Education row: Willie Jackson, Erica Stanford spar over private schools amid NCEA talks
'Oh, but you send your kids to private school', Stanford fired back.
Education Minister Erica Stanford pictured at Mt Albert Grammar School in Auckland in May, just before a damning report on NCEA came out. Photo / Alyse Wright
Asked by Bridge if he supported the increase in subsidies for independent schools announced by Associate Education Minister David Seymour in the last Budget, Jackson said, 'No, that's very questionable'.
'I won't support David Seymour over anything, really, at the moment.'
His kids were 'in the mainstream … doing NCEA' when he moved them to King's, Jackson said.
The national qualification appears set to change after its credibility was the subject of a damning Government briefing in June, and Stanford subsequently indicated substantial changes were planned.
Asked by Bridge if he switched his kids to private school because NCEA was 'crap', Jackson disagreed.
There'd been some 'great things that came out of the public schooling system' including the award-winning Te Kura Māori o Ngā Tapuwae, which one of his children had attended.
'You know, a lot of our kids have been failing in the education system. And so for me, I try to get my kids the best of everything … [my kids' state education] was no big failure, it was just I wanted the best of both worlds.'
Education Minister Erica Stanford has indicated high school qualifications will be reformed after a damning report into NCEA.
The previous School Certificate and University Entrance qualifications had made students 'either a failure or a success - in my case, I was a failure, and there was a lot of kids like myself'.
'So you had to reshape the education system to make it more palatable for everyone … I respect what Erica is saying … but I think there's a lot of parts of the [NCEA] system where kids were feeling like they were successful, and they were absolute failures under the old system.'
His kids 'had some great years' at King's, although it was 'tough' and a 'huge cultural transition'.
However, Jackson's decision was why change was needed, Stanford said.
'People are sending their children to private schools to escape schools and a system they don't believe in. We have to change that.
'That's why we need a national qualification that we can all stand behind and be proud of.'
Her two teenage children were at a state high school, but had previously attended a mix of public and private schools, Stanford told the Herald after the on-air stoush.
'I went to a private school myself for a very short period of primary school, before I went to [state] Rangitoto College.'
Her comments on Herald Now were 'not a criticism' of private schools, Stanford said.
'People are free to do what they want.
'It's the hypocrisy of saying, 'You shouldn't have health insurance, you shouldn't rely on the state', and yet their own kids [are] going to private schools.'
Cherie Howie is an Auckland-based reporter who joined the Herald in 2011. She has been a journalist for more than 20 years and specialises in general news and features.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
14 minutes ago
- NZ Herald
Editorial: NCEA reform is a once-in-a-generation opportunity
Epsom Girls Grammar announced in May that it would start its Cambridge International exams pilot next year after being flooded with 'overwhelming community demand'. Mount Albert Grammar School principal Patrick Drumm has said his school was also under growing pressure to offer Cambridge exams from parents concerned the NCEA lacked 'rigour'. Meanwhile, the Education Review Office (ERO) has called the NCEA 'difficult to understand' and said it doesn't prepare students for future achievement. It would be tough to argue that change isn't required. When NCEA was introduced between 2002 and 2004, it was designed with the idea that each student was unique, and it offered flexibility in what students could study and demonstrate achievement and competence in. That was a shift away from the blunter, one-size-fits-all system that was School Certificate and Bursary. Education Minister Erica Stanford said this week, 'This has come at the cost of developing the critical skills and knowledge they need for clear pathways into future study, training or employment'. NCEA has often been criticised for being too hard to follow and inconsistent across students and schools. It is a different world from the one in which NCEA was designed, and whatever your view, we now have the opportunity to design a better way of assessing and preparing students for life after school. And so it is good to see acceptance of the need for change, even from those more sympathetic towards NCEA. Chris Abercrombie, president of the Post Primary Teachers' Association (PPTA), while saying NCEA should 'evolve' rather than be destroyed, said 'Reform is necessary – but it must be thoughtful, inclusive and evidence-based". Opposition leader and former Education Minister Chris Hipkins warned against taking a backward step but admitted there was 'clear evidence that NCEA is not operating as intended and there is change required'. He didn't want the debate to become 'ideological' or 'unnecessarily political'. And that will be the key to developing whatever replaces NCEA. The world is rapidly changing, and all concerned parties need to come to the table to ensure New Zealand's secondary education system is enduring and fit for purpose in 2030 and beyond.
