% of users exceeded a 79%-win rate, while a chance-based simulation showed only 0.01% doing the same. A Z-test confirmed this difference to be statistically significant. Learning Curve & Experience Gap : Players demonstrably improved their performance with experience. On Probo, median win rates increased with the number of events played, with correlation tests rejecting the hypothesis of no learning. Similar trends were observed on the other 2 opinion trading platforms.
: Players demonstrably improved their performance with experience. On Probo, median win rates increased with the number of events played, with correlation tests rejecting the hypothesis of no learning. Similar trends were observed on the other 2 opinion trading platforms. Strategic Use of Exit Tools Drives Higher Win Rates : Players who actively used exit strategies—choosing to close positions early based on real-time market shifts—secured a 70% win rate, compared to just 42% among those who passively waited for event outcomes. To summarize, players with exit strategies won 70% of the time, vs just 42% among those without. This demonstrates the importance of active, tactical engagement in opinion trading.
: Players who actively used exit strategies—choosing to close positions early based on real-time market shifts—secured a 70% win rate, compared to just 42% among those who passively waited for event outcomes. Experience Leads to Sophisticated Market Behavior : The study also highlights that users with >250 trades placed 2X more strategic price-point trades than beginners, showing nuanced market behavior. This reflects a deeper understanding of market dynamics, as seasoned players diversified positions across fluctuating price bands to hedge risk or capitalize on market inefficiencies.
: The study also highlights that users with >250 trades placed 2X more strategic price-point trades than beginners, showing nuanced market behavior. This reflects a deeper understanding of market dynamics, as seasoned players diversified positions across fluctuating price bands to hedge risk or capitalize on market inefficiencies. Strategic Behavior: Skilled players were found to diversify trades, hedge across price points, and time their exits. For instance, users placing orders across 12+ price points recovered over 80% of their investment on average, reflecting active market reading, analysis and informed decision making. Many players also seem to use a combination of these strategies, with them placing multiple orders and exiting before the conclusion of the event. Such players on Probo have a win rate of 63%, again demonstrating their strategic behavior to maximize returns.
About the findings of the report, Ashish Garg, Co-founder and CTO of Probo, said, 'This report is a significant step forward in establishing a data-backed understanding of opinion trading. For years, we've seen firsthand how our top users display a deep grasp of probability, real-time decision-making, and strategic foresight. We're glad that independent researchers have validated what our internal data has long shown—success in opinion trading is built on skill, not luck."
Shashank Reddy, Managing Partner - Evam Law & Policy shared, "Opinion trading sits at the intersection of market-based reasoning and digital gameplay. This study provides much-needed empirical clarity to an emerging format that has often been misunderstood. The evidence shows that these platforms reward strategy, experience, deep knowledge, and skill development. Importantly, this study offers a crucial policy contribution amid ongoing debates over the legal classification of emerging digital games. Under Indian law, games of skill enjoy protection and are treated differently from games of chance. By rigorously applying the "predominance test', recognized by Indian courts, the study affirms that opinion trading falls firmly within the skill-dominant category.'
As the Indian gaming sector evolves, this study offers a foundation for nuanced regulation, informed public discourse, and better industry practices.
To access the full study- click here
Disclaimer: This article is sponsored content curated by HT Syndication. The inputs and details accounted for in the article do not necessarily reflect those of HT, and HT does not endorse or assume any responsibility for the information provided.
Want to get your story featured as above? click here!
First Published Date: 20 May, 15:17 IST

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

After Air India crash, activists warn of bird threat from 'illegal' meat shops near Navi Mumbai airport
After Air India crash, activists warn of bird threat from 'illegal' meat shops near Navi Mumbai airport

Time of India

time18 minutes ago

  • Time of India

After Air India crash, activists warn of bird threat from 'illegal' meat shops near Navi Mumbai airport

NEW DELHI: The deadly in Ahmedabad has brought fresh scrutiny to illegal meat shops operating near the under-construction Navi Mumbai International Airport (NMIA), a social organisation has said. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now Despite a warning from India's aviation regulator, the Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA), these shops continue to function, the group claimed, according to news agency PTI. The concern centres on the potential for bird strikes caused by the slaughter and sale of meat in close proximity to the airport. Two Indian carriers, IndiGo and Aksa Air, have already announced plans to shift part of their operations to the Navi Mumbai airport once it opens — expected in August. The Navi Mumbai International Airport is being developed by NMIAL, a joint venture between Adani Airport Holdings Ltd (AAHL) and the City and Industrial Development Corporation of Maharashtra (CIDCO), with a 74:26 shareholding ratio. NGO NatConnect, which has repeatedly flagged the issue of meat sales and slaughter in Ulwe — an area within three kilometres of the airport site — has once again raised an alarm, citing safety concerns. It has urged the DGCA to press local authorities to address the matter urgently. 'The slaughter attracts big birds, such as kites, which can pose threats to the aircraft operations,' said NatConnect director B N Kumar in a statement. The renewed concern comes in the wake of the Air India crash, in which a Boeing 787-8 Dreamliner, carrying 242 people, went down in Ahmedabad's Meghaninagar area shortly after take-off on Thursday. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now All 270 people onboard, including 12 crew members, were killed. Investigators are probing the cause of the crash, and a bird strike is among the possible reasons being explored. Kumar said that the aviation regulator had previously acknowledged the issue. 'The aerodrome operator has been advised to act against the slaughter that can attract birds,' the DGCA said in response to an earlier complaint. However, Kumar alleged that "there has been no action against the illegal slaughter of animals and the open sale of mutton and chicken." The NGO also pointed to a recent notice from the Aeronautical Information Service (AIS), which is run by the Airports Authority of India (AAI). The NOTAM — or Notice to Airmen — flagged 'lack of operational readiness' at the upcoming airport, but, according to NatConnect, it did not mention the illegal slaughter in its risk assessments. The NOTAM did list 225 obstacles around the airport site, including 86 buildings, 79 hilltops, 23 power transmission towers, 12 mobile towers and eight floodlight poles. The Maharashtra government, through its Aerodrome Environment Monitoring Committee (AEMC) chaired by CIDCO, has already issued a directive banning slaughter activities within a 10-km radius of the airport, the NGO said. Kumar said that after raising the issue with the Airports Authority of India, he was told the matter had been passed on to relevant officials at NMIAL. However, no action has been taken so far by CIDCO, which administers the Ulwe area. "We have drawn the attention of CIDCO's chief vigilance officer over such a grave lapse (10-km radius norm)," he added.

