Minister Priyank Kharge says Savarkar first propagated two-nation theory, cites Ambedkar
Bengaluru, Aug 17 (PTI) Karnataka Minister Priyank Kharge has claimed that the concept of two nations in India was first articulated by Vinayak Damodar Savarkar, much before it was adopted by Muhammad Ali Jinnah and the Muslim League.
'In 'Essentials of Hindutva' (written in 1922), Savarkar defines Hindutva not by religion, but by homeland, India as both 'Fatherland and Holyland',' he stated.
Kharge pointed out that during the Hindu Mahasabha's 19th session in Ahmedabad in 1937, Savarkar had said, 'There are two antagonistic nations living side by side in India. India cannot be assumed today to be a unitarian and homogenous nation. On the contrary there are two nations in the main: the Hindus and the Moslems, in India.' He further cited Savarkar's remarks in 1943 at Nagpur: 'I have no quarrel with Mr Jinnah's two-nation theory. We, Hindus, are a nation by ourselves, and it is a historical fact that Hindus and Muslims are two nations.' Questioning whether the BJP acknowledges this history, Kharge quoted B R Ambedkar's observation, 'Strange as it may appear, Mr Savarkar and Mr Jinnah, instead of being opposed to each other, on the one nation versus two nations issue are in complete agreement about it. Both not only agree, but insist that there are two nations in India — one the Muslim nation and the other Hindu nation. They differ only as regards the terms and conditions on which the two nations must live.' Kharge, son of Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge, made the remarks on Partition Horrors Remembrance Day, highlighting ideological links between Hindutva leaders and the two-nation theory.
The post drew sharp responses from users on the platform. PTI GMS ADB
This report is auto-generated from PTI news service. ThePrint holds no responsibility for its content.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News18
41 minutes ago
- News18
Karnataka Assembly passes bills on Child Marriage, Devadasi system
Bengaluru, Aug 18 (PTI) The Karnataka Assembly on Monday passed two significant bills — the Prohibition of Child Marriage Amendment Bill and the Devadasi Bill. Both were presented by the state Woman and Child Welfare Minister Laxmi Hebbalkar. The Prohibition of Child Marriage Amendment Bill makes 'attempt and preparation to make engagement of a child punishable by rigorous imprisonment, which may extend to two years or with fine, which may extend to Rs one lakh or with both". The objective of the Karnataka Devadasi (Prevention, Prohibition, Relief and Rehabilitation) Bill is to raise awareness in the society about the practice of dedicating women as Devadasis, liberate oppressed Devadasi women from all forms of exploitation and their children from social taboo through empowerment. Apart from them, bills pertaining to fire force, tourism and cooperation were also cleared. PTI GMS GMS ROH view comments First Published: August 18, 2025, 22:00 IST Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Loading comments...
India Today
41 minutes ago
- India Today
Why Goa says no to plaster idols of Ganesh
Ahead of August 27, when Ganesh Chaturthi, the most popular festival in Maharashtra and Goa, begins this year, the Goa government has banned the import, transportation and sale of Ganesh idols made from plaster of Paris (PoP) citing its adverse effects on public health and the environment. In South Goa, the district collectorate has issued a memorandum asking deputy collectors to monitor the situation, enforce the government's directive, and file complaints in court against violators under relevant sections of the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986. Chitrashalas—the workshops where Ganesh idols are crafted and given finishing touches—are being inspected, says Egna Cleetus, Collector, South Goa Goa Pollution Control Board, too, is taking samples from the chitrashalas to check for the presence of PoP in idols, with or without clay, in the making and crafting of idols. No PoP traces have been detected so several PoP idols were being brought in from neighbouring states for sale in Goa during the Ganesh festival, the state government's department of environment and climate change notes in its directive that the idols manufactured from hydrated calcium sulphate by the calcification process harm the environment as they do not dissolve or disintegrate fast enough after immersion in water. Moreover, the chemical paints and dyes applied on the idols include toxic substances such as mercury, zinc oxide, chromium, lead and cadmium, which harm marine life. These are carcinogenic to humans when worship in Maharashtra used to be a modest, private ritual, with small, hand-crafted idols made from local clay, until 1893-94, when, following a series of Hindu-Muslim riots, Lokmanya Bal Gangadhar Tilak elevated the festival to a public spectacle. The most popular festival among both Muslims and Hindus in the 19th-century Bombay presidency had been Muharram. In Pune, the taziyas or taboots representing the tombs of the martyrs of the battle of Karbala were installed in the wadas (mansions) of prominent aristocratic families like the Rastes, the Khasgiwales and the Kunjirs. Tilak wrote against the British government's moves to curb Muharram processions during the bubonic plague epidemic. There is a photograph of the nationalist leader participating in one such procession at the Budhwar Chowk in Pune in 1892. The scholar 'Ahitagni' Shankar Ramchandra Rajwade writes how the Brahmin Bhikobadada Agashe, a renowned wrestler in the Lokhande Talim in Pune, would don the attire of a malang (Muslim faqir) and perform the lezim before the taziya procession of the Ghodepir dargah in Pune, with his disciples. The Ghodepir procession was so revered and popular that a bullock cart used to move around with it to collect the revdis (a sweet) showered on it by bystanders and with Hindus refusing to commemorate Muharram due to sectarian tensions, the number of taboots in Pune fell to around 50-75 in 1894 from a much higher 400 the previous year and Tilak began promoting the celebration of Ganesh Utsav, which soon replaced Muharram in its popularity among the masses. Though many credit Bhau Lakshman Javale a.k.a. Bhausaheb Rangari for launching