‘The Disappearance of Josef Mengele' Review: An Artfully Directed, Intellectually Vacuous Holocaust-Ploitation Flick
Throughout the impressively crafted and increasingly exasperating 135 minutes that make up Kirill Serebrennikov's postwar Nazi-in-hiding chronicle, The Disappearance of Josef Menegele, the same question keeps coming to mind: Why am I watching this?
Certainly, for those curious to know how the notorious Auschwitz doctor, aka the 'Angel of Death,' eked out the final decades of his life in various South American countries, changing homes and identities, farming, scheming and, yes, getting the occasional handjob, the film answers that question many times over. But for those who aren't Third Reich completists, nor have any interest in historical fantasy that does little beyond embellishing Mengele's ignoble reputation, this intellectually vacuous exercise can be tough to stomach — despite how well put together the whole thing is.
More from The Hollywood Reporter
Feinberg on Cannes: Oscar Contenders Emerging From First Half Include 'Nouvelle Vague' and Jennifer Lawrence for 'Die, My Love'
'A Magnificent Life' Review: Sylvain Chomet's Beautifully Animated but Clumsily Scripted Love Letter to Marcel Pagnol
'Peak Everything' Review: Piper Perabo Headlines a Cute Canadian Rom-Com Imbued With Very Timely Anxieties
The Russian-born Serebrennikov is a talented auteur with plenty of style to boot, showcasing his directorial chops in six eclectic features made since 2016. He jumps easily between genres, from a scruffy rock 'n' roll flick (Leto) to a post-Soviet mindfuck (Petrov's Flu), from a brooding period piece (Tchaikovsky's Wife) to a continent-hopping tale of a political mystery man (Limonov: The Ballad of Eddie).
A feted cinematic chameleon who was controversially put on trial in Russia, Serebrennikov can be hard to pin down. It's perhaps the latter quality that attracted him to French writer Olivier Guez's 2017 fictional biography imagining Mengele's life after World War II, when he was constantly evading arrest by local authorities or possible kidnapping by Mossad. Like its unwholesome protagonist, the film — and the roving camera of Vladislav Opelyants, shooting in gorgeously high-contrast black-and-white — is forever on the move, creating an immersive aesthetic experience that amounts to a big pile of nothing.
To his credit, Serebrennikov never attempts to turn Mengele, played by August Diehl (A Hidden Life) in a committed performance that borders at times on caricature, into a likeable protagonist. There are no save-the-cat redemptions for a man who became famous for torturing, murdering and performing hideous experiments on countless Jews as part of a team of doctors overseeing medical services at Auschwitz-Birkenau.
We never have an ounce of sympathy for the loathsome fugitive, whether he's trying — though barely — to reconcile with his son, Rolf (Max Bretschneider), who pays him a visit in Sao Paulo in 1977, hoping to finally get to know his long-lost dad. Nor do we shed a tear when he's forced to flee the farm where he's being protected — though barely — by a Hungarian couple (Annamaria Lang, Tilo Werner) who openly despise him. And we certainly don't get upset when, during his dying days, Mengele is unable to get it up while his Brazilian housekeeper offers him a massage with a happy ending.
Watching The Disappearance of Josef Mengele leaves one without any real feeling beyond indifference or deep disgust. The one sequence capable of provoking some other kind of emotion is also the film's most problematic: Midway through the narrative, the screen suddenly shifts to color and we flash back to Auschwitz to watch some of the doctor's dirty deeds. Set to lush classical music serving as a counterpoint for all the atrocities we're witnessing, it's a moment of pure Holocaust-ploitation, pulling on our heartstrings while offering up snippets of unspeakable evil and squeamish gore. Unlike Jonathan Glazer's The Zone of Interest, which kept such scenes forever out of the frame, Serebrennikov's decision to show us Mengele at his absolute worst feels both morally suspect and cinematically vulgar. At best, it makes us hate the Nazi even more.
Slightly more successful are the postwar thriller aspects of the story, which shift between time periods (from the mid-1950s to the late-1970s, with a prologue set in 2023) and countries (Germany, Argentina, Paraguay, Brazil) as Mengele keeps outsmarting those trying to bring him to justice, aided and abetted by a network of exiled Hitler sympathizers. He was also supported by his wealthy German family, who are as unapologetic as he is about what happened during the war and refuse to acknowledge his crimes.
'You did your duty, you didn't do anything wrong,' they keep reminding him. It's a motto Mengele lives by till the bitter end, dying the kind of natural death that his countless victims were never afforded. And he seems to have lived quite well for the most part, marrying his second wife (Friederike Becht) in a beautiful private ceremony captured by the director in a single take, the camera honing in at one point on a wedding cake capped by a cute little Nazi flag. Or else frolicking with his first wife (Dana Herfurth) along the Rhine, then having rough sex with her until he violently orgasms and nearly breaks the bed they're doing it on. Good for the doctor, bad for us.
