Nithin Kamath: Why the broking business isn't as glamorous as it seems
Live Events
(You can now subscribe to our
(You can now subscribe to our ETMarkets WhatsApp channel
Zerodha co-founder Nithin Kamath has offered a candid assessment of the hidden risks in India's broking business—particularly what he calls a 'massive concentration risk' that the market rarely talks about.In a post on X, Kamath recalled a conversation with a veteran from private equity who had evaluated a broking firm in 2008 but backed out. 'The revenue was concentrated in just a handful of clients,' the investor had said—something that spooked them. At the time, a very small group of traders generated most of the exchange turnover. 'This was a lot worse back then,' Kamath noted.Fast forward to today, and while the number of retail traders has increased, the problem hasn't gone away—it has only shifted shape. 'For us, it's over 80%,' Kamath said, referring to the share of Zerodha's revenue that comes from just two F&O contracts: Nifty and Sensex. He added that this trend is true for most brokers in India.That's a risky dependence. 'That means one change can wipe out a big chunk of our revenues,' he warned.What makes it worse, Kamath pointed out, is the lack of alternative revenue levers in India. There's no payment for order flow (PFOF)—a controversial but lucrative practice in countries like the US. Cryptocurrency trading is largely off the table. And new rules such as quarterly fund settlement, which require brokers to return all unutilized funds to customer accounts every quarter, add operational stress.'I wonder why the brokerage business looks so sexy from the outside,' Kamath quipped.His reflection is a rare public unpacking of how regulatory limits, market behaviour, and structural dependencies create a fragile business model—even for India's most successful brokerages.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mint
2 hours ago
- Mint
Friday fortune: Nifty, Sensex end 3-day slide but caution lingers
India's benchmark equity indices snapped a three-day losing streak to end more than 1% higher on Friday, lifted by short-covering ahead of next week's monthly derivatives expiry and US president Donald Trump deferring his decision to join Israel's attack on Iran. Adding to the new market momentum were two significant semi-annual index rebalances: the Sensex and London's FTSE, according to Abhilash Pagaria, head of Nuvama Alternative & Quantitative Research. Siemens Energy is set to be dropped from the MSCI Global Standard Index, which could spark an estimated $210 million outflow. Since it's also part of the Nifty 50, an additional $50 million in outflows is anticipated from that front. In contrast, Tata Group fashion retailer Trent Ltd and state-run Bharat Electronics Ltd are set to replace Nestle and IndusInd Bank on the Sensex, potentially drawing in fresh investments. Meanwhile, the FTSE reshuffle is expected to bring in around $150 million into India, primarily due to the inclusion of Vishal Mega Mart. 'The market is like a person whose average temperature is fine as one leg is in cold water and the other leg is in boiling water,' said Nilesh Shah, managing director of Kotak Mahindra AMC. He said that stable domestic macros are currently outweighing geopolitical uncertainty. And, since the valuation of Indian equities is unlikely to be rated further up from here, Shah believes investor returns will come from earnings growth moving ahead. On Friday, both Nifty 50 and S&P BSE Sensex closed 1.3% higher at 25,112.40 and82,408.17points, respectively. Gains in Nifty 50 were led by a surge in heavyweight stocks such as HDFC Bank, Reliance Industries, Bharti Airtel, and ICICI Bank. The Nifty 50 finally broke past the 25,000-mark on Friday, a level that had acted as a key resistance. With the index closing firmly above it, Kkunal Parar, vice-president at Choice Equity Broking, sees room for further gains, possibly up to 25,300 points. 