Wyoming Supreme Court maintains that convicted thief must pay thousands in restitution
Timothy Duke was one of five co-defendants arrested in connection with an investigation of the burglary of three Cheyenne homes in December of that year.
Under a plea agreement, Duke pleaded guilty to the aggravated burglary charge and prosecutors dismissed the theft charge, according to court documents. The parties recommended a sentence of not less than five years and not more than eight years of imprisonment, and Duke agreed to pay restitution, jointly and individually, with his co-defendants.
The homes that were burglarized — owned by Joseph Walsh — housed rare coins, police memorabilia and firearms. They were primarily used for storage.
Walsh was the only witness called to the stand at Duke's restitution hearing. He described his properties, saying one house he had inherited from his late mother. He stored her coins, guns, collectibles and a 'substantial amount of cash' at the property.
The second home held the entire unsold inventory from a coin shop Walsh had previously owned, according to court documents. The third home Walsh inherited from his father. He considered it a secondary residence. That property held cash, collectibles and personal effects.
When Walsh arrived to pick up mail from one of his properties in December of 2023, he found the front door had been left ajar, and the place had been 'ransacked.' Household items were missing and piles of stuff had been left around the house, according to court documents.
He later visited another property to find it in the same condition.
He then called the Cheyenne Police Department to report the stolen items, including missing cash, collectible coins, silver dollars, more than 70 firearms, various trade tokens and antique Wyoming police badges, according to court documents.
The entire restitution claim equaled $507,000. Walsh did not request restitution for the missing coin shop inventory, and prosecutors were only seeking restitution for 'calculable' items that had not been returned.
In court, prosecutors presented a large binder containing 880 pages of receipts to demonstrate how much work Walsh had put into organizing the mess and assessing the loss. Walsh and his wife, Denise Parrish, had not kept a complete inventory of the items in storage and had to sort through their remaining belongings to determine what was stolen.
Following the restitution hearing, the district court received an amended pre-sentence investigation report and victim impact statement from Parrish, which confirmed that only a small amount of the stolen property was recovered.
The court ultimately ordered Duke to serve five to eight years in prison and pay the more than half-a-million dollars in restitution, along with his co-defendants, according to court documents.
Duke appealed the District Court's ruling based on claims that 'Walsh never fully articulated what had been retrieved by police and what was still missing,' and that Walsh was only able to provide estimated values for the items stolen.
Since Walsh adjusted his restitution claim to account for the returned items and had personal expertise regarding the remaining missing items, the Wyoming Supreme Court found that 'there was sufficient evidence to sustain the district court's findings with respect to restitution.'
Additionally, the state Supreme Court ruled that the district court had not abused its discretion, which was the basis of Duke's appeal.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
30 minutes ago
- Yahoo
State auditor releases full report on Mesalands Community College
Jul. 14—A state auditor's report into Mesalands Community College in Tucumcari dating back several years found the school's spending at one point put it in danger of shutting down. The report found the college submitted inaccurate fiscal reports and increased salaries for certain high-level staff members, among other examples of financial mismanagement. It also scrutinized the school's contracting process on at least two occasions and that the president had hired family members. The New Mexico Office of the State Auditor intervened in 2023 and plans to assist the college until 2028. The auditor predicts that by next year, the college could be financially stable. However, the auditor's office said the situation at Mesalands could have been caught earlier and pointed the finger at the state's Higher Education Department (NMHED) for not recognizing the issues at the school sooner. "While inaccurate reporting was provided to NMHED over many years, NMHED did not take action or begin to request the necessary corrective measures from the college until November 2022," State Auditor Joseph Maestas said in an interview last week. "This delay in oversight allowed the college to continue operating without the required financial transparency and independent oversight for a significant period." In a letter obtained by the Journal sent to NMHED Secretary Stephanie Rodriguez, Maestas said the "audit determined that the statutory authority of NMHED was significantly undermined" and also that he "strongly urge(s) the implementation of robust review and verification protocols to independently confirm the accuracy of financial reports submitted by higher education institutions across the state." "Who's to blame here? I think it's a draw, and that's the way that this is posed, but our letter to NMHED is we're telling them, 'Hey, this happened on your watch, and you guys really need to double-check the breath and the substance of your oversight of higher education institutions across the state,'" Maestas said. He also thinks it's possible the agency dropped the ball in Silver City, failing to provide adequate oversight to Western New Mexico University, where its former president, Joseph Shepard, was hit with an investigation in 2024 by the auditor's office — and a subsequent lawsuit from the state's ethics commission — for "lavish" spending. NMHED acknowledged the letter Monday and said that it "provided governance and financial oversight