If there's perhaps anything Serebrennikov is trying to say in this noirish Nazi fantasy, it's that men like Mengele ultimately managed to escape retribution through the help of other people, who were either seduced by his commanding virility or remained loyal to the Third Reich long after the war ended. At a time when fascism is on the rise throughout the world, The Disappearance of Josef Mengele maintains that evil persists because some of us let it happen. It's the only possible takeaway from a movie that gives little justification for immortalizing such a vile life on screen.
Best of The Hollywood Reporter
'The Goonies' Cast, Then and Now
"A Nutless Monkey Could Do Your Job": From Abusive to Angst-Ridden, 16 Memorable Studio Exec Portrayals in Film and TV
The 10 Best Baseball Movies of All Time, Ranked
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Celebrities react to LA protest against ICE detention policies
Following Donald Trump's deployment of the National Guard to Los Angeles, artists have been speaking out against U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) deportation raids and offering support to protestors in LA. As reported by Euronews, Trump deployed another 2,100 National Guard members and 700 US Marines, in what the authorities have dubbed Task Force 51 meant to "provide continuous coverage of the area" as unrest in Los Angeles continues. Many celebrities posted messages on social media supporting the protestors and criticising the National Guard's deployment, including Eva Longoria and Mark Ruffalo. Longoria took to Instagram to express her frustration and described the actions as 'Un-American', while Ruffalo shared a lengthy message to Instagram with the caption: "When you have working class people going after the poor and other working class people you know you are living in an oligarchy." He added: "The billionaire up at the top is stealing you blind, and you are worried about the poorest of the poor ruining your life? You are pointing your guns in the wrong direction... The president is a grifter." Ruffalo's post went viral, racking up to 200,000 likes—including from other celebrities, including Jennifer Garner and Halle Berry. Voir cette publication sur Instagram Une publication partagée par Mark Ruffalo (@markruffalo) Green Day's Billie Joe Armstrong posted a scene from one of the LA protests to his Instagram over the weekend, which he captioned with a middle finger emoji and an ice cube emoji, while Tyler, The Creator wrote on his Instagram Story: 'FUCK ICE.' Singer and actress Reneé Rapp also condemned ICE's actions, writing: 'Fuck ICE fuck this administration fuck all of yall who are complicit in ensuring that this happened this is a fucking disgrace.' One of the most notable reactions came from Oscar-winning singer-songwriter Finneas, brother of Billie Eilish, who attended the 'very peaceful protests' himself and claimed to have been teargassed by authorities. 'Tear-gassed almost immediately at the very peaceful protest downtown. They're inciting this,' he wrote on Instagram. Finneas also reposted a clip that appeared to show a reporter, Lauren Tomasi, being shot in the leg with a rubber bullet by law enforcement while she was reporting from the scene. Elsewhere, Grammy-winning rapper Doechii spoke out against the immigration raids in Los Angeles at the 2025 BET Awards last her speech, Doechii said that though she was 'honoured' by the award, she wanted to 'address what is happening right now outside of the building'. 'There are ruthless attacks that are creating fear and chaos in our communities in the name of law and order,' she continued, citing Trump's deployment of the National Guard. 'Trump is using military forces to stop a protest,' Doechii added. 'I want you all to consider what kind of government it appears to be when every time we exercise our democratic right to protest, the military is deployed against us. What type of government is that?'The heated situation has also prompted a fierce political backlash. Governor Gavin Newsom took to X to announce his plans to sue the federal government over the National Guard deployment, calling it 'an unconstitutional act.' "This is exactly what Donald Trump wanted. He flamed the fires and illegally acted to federalize the National Guard. The order he signed doesn't just apply to CA (California). It will allow him to go into ANY STATE and do the same thing. We're suing him."