NZ Herald
9 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Ōtaki to north of Levin highway cost doubles to $2.1b, construction yet to start
'Our Government is committed to the road as it will deliver substantial safety benefits and unlock business and housing growth.' The Greens' transport spokeswoman Julie Anne Genter told the Herald that going ahead with the road after another cost escalation was an example of 'the coalition Government ploughing ahead with a highway at any cost'. She said the Wellington region would be better served by 'rail investment, along with safety improvements to the existing roads'. The new figure was first reported by BusinessDesk, owned by Herald publisher NZME. The road is a link in the Kāpiti Expressway, which connects the capital with the lower North Island. The highway began as a proposal to take the expressway to Levin and beyond. The expressway is a road of national significance project and was built in stages. It links the Transmission Gully motorway with a string of four-lane, grade-separated projects along the Kāpiti coast. It was funded to the tune of $817m in 2020 as one of the NZ Upgrade infrastructure projects by the then-Labour Government. That programme was fraught and most of its road projects increased in cost in the space of just months. By 2021, some of the upgrade projects were dropped, others were scaled back, while others had additional money tipped into them to keep them on track. The Auditor-General later criticised the upgrade programme for being hurried with a focus on announcing projects quickly – in many cases before up-to-date business cases could be completed. The Ōtaki to North of Levin highway was one of the lucky roads to get additional funding to stay on track, with Labour increasing its budget to $1.5b. In May 2025, NZTA went out to the community with some cost-saving proposals as it had escalated to around $1.7b. Those cost-saving proposals were mainly rejected. BusinessDesk reported these changes were rejected because rescoping aspects of the project would have required reconsenting, which could have caused significant and costly delays. An NZTA spokesman said the agency's board opted to put extra money into the project because 'it considers it a high priority relative to other initiatives included in the National Land Transport Programme'. 'The road will be tolled, as announced by the Government in December 2024, with revenue raised and returned to the National Land Transport Fund, which will include the maintenance for Ō2NL [Ōtaki to north of Levin],' he said. Genter, who has criticised the NZ Upgrade roads since they were announced – despite being an associate transport minister in the Government that announced them – warned that tolling would not cover close to the full cost of the road. 'This project won't get the test of paying for itself with tolls,' she said, noting a submission made by the Infrastructure Commission to the Transport and Infrastructure Select Committee last month. That submission said that for a road to completely pay for itself it needed to cost about $32m a km, save motorists 15 minutes and have about 40,000 vehicles travel on it a day. This highway costs about $85m a km and is expected to have more than 20,000 vehicles travel on it each day by the late 2030s, according to NZTA business cases.
RNZ News
14 hours ago
- RNZ News
NCEA overhaul concerns Kura Kaupapa Māori, opportunity to consider own qualifications
A student's book at Te Kura Kaupapa Maori O Takapu Photo: RNZ / Cole Eastham-Farrelly Kura Kaupapa Māori have expressed concern about the government's proposal to replace NCEA with a new qualification model, saying kura kaupapa students have only just mastered the current system. Co-chairperson of Te Rūnanga Nui o ngā Kura Kaupapa Māori o Aotearoa Rawiri Wright said he supports the establishment of an assessment framework that ensures integrity and mana for Māori learners, but the current proposal fails to accommodate the proven strengths of Kura Kaupapa Māori. "My gut reaction is it's a return to the bad old days of the school certificate regime and that didn't do us any favours as Māori people." But Wright said there could be an opportunity for kura to consider their own qualifications. "Perhaps the time has come for Kura Kaupapa Māori and Te Aho Matua schools to consider establishing our own qualifications and assessment strategies, aligned with the learning programmes of the Māori wānanga across the country." Education Minister Erica Stanford told Nine to Noon there was "too much credit counting" with NCEA. "I can see the system is being gamed... Credits are being used to get students across the line, like participating in a group activity or filling out a form," she said. Rawiri Wright says the proposed replacement was a monocultural, Eurocentric approach to education, he said. Photo: Te Rawhitiroa Bosch But Wright said the NCEA model has provided greater flexibility for Kura Kaupapa. He questioned why the game was being changed now. "It seems to us that our Kura Kaupapa Māori kids and kaiako (teachers) and kura, we got really familiar, we learnt how to play the NCEA game really well, to the point where the ministry now has 15 years of data which shows that our kids have outperformed all other schooling options in the country in terms of NCEA achievement." A Qualifications Authority report from 2024 showed that students at kaupapa Māori schools achieved better NCEA results than their peers at comparable English-medium schools. They had NCEA achievement rates of 63 percent at level 1, 72 percent at level 2 and 73 percent at level 3. Achievement rates for all students in the comparator group of English-medium schools were 54, 66 and 61 percent and for Māori students in those schools the rates were 50, 64 and 56 percent. Wright said the consultation process, which closes 15 September, is a very short window to pull together a high quality meaningful response to the governments proposal. "The minister and the prime minister have said themselves that they want to get something in place before the end of the year so it just means that we all have to be on our game and get our submissions together quickly." The proposed NCEA replacement was a monocultural, Eurocentric approach to education, he said. "The process of education that they're still insisting on foisting upon us is that of a mono-cultural Eurocentric education system which has been in place in the country for 269 years. It has not worked for thousands of Māori and Pasifika students, why on earth would they think these changes are going to make any significant difference to that."