for the college to address the concerns." "The New Mexico Higher Education Department fully supports the concerns outlined in the audit and in the letter from the Office of the State Auditor, as we have been collaborating on this effort for some time now," NMHED spokesperson Auriella Ortiz said in a statement. The repot found that the college awarded a contract to a company owned by someone employed by the school, and another contract was awarded to a company owned by the spouse of someone who was a high level employee of the college's, both raising concerns about conflict of interest. Additionally, the report said that then-President Gregg Busch hired his wife and son to positions at the university — raising the question of nepotism — and that he also took multiple trips of "questionable value" to the college. The report also states that at one point, the school's financial health reached the point of "insolvency," and conversations took place about Eastern New Mexico University taking over the community college, which Eastern New Mexico confirmed on Monday. The state auditor said that the sale likely would have happened and would've "sent a chill" in the community had his office and NMHED not gotten involved. "Mesalands offers a very unique kind of careers, I think nursing and renewable energy, they have that niche," Maestas said. "I think that would be thrown into this period of great uncertainty, and it could have had negative economic consequences on the city." The college, which serves just under 1,000 students in the city of roughly 5,000, increased its reserve fund to around $2.1 million by the end of 2024 fiscal year, a sizable improvement, according to David Peña, director of policy for the auditor's office. The college's leadership also feels it's turning a corner. "I feel like we're in a really great position right now where we can actually start expanding the programs that we can offer our community," Mesalands President Allen Moss said in a phone interview on Monday. Moss joined the college in 2022, leaving his job as superintendent of a rural southern Missouri school district to become the director of Mesalands' small business development center and was eventually promoted to interim, then full-time president of the school. While he said he was not surprised by the auditors' report findings and appreciates the office's assistance to the college, he takes issue with the report's tone. "It's difficult not to take those things personally because even though a lot of my staff and I weren't a part of that, you're still talking about the college," Moss said.
CBS News
33 minutes ago
- CBS News
Family releases balloons in honor of woman fatally stabbed at Eastpointe McDonald's restaurant
Hundreds of people gathered on Monday afternoon outside of the McDonald's in Eastpointe, Michigan, to remember 39-year-old Jennifer Harris, who was stabbed to death by a coworker last week. Who was allegedly stabbed to death while on the job at the McDonald's as a manager of the restaurant by a disgruntled employee. "It hurts so bad that my mama is not here," said Harris's second eldest daughter, Anttenisha Griffin. Harris was a mother of six children, each of them now heartbroken that their mother is no longer with them. "I just got to be strong and just think, this is what my mama would want me to do. This is what my mama would want me to do. My mama would want me to be here for my siblings," Harris's eldest daughter, Antonia Griffin. The family's pastor, along with the McDonald's franchise owner, also spoke, reassuring the family and the community that Harris's children will be taken care of. "We have established the official Jennifer Harris legacy fund, which will serve as a trust dedicated exclusively to support the children for basic life expenses, from housing to food and transportation to their education," said franchise owner Yusef Alcodray. The suspect, 26-year-old Afeni Badu Muhammad, is scheduled to return to court for a probable cause conference next Wednesday, and her preliminary examination is scheduled for July 30. Muhammad is charged with first-degree premeditated murder and carrying a dangerous weapon with unlawful intent. The murder charge carries a mandatory life in prison sentence without parole. The weapon charge is a five-year felony.
Yahoo
38 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Frostbite and fear: Inside a journey into Canada with human smugglers
Chidi Nwagbo says he made a "stupid" decision paying human smugglers to get him into Canada that left him permanently scarred and in the hands of the very U.S. immigration authorities he was trying to flee. The 57-year-old says he paid $2,000 US in cash to a human smuggling organization in New Jersey to escape the immigration raids sweeping the U.S. He says the smugglers lied to him about the dangers of the journey that almost killed him along the borderlands between New York State and Quebec in February of this year. "If I had known that this would have been the outcome, I don't think I would have done it," said Nwagbo in a phone interview with CBC News from the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) detention centre in Batavia, N.Y. The Canada-US Border Rights Clinic, an organization that provides legal advice to migrants, is working on his case but he's facing imminent deportation to Nigeria — a country he left 37 years ago. He's now warning others not to follow in his footsteps. Nwagbo, moved to the U.S. from Nigeria in the late 1980s, where he built a life. He has five U.S.