As Australia's teen social media ban looms, here's how the platforms are lobbying for an exemption
The social services minister, Tanya Plibersek, on Monday said the government would not be 'bullied out of taking action by any social media giant'. But the tech companies are doing their best to argue that their services should be exempt from the legislation that comes into effect in December.
Here's what the social media companies are doing to make their case.
The parent company of Facebook and Instagram has been showcasing its teen account settings for Instagram as a not-so-subtle message to the government that it takes teen safety on its platform seriously.
Last week, Meta announced new protections around direct messages, including blocking features, in addition to the existing protections around automatically censoring potentially nude images.
Meta also hosted a 'screen smart' Instagram safety event for 'parent creators' in Sydney last week, hosted by Carrie Bickmore.
Sign up: AU Breaking News email
YouTube has been even less subtle. The platform was originally promised an exemption from the social media ban last year by then communications minister Michelle Rowland.
The eSafety commissioner, however, last month recommended to the government that YouTube not be excluded, highlighting research showing when children encounter harmful material, it is on YouTube more than any other platform.
Since then, the company has been in a lobbying blitz. In addition to full-page ads in newspapers and billboards across the country saying YouTube is in a 'category of one' of services for everyone, the company has sent a letter to the communications minister, Anika Wells, raising the threat of a high court challenge should YouTube be included in the ban.
As Guardian Australia reported last month, Google this week will host its annual showcase in Parliament House on Wednesday, where content creators such as the Mik Maks – children's musicians who have argued against YouTube being included in the ban – will make an appearance and no doubt make their views known to the politicians.
Last year's event featured the Wiggles, who met with Rowland. The meeting was mentioned in a letter the global CEO of YouTube, Neal Mohan, sent to Rowland last year pleading for an exemption less than 48 hours before the exemption was promised.
Guardian Australia reported last week YouTube had also met with Wells this month to discuss the ban directly.
This month TikTok has been running ads both on TikTok itself and on Meta's platforms about the educational benefits for teens on the vertical video platform.
Sign up to Breaking News Australia
Get the most important news as it breaks
after newsletter promotion
'1.7m #fishtok videos are helping them swap screen time for time outdoors,' one ad stated, in a nod to the government's claim that the ban will lead to children spending more time off their screens and outside. 'They're mastering their chef skills thanks to over 13m cooking videos,' it added.
'One in three are visiting the stem feed every week, inspiring their learning,' another stated.
On the messaging app Snapchat, much of the focus has been on user safety. Guardian Australia reported in May that an 11-year-old Australian girl, who added random people on Snapchat as part of an informal competition with her best friend to get a high score in the app, went on to be sexually abused by one of the people she added.
This month, Snap announced it had partnered with with the Australian federal police-led Australian Centre to Counter Child Exploitation for a series of educational videos rolled out on several Australian influencer accounts, as well as ads advising parents and teens how to spot grooming and sextortion.
'The safety of the Snapchat community has always been our priority, and working closely with law enforcement and expert safety partners is a critical part of that ongoing effort,' Ryan Ferguson, Snap's Australian managing director, said.
The company also reiterated its teen account settings for 13 to 17-year-olds that include private accounts by default and in-chat warnings when communicating with someone with whom they don't share mutual friends or who is not in their contact list.
So far, the government appears to be not for turning.
'There is no doubt that young people are being impacted adversely in their mental health by some of the engagement with social media and that is why the government has acted,' the prime minister, Anthony Albanese, told ABC's Insiders on Sunday.
