High court rejects appeal by Bobby Thomas for new trial in murder of Megan Gallagher
Bobby Thomas pleaded guilty to second-degree murder in December 2024, admitting to killing Megan Gallagher in September 2020.
In March, he appealed that plea and asked for a new trial.
In his notice of appeal, Thomas cited unspecified "Charter right violations," adding that he hoped "to have one last chance of having some kind of life with my four kids. They lost their mom to an overdose in Sept. 2024, so I wanna make sure they have one parent to go to, and I feel I haven't had a fair court case either."
Justice Neal Caldwell heard the appeal on June 11 and released a written decision two days later.
"Bluntly, the allegations made orally by his counsel in this matter are not only wholly unsupported by any evidence, they are, at least to some extent, dispelled or contradicted by the court record," Caldwell wrote.
Thomas suggested that he had gotten bad advice from his earlier counsel. Caldwell said Thomas' own words at his sentencing undermined this position.
"As is evident, the contention of improper pressure from his trial counsel is inconsistent with Mr. Thomas' own, unsolicited statement in his sentencing hearing that his first lawyer had several times attempted to arrange for Mr. Thomas to plead guilty to a lesser offence than second-degree murder."
Summer-Sky Henry, Roderick Sutherland and Cheyann Peeteetuce were all charged with first-degree murder along with Bobby Thomas. Henry and Peeteetuce pleaded guilty to manslaughter. Sutherland is set for trial later this year.
Thomas Sutherland was charged with manslaughter, but it was stayed.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
24 minutes ago
- CBC
Basketball tournament in Six Nations honours Dylan Isaacs's dream of bringing the sport to Indigenous youth
It was a few months after his death that Dylan Isaacs's friends approached his family and asked if they could do a basketball tournament in Six Nations of the Grand River, honouring the 30-year-old. "[Isaacs] always talked about bringing basketball to our community more, and especially for the youth," said his aunt, Cecelia Sky. Now, 19 months after he was killed, the second annual Dylan Isaacs Memorial Basketball Tournament is underway this weekend and it has become something he'd be "over the moon" with, Sky said. The event brings in several, mostly Indigenous, basketball groups from all over the U.S. and Canada, and this year, they accomplished their initial goal of having part of the event aimed at youth from the community. Isaacs was a member of the Cayuga Nation. On January 7, 2024, he was leaving a NFL stadium with his friends in Miami, Fla., when he got into an argument with someone who was driving erratically, according to police. The driver allegedly pulled a gun and shot Isaacs to death, Miami Gardens police said at the time. CBC contacted police there this week for an update on the investigation but they did not respond. "He's really missed. He was a big presence in our family," said Sky, adding kids in the community looked up to him. "He was a big guy, big tall guy, and his personality was just as big as him." His mother and Sky's sister, Sue Sky-Isaacs, told CBC Hamilton a few days after his death "he was a character in everything he did." "He was full of love and we loved him." The family was on board to make Isaacs' basketball dream a reality and formed a committee with his friends to organize the first tournament, which took place Aug. 22 to 25, 2024. This year, the event is underway once again, and they're inviting everyone to come by and watch. 'He'd be just loving this' Sky said those coming out to play are "high level" teams. "So if anybody likes basketball, you know, they should come and watch." The tournament includes teams from the Seneca and Buffalo nations in New York, the Oneida Nation in Wisconsin, the Makah Nation in Washington, the Seminole Nation in Florida, which Isaacs played with, and more. This year, in addition to the tournament, organizers also held a youth skill camp for Six Nations kids aged 10 to 14 where they gave away running shoes and basketball t-shirts. The skill camp ended Thursday with a small competition and lunch. "The kids were just happy to get their gifts," said Sky. "They sat down and put their shoes on right away and it was just awesome." Sky said it was an "overwhelming feeling" seeing the skill camp become a reality. "It's something that [Isaacs] always wanted to bring to the community," said Sky. "It's unfortunate that we had to wait until he passed to do that kind of thing, because we know he'd just, he'd be just loving this." She said the community in Six Nations has been very supportive and feels their goal of bringing more eyes to basketball in the region is on its way to being achieved. Finals will take place on Sunday with a smoke dance contest in between the men's and women's matches. Entry is free to the games, which take place at Six Nations's Dajoh Youth and Elders Centre at 1738 Fourth Line. Organizers are also encouraging attendees to buy merchandise and participate in auctions and events going on to keep the skill camp going for next year.
CTV News
5 hours ago
- CTV News
Police arrest suspect after death threat against Jewish man in Montreal
A screenshot of a video posted on social media showing a man during an altercation in Montreal's Saint-Laurent borough. (Source: X/Mayer Feig) Montreal police say they arrested a suspect Friday after receiving reports of a man making 'threats and hateful remarks' toward a group of people in the city's Saint-Laurent borough. At around 4:40 p.m., police received several 911 calls and responded to the intersection of Fraser and Saint-Louis streets. When officers arrived, they quickly found the suspect, a 28-year-old man, and arrested him after speaking with witnesses. A short video posted on social media shows part of the altercation. In the video, a man can be heard saying 'we will kill you' and 'you f-cking pig' when speaking to people, including at least one of them being a member of the Jewish community, before walking away. Caroline Chevrefils, a Montreal police spokesperson, said the suspect will remain in custody until he appears in court Saturday via videoconference from a detention centre. Police say the hate crime unit was informed of the incident and that it will be up to the Crown prosecution office to determine whether charges will be laid. The Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs (CIJA) said in a statement that it was pleased that police made a swift arrest. 'Those who seek to threaten members of our community must be held accountable. If you see something, say something,' the group said in the statement. The incident comes days after a Jewish father was beaten up by a man in a park while he was with his children. A suspect in that case, which was also caught on video, is facing charges.
CTV News
6 hours ago
- CTV News
1 dead in crash involving motorcycle in northwest Calgary
Centre Street North is closed at 12th Avenue N.W. after a crash late Friday afternoon between a vehicle and a motorcycle. A motorcyclist is dead following a vehicle collision in northwest Calgary. Friday's crash happened shortly before 4 p.m. at the intersection of 12th Avenue and Centre Street. It involved the motorcycle and another vehicle. Police say the motorcyclist was taken to hospital in critical condition and was pronounced dead after he got there. In the aftermath of the crash, 12th Avenue was closed at Centre Street in both directions.