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Gary Oldman on ‘Slow Horses' being ‘an extraordinary show to work on' and ‘one of the highlights of my career'
Gary Oldman is clearly having a ball playing the gruff, ill-mannered and often underestimated Jackson Lamb in the Emmy-winning Apple TV+ spy thriller Slow Horses. "We often laugh actually, while we're doing it. We crack up and then and do retakes," he tells Gold Derby. "It's been an extraordinary show to work on, not only because the material is very good and obviously the character is just a dream. But it's been really made all the more special because of the people working on the show. And that is really across the board from makeup, costume, DP, camera operator, clapper loader, although they're not really clapper loaders anymore," he says. "I love regrouping after a break and then getting back and seeing everyone. The set is very easy to work on in that respect. Just an incredible bunch of people and that really has made it, I think, one of the highlights of my career." (Watch our full interview above.) More from GoldDerby Michelle Williams and Jenny Slate on playing best friends in 'Dying for Sex': 'It was love at first sight' Seth Rogen on taking big swings with 'The Studio': 'Are people just going to think this looks insane?' 'Disclaimer' star Leila George on how she landed 'the best job of her life' Slow Horses is based on Mick Herron's series of novels, adapted by showrunner Will Smith (Veep), about a group of MI5 agents who are consigned to a dumping ground for rejects paying the price for their past mistakes. The outcasts of the British intelligence agency banished to the administrative purgatory of Slough House are known as 'slow horses.' They're expected to endure interminably dull, paper-pushing drudgery, along with occasional berating from their abrasive boss, Jackson Lamb. Oldman plays the rude, crass, and often drunk department head with a bracing panache, reveling in being as unapologetically miserable as possible, while showing flashes of the intellect, perceptiveness and savvy from his former life as a respected spy. The spy drama costars Emmy nominee Jack Lowden, Oscar and Emmy nominee Kristin Scott Thomas, Saskia Reeves, Rosalind Eleazar, Christopher Chung, Aimee-Ffion Edwards, Kadiff Kirwan, Freddie Fox, Chris Reilly, Joanna Scanlon, and Tony winner and Oscar and Emmy nominee Jonathan Pryce, with new additions to the show's riveting fourth season, including Tom Brooke as the newest slow horse and former "psych eval" operative, Ruth Bradley as the new head of "the Dogs," James Callis as the new "first desk," and Hugo Weaving as deadly mercenary Frank Harkness. SEE Gary Oldman, Jack Lowden, Kristin Scott Thomas, Jonathan Pryce: Here is every 'Slow Horses' Emmy acting submission for Season 4 After four seasons, with a fifth on the way (premiering Sept. 24), it's no wonder that Oldman loves this role, not only because it's a fun set to work on, but because the writing is so excellent. "If the source material is good, then it dictates what you do. It's a psychological and an emotional map that you follow. When you come up against bad writing, that's when you feel that you're working too hard for it. If you're breaking a sweat, then you know that you're not in the hands of a very good writer. It's a joy to speak this stuff and to navigate, both physically and psychologically, through the world of these people in this character," says Oldman. "As the seasons go on and incrementally more is revealed of Jackson, you as an actor are forming a more complete picture of him. And then of course we have Season 5, and that pulls back another layer of the onion to his character and really why he is the way he is," he says about fleshing out the why behind his grouchy, ill-tempered exterior. "It works in a way as a defense mechanism. He's not gonna let you in. You're not going to really get to know him. And that really is part of his skill also, because by doing that, he has an edge over you. I mean, we've said it before; people around him are playing checkers and Jackson Lamb is playing chess." The writers are have also proven to be very adept at cramming an abundance of plot and narrative into short and sharp six-episode seasons, leaving audiences breathlessly anticipating the next installment. The plot thickens as the show unwraps a self-contained mystery each season, while leaving room for getting to know the characters, who often amusingly bare the brunt of Lamb's witty asides and cutting insults. "As far as making the next one as good, if not better, you can't drop the ball," Oldman says about always wanting to up the ante. "There's a lot of people involved that come together. We have a standard. The audience are expecting something from us and we cannot disappoint. That's part of the reason why we do six episodes with a short break, and then we do another six, because who wants to invest their time in characters in a show and then wait two or three years for it to come back? We are very conscious of making the next one as good, if not better. So that's the first thing; audiences come back to the show and they're not disappointed." SEE Jack Lowden reveals his favorite bit of improv on 'Slow Horses': 'He doesn't know why he's doing it' "We're so used to glamor and the world of James Bond and tuxedos, martinis and casinos that I think the appeal of it is it's these very dysfunctional and often ordinary people who have to deal with all the stuff in their life who go to the launderette, who may have to make their car payments, have problems in their relationships and are dealing with a mortgage," Oldman says. "They're dealing with all the problems that we all deal with. They're ordinary people who do this extraordinary thing for a living. That's a part of its appeal. It's a spy show, but they are the every man. And of course, some of the things that come out of Jackson Lamb's mouth, I think maybe secretly we watch the show and think, we may have in our time had a bullying horrible boss and you think sometimes, 'Oh, I wish I could have a comeback like that.' He doesn't give a flying monkeys, you see? He's seen it all and can't track with the bureaucratic side of it all, of the Park and all of that crap. He's, he's been there, seen it, and he has no, uh, time for it. I think the kindest thing that Jackson can do is make life so miserable for the people that work for him, so that they get out of the game, because they don't wanna end up [like him]. I think that's probably the kindest thing that he can do. And yet, for all of his rough edges and bullying, he's incredibly loyal and would take a bullet for them." Asked his thoughts on why he seems to be widely revered and admired among other actors, the Oscar- and BAFTA-winning veteran actor replies, "I think it's very flattering. It doesn't occupy my thought process a lot, but it's always nice to hear that someone says something nice about your work. I'm a big one for, if I run into someone and I like their work or I like a performance, I'll say so. I even will drop a note to people and write them how much I liked their performance or their work. Less than a week ago I dropped a note to Tom Hardy and I said, 'I really like your work in MobLand.' I've written to different people over the years. I think it's a nice thing. I think it's a nice thing when a colleague likes your work. It's a lovely thing." Slow Horses Season 4 is now streaming on Apple TV+. SIGN UP for Gold Derby's free newsletter with latest predictions Best of GoldDerby Michelle Williams and Jenny Slate on playing best friends in 'Dying for Sex': 'It was love at first sight' Dan Fogelman and team on the making of 'Paradise': 'It only works if you have talented people who you trust' Brandon Scott Jones on CBS' 'Ghosts': 'I enjoy playing characters that are desperate' Click here to read the full article.