'I'll be meeting with parents again this week of people who've been through tragedy, frankly … And one of the things that concerns some of the social media companies is that we are leading the world and I'm proud that we're prepared to stand these people up effectively from their threats.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BreakingNews.ie
22 minutes ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Dianne Buswell wants to have children with Joe Sugg ‘when the time is right'
Strictly Come Dancing star Dianne Buswell has revealed she wants to have children with her partner Joe Sugg when the time is right and 'everything aligns'. The dancer, 36, met YouTube star Sugg when they were partnered together on the BBC One dancing show in 2018. Advertisement She told Prima magazine: 'When Joe and I met, it wasn't until the show ended that we realised we missed each other's company a lot – our relationship went from there. We always got on, he was so funny to me, and I loved how creative he was. 'We've always wanted kids, it's just finding the right time. I don't feel worried about taking time out from dancing, I just don't see the point in worrying. Dianne Buswell on the September cover of Prima UK (Prima UK/David Venni) 'When everything aligns, it will happen. I have to have that vision. I like to practise manifestation, I'm quite spiritual.' Reflecting on life in the public eye, she said: 'Joe and I forget we're famous sometimes – when we're out and about, we'll be like, 'Why are they looking at us? Ah, okay, I remember'. Advertisement 'It doesn't feel that difficult to have a relationship in the public eye – we're good at not taking notice of things that are written about us. 'Sometimes, though, people are obsessed with wanting to find out things, such as where we live, so it can be hard in terms of privacy.' Buswell also reflected on what it was like to win Strictly in 2024 alongside her celebrity dance partner, Chris McCausland, who became the first blind person to compete on the series. 'He had to trust me 100%, I had to trust him 100% and so it was a really strong bond from the word go', she said. Advertisement 'I taught him a lot, but he taught me just as much. I've always loved comedy and had a niche for comedic timing but being a dancer, we don't talk, we dance. Chris has allowed me to be more of the character that I naturally am.' During the series, the couple performed a viral 'blackout' dance which saw comedian McCausland place his hands over Buswell's eyes as the room faded to black, mimicking his everyday experience. When the lights returned, the 48-year-old was spinning around with Buswell on his shoulders as pyrotechnics flared in the background. Read the full interview in the September issue of Prima, on sale Wednesday July 30. Advertisement
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
YouTube most popular first TV destination for children, Ofcom finds
Children are now heading to YouTube from the moment they turn on the television, in the latest sign of the video platform's migration from the laptop to the living room. YouTube is the most popular first TV destination for generation Alpha, according to a comprehensive survey of the UK's viewing habits by Ofcom, the communications regulator. One in five young TV viewers aged from four to 15 turned straight to the platform last year. The survey showed Netflix close behind. While BBC One was in the top five first destinations, children were just as likely to choose BBC iPlayer. YouTube's increasing presence on televisions is not just down to the very young. In a gradual cultural shift, viewers aged 55 and over watched almost twice as much YouTube content last year as they did in 2023, up from six minutes a day to 11 minutes a day. An increasing proportion of that – 42% – is viewed through a TV set. Overall, viewers spent an average of 39 minutes a day on YouTube in 2024. The platform is now the second most-watched service in the UK, behind the BBC but ahead of ITV. Those aged 16 to 24 watched just 17 minutes of traditional, live television a day last year. Only 45% of them tuned into any broadcast TV in an average week, down from 48% in 2023. YouTube has evolved to become a closer competitor for traditional broadcasters. Half of the platform's top-trending videos now resemble the content of mainstream broadcasters, including long-form interviews and gameshows. The rise of YouTube is presenting a major challenge for public service broadcasters such as the BBC, ITV and Channel 4, who have to decide how much of their content to place on the platform. While doing so helps them reach new and younger audiences, YouTube also takes a huge chunk of advertising revenue. There is also a risk that putting shows on YouTube ensures viewers spend less time on a broadcaster's own platforms. 'Public service broadcasters are recognising this shift, moving to meet audiences in the online spaces where they increasingly spend their time,' said Ed Leighton, Ofcom's interim group director for strategy and research. 'But we need to see even more ambition in this respect to ensure that public service media that audiences value survives long into the future.' Ofcom has already told 'endangered' broadcasters they should work with YouTube to place more of their content on the platform, but it has also said this must be done 'on fair commercial terms'. Michael Grade, Ofcom's chair and a former head of Channel 4, said ministers should look at new laws forcing YouTube to give content from Britain's public service broadcasters more prominence. Sign up to Headlines UK Get the day's headlines and highlights emailed direct to you every morning after newsletter promotion Channel 4 has gone the furthest in placing its content on YouTube. Executives insist it is only helping them reach new viewers, rather than cannibalising its own platforms. ITV also announced a new deal with YouTube at the end of last year. While there is a live debate within the BBC over how much content to place on YouTube, more of its coverage is set to be featured on the site. Deborah Turness, the head of BBC News, told staff this week that the head of the corporation's new AI department would also be responsible for 'driving growth off platform with a focus on our YouTube strategy and younger audiences'. The amount of time people are watching video content every week is holding steady. Overall, the average person watched four hours, 30 minutes a day at home last year, just a minute less than the previous year. Content from traditional broadcasters still accounts for most viewing, making up 56% of the total. However, the proportion has fallen significantly, from 71% in 2018. YouTube is also the most popular online audio service, used by 47% of UK adults each week, followed by Spotify, used by 36%. Podcasts are now increasingly streamed on YouTube – a sign of its impact right across the media.