'If momentum holds and the index surpasses that level', he believes Indian equities could be on track for a fresh high. Meanwhile, Nifty Smallcap 250 ended the day 0.6% higher and Nifty Midcap 100 surged 1.5%. A 2 June report from Morgan Stanley highlights the resilience of Indian markets, noting that 'market wants to go up, not down.' Since September 2024, the market has absorbed a wave of negative developments—from stretched valuations in small- and mid-caps and a broad-based correction, to concerns over slowing macro growth and earnings, US tariff-related volatility, and even a major terrorist attack followed by India's response. Yet, large-cap indices remain just about 5% below all-time highs, 'and almost negligible changes in implied volumes,' the report said. Israel and Iran continue to exchange fire after Israel launched strikes on Iran's military and nuclear sites on 13 June, drawing a retaliation from the Islamic nation and ratcheting up geopolitical tensions. Both Israel and the US want Iran to abandon its nuclear programme, and Trump has deferred his decision on attacking Iran by two weeks, opening a potential negotiating window. Foreign institutional investors (FIIs) were net buyers on Friday, picking up ₹ 7,940.70 crore, while domestic institutional investors (DIIs) booked profits with net sales of ₹ 3,049.88 crore, according to BSE provisional data. Over the past week, both FIIs and DIIs emerged as net buyers, with inflows of ₹ 1,209.57 crore and ₹ 18,726.90 crore, respectively, according to NSDL data. Overall cash levels of the mutual fund industry remain elevated, particularly concentrated within three asset management companies (AMCs), as per an Elara Capital report dated 17 June. 'It is important to understand that this is not a short-term tactical move but a strategic positioning reflecting caution on current market valuations—especially in the Mid and Smallcap segments.' The report highlighted that almost 25% of the total cash in the system is held by only 4 schemes and 50% by 18 schemes. And most of these schemes have maintained elevated cash level for more than a year. Rather than channeling funds into the secondary market, fund managers are increasingly turning to the primary market, where issuance activity has seen a notable resurgence since May 2025, the report pointed out. Still, some amount of caution continues to linger among investors, considering the ongoing conflict in West Asia. market experts said. A flare-up in tensions could drive up crude oil prices and heighten volatility, quickly souring the overall investor sentiment.
United News of India
2 hours ago
- United News of India
Sensex Zooms by 1,046.30 points
Mumbai, Jun 20 (UNI) Snapping three consecutive sessions of losses, the BSE Sensex on Friday surged by 1,0436 points to close at 82,408.17. Today's surge is seen as the result of gains in Asian markets and renewed foreign fund inflow, a trader explained. Markets sentiments turned bullish after the US President Donald Trump announced that he will decide in the next two weeks whether or not to get involved in the Iran-Israel conflict. This announcement eased crude oil prices improving investor sentiments, the trader added. National Stock Exchange (NSE) too advanced by 319.15 points to settle at 25,112.40. The Sensex opened marginally lower at 81,354,85 against its previous close of 81,361.87 .66 Sensex recorded an intra day high of 82,641.54 and low of 81,323.20. The NSE registered a day's high at 25,132.80 and a day's low at 24,738.10 Mid-cap rose by 1.20 pc and the Small-cap advanced by 0.22 pc. The market breadth stayed strong on Friday. The BSE witnessed 2,469 shares rising and 1,471 shares falling. A total of 151 shares remained unchanged. All Sectoral indices ended the Session in green with Telecom being the Top Sectoral gainer up by 2.73 pc Other Sectoral gainer were Commodities by 0.54 pc. Energy By 0.99 pc, FMCG by 0.52 pc, Financial by 1.35 pc, Health Care by 0.78 pc, Industrial by 1.21 pc, IT by 0.65 pc, Utilities by 1.62 pc, Auto by 0.84 pc, Bankex by 1.15 pc, Capital Goods by 1.17 pc, Consumer Durables by 0.84 pc, Metals by 1.10 pc, Oil & Gas bty 0.61 pc, Power by 1,46 pc , Realty by 2.22 pc and Teck by 1.42 pc Among the 30 scrips, 27 advanced while 3 declined. Notable gainers were Bharti Airtel by 3.17 pc to Rs 1,935.00, Nestle India by 2.98 pc to Rs 2,388.20, M&M by 2.86 pc to Rs 3,180.20, Power Grid by 2.18 pc to Rs 292.55, Reliance by 2.16 pc to Rs 1,462.65, NTPC by 1.70 to RS 33.35 and Eternal by 1.60 pc to Rs 253.40. The losers were Axis Bnak by 0.16 pc to Rs 1,215.00, Ultra tech by 0.07 pc to Rs 11,399.70 and Maruti by 0.02 pc to Rs 12,803.00. US Dow Jones futures were up by 0.56 pc, European shares advanced on Friday, FTSE by 0.47 pc, CAC by 0.58 pc and DAX by 0.95 pc Most Asian markets ended higher as investors assessed China data and monitored escalating tensions between Israel and Iran. Nikkei was 225 down by 0.22 pc, Straits Times rose by 0.28 pc, Hang Seng advanced by 1.24 pc and Kospi by 1.46 pc. UNI JS RKM