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Emmy experts predict Drama Series race: ‘Severance' out front, but watch out for ‘The Pitt'
As Emmy voting begins, can Severance hold onto its momentum as the Best Drama Series frontrunner, or might another show steal its thunder? Four top Emmy experts — Variety's Clayton Davis, The Hollywood Reporter's Scott Feinberg, Indiewire's Marcus Jones, Deadline's Pete Hammond — predict the race with moderator and Gold Derby editor-in-chief Debra Birnbaum in our latest slugfest (watch above). "We have to talk about Severance — that's Apple's main play," says Jones. The sci-fi series has been the category's de facto leader all season long. HBO and Max have an incredible amount of product this year, he says, including The Pitt, The White Lotus, The Last of Us, Industry, and House of the Dragon. He also declares Hulu's apocalyptic series Paradise to be "one of the big newcomers" of the year, with "an amazing performance from Sterling K. Brown." More from GoldDerby 'You killed America's sweetheart!' Kaitlyn Dever teased for offing Pedro Pascal by 'Last of Us' cast, creators as bigger role looms in Season 3 Dan Fogelman and team on the making of 'Paradise': 'It only works if you have talented people who you trust' 'Thank you for dying': 'Squid Game' creator, cast share deeper meanings of hit Netflix series, reveal on-set flower ceremonies for 'killed' actors Feinberg agrees that The Pitt is "the most obvious" freshman drama to receive a nomination, adding, "I think it could even end up winning." Looking beyond the frontrunners, he's "impressed" by how many voters are telling him they're watching Your Friends & Neighbors on Apple TV+. But what about Landman? "That's a real wild card to me because, out in the real world, everybody's watching it, but it's TBD who's watching it in the TV Academy." Hulu "There are a lot of good possibilities in the drama series category," says Hammond. The Handmaid's Tale ended its final season amid "everything going on in the world, and seemingly this show has turned into a documentary, ... Handmaid's Tale is now true life!" As for The Pitt, he thinks it's "so hard to watch" because of all the realistic medical stories, and wishes there were commercials. "I need a break [from all the blood]." Davis is already looking ahead to the Emmy ceremony, claiming, "Win-wise, I think this is Severance vs. The Pitt for the rest of the year. I think The Pitt is so Homeland Season 1 coded. I want to know how many nominations it gets before I can really cross over and say it can do it." He also creates a stir when he mentions how Pedro Pascal should drop down to supporting for The Last of Us because it's "more appropriate" after what happens to his character in Season 2. As for shows that people are actually watching "in the real world," Birnbaum singles out Matlock, with its star Kathy Bates on the cusp of being the oldest winner ever for Best Drama Actress. "It's just such a strong narrative," she says. "You have to imagine voters are going to get swept up with that." Which Emmy expert do you agree with the most? Be sure to make your predictions and join the Emmy discussion in our TV forum. SIGN UP for Gold Derby's free newsletter with latest predictions Best of GoldDerby Michelle Williams and Jenny Slate on playing best friends in 'Dying for Sex': 'It was love at first sight' Dan Fogelman and team on the making of 'Paradise': 'It only works if you have talented people who you trust' Brandon Scott Jones on CBS' 'Ghosts': 'I enjoy playing characters that are desperate' Click here to read the full article.