-born children from two marriages. He received a bravery award in 2014 from the Columbus, Ohio, fire department after saving a 10-year-old girl from drowning. Yet, he failed to get U.S. citizenship and faced a removal order in 2021 after missing an appearance at an immigration hearing, which his lawyer blamed on a "scheduling error," according to records. Nwagbo said he felt he had no choice but to flee to Canada after U.S. President Donald Trump's election victory last November. A friend gave him a phone number linked to a WhatsApp account run by human smugglers from New Jersey. He flew from Atlanta, Ga., to Newark, N.J., early on Feb. 1, then took an Uber to a McDonald's in Paterson, N.J., where the smugglers told him he'd be picked up. Nwagbo, carrying $2,000 US cash stuffed in his pocket, says he waited for several hours. "I was afraid. I got nervous," he said. "I thought, 'What if they were police or ICE or something?'" Finally, he received a text telling him to step outside where a pickup truck waited. He was taken to a Dunkin Donuts and transferred to the very back seat of an SUV with Florida plates. They headed toward the Canadian border in the early afternoon. He says the journey took about seven hours. About 15 minutes before the drop-off point somewhere along a rural road near the New York State border with Quebec, Nwagbo says the smugglers told the group to prepare to exit the vehicle and run into the bush. He was told to download a compass app on his phone and keep the arrow pointing north. They were assured someone would be waiting to pick them up on the other side. "As soon as I took a few steps, I knew I made a mistake," he said. LISTEN | Diving into the history of ICE: Nwagbo recalls thinking he was going to freeze to death as he trudged through deep snow in the forest for hours under a waxing crescent moon on that cold February night. A woman from Guinea who walked with him kept losing her shoes in the snow until finally, she left them and continued in her socks. Two women from Haiti struggled behind them, one carrying an 11-month-old boy. As Nwagbo pushed his way through snow and brush, he lost his gloves and all feeling in his fingers, making it difficult to answer calls from the smugglers trying to direct their movements. "These people will call me and say, 'Just keep going, you only have 10 minutes,' " he said. "It was supposed to be a 30-, 40-minute walk." Exhausted and numb from temperatures that dipped to -28 C overnight, they called 911 for help. Nwagbo wasn't sure where he was along the border, and feared apprehension by U.S. Border Patrol agents. "When I found out that it was Canadian [police], then it was a big relief," he said. WATCH | A surge in asylum claims at the Quebec-U.S. border: The journey exacted a price on Nwagbo's body. Frostbite forced the amputation of his pinky, ring and middle finger along with the top of his thumb on his left hand. He lost the top of his middle and ring fingers on his right hand. Quebec RCMP said officers received a call in the evening of Feb. 1 that a woman and her children were lost in a forested border area roughly 30 kilometres south of Salaberry-de-Valleyfiel, Que. The RCMP told CBC News that officers found a group of three women, one man and a child who were "illegally crossing from the U.S. to Canada." The group was taken to hospital and treated for "various frostbites," according to the RCMP. They were then transferred into the custody of Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA) at the Saint-Bernard-de-Lacolle port of entry, about 64 kilometres south of Montreal. Nwagbo was one of 99 people intercepted by the RCMP in February crossing irregularly over the Quebec-U.S. border, according to data from Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC). The latest data says RCMP intercepted 329 people crossing into Quebec from the U.S. between January to April. That number is trending slightly higher over 2024 levels. Nwagbo said he chose to use human smugglers because he wrongly believed he needed to go through U.S. customs to reach a Canadian port of entry. "I didn't have all the information that I needed to make the right decision," he said. Nwagbo made an asylum claim at the Saint-Bernard-de-Lacolle port of entry, saying he had a brother who was a Canadian citizen. This is one of the exemptions under the Safe Third Country Agreement (STCA) between the U.S. and Canada. Under the agreement, refugee claims must be submitted in the country where people first arrive. For this reason, Canada turns away most asylum seekers who attempt to enter from the U.S. at land-border crossings, but there are exceptions to this rule. His asylum claim was rejected after a CBSA officer determined he couldn't prove the relationship with his older brother Jolly Nwagbo, 74. "He had no copy of his birth certificate to confirm the relation," read the CBSA determination obtained by CBC News. The CBSA officer wrote they could not reach Nwagbo's brother by phone despite three attempts. Nwagbo was transferred into U.S. custody at the Champlain, N.Y., port of entry later that day, according to records. Jolly Nwagbo, who lives in St. Catharines, Ont., says he never received a call from CBSA. "The situation right now is deplorable," he said. The writer and academic says his family faces danger in Nigeria as a result of his book, Nigeria for Sale, about corruption in the country. Jolly says his brother could be killed if he's deported to Nigeria. "They might eliminate him because he's my brother," he said, noting that other family members are in hiding. The family is also part of the Igbo tribe that has historically faced persecution in Nigeria. Gauri Sreenivasan, co-executive director for the Canadian Council for Refugees, says they've received reports that CBSA has been taking a harder line on asylum claims made under exceptions to the Safe Third County Agreement. "We have seen a major shift in how the border rules are being enforced, with serious consequences," said Sreenivasan. Between Jan. 1 and July 7, CBSA has ordered the removal of 620 people who crossed irregularly between ports of entry and were found ineligible under the STCA, according to the latest CBSA data. The agency ordered the removal of 645 people between Jan. 1 and July 31 under the same circumstances in 2024. Nwagbo, who is still awaiting word about when he will be deported, says he regrets his decision to use smugglers to come to Canada and is now warning others. "Don't do it. It's risky." He says smugglers "only care about money. They don't care about your safety."