Telegraph
an hour ago
- Telegraph
BBC risks exodus as older viewers flock to YouTube
The BBC is at risk of a fresh exodus of viewers as older audiences increasingly turn to YouTube over traditional television channels. The streaming giant accounted for 14pc of all viewing time in UK households last year, overtaking ITV for the first time to become the second most-watched service in Britain. It means YouTube is now closing in on the BBC, which remains Britain's most-watched service with a 19pc share of viewing time. ITV now holds a 12pc share, according to the findings published by Ofcom. The trend is being driven by younger audiences, with adults aged between 16 and 34 watching 18 minutes of YouTube a day on their television sets. One in five children aged between four and 15 head straight to the app as soon as they turn the TV on. But Ofcom found that the flood of viewers to YouTube is not confined to Gen Z, with over-55s nearly doubling the amount of YouTube content they watch on TVs to 11 minutes per day. While the most popular types of video vary greatly by age, adults are most likely to use YouTube for music or to watch 'how to' videos, such as recipes and DIY. YouTube's surging popularity among older Britons also comes amid the rapid growth of video podcasts, with shows such as The Rest is History racking up huge audiences for their filmed episodes. The radical shift in viewing habits presents a further threat to traditional broadcasters such as the BBC, ITV and Channel 4, which are already grappling with competition posed by streaming platforms. The research found that YouTube now poses a direct threat to traditional TV viewing by older audiences, with 42pc of all viewing of the platform among over-55s taking place on a television set. Moreover, audiences are increasingly watching longer-form videos on YouTube that more closely resemble traditional programming. Half of the platform's top-trending videos last year were longer shows, including interviews and quiz shows. Ofcom found that the BBC's average weekly reach remained stable in 2024 following a 5pc decline the previous year. Higher demand for iPlayer, thanks largely to the Euro 2024 football tournament and Olympic Games, meant overall viewing of BBC videos even increased slightly last year. But overall, people spent 4pc less time watching broadcast TV in 2024 than the previous year, with average viewing time dropping to 2 hours 24 minutes a day. The growing threat from YouTube has prompted Ofcom to urge public service broadcasters to make more programming for the platform or risk fading into irrelevance among an entire generation of viewers. ITV and Channel 4 have already struck deals to put their programmes on YouTube and other streaming services, while Tim Davie, the BBC director general, has said the corporation will start making news programming specifically for streaming platforms and social media apps. One industry source accused Ofcom of conflating the content with the platform, arguing that broadcasters attracted large audiences on YouTube. However, figures released by the regulator last week showed that only about a fifth of the time Britons spend on YouTube is done so watching content made in the UK, while North America accounts for more than half. While Ofcom has encouraged broadcasters to strike commercial deals with YouTube, it also suggested that ministers could intervene to force the US company to boost British TV programming on the platform. 'Alien to younger viewers' Ed Leighton, Ofcom's interim head of strategy and research, said: 'Scheduled TV is increasingly alien to younger viewers, with YouTube the first port of call for many when they pick up the TV remote. But we're also seeing signs that older adults are turning to the platform as part of their daily media diet too. 'Public service broadcasters are recognising this shift – moving to meet audiences in the online spaces where they increasingly spend their time. But we need to see even more ambition in this respect to ensure that public service media that audiences value survives long into the future.' The continued relevance of the BBC to British audiences will be a key negotiating point in discussions with the Government over the future of the corporation's funding. Samir Shah, the BBC chairman, has said the corporation is looking at a potential overhaul of the licence fee model after a further 300,000 stopped paying the levy last year. A BBC spokesman said: 'We welcome Ofcom's recognition of the role of the BBC in bringing people together – with three of the most-viewed programmes of last year on the BBC. 'Despite ever-increasing competition, the report finds that reach of BBC channels across all age groups remained stable year-on-year, maintaining the BBC's role as the most-watched broadcaster or service. While BBC iPlayer was the UK's fastest-growing long-form video-on-demand service in 2024/25, we know that audience needs are rapidly changing, and so we continue to transform what we do on digital platforms. 'We remain focused on delivering value for all audiences and being the place where people come together for unforgettable moments.'