the celebration, Tilak's massive popularity and mass contact helped popularise it. Soon it spread to the neighbouring states such as Goa and Karnataka, which have organic cultural and economic linkages with shift to plaster idols has its origins in tinsel town. The movie Navrang (1959), produced and directed by the legendary V. Shantaram, featured a 11-feet Ganpati idol, crafted in-house by his Rajkamal Kalamandir studio, in a dance scene depicting the Holi festival. This idol was later immersed ceremoniously, says his son Kiran Shantaram. Idols worshipped at the public Ganesh mandals used to be much smaller in comparison, but this trend of installing huge PoP idols gradually caught on. Gradually, even households switched to these and environmentalists note that PoP pollutes water sources and enters the human food chain through seafood. PoP is made by heating gypsum to remove water, resulting in a powder that hardens when mixed with water. A 2023 study on the Tapi river, which runs through Maharashtra's northern edge, found a clear correlation between PoP idol immersion and degraded water quality. The paints often contain toxic metals like lead and cadmium. PoP itself may take months—or even years—to dissolve, raising water hardness and harming aquatic life. The PoP clogs the burrows of fish and crabs, damages mangrove roots, and is blamed for affecting the breeding of Bombay duck, sponges and other marine annual use of PoP across Maharashtra is about 4,500 tonnes, with Mumbai alone accounting for 675 tonnes, notes the 2023 study. PoP and clay idols from Pen in Raigad district and nearby areas like Hamrapur, Tambadseth, Johe, Kalave and Dadar are exported to states like Goa and Gujarat, and even others say PoP idols are cheaper and lighter than those made of clay, leading to the end consumers preferring them. The idols are also said to be durable and 2000, the rationalist and anti-superstition group Maharashtra Andhashraddha Nirmulan Samiti (MANS) launched a campaign in Kolhapur seeking to dissuade citizens from immersing plaster idols in the Rankala lake, but its activists faced a wall of opposition. In 2005, the late Narendra Dabholkar of MANS filed a PIL with the Aurangabad bench of the Bombay High Court. On January 30, the court, in an interim order, instructed the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) and other civic bodies in Maharashtra to strictly enforce the Central Pollution Control Board's (CPCB) 2020 guidelines—against the use and immersion of PoP idols, even in artificial tanks, during the Maghi Ganeshutsav (January-February).On June 9, the court modified its order, allowing the manufacture and sale of PoP idols, albeit with a caveat that they cannot be immersed in natural water bodies. This followed a submission by a CPCB expert panel that clarified the 2020 guidelines were advisory, not binding. In May, the state government's Rajiv Gandhi Science and Technology Commission had also submitted a report to the high court on eco-friendly approaches to the immersion of Ganesh idols, and strategies to minimise pollution of water bodies like the use of smaller idols and eco-friendly July 24, a bench of Chief Justice Alok Aradhe and Justice Sandeep Marne cleared the decks for the immersion of only those idols exceeding the height of 6 feet in natural water bodies. All idols below the height of 6 feet shall be immersed only in artificial water tanks. The court's order will prevail until March to India Today Magazine- Ends
Mint
an hour ago
- Mint
Faster approvals for critical minerals, but no green law exemption: Centre
New Delhi, Aug 18 (PTI) The Environment Ministry has set up a separate category on its online clearance portal to speed up approvals for mining projects involving critical minerals, a move aimed at boosting domestic supply of resources considered essential for clean energy and advanced technologies, the government informed Parliament on Monday. In a written reply in the Lok Sabha, Minister of State for Environment Kirti Vardhan Singh said the Mines Ministry had in February requested faster clearances for such projects, following which the new facility was added to the Parivesh 2.0 portal on March 13. The step comes after amendments to the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957, which gave the Centre powers to auction 24 minerals identified as critical and strategic. These include lithium, nickel, tungsten, titanium and graphite, which India largely imports but needs for sectors such as defence, electronics and renewable energy. So far, 34 blocks of these minerals have been auctioned across the country, the minister said, adding they are vital to meeting India's goal of becoming self-reliant in key materials for the energy transition and its net zero target for 2070. Singh also said that projects will not get any exemption from the Forest Conservation Act, 1980, or the Environment Impact Assessment (EIA) Notification, 2006. The new sub-category on the portal has only been created to improve monitoring of proposals that need central approval under the forest law, he said. He also informed the House that detailed guidelines were issued on March 17, 2025, for linear projects such as highways and railways. These allow the extraction of more than 20,000 cubic metres of ordinary earth without a separate environmental clearance, subject to conditions laid down under the amended EIA rules. According to him, the time limits for considering terms of reference and environment clearance applications remain unchanged under the EIA notification. State governments will continue to play the lead role in protecting forests and wildlife, including demarcation and digitisation of boundaries and action against violations. Joint Forest Management Committees and eco-development groups are also involved in monitoring, while breaches of the forest law attract penalties under the Van (Sanrakshan Evam Samvardhan) Adhiniyam, 1980. The Union Cabinet in January this year cleared the National Critical Mineral Mission, which covers exploration, mining, processing and recovery of these minerals from end-of-life products. The mission is intended to secure supplies of minerals that India currently depends on a few countries for and to provide a quicker regulatory pathway for projects in this sector.