Sanjay Raut's dig at Donald Trump on Iran-Israel conflict: 'Why not stop the war?'
Sanjay Raut's dig at Donald Trump on Iran-Israel conflict: 'Why not stop the war?'

Hindustan Times

time30 minutes ago

  • Hindustan Times

Sanjay Raut's dig at Donald Trump on Iran-Israel conflict: 'Why not stop the war?'

Shiv Sena (UBT) MP Sanjay Raut on Sunday took a dig at Donald Trump over his claim that he stopped India and Pakistan's conflict, asking why the US president is unable to stop the "Iran-Israel" war. India had rejected Trump's claim, saying the ceasefire understanding between India and Pakistan was achieved after the nation's DGMO called his Indian counterpart. "Such a war is going on, when I watch images, I get scared, and I feel pity for the dead. Israel and Iran are both nuclear states. Why is US President Trump not stopping the war? The way President Donald Trump forced India and Prime Minister Narendra Modi to stop the war in the name of trade, and is saying repeatedly that the war would have been harmful, as both India and Pakistan have nuclear weapons," Sanjay Raut was quoted as saying by the news agency ANI. Also read: Israel strikes Iran's gas fields: Why is South Pars indispensable for Tehran? "Both Israel and Iran have nuclear weapons, and they've started using them. Neither the Iranian President (Masoud Pezeshkian) nor the Israeli PM, Netanyahu, is ready to listen. Both nations say that they are fighting for their dignity, so we also started a war against terrorism. Why did President Trump stop our war? And why did we back off under Trump's pressure?" he added. Also read: Donald Trump warns Iran: 'Full might of US military will come down on you if…' Iran and Israel have been firing salvos at each other since Friday, when Tel Aviv attacked Tehran's nuclear installations and killed a bunch of its nuclear scientists. Iran also attacked Iran, with many of its projectiles reaching their targets despite the Israeli forces' Iron Dome defence system. Questioning Prime Minister Narendra Modi's foreign visits, Raut said, 'PM Modi's war was stopped by Trump. How come Modi can stop a war? Now, PM Modi is going to Canada, Cyprus, and Croatia, where he will give speeches.' Pakistan attacked India's civilian and military buildings after New Delhi's Operation Sindoor targeting terrorist bases in Pakistan and Pakistan-occupied Kashmir. After a four-day skirmish, Pakistan's DGMO, rattled by India's precision strikes on the nation's air bases, called up his Indian counterpart and urged for a ceasefire understanding. With inputs from ANI

Might end up dead: Minnesota shooter's text before killing lawmaker, wife
Might end up dead: Minnesota shooter's text before killing lawmaker, wife

India Today

timean hour ago

  • India Today

Might end up dead: Minnesota shooter's text before killing lawmaker, wife

The suspect in the Minnesota shooting in the US, Vance Boelter, 57 -- which left a lawmaker and her husband dead, and another lawmaker and his wife injured on Saturday -- had texted his roommates that he would be gone for a long time and might end up dead, adding that he had "made some bad choices.""David and Ron, I love you guys. I've made some choices and you guys don't know anything about this, but I'm going to be gone for a while. I may be dead shortly. So I just want to let you know that I love you guys both. And wish it hand's gone this way. I don't want to say anything more, and implicate you in any way because you guys don't know anything about this, but I love you guys and I'm sorry for all the trouble this has caused," he was quoted by Fox 9 as telling his roommates in the hours leading up to the who has worked in security operations for most of his life, had been impersonating a police officer while carrying out the crime. According to reports, he was in a vehicle with sirens and had a manifesto with the names of several lawmakers, including the ones he shot, as targets. The FBI has released photos of Boelter wearing a rubber mask in a police-like uniform and offered a reward of up to USD 50,000 for information leading to his arrest and a massive operation led by the FBI to arrest Boelter is underway, the motive behind the attacks remains early Saturday, former Minnesota House Speaker Melissa Hortman and her husband, Mark, were shot and killed in their Brooklyn Park home by a man posing as a police officer. Just hours later, State Senator John Hoffman and his wife were wounded in a similar attack at their Champlin residence. Authorities say both lawmakers were named in writings found in a fake police SUV used by the from Reuters

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store