The Print
3 hours ago
- The Print
Markets snap 3-day losing run; Sensex jumps 1,000 pts as financial, telecom shares gain
The 50-share NSE Nifty climbed 319.15 points or 1.29 per cent to 25,112.40. A largely supportive trend overseas and renewed foreign capital inflows supported domestic equities following signs of easing tension in the Middle East, traders said. After a flat start, the BSE Sensex later found its mojo back and surged 1,046.30 points or 1.29 per cent to settle at 82,408.17. During the day, it jumped 1,132.62 points or 1.39 per cent to 82,494.49. Mumbai, Jun 20 (PTI) Equity benchmark indices Sensex and Nifty rebounded sharply by over 1 per cent on Friday after sliding for the past three sessions, propelled by bargain hunting in financial, telecom and tech stocks amid a correction in global crude prices. As many as 2,463 stocks advanced while 1,484 declined and 147 remained unchanged on the BSE. This week, the BSE benchmark gauge jumped 1,289.57 points or 1.58 per cent, and the Nifty surged 393.8 points or .59 per cent. 'Equity indices surged as Middle East tension moderated with risk of immediate military actions reduced as US dialogue with Iran is expected to take place. The development led the crude price to correct, favouring domestic markets and boosting foreign investors' sentiments. 'In the broader market, rapid fall in VIX index and buying was witnessed in rate sensitives and consumer-oriented sectors like Finance, Auto and Reality and in anticipation of better Q1FY26 results led by rate cuts benefits, drop in inflationary pressure and rebound in consumer spending,' Vinod Nair, Head of Research, Geojit Investments Limited, said. From the Sensex firms, Bharti Airtel, Nestle, Mahindra & Mahindra, Power Grid, Reliance Industries, NTPC, Eternal and HDFC Bank were among the biggest gainers. In contrast, Maruti was the only laggard. The BSE midcap gauge jumped 1.20 per cent, and smallcap index climbed 0.55 per cent. All BSE sectoral indices ended higher. Telecommunication surged 2.73 per cent, realty (2.22 per cent), teck (1.42 per cent), capital goods (1.17 per cent), bankex (1.15 per cent), consumer discretionary (1.12 per cent) and metal (1.10 per cent). 'Sentiment improved after the news report indicated a possible de-escalation in the Iran-Israel conflict, with the US signalling a delay in potential action, which led to a softening in crude oil prices. Additionally, consistent buying by FIIs in the cash segment further supported the market,' Ajit Mishra – SVP, Research, Religare Broking Ltd, said. In Asian markets, South Korea's Kospi and Hong Kong's Hang Seng settled in positive territory, while Japan's Nikkei 225 index and Shanghai's SSE Composite index ended lower. Markets in Europe were trading higher in mid-session trade. US markets were closed on Thursday for the Juneteenth holiday. Global oil benchmark Brent crude dropped 1.93 per cent to USD 77.33 a barrel. Foreign Institutional Investors (FIIs) bought equities worth Rs 934.62 crore on Thursday, according to exchange data. Domestic Institutional Investors (DIIs) also bought equities worth Rs 605.97 crore. On Thursday, the 30-share BSE Sensex declined 82.79 points, or 0.10 per cent, to settle at 81,361.87. The Nifty dipped 18.80 points or 0.08 per cent to 24,793.25. 'In the absence of any major domestic events, global markets will continue to guide sentiment. We maintain our positive yet cautious stance and advise focusing on stock selection, particularly in line with sectoral trends,' Mishra said. PTI SUM SUM BAL BAL This report is auto-generated from PTI news service. ThePrint holds no responsibility for its content.
